63 karma · joined January 3, 2012
The book itself is lengthy and comprehensive. He cites a lot of research to make his case, and the citations are available in the book.
With that said, I don't think calories in - calories out is wildly inaccurate, and I don't believe Taubes makes that case.
You should also probably look at surveys of language adoption b/c PHP has much greater market share. Hacker News is a very skewed sample.
Do you remember how much publicity Milk got without a single product and just from having Kevin attached to it?
Why is it absurd? What's your opinion about people that have currently been displaced from their jobs/industry (eg the auto industry), or any other long-term unemployed? Are they just lazy people that haven't found any other ways to create value?
Most artists and musicians I know make nearly nothing from their work.
Of course, you can treat this as an educational experience to learn more about what you need to consider for these types of businesses going forward. Just realize that proving you can sell a product at a low but unsustainable price point does not prove the product is viable.
Imagine if you were laid off and no convenience stores, chem labs, or whatever you could find simply didn't exist. Instead of weeks to get back to you, it took months, and the factory never called you back. Then, someone from an older generation started with the same rhetoric you're on now.
I'm not saying that's the case, but just as you want 20-somethings to have some perspective, accept the possibility that it could just be worse now even compared to the struggles you had.
On the other hand, Udacity seems more focused on a couple of core offerings.
You seem to believe that women deciding to be dominated sexually must be subjugated, and that her choice is a result of the oppressiveness of our society. Many women would find that view very offensive.
It also isn't one culture that permeates through all of programming. Go find a place with the right cultural fit for you.
Chances are you'll have to make compromises. Find out the most important things to you and figure out how to get there while balancing other considerations, like the amount of risk you can actually take.
If that's what he's going for, then it's workable, and I agree with you, it's a good market to target. But that's rather different from creating custom prototypes for $99.
For non-tests, students can and do cheat at regular Universities.
I completely agree that for this system to work, a verification/credentialing component is needed and I actually believe that the money will be there. Give away the lectures and problem assignments but make money off of more personal tutoring and the credentials.