HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

calhoun137

1,201 karma · joined February 8, 2013

I am a builder, not a breaker.
submissionscomments
calhoun137··on Microsoft CEO defends US military contract that employees say crosses a line
> I can never understand those protesters

In my opinion, the potential for the technology that microsoft could develop for the military is just as dangerous if not more so than chlorine gas, which was used in WW1.

You should watch this video [1]. It is about Einstein and Fritz Haber (who was the father of chlorine gas). Einstein was horrified at the way Haber was so casual about mass murdering people.

Speaking for myself: I have never and will never work on any weapon technology that is meant for killing other people. If I was at MS and someone asked me to do that I would raise hell like these people and absolutely refuse to do it and quit.

There is no reason or need for an arms race on super high end weaponization of AI between the US, Russia, and China. That is super dangerous and crazy talk. We need peace in this world, not more high tech weapons.

I support the action of the protesters at MS 1000%. Hope that helps you understand them.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jWFe253TYmA

calhoun137··on Instacart paying 80 cents an hour because worker received a large tip
I swear to god I am never going to order from instacart ever again.
calhoun137··on The Looking Glass – Holographic Display
I thought there might be a way to use constructive and destructive interference of a large number of sources to build an open air 3d hologram out of pure light. If light didn't have to travel in a straight line, and we could control the index of refraction at any point in space, this would probably work.
calhoun137··on The Looking Glass – Holographic Display
> Aside from the fact that it's not in open air

I once put a lot of work into researching how to build an "open air" 3d hologram like they have in the movies and came to the conclusion that it is basically against the laws of physics. This is because its impossible to bend light beams in free space.

There are however a lot of cool tricks and hacks, 3d holograms are a really cool subject, this Looking Glass product looks fantastic I want one.

One of the biggest problems these kinds of holograms in a box have is, even though horizontal scrolling works fine, being able to look at it from the top and bottom does not. Here [1] is a video of a 3d hologram in a box based on a rotating mirror that has a head tracker for viewing from different vertical angles. It's really cool but the thing rotates so fast it's also extremely dangerous.

Another approach for open air 3d holograms is to create a series of small explosions that emit light by shooting dangerous high powered lasers into the air and using plasma emission. See [2]

Finally here is a cool video of some fan based holograms [3]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8gvPS1m40gw

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KfVS-npfVuY

[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjvq0SNczrI

calhoun137··on Why are amplitudes complex?
> In this post, I’d like to focus on a question that any “explanation” for QM at some point needs to address, in a non-question-begging way: why should amplitudes have been complex numbers?

I will take your word for it that

> The question in the post is "Why is the universe this way and not another way?" not "Why do we choose to use complex numbers in our description of the universe?"

but why then does he so prominently raise this question at the beginning, answer it later, and title his post "why are amplitudes complex?". I must be really out of the loop. Did I really get the subject of this post so badly wrong? Sorry about that. Is this not a very confusing way to go about discussing why the universe is this way and not another?

calhoun137··on Why are amplitudes complex?
Great points, let me try and explain better where the group O(1) appears in basic QM. An amplitude in QM is only defined up to a global phase transformation e^it. To be more clear, given some amplitude A and a real number t, we will calculate the same probability for any measurement by using the amplitude Ae^it instead. Well there is the group O(1) right there.

What's super interesting is that this fact is literally the reason why charge is conserved. This can be seen by expanding our horizons and instead of only looking at Ae^it, we instead replace i by its matrix representation, and then also add the matrix representation for the lie algebra elements of SU(2) i.e. the pauli matrices. Then for QCD use the 8 lie algebra elements of SU(3). This kind of progression seems very natural and intuitive to me, which is why I included this in the original comment.

I see math as very distinct from physics. Math is a language for understanding universal truths about abstract concepts, and as far as QM is concerned, I think what it says about nature is that there are a number of symmetries besides the ones found in classical physics. The mathematics of symmetry is all tied up with complex numbers, but it could all be done without it if you really wanted. I believe that by understanding the mathematics of lie groups and lie algebras we gain a much better understanding of the relationship between complex numbers and quantum amplitudes.

I even think the question "why are quantum amplitudes complex" potentially raises a number of red herring questions that wont help us understand nature better, when what we really should be focusing on is the role of the mathematics of symmetry in QM, not complex numbers.

(P.S. I am going from memory here and may have gotten some details wrong and apologize for being possibly misleading by accident, its hard to communicate this kind of thing but its fun to try)

calhoun137··on Why are amplitudes complex?
> the chance of different configurations being realized are complex for quantum mechanics

I don't think there is anything essential about complex numbers when it comes to formulating the laws of QM. Everything can be done without complex numbers by using matrices. A simple way to convince yourself of this is to realize a complex number is just a pair of real numbers at the end of the day.

In the wiki article on the Heisenberg picture [1] of QM we read:

> By the Stone–von Neumann theorem, the Heisenberg picture and the Schrödinger picture are unitarily equivalent, just a basis change in Hilbert space.

Then in the article on the Stone-von Neumann theorem [2] we read:

> Informally stated, with certain technical assumptions, every representation of the Heisenberg group H2n + 1 is equivalent to the position operators and momentum operators on Rn

And in the article on the Heisenberg group [3] we find out that this group consists of 3 by 3 upper triangular matrices with three independent elements that can be taken from any ring.

This kind of high level lie group lie algebra approach is something I got really into in the past and continue to be fascinated by. I wish I could explain better why as a result I don't see complex numbers as essential at all in the foundations of quantum theory, but rather, just very convenient for doing calculations. I hope you find the linked wiki articles as interesting as I do. Cheers!

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heisenberg_picture

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stone%E2%80%93von_Neumann_theo...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heisenberg_group

calhoun137··on Why are amplitudes complex?
The question of the relationship of complex numbers and QM is extremely interesting imo, and a lot of the article is devoted to this question, not sure I totally agree the subject at hand is why is the universe the way it is. Additionally, if by real amplitudes he meant a completely different set of laws, I don't see how that is relevant to a discussion of why complex numbers play such an important role in QM.

QM is really weird. One of its strangest properties is that although it contains classical mechanics as a limiting case, QM also required classical mechanics for its very formulation, see page 3 here [1]

When most people encounter QM for the first time, they want to come up with some "intuitive sounding" principles from which they can derive everything else. That's natural. Most people just give up at that and work on other things, other people take it really really far. So far no one has been able to do it, but who knows right.

In the article we can find this passage:

> A major research goal in quantum foundations, since at least the early 2000s, has been to “derive” the formalism of QM purely from “intuitive-sounding, information-theoretic” postulates

The entire approach of deriving QM from first principles without reference to classical mechanics may never work, not to mention that concept of "intuitive sounding" is highly subjective. Therefore, considering that there is no such set of axioms known at this time and the whole approach could be wrong, I find it objectionable to use this argument as a basis for explaining why amplitudes have to be complex.

[1] http://power1.pc.uec.ac.jp/~toru/notes/LandauLifshitz-Quantu...

calhoun137··on Why are amplitudes complex?
The reason amplitudes are complex is because a fundamental role is played in quantum theory by symmetry, and the imaginary number in an exponential (e^it) is a very algebraically convenient way to capture an important symmetry.

In quantum field theory, the lie algebra elements of certain lie groups (U(1), SU(2), and SU(3)) play a fundamental role. For example, the 8 quarks correspond to 8 lie algebra elements of SU(3).

A lie group is a continuous symmetry group (such as the rotation of a circle which leave it unchanged, as opposed to a finite group like the rotations of a square) and the lie algebra are the "generators" of lie groups in the same sense that finite groups can be generated, such as the symmetry group of rotations of a square can be generated by a single rotation of 90 degree's.

Here is the real kicker, the imaginary number i is actually equivalent in a very strong sense to the lie algebra element of O(1) (which is just the rotations of a circle) and can also be represented by the matrix:

0 -1

1 0

as can be proven by taking the powers of this matrix and the powers of i and simply checking everything.

calhoun137··on Why are amplitudes complex?
I imagine a lot of people are going to be checking the comments here to find out what the answer to the question in the title is.

I believe this part is what the answer is supposed to be:

> “local tomography”: i.e., the “principle” that composite systems must be uniquely determined by the statistics of local measurements. And while this principle might sound vague and unobjectionable, to those in the business, it’s obvious what it’s going to be used for the second it’s introduced. Namely, it’s going to be used to rule out quantum mechanics over the real numbers, which would otherwise be a model for the axioms, and thus to “explain” why amplitudes have to be complex

I will leave it to other to explain what this means in comments. For the record I don't think this explanation is correct, and strongly object. I don't think amplitudes "have" to be complex, it's just a mathematical convenience. If anything, the actual question we should be asking is: why are complex numbers so convenient.

calhoun137··on Reasons Python Sucks
At the end of the day the thing that makes Python the best programming language is not actually the language itself, which has a lot going for it, but the community around it. The python community is the full of extremely good programmers, and there is a vast ecosystem of first class resources that are available for everyone.

Yes, these are all valid points, and I laughed. Holding up javascript (npm anyone?) as some kind of counter example that proves python is bad may have held some un-intentional humor as well. Don't get me wrong, I love js but it seems to me like if you took these same 8 points and made them about javascript it would be 100 times more damning.

Heck, I am even willing to count this great article itself as a reason to love the python community even more. Someone who hates python so much must do so from a place of extreme love.

calhoun137··on UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for Elsevier journals
It's a tricky problem. The suggestion at hand was UCLA walk from the negotiation. Would that mean faculty at UCLA are given a mandatory "DO NOT REVIEW" order? I would have assumed their free labor would still be most welcome, especially from experts.

If UCLA walks, that would possibly cause other universities to follow suit, and I bet Elsevier would come back to the table with a better offer.

The way I see things, the universities are not organized at all and are being taken to the cleaners because of things like this. It looks like the people doing the negotiating on behalf of the faculty are in way over their heads and don't even realize how the game is played and are being out maneuvered at every turn by a savvy, massively powerful corporation for which this is pretty much all they do all day, every day.

calhoun137··on UCLA asked faculty to consider declining to review for Elsevier journals
You say "You seem to blame this squarely on the faculty, and yet faculty have the least amount of freedom when it comes to publication venue"

I assume you are referencing this

> If UCLA were serious it would simply walk from the negotiation. THAT would send a message to all parties. It might actually spur some action on the part of faculty to get off their collective backsides

Then you suggest "Concerted action at the national and international level is required".

Who exactly is supposed to be responsible for organizing national and international action and to do what exactly, disband Elsevier? This is not a practical suggestion. A practical approach would be for the institutions that pay Elsevier for access, i.e the faculty/admins to get better organized and get better at negotiating.

asking faculty to consider the mere act of not reviewing (much less not submitting papers to) these top journals is a third rate negotiating tactic. A strong negotiator would simply walk out at this point. That would send a much stronger message.

calhoun137··on Internal Tensions at Facebook Are Boiling Over
"I don’t think I’ve ever read such a deeply toxic comment in my life"

I find this pretty hard to believe, you must have read something on the internet more toxic than that!

I don't think the person being quoted means what you think they do, unless you assume the absolute worst about them, and I don't see how we have enough information to make a judgement one way or the other about this persons worldview.

In the previous paragraph we read another quote from the message boards “One does not simply fire the author of ‘Lean In’ and pretty much the sole female executive in top leadership,”

Isn't the part of the culture that is truly toxic that she is "pretty much the sole female executive in leadership"?

calhoun137··on Internal Tensions at Facebook Are Boiling Over
>> Calling these "burner phones" is a little silly.

I agree, but it's still not as silly as how many people are commenting in here about whether or not its ok to call it a "burner phone" lol

calhoun137··on World Chess Championship 2018 - Game 2
Oh this should be an exciting 150 move game that ends in a draw. Looks like I know what I will be doing for the next 9 hours.
calhoun137··on They Hacked Their School District When They Were 12
Also happened to me when I was in high school, but luckily my mom was able to convinve the school to drop everything.

The school is not only incapable of provoding a quality education for these super smart kids, but they also were exposing everyones data in a negligent and reckless way. Where is the punushment for the network admin?

Seems like the real lesson here is dont be a black hat hacker, or at least if you are gonna do that, dont get caught no matter what. The truth is if they werent minors theyd be totally fucked for this. I imagine lots of us here had similar experiences. Its natural enough to want to explore and play with this kind of thing. But life isnt fair, and that is an important lesson we all have to learn at some point.

If I knew either of these guys I would hire and mentor them right now.

calhoun137··on Why [Insert Thing Here] Is Not a Password Killer
This. I think Slack is doing this perfectly, they still use passwords but emphasize the magic link email. I find it a lot easier to just use the magic link the first time I join a new slack. Then once you are logged in you basically never need to log out and if you ever need to reset the password its just a click away.
calhoun137··on How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would prefer you don't ask
fair enough. I guess the difference is that bike rental stores don't have automated systems which apparently have a bug where they charge the unknowing victims of a crime rent for previously rented bikes which were stolen and sold online.
calhoun137··on How much does a cable box really cost? The industry would prefer you don't ask
Slightly off topic, Comcast actually stole my mom's modem that she bought from amazon! What happened is most likely the modem she bought was supposed to be returned to comcast by another customer, but that person instead just put it up for sale on amazon. Every so often a charge for a box rental would show up on her bill, she would go to the store in person to show them the receipt, get a refund and the charges would stop. Then 3 months went by and the charge appeared on the bill again. This went on for a year and a half. No one in customer service could help and at the end they said the only solution is just give us the modem and buy another one.

Apparently in order to deal with stolen modems, comcast simply charges whatever customer has that modem regardless of whether or not the modem itself was supposed to be returned by another customer but never was. That is one hell of a way to get your stolen modem's back. Can you imagine if you went to the golf course and had your own clubs which you bought on amazon, but the course charged you for club rental every time you went, until they demand you hand over your clubs, and force you to buy another set to be allowed to play?

That is how comcast harassed my mom for a year and a half, stole her modem, and tried to charge her rent for a different customers box.

calhoun137··on Quantum computers will break the encryption that protects the internet
What I meant was the debate which has been taking place in the main stream of physics for many years now is whether or not its possible to build a quantum computer on the scale where it can do anything useful. In the article we read:

>> When Dr Shor made his discovery such computers were the stuff of science fiction. But in 2001 researchers at ibm announced that they had built one, programmed it with Shor’s algorithm, and used it to work out that the prime factors of 15 are three and five. This machine was about the most primitive quantum computer imaginable.

The context which was lacking is that I meant on a large scale and not simply the most primitive thing. And no I am not fabricating anything, see here [1] for some of the main stream discussion by someone who is more articulate and knows more about it than me.

Let's keep in mind that just this week it was announced that a grad student figured out an algorithm to verify that the computations done by hypothetical quantum computers actually are giving a correct answer [2].

I seriously don't think you know what you are talking about when it comes to the idea that its "already been done", D-Wave is not a "quantum computer" in the sense of this article or shors algorithm.

However, you are correct that my comment was overly hyperbolic and lacking context. Next time this comes up on here I will try to do a better job and not use phrases like "its a hoax" because to be honest, its not a hoax, it might be possible one day they will exist. I personally believe at that point there will be so many other advances that non quantum computers will simply outperform everything else.

[1] https://www.quantamagazine.org/gil-kalais-argument-against-q...

[2] https://www.quantamagazine.org/graduate-student-solves-quant...

calhoun137··on Quantum computers will break the encryption that protects the internet
"Damgerous misinformation" to say quantum computers are not magical oracles? The entire subject of QC is literally a hoax! The only danger is that if people dont think they are magical they might want to cut off the funding. If I were to say I know a magical oracle who can break encryption with pure thought, it wouldnt be much different than the kinds of claims you hear about quantum computers on a daily basis. I used to do experimental physics for many years, all of my colleages and I thought quantum computers were a joke. Main stream physics people understand there is an intense debate over whether or not its even possible to build a quantum computer. Nothing to see here, its just the QC hype train doing its thing.
calhoun137··on Why Is Behavioral Economics So Popular?
Behavioral economics is popular because its a better model. It's clear that any model of human behavior and decision making will necessary be very complicated. It doesn't make any sense to right at the start decide that the only factor that will be considered is financial expected value. Even though any model based on such an assumption will be severely flawed, this is the view of main stream economics, and this explains why behavioral economics is a better model.
calhoun137··on The Best Article Ever Written About Bragging
This. I try to never brag, but I do it without realizing it sometimes. You are lucky to have such smart and humble friends! Unlike you, I am so much smarter than everyone I know irl. Just telling people what I had for breakfast, much less what I was working on while I ate it, literally makes people feel bad about themselves. I'd love to expand on this idea but you guys are smart just like me so I probably don't even need to explain anymore. I also need to get back to this calculation I am doing for my deep learning nueral network model to search for a possible newly discovered particle at CERN, where I work.
calhoun137··on Machine Learning Confronts the Elephant in the Room
In this article, learn the secret AI researchers dont want you to know, my non tech friends love talking about it! Gonna have to agree with everyone else here, the title is clickbait and you can just code around it.

There is nothing fatal here its just one more problem to solve. Havent we heard all about this issue of image recognition being trickable 1000 times, why is this the top post?

calhoun137··on Papers of Srinivasa Ramanujan (1887-1920), mathematician
I recently started working through his collected papers a few months ago and have a really nice hardcover. Wow they are so hard!! Also have read every volume of his lost notebooks back in college. Sometimes when I start a new paper I think: why would anyone ever think of that, who cares anyway, and what does that even mean.

It takes about 10 minutes to read one line. But its worth it cause he was able to create his own path and what he does with formal power series and summing divergent series is staggering to behold

calhoun137··on SageMath – Open-Source Mathematical Software System
Hi deepakkarki,

I prefer to only correspond with serious mathematicians, and for fun recently I have been using Sage to work through Mochizuki's paper on Inter-universal Teichmüller theory, I got a little stuck on this passage, if you can explain it to me I will tell you more about my project:

"In the first three papers of the series, we introduced and studied the theory surrounding the log-theta-lattice, a highly non-commutative two-dimensional diagram of “miniature models of conventional scheme theory”, called Θ±ell NF-Hodge theaters, that were associated, in the first paper of the series, to certain data, called initial Θ-data. This data includes an elliptic curve EF over a number field F , together with a prime number l ≥ 5. Consideration of various properties of the log-theta-lattice led naturally to the establishment, in the third paper of the series, of multiradial algorithms for constructing “splitting monoids of LGP-monoids”.

Just Kidding!!!!! I sent you an email =) Thanks so much for your interest in this project, looking forward to hearing more about what you are working on as well. Cheers!

calhoun137··on SageMath – Open-Source Mathematical Software System
Hello! I am a mathematician as well as a programmer and have been very interested in Sage for many years, it has inspired me over the years to make various calculator type projects. You are going to love my new one which I am preparing to release, promise! Thanks so much for all your hard work I have followed your career.

I have almost completely finished a visualization block coding system which sits on top of Numpy, Scipy, and Sage designed to help kids who are learning math on youtube, to be able to create "problem set" style save files which can be shared to supplement math education videos, and to create animations for my upcoming youtube channel for math education. It also has a fully functional debugger and console, its like web inspector but for math, so I have named it Math Inspector.

I think it's really exciting what is happening in the world of math education and the way that the medium of video is being used for the first time to communicate the joy of mathematics to the world, especially to young people. It's revolutionary. My goal has been to create a tool which enables people to be able to interact with Sage without needing to even know python at all. I wish you the best!

calhoun137··on Show HN: I'm 12, learning JS, and wrote Wolfram's cellular automaton in Node
This is so great and I am really impressed, and even a little inspired! When I was 12 there was no internet and learning programming was really hard, but it was more fun for me than anything else. Your project has reminded me how I felt so many years ago when I was 12 and I would sneak out of bed to program QBASIC on my APPLE 2C. Thanks for the inspiration and keep up the great work! Keep working hard like this and you will become a master programmer of the first rank.
calhoun137··on The Ugly Truth of Ugly Produce
Well said. I think the major problem here is not that PhatBeets is being out-competed by a more well funded company. The problem is that there is enough food in the world to feed everyone in the world and more, but because of economic inequality there are many people who cannot afford to put enough food on the table for them or their kids. It's not Imperfect Produce's fault that the world is so fucked up, and I love the mission of PhatBeet's. My take away is that if I was in PhatBeet's shoes I would be incredibly frustrated and would feel very powerless and might make a blog post with similar hyperbolic language lashing out at the easiest target I could find in a desperate effort to save everything I had been working so hard on for so long by any means necessary. If I were in Imperfect Produce's shoes I would feel like this ire has been misdirected at me when the real problem lies with extremely complex and difficult problems which exist in general in our society.
← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →