HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cartoonworld

1,021 karma · joined October 21, 2019

submissionscomments
cartoonworld··on Open Insulin Foundation
I know so many people who are or have been walking around with health conditions they either can't, don't think they can, or are literally afraid to fix because they don't want to ruin their family's financial prospects or go bankrupt.

Most recently, I ran into an old acquaintance with a back problem that sounds like a slipped disc, and this poor dude doesn't have the coverage to get the surgery and treatments needed not to be in constant pain all day.

Hey, maybe he's wrong and its a $300 quick fix, but he's walking around with the free uncomfortable treatment we have in America.

Personally, I think healthcare is worth it. We should just pay for it and reap the incalculable benefits of a more effective society that is much less burdened by disease and chronic injury.

cartoonworld··on Open Insulin Foundation
I worked with a guy with diabetes. Hes about to retire around now.

The company we were working for was acquired by a VC backed larger entity who offered much less in terms of benefits. His out out pocket expenses increased quite a bit as the new entity self-insured and even the best health plan had really high deductibles and the coverage was not great even after that. IIRC it covered like 60-80%, its a bit foggy because I could basically never use it.

He was using blood test strips and injecting insulin because it was the only thing that fit in his budget. We talked about it very occasionally, I asked him if he could get the electronic insulin thing that attaches to your arm and talks to your iPhone, and he told me about the coverage and costs and he really couldn't swing the out of pocket.

This guy was pretty advanced in years and had controlled his diabetes pretty well, but I saw the inconvenience and sometimes normal forgetfulness affect him often. His mood would be unpleasant at times, and I could see that he was often not feeling ok. Eventually, his doctor had an old tamagotchi looking leftover electronic blood sugar monitor that he ended up giving him for free, I guess it was old enough it wasn't going anywhere. His doctor thought the diabetes could be better controlled and took it upon himself to try to get him to upgrade his quality of life.

He used that for a while and it was a bit janky but worked, I noticed his mood and demeanor improve quite a bit for a few months, this also improved our work, but he stopped using that because there was some upkeep on it that was also not covered in our plan. So he went back to the blood-finger-strips.

I felt pretty bad about this situation, this dude was stuck in a job that even I hated (and quit, nowadays I have BCBS from an actually good organization) because the old, acquired company had a really good deal: Employee Ownership. When the firm acquired and consolidated that company, they took on the employee ownership agreement. This was a huge chunk of this man's retirement, but the new deal required him to stay on in order to claim the benefits he had been planning on retiring with for 25 years.

He could definitely have quit and made more money with better benefits, but he would have lost his retirement strategy.

cartoonworld··on Soldiers speak out about being blocked from repairing equipment by contractors
Yeah, the military contractors silo off the repair data and probably special tools, but I mean if it were really an emergency the Defense Production Act can compel the contractors to turn it over today. They can throw them in jail, too.

Not saying this is likely, but it is possible. I'm not educated enough to rate the probability.

Here's an example of this power being used to compel telecoms to spill some beans: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2011-11-30/obama-inv...

cartoonworld··on Soldiers speak out about being blocked from repairing equipment by contractors
In time of full scale war (or potentially whenever they want) the gov't can do whatever they want including changing the deal. This of course doesn't obviate your claims, because in case of all out war all the broken equipment contractors have been milking might cause huge problems. Also, it might be nuclear already, so who knows if anyone will be there to fix it, or even pull the trigger.

Regardless, this looks to me like a function of the huge $$$ that is referred to as the "Military Industrial Congressional Complex[0]", in which the mostly protected cost center of "defense" and of course those thousands of global US mil installations essentially milk these degenerate spasms of cash all over each others faces in the name of patriotism, service, the public, and whatever else.

Also refer to "War is a Racket" (1935)[1] by medals of honor recipient Major General Smedley Butler

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military%E2%80%93industrial_co...

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Is_a_Racket and https://feralhouse.com/war-is-a-racket/

cartoonworld··on My app just got removed with no prior warning
This comment, and the truth within it, causes me to think of Stallman.

Aside discoverability, usability and the messaging problem of selling libre software to Mom, proprietary software and walled gardens will just do this to people.

At this time in history there is not really a viable option to access the huge market of app stores with de facto monopolies of the app ecosystem aside from hoping some multinational corporation won't capriciously squash your vulnerable sapling beneath its crocs or birkenstock on its way to exercise some stock options.

The app developers are barely a blip on corporate radars, they don't see 10k users of an app as valuable at all--but this person sure does! Javier probably feels this as much as google, apple, etc would an antitrust suit. Probably more, as unlike them, he has not prepared a multi-million dollar legal defense.

Even though F-Droid is available and those apps are usable and often very good, individuals are basically beholden to this garbage!

Of course he doesn't expect to be treated fairly, this blog concludes that it is unreasonable to yank his side project app and that he has no recourse because of the way that the app ecosystem is. I don't know how these state of affairs can be improved, quickly, but I hope it is possible.

cartoonworld··on The humble water heater could be the savior of our energy infrastructure woes
It's controlled in the water heater by maintaining appropriate temperatures. No need to sanitize the fixtures when there is no growth in the tank.

All that other stuff assumes a minmax hot cycle in a waterheater tank.

On demand heaters work fine too.

cartoonworld··on Inventor harvests methane gas from ditches and ponds to power his moped
Moped is a 2-stroke engine, the fuel is also the lubricant, It won't combust on oil alone.
cartoonworld··on Tesla’s $16k Quote for a $700 Fix Is Why Right to Repair Matters
The damage was caused by debris yanking the cooling lines attached to the port, the cooling lines run out toward the wheel well.

It does look pretty concealed, I'm gonna have a look at one the next chance that I get.

cartoonworld··on Inventor harvests methane gas from ditches and ponds to power his moped
Wood gas was really common and used to power all kinds of lighting before electrification. FEMA even created and distributed plans[0] for a Gasifier in the late 80's. You can find the PDF all over the internet, I think its a pretty cool looking project.

Youtube is full of weird wood gas car projects such as this pickup truck: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9AFw3Agg7SM

I don't see how these could be street legal in general, but pretty fun.

[0] https://survivalring.org/pdf/fema_wood_gas_generator.pdf

cartoonworld··on Tesla’s $16k Quote for a $700 Fix Is Why Right to Repair Matters
Oh for sure, once these things have been around and there exists an aftermarket, there's going to be all kind of fixes and repair kits available once people figure out how these fixes work. I feel a lot more in accord with your comments.

I don't think its disingenuous or crazy unreasonable for Tesla to not support a repair like this, I kind of think they can't wrap their heads around it. Their service network is still very underdeveloped and they don't have the benefit of real-world repair data like everybody else. Their solution to everything seems to be "Replace the unit." It does indeed seem crazy that Tesla does service this way and has such a weak cooling port on such a critical component though.

I wouldn't be at all surprised to learn that broken Tesla windows come only as the whole door, too.

The thing about the plastic repair is for real though, brass is the way to go. Nothing will make it less susceptible to this kind of damage aside from protecting and anchoring the cooling line in a much less dumb way.

cartoonworld··on Tesla’s $16k Quote for a $700 Fix Is Why Right to Repair Matters
Man, that reminds me of the time I cracked an oil pan in my old MB 190e. I was going to a trail head for a planned hike, and the vehicle markings were....ambiguous.

I followed some tracks between two trees, but a wheel dropped into a pothole in the dirt, bottoming out right over a big ass rock which nicked the side of the pan, cracking it wide open. It can and does happen.

Oil pans are metal and can usually handle a gopher or a 2-by-4. They are also usually guarded by a subframe to which the motor mounts attach.

I don't know that Tesla uses glycol, which is pretty darn poisonous, I was under the impression it was HOAT, which is much less so, still not good, but who knows.

I can see from the video there is a large plate that was supposed to shield this part, that the debris worked its way around, yanking on the poorly moored cooling line, cracking the coolant port. On consideration this looks a lot more like a fluke, so your point is well taken.

cartoonworld··on Tesla’s $16k Quote for a $700 Fix Is Why Right to Repair Matters
The right move is to route the coolant lines away from harmful road debris or add a shield or deflector. If the coolant line is the protection for the case, that sounds like a big mistake. The owner is indeed lucky that the bunge snapped off rather than crack the case, spilling gallons of toxic coolant all over the place and resting his un-burnt flesh in the failsafes of this battery monitoring system.

It really smacks of someone who hasn't designed a lot of cars. Not that I have designed even one, but of all the things that can go wrong, coolant line damage seems pretty obvious.

Teslas are full of weird stuff like this.

cartoonworld··on Tesla’s $16k Quote for a $700 Fix Is Why Right to Repair Matters
Regarding your confounding over R&D -- Yes it is. I am on board with you that the specialized Tesla mechanics are gonna charge more per hour, $200-$350 sounds reasonable for a car you can buy and sell for %30 more than you paid for it -- But its R&D for this reason: The worthiness of Tesla repairs are totally unknown. These technicians are taking a chance (and I'll bet they offer a warranty, standard practice among reputable practitioners in the industry) that they can tap the brass fitting into the Tesla plastic which has an unknown composition to me and you and it will be a more or less permanent fix.

Just because it looks like 2 hours of labor doesn't mean there aren't other risks involved as well as servicing the battery cooling system properly. Such risks include: fire, poisoning, accidental damage, environmental disposal and cleanup, future warranty service, or even an unfortunate death caused by the repair failure causing the batteries to ignite.

If you get the Monroe to spend 2 hours on it, it won't work and I can guarantee that.

>You do realize that all the usual pipe fitting shapes come in materials besides brass, right?

Yes I do. The materials are designed to be compatible with the components in the system. This is why Japanese aluminum motors typically use EPDM rubber parts and HOAT coolant without silicates, to prevent oxidization of the channels and water pump. Throw some ethylene glycol or silicate/borates and natural rubber in there and suffer the consequences.

What will PVC do with the (speculating) polycarbonate body of the battery packs or the coolant(Another commenter claims it is the pretty expensive Zerex G48[0] wich will dissolve some plastics)? Brass is a good guess for compatibility, but why they chose that will cost you $700 to find out -- a bargain! I'm betting it's because available plastic fittings aren't going to have the strength to last in the reduced tolerances caused by the repaired threads in the plastic housing. Quite a bit of experience is really required to know if and how to do this right.

>> Lastly, road hazard insurance didn't cover any repair.

>Yes, this is reflected in my comment.

>[...]

>...For Tesla to charge an insurance company $16k with the justification of replacing the whole pack...

Edit: I see your point here, Tesla dumbery = costly repairs. Definitely agree.

Hopefully Right To Repair will free this proprietary information up to Alldata so anybody can pay a subscription fee and learn of the specifications and repair data. Also, it will standardize labor book time...

[0] - https://www.valvoline.com/our-products/heavy-duty/zerex-g-48

cartoonworld··on Tesla’s $16k Quote for a $700 Fix Is Why Right to Repair Matters
This repair is R&D that is definitely worth the price.

There's no way this is a $200 repair, that Tesla took up a bunch of shop time and their specialized technician for the better part of a day, carefully researching and installing this repair fitting. If you are charging $25/hr labor you are out of business.

If the repair fails, they will likely take it back and improve the fix.

Your plastic mystery fitting would likely not be compatible and cause a leak of whatever coolant is running around in there.

Lastly, road hazard insurance didn't cover any repair. Tesla doesn't do this kind of repair as well, leaving the only recourse replacing the entire part.

cartoonworld··on Who’s running the Vincere bot network on Instagram?
>There is no value add or special thing about the product; you could order it from the supplier yourself for much less

While otherwise true, I hate to say it but this point misses something.

There is definitely a value-add in marketing something to someone who wants it. There are tons of products (especially fashion) that people might be interested in but don't know exist. This is the most benevolent thesis of the entire marketing field. As scummy as marketing can be, there is definitely some value in curating a basket of stuff and generating a commission on the sales lead.

What the markup is, of course, can really color the palette, but I don't see anything inherently wrong with marketing. This whole scenario is a lot more on the astroturf side of the scale, but social media is a lot of astroturf in some respects.

cartoonworld··on Quarter-dose of Moderna Covid vaccine still rouses a big immune response
Probably redeploy the advanced manufacturing capital into other highly desirable state-of-the art biotech.
cartoonworld··on Solar is dirt-cheap and about to get even more powerful
30-40+ years ago they would flush it down the drain too. There are unscrupulous contractors out the wazoo, but today you will get your license yanked so fast.
cartoonworld··on Solar is dirt-cheap and about to get even more powerful
I don't think "absolutely minimal" is the correct description of the nature of A/C electrical demand.

EIA places the total percentage of A/C electrical expenditures at %12 in 2015[0], energy.gov cites it at 6% of the total usage[1]. This number looks pretty "meh", however note that A/C demand is highly variable, seasonal, and on a daily basis will spike quite a bit.

Contextualized with the annual data this is positioned within, the %6 usage is concentrated regionally, during the day, in the vaguely 4-month summer season in CONUS. Contrasted with heating electrical requirements, which operate more or less all the time in the winter (to prevent freezing pipes, and thermal inertia of a cold-ass house) and the averages of the electrical demand begin to look a lot different.

The relatively low aggregate demand is smoothed out of the highly variable nature of A/C load. Electrical load is immediately produced and consumed for the most part. An electrical grid will struggle to supply this peak-load demand a small but critical percentage of the time.

This A/C demand happily coincides with the times solar power will be most effective. It appears to me that solar is very well suited to augment the baseline load of a national/regional electrical grid to support peak summer demand. There is also some effect of the increased summertime temperatures on electrical grid transmission losses[2], but I'm not sure how all that shakes out.

[0] - https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=36692

[1] - https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/home-cooling-systems/air-...

[2] - https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/11/1...

cartoonworld··on Why writing software is not like engineering (2008)
This is a really great point!

In medical, automotive, aerospace, military applications, the software that goes into the device is kind of considered part of the object. It needs this validation for obvious reasons, such as the long lifecycle and critical nature of these products.

But in cellphone handsets, PC software and firmware such as in IoT home devices, and even IT infrastructure like SoHo routers especially but also other devices, there is no agreed upon standards that I am aware of. Even in payment applications, there isn't much there. Large institutions and banks get by often by using "legacy" infrastructure like mainframes to keep the COBOL stuff running, as it has been vetted over decades.

Going further, the architecture of infrastructure, firmware and software should be examined more closely. Recently, IT architecture has been exploited over and over (Kaseya, SolarWinds, MTA) having quite asymmetric effects. In the past it was worms and drive-by malware from janky websites, today it is extremely costly disasters that make the news but roll on bye until the next turd is flipped over.

The problem space is very difficult to define, since "software" and "architecture" are such general terms encompassing basically anything. I rate the difficulty in analyzing these problems for sufficient solutions as very high. When I consider neural-net AI applications, it seems to get even more murky.

Is anybody aware of other software and infrastructure standards that exist or are in research which could apply to more general fields, or to corporate/business IT infrastructure, or to home devices, etc?

cartoonworld··on Why Japan Celebrates Christmas with KFC (2016)
It's just par for the course for generic-ass buy-a-job franchise schemes. McDonald's afiak has pretty close management of their operations to counteract this expected behavior.
cartoonworld··on Uber and Lyft surge pricing drives SF customers back to taxis
Maybe you can just chalk "failure" up as a superlative regarding the doe eyed gushing public perception of this developing technology.
cartoonworld··on Uber and Lyft surge pricing drives SF customers back to taxis
Cruise operates in a very few markets for which their specialized self-driving cars have been designed for live testing. They have received special attention and care to have extremely up-to-date local information and are closely managed by operators. It is indeed very encouraging that Cruise is operating this local taxi and soon a local shuttle with almost completely driverless capabilities..

But keep in mind, this doesn't mean they work anywhere else in the country or world. What will happen to them in bad weather or some damage to the vehicle or a flat tire or navigating a scene cordoned off by police, or a parade? What happens when they do not have the meticulously groomed information? Likely, Cruise will manually tell the vehicle to avoid the area, shut the vehicle down, or take over control remotely.

Self-Driving cars are designated into technology levels 0 through 5[0], from no capabilities, to "simple" lane-keeping and/or cruise control, to autonomous with caveats

I don't know exactly which technologies Cruise is using to achieve their mostly autonomous taxi, as that information is worth the billions invested in the company, however from what I have been able to gather, they still use a remote safety operator in some instances. The safety operator can take control of the car if a safety problem presents.

The cruise cars in SF are essentially bespoke for their market. If you take it to Wichita or Maryland, these things will likely not be able to manage the environment. The self-driving capabilities are still unable to reach SAE level 5, fully autonomous driving in all conditions.

Its easy to look at Cruise and conclude, "We've arrived!" but I would still caution restraint, as it has been possible to operate autonomous vehicles with extensive constraints for many years, such as autonomous rail.

[0] - https://www.sae.org/news/press-room/2018/12/sae-internationa...

cartoonworld··on Kaseya Hack: Incident Overview and Technical Details
Kaseya doesn't have a CISO from what I can see.

CEO Fred Voccola retreived from https://blog.malwarebytes.com/ransomware/2021/07/kaseya-ceo-...

  We weren’t quite sure exactly what it was, but as third parties, the community, our own monitoring customers, we started noticing some strange behaviors,” Voccola recounted in the video. “Within an hour, we immediately shut down VSA.” 
[...]

  “When something happens, it’s how prepared the organization was, how quickly the organization is to admit something happened,” Voccola said. “Seek help from people and try to get focus on the customers and get information out there.”
That makes sense though, their leadership is laser-focused on successful outcomes and a commitment to their customers. It was their incompetent acquisition culture who cut corners on all the boring stuff, like validation, testing, assurance, quality, engagement with for-free security researchers. Their plan was to stumble into the dashboard and trip over the off switch, after someone else told them they'd been wrecked.

This is absurd, incompetent, immorally negligent and contrary to industry SOPs (use bug bounties, have a CISO).

cartoonworld··on Manual for a popular facial recognition tool shows how much the software tracks
I just want to add this to the discussion as well. From 2017, it is an adversarial 3d printed turtle that some recognizers detect as a gun:

https://www.theverge.com/2017/11/2/16597276/google-ai-image-...

Its dark, but I can envision someone giving a version of this bad boy to someone they would like to prank. Kids will be kids...

There is no need for this razzle-dazzle anyhow.

The more ethical solution is to add a beacon to the id card or bracelet or whatever you need to move around the school, like an EZ-Pass. You can use a shielding bag or turn them off or leave them at home when you aren't at school.

You can use human presence sensors to identify people in general and where they aren't. When theres another tragic shooting, you can failsafe open the maglocks or access controls except where people are taking shelter, and either track the person directly or track where there is a person without a beacon.

Then, give cops the regular camera feed for situational awareness.

cartoonworld··on More than 30 states sue Google over 'extravagant' fees in Play store
There are two very different scenarios and companies that both happen to be about exorbitant fees. I'm not sure about this but I think you can't really do the suit at once with two companies. You would require legislation for that, I think.

Apple also has a tighter hold on the app ecosystem, as well as the developer fee, xcode, no third party app stores, "entitlement" apis, etc.

cartoonworld··on The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020)
I'm sure they can relate, but the good alternative is probably going to involve thinking about something. Just consider how many people can't stop clicking phishing emails.

Our society has really turned the screws up wrt attention, it's pretty taxing just living life sometimes. I hate to get all "hoi polloi", but I mean people are out there that are sure Sars-CoV-2 vaccines render them magnetic.

cartoonworld··on Manual for a popular facial recognition tool shows how much the software tracks
I'll bet an image processor that can recognize guns and gunfire and dead people would be even better.

I suspect that people are drawn to "The Bourne Supremacy" look and feel of their command center, just behind the parent-teacher conference whiteboard.

cartoonworld··on The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020)
>Consider avoiding the use of stuff you don't control for important things. Be conscious when consuming free candy from a for-profit entity, even if you think your interests are currently aligned. But don't force anybody's hand.

This is excellent advice, but it doesn't help all the people who are not even in the same league as this idea, who are just making their way through the landscape using whatever they come across to not get herded further into the vortex of asshole walled gardens.

The value proposition of this to mom or some kid is gonna sound like: "What?"

cartoonworld··on The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020)
>it isn't clear to me why a unified messaging experience means that your real name will now be shown to other users. That seems like a product decision, rather than an inevitability.

They've probably noticed that Instagram has more marketshare with younger audiences and better engagement, where Facebook is full of your grandma and "old people".

If they can slowly boil the frog and make them the same, they have a much stronger grip. Its better to ask for forgiveness than for permission.

cartoonworld··on The cost of the “new way to message on instagram” (2020)
Yes, proprietary software is negative in the freedom dimension.

You have to realize that what your saying here is a category error: The libre alternatives don't have billions of dollars of marketing, engineering, market cap and users.

EFF here is trying to point out exactly what you are espousing. These kind of dark patterns are used at all levels to drive engagement, including sign up and retention. ("But ... How will I be able to talk to my friends if I delete Facebook??")

I can't recommend a solution, but "Well, its free, what do you expect?" is even worse.

← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →