HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

calhoun137

1,201 karma · joined February 8, 2013

I am a builder, not a breaker.
submissionscomments
calhoun137··on Solution claimed for Navier-Stokes equations, one of the millennium problems
There are already a large number of solutions to Navier-Stokes that are known. The millennium problem asks to prove existence or non-existence of smooth (infinitely differentiable) solutions that are valid for all time See pg 2, here: http://www.claymath.org/sites/default/files/navierstokes.pdf
calhoun137··on Solution claimed for Navier-Stokes equations, one of the millennium problems
According to this article, he claims to have found a strong solution. My prediction was/is that the types of solutions asked for by the millennium problem were not going to exist, so my first instinct is to not believe this, but clearly that is not a good reason. So, at the risk of being wrong, I will make the following not so bold prediction: there is a critical mistake somewhere in the paper and the approach will ultimately not pan out.
calhoun137··on User Culture Versus Programmer Culture
I find a decent amount of fault with this article, but it's not all bad. It starts off with a really cool premise and then goes on to equate "programmer culture" with using the command line. I think the author is spot on when he describes how user's think about software/apps, but obviously the command line is not the be all and end all of how programmers think about software, it's just (a very important) one of many tools.

One group of people have no idea what programming is, the other group do. It's not that complicated. There is no user/programmer culture divide, it's simply a matter of understanding a complex topic or not.

I think a lot of "programmers" use apps and other software like "users", but when something goes wrong we like to hunt down the solution and fix it, and I think that explains why it is not uncommon to hear programmers complaining about how stupid the people who wrote the software they use everyday must be; because it can be frustrating and annoying when it ends up being something really obscure.

Programmers have a better understanding of how software works, but just like everyone else we get frustrated and annoyed when our app's crash. We can complain in more elaborate and accurate ways than the average person is all.

calhoun137··on When You Criticize Someone, You Make It Harder for that Person to Change
It's hard to take an article seriously when the title is obviously false.
calhoun137··on Google Acquires Boston Dynamics
> Nearly all the technology in front of you right now (your computer)

Very True!

"Like the ENIAC, the EDVAC[1] was built for the U.S. Army's Ballistics Research Laboratory at the Aberdeen Proving Ground by the University of Pennsylvania's Moore School of Electrical Engineering. Eckert and Mauchly and the other ENIAC designers were joined by John von Neumann in a consulting role; von Neumann summarized and discussed logical design developments in the 1945 First Draft of a Report on the EDVAC"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EDVAC

calhoun137··on Websmart, Inc. and 100,000 Vulnerable Websites
One problem is that the SQL error messages are being displayed. That is really bad, since being able to read the error messages can be used to systematically find vulnerable queries.
calhoun137··on Explain Shell
> If there's a way to make it top to bottom while keeping the UI useful, I'd love to hear!

I understand that the UI looks very nice, but at least for me, having the explanation boxes be in order would make it a lot easier to use. So here is my suggestion:

You can keep everything looking exactly like it is now, except get rid of the lines altogether, and display all of the explanation boxes in order.

When the user scrolls down far enough, display the query at the top of the page with fixed position so that it is always on screen. Then topmost displayed explanation box will get highlighted, along with the relevant portion of the query; unless the mouse is hovering over a certain box or portion of the query, in which case that command/box pair becomes highlighted instead.

If a user tries to scroll with the mouse wheel or keyboard, but there is no more content to display on the page, then the scrolling causes the highlighted box to change instead.

If a portion of the query is highlighted which is not on the page, then clicking that portion will cause the page the jump so that the corresponding box appears and becomes highlighted.

calhoun137··on A spreadsheet in fewer than 30 lines of JavaScript, no library used
Sorry for breaking it, I couldn't help it =/
calhoun137··on The Big Data Brain Drain: Why Science is in Trouble
I am an example of this trend, having dropped out of a physics PhD program to pursue programming, and feeling great about the decision. There are two points which are not made by the author and which I think deserve to be mentioned:

1.) Scientific research is hard. It is very frustrating to spend all day working on something you can't be sure is going to even work. On the other hand, programming is easy, it's mostly monkey work. Sure there are places where you have to be clever and think things out carefully, but at the end of the day, when you write code it just feels like you have so much more to show than when you do research.

2.) In research, you need to get grant money to do anything, because research is expensive. So much time is then spent writing grant proposals, and even when you get money you still can't do everything you want because it's just too expensive and/or time consuming. I'm not talking about LHC money here, but just the standard money for a professor running a lab in a university.

In programming, you can work on (I'd estimate) 95+% of problems with nothing more than your computer and some old fashioned hard work. There are so many good, free to use open source libraries out there, making it pretty easy to jump into whatever field is interesting to you. Best of all, when you finish a project, there is no need to spend weeks writing a paper about it or any of the nonsense associated with that, you can just publish your code.

calhoun137··on Magic: The Gathering API
Ahh Magic cards! The first website I ever made was a magic card trivia page, oh about 15 years ago. If I had known about this API, I would have used it back then ;)

By the way, there is an awesome program called lackeyCCG[1] that I use whenever I feel the need for a quick fix, it's almost like a free version of magic online. Plus you can use it to test your own CCG's if you ever had the urge to make one.

[1] http://www.lackeyccg.com/

calhoun137··on I’m Thinking. Please. Be Quiet.
I personally find that I am much more distracted by people who are trying to get my attention than I am by background noise. This article reminds of an anecdote about Poincare that can be found on page 533 of the excellent book "Men of Mathematics"[1]

"...when a distinguished mathematician had come all the way from Finland to Paris to confer with Poincare on scientific matters, Poincare did not leave his study to greet his called when the maid notified him, but continued to pace back and forth - as was his custom when mathematizing - for three solid hours. All this time the diffident caller sat quietly in the adjoining room, barred from the master only by flimsy portieres. At last the drapes parted and Poincare's buffalo head was thrust for an instant into the room. "Vois me derangez beaucoup" (You are disturbing me greatly) the head exploded, and disappeared. The caller departed without an interview..."

[1]http://books.google.com/books?id=BLFL3coT5i4C&q=533#v=snippe...

calhoun137··on Explore what is Trending on GitHub
This is pretty cool! I have a dream about making small-medium contributing to tons and tons of random projects, just to learn and get to work with interesting people. The old search feature made it kind of hard to find cool repo's to work on that weren't seemingly saturated with contributors, I thought maybe I was using the "explore" feature wrong or else that you were supposed to find links on places like HN.

I'm hoping this one is better suited for such a purpose, but hoping even more that I find the motivation to follow through on the dream. No better time to start than tonight I suppose ;)

calhoun137··on No, really—consciousness is worth thinking about
> I think what you're saying is quite stupid.

I'm assuming this is meant to be ironic and to try and prove something. But I challenge you to find a serious comment on HN that is this over the top negative and backs it up with as little as you do. It really doesn't bother me to be told I'm wrong, if I'm saying something stupid I want to be told that in no uncertain terms so that I don't repeat the same mistake again. But most of all, I want to know why what I said was wrong.

>The atmosphere on other online communities is more positive, which is a good thing. You can disagree without being negative.

I don't disagree that HN comments are different from places like reddit, but you haven't really explained why it's "a good thing". I personally don't find a lot of value in being praised, because I don't learn anything and the danger is I might get a big ego. However, I do find enormous value in constructive criticism. When I have a young student without a ton of self-confidence, then I am generous with giving praise; but when a colleague who I respect comes to me with a bad idea, I treat them with respect by telling them why I think they are wrong.

calhoun137··on No, really—consciousness is worth thinking about
Since we are doing another meta-discussion on how supposedly nasty the comment section is sometimes, I'd like to say I don't have a problem with the tone of the comments at all, and I for one would be really sad if people started pulling their punches. The extremely high degree of criticism found in the comments is actually something I value very highly about this community.

One of the things I love about the comment section is that people treat each other like adults who are capable of handling criticism. This isn't the office, this is HN.

Not being able to handle criticism is a debilitating personality trait for someone who wants to achieve a high level of success in any sort of intellectual pursuit; and that is the reason why I strongly disagree with the desire on the part of some to change this aspect of the community.

calhoun137··on NYTimes Objective–C Style Guide
I hate absurdly long variable names like this:

    static const NSTimeInterval NYTArticleViewControllerNavigationFadeAnimationDuration = 0.3;
I feel like if your naming convention forces you to have variable names over 50 letters long, there is a problem.
calhoun137··on Big-O notation explained by a self-taught programmer
One of the nice things about big-O notation from a mathematical point of view is that it allows you to avoid dealing with limits.

As everyone knows, calculus is based on limits, but when handled rigorously limits have a lot of subtle pitfalls that take a lot of work to deal with. For example, given a function f(x,y), if we want to take one limit after another, the result might depend on the order in which the limits are taken. In other words, taking limits is not commutative unless certain conditions are satisfied.

None other than the great Donald Knuth went so far as to claim that all of calculus could be taught without limits! Quoting from [1]:

"Students will be motivated to use O notation for two important reasons. First, it significantly simplifies calculations because it allows us to be sloppy — but in a satisfactorily controlled way. Second, it appears in the power series calculations of symbolic algebra systems like Maple and Mathematica, which today’s students will surely be using.

For more than 20 years I have dreamed of writing a calculus text entitled O Calculus, in which the subject would be taught along the lines sketched above."

[1] http://micromath.wordpress.com/2008/04/14/donald-knuth-calcu...

calhoun137··on Faster Than the Speed of Light?
This explanation is wrong, and is not what the article is talking about at all. This article is about creating a warp bubble using negative energy, which changes the distance between two points. You can think about it sort of like creating a kink in a piece of metal with a piece of dust inside of it, the kink then propagates through the metal by distorting the geometry of the larger object in such a way that the distance traveled by the piece of dust is less than the original distance between the start and end point of the kink. The reason this works has nothing to do with special relativity, it comes from the fact that if you plug negative energy into the equations of general relativity, you get warp bubble solutions which travels between two points faster than light could travel between the two points if there was no warp bubble.

A few years ago I actually read through most of the original paper[1], and worked out a lot of the equations.

Although I don't see it mentioned in the article, and I'm speculating here, the reason the approach described in the article might work out for photons is that negative energy has been discovered at the quantum scale in something called the Casimir effect[2]. The Casimir effect happens when you have two conducting plates which are placed very very very close to each other, then in the space between the plates, something which behaves exactly like negative energy exists[3], and it causes an attractive force to be exerted between the two plates.

A natural thing to try would be to harness this type of negative energy to create a tiny warp bubble, and try somehow to stick a quantum particle like a photon in it.

[1] http://arxiv.org/abs/grqc/0009013

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect

[3] http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/47922/can-negativ...

calhoun137··on What I Learned In College
The most important thing I learned in college was how to learn things on my own.
calhoun137··on If Kerouac wrote JavaScript
George R.R. Martin:

    function factorial(n) {
        delete n;
    }
calhoun137··on What Is the Most Surprising Result in Mathematics?
One reason to not have 1 be prime, is otherwise the prime factorization of natural numbers would not be unique. This property of unique prime factorization is not simply "convenient", it is used to derive a large number of other important results.

Do remember that math is a bunch of rules that are made up by people to capture certain abstract concepts, and to understand patterns and relationships between those abstract concepts. So although it might feel like a "kludge" to you, that's just the way math is. You can make up whatever rules you like, and some rules exclude "inconvenient results", leading to a deeper understanding, and thus are more widely adopted by other mathematicians.

calhoun137··on Startup Investing Trends
I'm not sure where you got the 3-5 years figure, but my understanding was that the fed has issued a lot of money that has not entered the money supply yet. According to [1], there has been a 259% increase in the monetary base, but only a 35% increase in the money supply. This is obviously really scary, since it implies that the dollar is likely to suffer massive inflation at some point.

[1]http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article40113.html

calhoun137··on The Strange Case of Barrett Brown
Isn't the purpose of a legal defense fund so that the person doesn't have to use a public defender? They are saying if you can't afford a lawyer, one will be appointed for you, and if you can afford a lawyer, then your money will be confiscated and we will use it to pay the lawyer we appointed for you.
calhoun137··on The Strange Case of Barrett Brown
This is a textbook case of extra-legal harassment. There was an excellent article of this subject in the recent issue of 2600[1], which unfortunately is not available online, but can be found in any Barnes and Nobles.

When an individual meaningfully opposes the state, they become a target of extra legal harassment, which includes attacks from outside the legal system, as well as within it. This includes things such as police raids of your home, intimidation of friends/family, trumped up charges designed to bring you into financial ruin, hit pieces in the media, and much more.

For example, $20,000 that was raised for Brown's legal defense from supporters was confiscated by the courts[2].

The entire purpose of extra legal harassment is to get a person to give up, and correspondingly, the best way to fight back is to continue doing activism, and to survive.

In this case, Brown made a major mistake by threatening an FBI agent in a you tube video. Perhaps if he had been less naive about the inevitable repercussions of his activism, he would have been better prepared for the campaign against him and would have known that his primary goal should be to survive and be able to continue his work, and that the worst mistake he could make is to give the authorities an excuse to lock him up.

[1] http://store.2600.com/spring2013.html [2] http://frontburner.dmagazine.com/2013/04/18/feds-seize-barre...

calhoun137··on Is it too late to be awesome?
Turing's Cathedral[1] is not a proper biography, but it's mostly all about Von Nuemann during the period where he worked on the early computer. I have read most of it while in the bookstore, and it's really good.

[1]http://books.google.com/books?id=6sElRNGXWFIC&printsec=front...

calhoun137··on Is it too late to be awesome?
If you really want to feel inadequate, check this out: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_von_Neumann
calhoun137··on Naomi Wolf: My Creeping Concern That The NSA Leaker Is Not Who He Purports To Be
This article is complete and utter bullshit.

Disregarding the obviously silly idea that he is a fraud because he is organized and well spoken, her basic point seems to be that since he doesn't have a lawyer present during media interviews, then Snowden is an actor basically playing a role in a news story created by the NSA whose purpose is to scare people from becoming whistle blowers.

Give me a break.

calhoun137··on It's not just metadata – the NSA is getting everything
Watch the video at the end of the article.
calhoun137··on It's not just metadata – the NSA is getting everything
Last month an FBI agent admitted on CNN that the contents of phone calls are being collected[1]. It was written up by none other than...Glenn Greenwald(GG).

One thing that has really bothered me since I become a hardcore HN regular is that GG articles almost never come to the front page, even when they are entirely on topic. I recall, on multiple occasions, finding links to places like Ars or a similar site which are basically just doing a summary of GG's latest article.

I really hope after the latest NSA revelations that HN will begin to take GG seriously, get his articles to the front page, and give him the respect he more than deserves.

[1] http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2013/may/04/telephon...

calhoun137··on "Microsoft engineer" on Xbox1
I should probably make a throw-away for this comment but whatever, as much as it hurts to admit it:

I kind of like windows 8.

calhoun137··on Solve This Math Problem, Win a Million Bucks
I came across this rather amusing discussion on google groups: https://groups.google.com/forum/?hl=en&fromgroups#!topic/sci...
← PreviousPage 7 of 10Next →