HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

carlisle_

1,089 karma · joined September 14, 2012

I'm currently an SRE with a history of operationally focused engineering roles.
submissionscomments
carlisle_··on Waiting for PostgreSQL 14 – SEARCH and CYCLE clauses
I'm always so impressed by Postgres' features and performance. I am unfortunately not as impressed with Postgres' operational model. As a disclaimer, I'm not highly familiar with very many databases, but it seems like Postgres sticks out as a poorly suited for robustly automated infrastructure.

Maybe I'm totally wrong on this, looking forward to reading other perspectives.

edit: If you’re going to down my post can you at least reply and tell me why? I’m asking questions to learn things outside my own perspective.

carlisle_··on A recent poll of employees who are working remotely
>People that work in the office will have casual conversations that exclude them, and they'll always be a little behind.

My experience is that this behavior doesn't get translated to remote-only workplaces. Casual in-person conversation doesn't shift to chat platforms, it just happens less frequently.

People being remote that miss out on office chit-chat aren't actually missing out on something if their coworkers can help it. I think these interactions are incredibly important for people who value them, and fear of "leaving out" remote workers isn't a very good reason to prevent them.

The most effective workplaces I've been at that have had successful remote workers are the teams that try to consistently involve those people. It's not a set of rules or trainings that makes people do this, it's a mix of cultural values and individual conscientiousness.

carlisle_··on Reddit's GameStop, AMC surge is the new Occupy movement
I'll take a ban to say this is the dumbest thing I've read all week congratulations.
carlisle_··on Facebook Says It Is Removing All Content Mentioning 'Stop the Steal'
This comment is what is called "attacking the strawman".
carlisle_··on Cydia, the original app store, sues Apple on antitrust grounds
>I see that it does harm developers, but that’s a different conversation entirely.

This is generally the conversation that's happening here. People talking about competition aren't talking about it as it relates to the quality of the product, they're talking about it from an economic perspective.

carlisle_··on How to Think for Yourself
Not to be rude, but if you googled his name you would have found all the information you could possibly need about why he’s considered important. For convenience here’s a link to his Wikipedia article: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Graham_(programmer)
carlisle_··on How to Think for Yourself
Paul Graham is in desperate need of people in his life that tell him 'no'.
carlisle_··on Americans Aren’t Making Babies, and That’s Bad for the Economy
How do people still attack the straw man like this and reduce everything to “communism bad”?
carlisle_··on Orthodox Privilege
This is such a strange post. Mr. Graham speaks in vague generalities, then finally hones in on a specific idea seemingly out of the blue:

> For example, how can it be that a large number of reasonable, intelligent people worry about something they call "cancel culture," while other reasonable, intelligent people deny that it's a problem?

Why “cancel culture” when there’s any number of issues this is equally true for? Why is it only “reasonably intelligent people” oppose it in this example.

This post just seems intellectually lazy. Making sweeping generalizations and then throwing in some appeal to popularity is not a well made point.

carlisle_··on California bans private prisons and immigration detention centers (2019)
They're not banning detention centers, they're banning private detention centers. I was confused at first too.
carlisle_··on Average adult will spend 34 years of their life staring at screens
This seems quite sensationalist.
carlisle_··on New 13-inch MacBook Pro
I use function keys extensively by touch. It's the most infuriating thing too when my hands drift while feeling for keys and I accidentally press a bunch of keys on the touchbar without realizing it.

I used a macbook with a touchbar for about 6 months. Never again.

carlisle_··on YAML: Probably not so great after all (2019)
Or you're just conceding that software is imperfect and trying to make it as error free as possible is the objective.
carlisle_··on Make Linux Fast Again (2019)
That’s why there’s no warning labels or disclaimers anywhere else in life right?
carlisle_··on An alternative to using Google Analytics on your website
Wow what a pretentious person you are.
carlisle_··on An alternative to using Google Analytics on your website
You mean at the very end of the article after they finish trashing GA?
carlisle_··on An alternative to using Google Analytics on your website
Your comment reminds me of this: https://rachelbythebay.com/w/2018/04/28/meta/

>"I am THE ONE. You only need to know me. I am better than all of you."

carlisle_··on An alternative to using Google Analytics on your website
>They’re perfectly up front and obvious about it, not hiding anything.

Wtf, this is the opposite of "up front." You had to poke around and figure it out yourself based on a suspicion. Up front means that they just tell you, no figuring out required.

carlisle_··on An alternative to using Google Analytics on your website
I really don't think so, I've never heard of this company I didn't know what they sell. I had to poke around the website and read the comments here to realize. That's really the exact opposite of being up front.
carlisle_··on An alternative to using Google Analytics on your website
If you're going to tear down a competitor's product and shill your own you should probably be up front about it.
carlisle_··on The Docker Compose Specification
I think you generally have the right sentiment, but some of these solutions are born out of necessity. Using containers at scale is really hard when you're trying to solve for optimal resource usage and resilience. These abstractions may seem crazy but other solutions are probably much crazier.

The other part of this problem that isn't applicable generally to other things, is this is a fairly unique problem to cgroups. By design cgroups don't have a singular implementation or solution, so there are a lot of "competing" solutions. I think some amount of unix philosphy is at play here, to do one thing (or really, fewer) and that's why it seems insane how many systems you have to hook up together to make the thing work the way it should.

I'm fairly devops centric, but I'd still take this with a grain of salt b/c containers aren't my area of expertise.

carlisle_··on I think Catalina 10.15.4 broke SSH
There's actually a good reason to not use SSH on a non-privileged port: It allows an unprivileged user to bind their own binary to the port when SSH restarts or otherwise stops listening.
carlisle_··on AB2712 – California Universal Basic Income
Good to know thank you.
carlisle_··on AB2712 – California Universal Basic Income
It doesn't exclude medicaid, that's a federal program. These are the programs it excludes:

> Medi-Cal program, the County Medical Services Program, the CalFresh program, the CalWORKs program, or Unemployment Insurance

I'm not entirely sure why, though.

carlisle_··on M3DB, a distributed timeseries database
That's entirely not true. The team was always forthcoming about the fact it was Mattermost, at least to other engineers.

Mattermost didn't work out of the box, and certainly not the way and at the scale Uber needed it to. I'm not overly familiar with the technical details, but one thing in particular stands out as an example. There was a Town Hall channel that every user had to be a member of. This unfortunately did not scale, and not enough ACLs were available to limit all the ways users could use this universal room. Eventually they really fixed the problem, but it was a tremendous pain point for a long time. There were a lot of fundamentally "less than great" things about Mattermost that had to get updated to work for Uber.

There was the amusing time employees found out anybody could change the topic in the room, even if our chat permissions had been disabled. It was absolute chaos for at least an hour, I can't remember if it actually negatively impacted the deployment though it sounds vaguely familiar.

It's pretty telling of employees that badmouth the uChat team. That team ultimately was trying to do what they thought was best for the company, even if at the time it seemed like they bit off more than they could chew. There was no other engineering team so directly visible and exposed to the entire company internally like they were. People dismissive of their efforts are generally not used to the difficulty of making so many very vocal customers happy all at the same time, and could be more sympathetic.

carlisle_··on M3DB, a distributed timeseries database
I think you're being overly dismissive of how much work that team did.
carlisle_··on M3DB, a distributed timeseries database
I accidentally left this point out. In retrospect it's easy to say Uber made the wrong decision to make uChat but it was one of few options at the time.
carlisle_··on M3DB, a distributed timeseries database
>It seems like Uber had too big of an engineering department with too little work to do, so they started reinventing wheels. Which is cool if they're willing to support them in the long term, but so far that hasn't proven to be the case.

Former Uber engineer here. I can assure you that while our engineering team was massive, there was anything but too little work. If anything most engineers were massively overtaxed. Whether or not the work we were undertaking was meritious and valuable is an entire branch of philosophy I'm pretty sure.

Part of the struggle at big companies is that a lot of existing solutions just don't work. Let me use an example with chat. A few years ago Slack was evaluated as a replacement for HipChat, since Atlassian's outages had finally started affecting us during our own outages.

Everybody wanted to go to Slack, but the cost of Slack was tremendously prohibitive and the state of the service then (as I was told) was such that it could not support a company of Uber's size. Tremendous effort would have been undertaken by Slack to support Uber and they didn't want to expend that effort for a single customer. This was late 2015 early 2016.

There were tons of options, but ultimately an in-house chat software was created. At the time it seemed required to make our own highly reliable chat, considering how distributed engineering teams were. I think if you talk to anybody without the background of how chat evolved at Uber they would think the in-house chat project would have been a boondoggle.

Not all over-scoped engineering projects are actually so noble. There was certainly a ton of "reinventing wheels" going on. There was significantly more "these problems are really hard and I only have bad solutions."

Though if the result is ultimately, "nothing more than interesting repos amongst a sea of interesting repos" sign me up.

carlisle_··on What 6 years of bootstrapping a startup has taught me
This blog post seems more like a marketing grab with generic platitudes than it does genuinely helpful advice.
carlisle_··on Why I Procrastinate (2019)
To try and provide feedback without being critical, the way you bold text from "So What's Up?" and through "Tips and Tricks" is very distracting. Since you use bold text for titles and the list items in that "So What's Up?" section, bold text is structural and serves a purpose to separate ideas. You overload it a bit by bolding long phrases you wish to draw the reader's attention to.

You use bold text well before and after these sections, when you're only bolding a few words at most at a time. Once you start bolding whole phrases your paragraphs start looking like striped lines. It was very distracting to try to follow your sentences when my attention is getting drawn to all the bolded text around me. It almost felt wrong at times to read the plain formatted text.

Your content was very engaging and I relate to it quite a bit. The illustrations are fantastic thanks for posting.

← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →