HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

canyonero

575 karma · joined October 26, 2015

submissionscomments
canyonero··on Google mandates workers back to Silicon Valley, other offices from April 4
Curious what makes you think distributed teams are less effective? I've personally been much more effective with my output working remotely than I ever was with the noise and distractions of the office. I've seen excellent productivity from my colleagues as well in remote settings, too.

It's unfortunate that companies and individuals, like yourself, can't respect the fact that others _are_ more effective remote and when they're not getting tapped on the shoulder by random colleagues.

As your GP comment pointed out remote vs in-office productivity likely breaks even. Companies should treat their employees like adults and let them work where they feel most productive and not cater to the preferences of upper-management or a desire to return to the status-quo.

canyonero··on MDN Redesign
I'll miss the old MDN and never had any issues browsing the docs there. The content is what matters at the end of the day, and kudos to the team for the redesign. I do have a couple of complaints though.

1. Font weight (especially with headings) feels far too thin. 2. Seems like there are some color contrast issues when running in dark mode (my system theme)

canyonero··on State of JavaScript 2021
Much of this discussion is about frameworks, technology and trends in JavaScript as a language.

However, I personally find it shocking to see such a huge disparity when reviewing the gender breakdown between male, female and non-binary https://2021.stateofjs.com/en-US/demographics/#gender.

Simply put, the JavaScript community is still not doing a good job when it comes to inclusivity. That needs to change.

canyonero··on Education Department Forgives $415M of For-Profit College Debt
How exactly does it penalize people who paid off their loans? I'm not following that line of reasoning. If you could pay off your loans, then that's great. You should feel good about that accomplishment.
canyonero··on Education Department Forgives $415M of For-Profit College Debt
Anyone in a privileged position is not going to be incurring tens to hundreds of thousands of student loan debt because they don't have to. The people disproportionately affected by student loans and are borrowing huge chunks of money to pay for school, don't have it. How do you see that as privilege?
canyonero··on Education Department Forgives $415M of For-Profit College Debt
> Debt forgiveness for student loans is a horrible idea.

This comment reeks of privilege. It ignores the fact that vulnerable people, poor people may have made a decision to to try to improve their future at a young age, say 17 or 18, and are forced to live in debt when their situation isn’t improved or worsens over time.

Loan forgiveness should be a tool that can be used to relieve suffering and/or stagnation in some circumstances. Hardly a horrible idea.

canyonero··on Discord is a black hole for information
I agree with this statement and am disheartened that the solution for communities (in particular developer communities) that is now winning is Discord. This is however not a new problem. Both Slack and Twitter are also black holes of information by design. Lots of interesting conversation, but nearly impossible to discover externally.

I think community maintainers are choosing it because it has the best moderation tools and community management tools compared to the alternatives.

canyonero··on Poll: Is the leetcode grind necessary to land a high paying remote job?
> Anybody with sufficient interest can find the time to get to a basic competence level in leetcode and system design.

OK. But, it has nothing to do with interest. It's time (which may already occupied with working long hours or a second job to pay off debt or looking after family). Who has extra time to perform leetcode tasks that have no alignment to day-to-day tasks and expectations. People with the luxury of free-time, thus attracting a certain type of profile.

> Getting real life experience or a college degree has got to be the bigger gate.

You don't just get a job doing leetcode. The experience and/or degree are table-stakes. The OP post is asking folks who likely already have experience or a degree related to the field of software engineering.

canyonero··on Poll: Is the leetcode grind necessary to land a high paying remote job?
> It discriminates against poor people: You're a programmer, you are not poor. Even if you were, the few weeks of time investment it requires is usually offset by the higher salary you can ask for. Think of it as an investment in your future. Or if you are not a programmer, the amount of skills you need to learn to get your first programming job is usually far excess of just learning leetcode

This comment does not acknowledge the experience experience of many people who grew up poor or put themselves into major debt because they didn’t receive financial support or live in economically disadvantaged areas.

I grew up poor and took out massive education loans to pay for my education. I still pay off those debts today. Does that mean I consider myself poor now? No, but my economic disadvantage has made me need to work much harder in other areas and I’ve needed to prioritize many other things over leetcode. I haven’t had the luxury of spending multiple hours a week to get “good” at leetcode

So yes, I’d argue that leetcode is responsible for gatekeeping people out of jobs who don’t have time/money to grind on it.

canyonero··on Poll: Is the leetcode grind necessary to land a high paying remote job?
How do you not understand that many people with families or other external obligations wouldn’t have the luxury of spending 7 hours a week for multiple months on leetcode?
canyonero··on Ask HN: Why does the modern web hate users?
Plenty of sites I use daily have nice features and reliability and while they aren't all perfect -- they help me do my job, learn and communicate. It's pointless to go down the rabbit-hole of identifying which sites I find useful or interesting with those that I don't enjoy using. Opinions will vary, but my point is that it's not in any way helpful to make generalizations about the "modern web" hating users. The "modern web" is a meaningless term that (in the OPs question) seems to define as the definition of "modern web". These two sites do not represent all modern websites in any way, they are mainstream content driven apps with the end goal of monetization, eyeballs, and user persona profiling. How are nitter or teddit not also the modern web?
canyonero··on Ask HN: Why does the modern web hate users?
I think this question embeds two assumptions that aren’t constructive.

First of all, it associates the “modern web” with Twitter and Reddit. There is more to modern websites and apps than those two companies. There are a lot of beautiful and useful websites that are built with modern tools.

Second, the question assumes users are hated. Quite the opposite is often true. We should assume most app and website builders want users to return and want to appeal to users interests. Designing with users needs is central to the practice of UX design and research.

I think this question could be rephrased to. Why do twitter and Reddit use perceived anti-patterns instead of good UX? The answers being they can be effective tools to drive ad revenue, increase time spent with the service and increase user base to name a few.

canyonero··on The burden of an Open Source maintainer
> Why there should be sustainability built in?

I don't think it should be built in by default to any software that is released open-source. But, I do think having guidelines for how software can be developed in such a way that doesn't lead to burnout.

The linked article pertains to avoiding the path to burnout, which if you are sharing code that an author a.) expects to "own" and maintain and b.) hopes other people will use, then you need should educate yourself as to how this can be achieved. Good literature on the subject is limited IMO.

> Not everyone should be publishing their code and definitely not everyone should be OSS maintainer.

I partially agree with this. I do think not everyone is up for the task of OSS maintenance and development, some of which is likely stemming because they don't have a good framework for how to do so sustainably.

I do think anyone should be able to freely publish their code if they like. Sometimes folks want to share things for fun or education or demonstration purposes, when they don't intend to accept or want PRs or contributions or downstream consumption or maintain it. There is value in OSS for many different reasons. I think GitHub in particular does a poor job of signaling to readers which software is sustainable and which is not.

canyonero··on The burden of an Open Source maintainer
I really liked an article on the subject of sustainability in open source by Dave Rupert. See https://daverupert.com/2021/12/sustaining-maintaining/

One of the of the points Rupert drives home is that open source with the goal of sustainability doesn’t have a framework in place that doesn’t lead to burnout. Everyone just learns lessons the hard way without any real manual for successful outcomes.

canyonero··on My Evaluation of SvelteKit for Full-Stack Web App Development
Long time React and Angular dev here. I've tried Svelte a few times now, hoping it feels better and something clicks with me each time I try it. But, I just don't get it and give up every time. I end up spending more time trying to understand the design decisions and patterns of the framework, and discovering Svelte packages that aren't abandoned/outdated instead of building anything cool or useful. There is nothing you can't accomplish with React or Vue based frameworks IMO, so it then comes down to taste/preferences/goals.

I do think building a meta-framework is the right call for adoption, though. The only way to survive and thrive in the frontend-framework landscape in 2022 is to provide first class support for batteries-included full-stack offerings. The community seems to be in a return to server-side rendering approaches and client-only SPA is moving out of fashion.

canyonero··on No code reviews by default
I could see this working well for teams that are engineering led and where customers don't expect a ton from the software. If you're trying to ship fast and get to market quickly, then fine, skip the tests, skip the code review.

Once you have lots of engineers shipping many different apps and need to work within and across teams. This system is not going to be fun. When a nasty bug ships and you're responsible, you'll wonder "should I have requested review for that one?" When one of your colleagues ships a few bugs that force you to paged during your on-call. This system is likely to erode trust on both ends. IMO, a no code-reviews model is going to stunt junior engineers career growth as they will not be performing what is common practice on software engineering teams. It's also going to keep out many other stakeholders who may wanna weigh in on the software you're delivering, be it UX, Accessibility, Security, Documentation, Product experts. Pull requests keep others on your team in the loop and educated.

I agree that this model gives you the advantage of speed, but I don't think it builds trust. I trust my colleagues and we do pull requests. I don't feel like I'm missing trust because I can't push to `main`. Code reviews have very little to do with trust. They serve as a communication tool and serve a tool to give the best possible experience for customers and provide an opportunity for alignment with our colleagues.

canyonero··on No code reviews by default
Yeah -- I LOLed at this one because I've caught at least hundreds, maybe thousands of bugs during review on pull requests.

It's weird and silly to expect prevention with tool that is not designed to prevent. Peer review (and the PR model) exists as quality control tool for many different aspects of someone else's work.

canyonero··on Search engines and SEO spam
I've been troubled by the just plain awful results being delivered by Google search over the last few years. I think these are just plain hard problems to solve and that Google is not incentivized to solve. Google wants you to click on ads at the end of the day, full-stop.

Often times I find myself searching for "best ($product|$thing_to_do)" which I think many other people do as well because we all want the best. Other times I'm looking for a music or a book recommendation with some depth. This of course nearly always leads to SEOd trash. There is no relevance nor is there trust. So, I like others to use keywords like "reddit" or "forum" to get to real humans who I trust and intentions are not to sell via affiliate links.

These issues often lead to the need in finding trust in real human-centered recommendations that stem from real human interests and needs. I've never found an algorithmic solution to this problem. This is why I think college radio stations or those south-of-the-dial end up being so, so much better. And why beer recommendations from your local brew-shop owner are better than anything you can find on the net.

I think building search vertical that are hand-curated would be very interesting to see. But I also think we need to build more communities which allow recommendations to be shared without an incentive to get hits via search and aren't paid for by large corporations and where community impact/quality _is_ incentivized. I do worry that those days may be gone and there are just not may be enough folks (not in tech) willing to spend so much time online and contributing to niche communities. A lot of folks spend much of their time in walled-gardens like Facebook, Instagram or Twitter, so it'll be challenging to be sure.

canyonero··on A Guide to Twitter
That's interesting. I've not really thought a lot about how Hacker News is social media platform. But it does fit the bill in terms of a virtual community for me.

I think of traditional social media as focusing on individuals rather than topics (like Hacker News or Reddit). Once you start giving power to individuals rather than ideas or topics, the community becomes toxic and unpleasant for me. Individual focused communities, where likes and followers determine value create deep centralization and power for those that wield it and frequently devolve into paid advertisements and/or product placement schemes. Topic based communities are of course not immune to toxicity and paid advertisement (as seen on Reddit). Despite that vulnerability, I've found the best social communities to be based on ideas and topics rather than those celebrating individual ideas/content.

I find the discourse and topics on this site to be excellent. It's absolutely my favorite site on the web. If Hacker News ever follows in the footsteps of Reddit by optimizing dark patterns for monetization, such as paid ads, I'll be deeply disappointed. For now, though -- thanks to all that contribute to making this site great!

canyonero··on There's never been a better time to build websites
The title intrigued me because it _is_ something I agree with. Speaking as a mostly frontend dev, it's been easy to experience a breadth of innovation and new programming/deployment paradigms. Lots of interesting rabbit holes to go down. However, I have trouble agreeing with some of the content from the author.

> Learning materials are almost unlimited

This is something that's hard to argue against. We do indeed have an astounding number of paid/free resources. However, I feel we have some serious challenges ahead of us, though. Trusting the resource is relevant and up to date is harder than ever. It's easier to navigate if you're an experienced dev, but sifting through the plethora of resources can cause more friction than not. To me this point begs the question -- is endless "free" information a feature of new web development frontier? To me it seems this is both a blessing and curse; furthermore, it's not exclusive to web development. Many fields have a glut of information, but the challenge is navigating through good/bad content.

> Frameworks are lifting each other up

I don't find any evidence cited in the article that frameworks are lifting each other up. To me, it's an arms race and it has become more cutthroat as framework developers have realized that they can build businesses on top of them. It does create competition to attract devs concerned about UX/DX and innovation.

Some of the best frameworks in the space IMO (Astro and Redwood for example) buck the trend framework/vendor lock-in, but the author only mentioned frameworks clearly focused on platform adoption.

> CSS is a solved problem

Hard disagree. CSS, the language, itself has gotten much better over the years. Tailwind in not the winner and you should expect that once a new hot CSS framework becomes available, all of the Tailwind hype-crew will disappear and you'll be stuck maintaining/refactoring it away.

Further, Tailwind today is not for everyone. It's not silver bullet. There is still innovation and trustworthy solutions in the space (CSS in JS, CSS Modules), but IMO CSS is an evolving language and not simply a solved problem. Avoiding writing CSS does not solve the problem.

> GitHub Copilot

I think it goes without saying that YMMV on this one. There are still many unknowns and mixed reviews on this one to say if it's a net benefit to building websites. It certainly created some conversation/controversy, but it's not really fair to say that GitHub Copilot make building websites any better. I'm still on hold as to the benefits on this one.

> Content management is limitless

No doubt there are more players in the space, but the author clearly stated bias. I'm glad that these options exist; however, I don't have enough knowledge to say what the limits are. Headless CMSs solve certain problems and may not help or be useful in building many different kinds of websites.

canyonero··on There's never been a better time to build websites
I'm amazed by the amount of shade I've seen lately being thrown onto SSGs and building websites with static HTML. Though, it seems to be permeating from folks that have a vested interested in having you run code on a (or their) SSR platform.

There are some interesting properties of server rendered websites and it can be the best option in some scenarios, but in others it adds complexity and burden on the end user. To suggest that static was a "fun diversion" detracts from the value and I feel we'll be going full-circle once again after we've realized that "what works" isn't always server render HTML.

canyonero··on Remix: On Rails
This isn’t how I see it really. It doesn’t make sense to label DHH as just a product guy. He is an engineer that designed a software framework.

The fact that all alternatives you see are done by engineers doesn’t feel that shocking because, well, all software frameworks require them to be built by software engineers.

Some are lucky to have a good sense of customer/user needs and the desire to build products too. Frameworks like Remix are thinking about balancing good UX, DX an what the tech of today can today and not simply solving engineering problems.

canyonero··on What would be your choice for setting up a new SaaS project for 2022?
I’d recommend you check out https://redwoodjs.com/ for the flexibility, modern tooling and great docs. Some other features included OOTB:

- Frontend In React

- Scaffolding code generation CLI

- GraphQL

- Prisma

- TypeScript

- Plug n play Auth

- Plug n play Database

- Easy deployments to Netlify, Render, etc

- Good community and long-term outlook.

Only thing that’s really lacking is the payments, but you should be able to easily integrate without issue into any third-party services like Stripe.

Good luck!

canyonero··on Two lines of CSS that will improve HN on mobile (IMO)
If any site developers from HN are reading this thread -- please prioritize some of these quick wins to improve mobile UX and a11y. Some small CSS changes such as those suggested in the Notion post demonstrate, these quick wins that don't require a full-redesign do make a difference.

Obviously, understand that your team may be lean and have other priorities, but maybe hiring a contractor to resolve some these issues would be a way to address concerns for those with sight issues and those browsing on small screens.

canyonero··on The Unfulfilled Promise of Serverless
> That’s what this article is about: Say what you will about serverless, it’s failed to live up to its promise and hasn’t proved to be particularly lucrative for anybody

Hard disagree. If you define lucrative as having a successful business model around serverless tooling/architecture or if your business is simply powered with severless services. Lots of folks have been had lucrative success without question.

Not only that, serverless has allowed full-stack web dev to flourish, so Id argue it’s helped some individuals build lucrative careers as well.

canyonero··on Ask HN: Is the Great Resignation in tech real? If so, why?
Yes, I agree that remote alone is not the complete picture. More anecdata: I work for a medium sized distributed company and we have seen a decent amount of churn. I have also been involved in the hiring process for backfills/replacements. Candidates have specifically mentioned that they’re leaving their current company because of RTO demand. The main reasons I believe causing so much job hopping now: RTO demand, money, new remote opportunities, demand for senior engineers, nature of existing churn in software business.
canyonero··on Show HN: Instant preview for static websites
Netlify shines in a git based workflow with teams (deploy previews on every pull request, collaborative tools, etc). For a solo dev, I can understand the limited appeal if you already have a workflow that works for you.
canyonero··on Show HN: Instant preview for static websites
I don’t know about Vercel, but I know Netlify supports drag and drop file uploads on https://app.netlify.com/drop

They’re ephemeral (only accessible for a day or so unless they’re claimed) and don’t require an account or repo.

canyonero··on The Case for ‘Developer Experience’
> It's why the Jamstack mascot is the loading spinner.

I know much of the HN crowd loves to hate on bloated SPA applications (and not for good reason, we all deserve better perf), but this comment makes no sense. You can have a fast website with no loading spinners, pre-rendering, static HTML and optional/client hydration running on Jamstack infra.

It's misleading to suggest Jamstack = complicated/slow/bloated and SSR = fast/simple/good ux. Please take time to understand your tools. You can build a brittle/slow/poor ux website with SSR if you don't know what you're doing and/or don't care.

I'd advise others to not worship one technique over another. Choose a stack that solves a problem for your users, demonstrate empathy, evaluate tradeoffs and things will be fine.

canyonero··on Ruby for eBook Publishing
I've been using mdBook: https://github.com/rust-lang/mdBook for a personal knowledge base in an ebook format and it's been a joy. Not Ruby, it's written in Rust instead.

It's very easy to customize either via plugins with Rust or by overriding template files. While the linked article is cool, it seems like a lot of effort to maintain such a set up. Then again, if you're a Ruby expert I could see this being worth it.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →