HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

captain_price7

471 karma · joined September 19, 2018

submissionscomments
captain_price7··on Iran’s Top Nuclear Scientist Killed in Attack
Even if Iran did have nuclear weapons, does anyone honestly believe they would try to destroy Israel with it? I mean Israel not only have nuclear weapons, they are 10/11 th most advanced military in the entire world, with history of single-handedly defeating multiple neighbors combined. This is nothing but shallow rhetoric by Iranian politicians desperate to maintain an unpopular regime.

A far, far more likely scenario is Israeli right-wing hawkish politicians starting a war with Iran in the name of "pre-emptive" strike.

captain_price7··on How Academia Resembles a Drug Gang (2013)
As a prospective student from a developing country looking to apply for fall'21 cycle- not really. Given the stipend provided by an avg US university, and taking cost of living into account, my standard of living is likely to be lower in USA than in my home country.

There are lots of great positives about doing a PhD in USA- salary/stipend is definitely not one of them.

captain_price7··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
> people trust Germany more

What people are you talking about here? Western societies or entire world?

captain_price7··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
Not just Iraq war- Vietnam war (pentagon papers), Wikileaks, Snowden revelations- boggles my mind just how many people still have unflinching trust in their government, specially when a comparison to other countries come in. I don't know if it's nationalism or a hidden desire to feel superior or something else.

But given how these western countries handled covid, and the fact that China has a history of fighting viruses like it- I'd rather trust a Chinese vaccine over an American one, all else being equal.

captain_price7··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
America launched a fake vaccination campaign to catch osama-bin-laden; many villagers in surrounding areas are refusing to take vaccine because they have lost trust.

Western governments are no doubt better for their own citizens than say Russia or China, but we outsiders have absolutely no reason to trust one government over the others. Russia's vaccine has only passed phase 2- now that's a good point, "Trust" absolutely isn't.

captain_price7··on My Resignation from the Intercept
Peter maas' arguments seemed quite reasonable, but then so did the counter arguments of Glenn. Hard to take sides.

But that response from another editor Betsy was garbage- she threw around words like "offensive" and "unacceptable" and didn't even bother to explain her position.

captain_price7··on My Resignation from the Intercept
> Just go to original sources and make up your own mind.

But that's not an easy thing to do, is it? Even if we can do this one time, that's not sustainable. We need to trust somebody, and that's unfortunately getting lot harder.

Usually, I would put more trust on an established media organization like The Intercept over an individual, even though he's a co-founder. But after seeing (what I perceive to be) media's blatant disregard for journalistic standards, specially in last 4 years, I'm not so sure anymore.

captain_price7··on My Resignation from the Intercept
> Folks who aggressively advocate for the verification of authenticity of documents, especially digital documents, have a very good reason for taking the stance that they do.

And who are those folks? Liberal media? Didn't they publish that embarrassingly fake accusation against Brett Kavanaugh that he gang-raped Julie Swetnick? Didn't they claim mutliple times to find "decisive proof" that Trump (himself) colluded with Russians, only to be humiliated again by Mueller report?

It seems that the media's standard for "verification of authenticity" depends a lot on who, or what party is getting accused.

captain_price7··on 14,000x Speedup (2015)
I fantasize about coming across optimization opportunities like this in real life.
captain_price7··on Harvard, Oxford, Stanford doctors among leaders of global anti-lockdown movement
> My point is that "the lockdown" isn't causing anxiety disorders.

It absolutely is- doctors, scientists have been warning about it from the beginning, including ones who strongly supported lockdown. Trivializing it as "your personal psychological issues"- yes that's very unsympathetic. And it also betrays ignorance, you can't just treat mental health issues with a beer.

captain_price7··on Why the Arabic world turned away from science (2011)
I'm from a 3rd world Muslim country, I also agree that the number of people who actively oppose "western education" is extremely small. They are on the fringe even in the rural, comparatively religious society I grew up in.

It's important to remember that most people don't really worry about this kind of ideological questions, like whether studying in university is incompatible with Quran. Hell, most people don't even know what's in Quran. So at least in contemporary world, I think lack of Muslim progress is better explained by poverty and not through those ideological analyses.

captain_price7··on Why the Arabic world turned away from science (2011)
Not disputing you, just wanted to note that Shia Iran is doing far, far better than it's Sunni neighbors, which is even more impressive when you consider the kind of government they have and all those sanctions.

And while we Muslims undoubtedly carry the biggest blame for our demise- lets' not forget the west has real interest in keeping the status quo- a free thinking, rational government is fundamentally at odds with the fundamentalist dictators west has been supporting (e.g. in Saudi arabia) for past few centuries.

captain_price7··on Why most Hacktoberfest PRs are from India
I disagree. I think the key point was that most Indians don't even know what they're doing is immoral. And the post spends majority of its space explaining why this problem is kind of unique to India.
captain_price7··on Reddit – “Windows 10 prompted me to register to vote”
Fyi, this prompt was shown to a Dutch user, to register for US election.
captain_price7··on Nvidia RTX 3080 cards are selling for thousands on eBay, and people are pissed
It's not just bots, the supply itself was extremely low. Many redditors pointed out, using employees as source, some microcenters had a grand total of 10 gpus each.

This was nothing more than a paper launch.

captain_price7··on Physics is stuck
> What does physics need? The world doesn't know. Nobody knows but someone will do it, someday in a manner no one else thought possible or could really anticipate.

I think that is precisely what the professor meant when he talked about Einstein, not the person himself with all his brilliance and mistakes, but someone capable of revolutionary way of thinking to jolt physics out of it's current stagnant state. Which is specially important since, physicists have turned into almost religious believer of their own, untestable theories, and incapable/unwilling to think outside of that narrow box.

captain_price7··on Working in Public: The Making and Maintenance of Open Source Software
Fame, bragging rights, catching attention of potential recruiters....
captain_price7··on Impressive backyard engineering on an obscure YouTube channel
wow, thanks
captain_price7··on Impressive backyard engineering on an obscure YouTube channel
Are there similar channels for software engineering? I'm aware of Engineering Man, other than that?
captain_price7··on Bangalore has 12M residents and only 385 Covid-19 cases
None of the countries who tried to hide it really succeeded, like Iran or China. There is no reason to believe governments of India or Bangladesh are more competent in this coverup business than those experts.

I'm a Bangladeshi and I don't trust my government a singe bit. Still, I believe that while these numbers may not be exact, they are not wildly off the mark either.

captain_price7··on The death of corporate research labs
Isn't this what universities basically do with graduate students? They tend to be a bit older, the pay maybe a little less, but universities does allow pretty high level of freedom.

Of course there are lots of problem with academic culture, like overemphasis on maximizing citation count. But the setup you describe will also require some form of simple metric to track progress- to ensure that 25k isn't going down the drain.

captain_price7··on Why are Soviet math textbooks so hardcore in comparison to US textbooks? (2017)
I spent 6 years in one of those highly selective schools, and I have mixed feelings about this.

One problem is that Small-fish-in-big-pond-effect, a good chunk of us realized there that we weren't special anymore, there wasn't the honor and praise for being top- and consequently that drive was lost.

Plus, once some schools become well established and start to attract highly talented kids- kind of kids who can do well by themselves without much external help, the school itself, I mean teachers and administrators, doesn't have to be very good. Their success starts to depend more on their ability to attract talent, and less on actually nurturing and developing them. Past success bring more success- a sort of virtuous cycle.

captain_price7··on Cleaning algorithm finds 20% of errors in major image recognition datasets
plus we'll have to register simply to see a few examples of mislabeling...that was disappointing
captain_price7··on Make Linux Fast Again (2019)
I guess the shocking simplicity is part of the appeal
captain_price7··on Providence Lost: The Rise and Fall of Cromwell’s Protectorate
That last line is interesting. Can you please provide any links for further reading?
captain_price7··on Providence Lost: The Rise and Fall of Cromwell’s Protectorate
The article says things got worse not because cromwell was worse than Charles 1, but rather he inherited the mess caused by charles' policies and a country broken by civil war. Naturally it was worse for many people (specially Irish). But I wonder what would happen if characters like Cromwell weren't there at that time, Charles was allowed to continue bypassing parliament and ruling like a tyrant, and Britain turned into an absolute monarchy like France and Prussia. I'm not defending Cromwell. But I think if he was an evil, perhaps it was a necessary evil.

About Iran, while it's absolutely not a perfect country, I can not agree that things got worse for average Iranian after revolution. Iranians dead from starvation was a common scenery in Tehran's street during shah. Things did get worse for a tiny ruling-westernised-urban elite, who were forced to go into exile and now vocal in western countries against the regime, but for an average Iranian I do believe things got better.

Btw, I'm from Bangladesh, meaning I'm neither British nor Iranian.

captain_price7··on Germany tries to stop U.S. from luring away firm seeking coronavirus vaccine
Good point on Marshall Plan. But "Modern Europe nearly owes its existence to the herculean efforts of Americans" - really? If you're talking about ww2, Soviet union had a far more important role to play. https://www.vox.com/2014/6/16/5814270/the-successful-70-year...
captain_price7··on Coronavirus: Some scientists say UK virus strategy is 'risking lives'
Yeah, was thinking the same. Even if it doesn't work as expected for UK, it would at least be a good lesson for the world.
captain_price7··on Languages of the Ottoman Empire
An interesting bit:

"Educated Ottoman Turks spoke Arabic and Persian, ...,with the former being used for science and the latter for literary affairs"

captain_price7··on Google cuts jobs at cloud-computing group
OP prefaced by saying "outrageous prediction" - admitting plainly its pure speculation. If s/he didn't do that, that would be something that deserves to be called out.
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →