HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cartoonworld

1,021 karma · joined October 21, 2019

submissionscomments
cartoonworld··on Towing a Tesla at 70 MPH replenishes battery at fast charger rates
This is commonly called power braking, usually called up in an emergency. It's a good technique that preserves handling. If you have RWD, your front suspension will remain more unsprung, in any case you can quickly apply the throttle to maneuver.

The friction isn't what's working here, it is the compression of the cylinders in the engine draining momentum from the wheels, think of it as negative torque.

As the forward momentum of the vehicle causes the rotation of the drivetrain to begin to overcomes the speed of the engine output shaft at the clutch or torque converter, torque is effectively being reversed. Instead of engine output pushing the rotation of the transmission, the forces invert causing the transmission to drive the engine speed upwards. Most ECMs will recognize the zero throttle position and cut off fuel, but older vehicles may not have this capability and especially carburetor fed motors are mostly incapable of reducing fuel delivery in this manner.

If you need to stop quickly and have the time, you can downshift even in an automatic, just throw it into 3 or maybe 2 while braking. If you have an electronic dual-clutch transmission with a "manual" mode, the electronic management controls will prevent the engine from over revving and causing damage.

Its important to keep the RPMs low if you do this a lot, if you redline, you redline no matter what your intentions are. I'd wager that running your ICE at 80-90% redline at low speeds for extended periods is also going to affect longevity.

There are other effects you might notice, such as additional bump and over/under steering as your suspension geometry responds to the unusual load. Also, other components will become loaded in usual ways during this maneuver causing some possibly unexpected handling characteristics to present themselves. Its good to practice this in a safe location, before employing it in the field.

If I may venture to say, it gets even more interesting; some vehicles are constructed in a manner where this happens all the time, the old school Porsches were notorious for an effect known as "Throttle Steer", a description of which exceeds the scope of this post, but a curious person will find several references to this in automotive literature.

cartoonworld··on Watchy: Open-source E-Paper Watch with ESP32
Fossil HR Collider is 4x the cost at least and is a commodity fashion accessory, this is a hacker toy. One should adjust their expectations accordingly ... I agree they should maybe compare to a defcon badge.
cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
If the US process nodes are older, larger node size, as we said and production is economically unsustainable as US production, but the customers are all in China, how is the tax credit for domestic US fab going to hurt Taiwan, Japan, Korea?

Wouldn't it simply help bootstrap domestic production and make the economics more attractive?

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
Well, that and the petrodollar's standardization of price in US Dollars following Breton Woods in the 1970's
cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
Really interesting, thanks for the insight.

Since I was a boy, I had wondered why we hadn't improved our launch vehicles, I saw new cars and planes and electronics and whatnot produced every year, but I often wondered why the Space Shuttle was still the thing we used "to go into space".

I learned about RAMJET/SCRAMJET, doted on Star Trek warp drives and fantasized about teleportation, I kind of never questioned that rocket lift technology might have just reached some newtonian limits. I've certainly never considered the total cost of launches and the reliability or weather considerations.

A 25% cost reduction from vehicle recovery sounds great, but I've read "Eccentric Orbits" and am now considering there are many additional factors in these programs. I don't know very much about launch economics, especially since there is clearly much to consider. Thanks for the perspective.

cartoonworld··on Spectre mitigations murder userspace performance
I have used NoScript for over a decade and I've been bitten by this too, but I've noticed that it has gotten better. CC processors seem to have encountered enough crappy browsers and broken JS implimentations that they've improved their services in the last half dozen years or so.

That said, when there's something old, important, and/or dumb looking, I usually spawn a new Firefox container (using Multi-Account Container plugin) and use NoScript's temporary bypass function.

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
Oh, yes. Don't get me wrong -- it's over!

I don't disagree with you either, it's another example of how misplaced development priorities can look like winning big until the handkerchief reveals a fat, dead rabbit.

edit: the rabbit stinks, too.

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
Its interesting to me that while in the US, we were spearheading the computer revolution with our cutting edge semiconductor industry, Soviet rocket designs remain pretty much unsurpassed to this day.[0]

There's a cool documentary called "The Engines That Came In From The Cold" (available on youtube[1]) and if you have a Netflix subscription, I recommend the documentary "Cosmodrome" (2008)[2] which is about the history of the Soviet space program and these engines.

I'm sure you're aware that the US Space program has been reliant on ex-Soviet heavy lift vehicles for decades more or less. Especially, since the Space Shuttle program was canned, if it weren't for SpaceX, the Russian lift would be the only bus on the route, aside from NRO launches and other um..stuff

Indeed, the Soviets had a completely parallel semiconductor and electronics industry as well. I don't know for certain but it was undoubtedly lagging western developments by a large margin. Nonetheless, the Soviets had some very interesting developments of their own, such as the Kola superdeep borehole. It is all terribly fascinating.

[0] https://sputniknews.com/russia/201704081052440303-russia-roc...

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMbl_ofF3AM

[2] https://letterboxd.com/film/cosmodrome/

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
Maybe, but the kind of fabs we have left in the USA are running older process nodes and I don't really see why they can't crank out lower performance MCUs and integrated parts indefinitely.

There's probably going to be a kind of sweet spot that develops for fab performance, it may very well be the case that most things don't need a 75nm node process, and it will be possible to squeeze a ton of value out between 100-500.

The 10-cent mcu surely doesn't need great RF and thermal performance. In my mind, the largest problem is where the integrators and product manufacturers are and not whether we can churn out silicon in the US.

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
Indeed I made a couple of typos.

But this is a great opportunity to observe some of the engineering challenges with these advanced manufacturing techniques.

Tesla Model S and X were constructed with alloy control arms (Tesla calls them 'fore links') which sometimes did not meet specifications, resulting in catastrophic failures[0] termed "Wompy Wheel" in the press.

I don't know if they are extruded or forged, I think they are extrusions but I haven't had a really close look. One thing that I've noticed about the failures is that the control arms have what appear to me to be unusually large rubber bushings. I don't know what conclusions can be drawn from that observation, but there it is. I would speculate that the largeish bushings provide improved ride quality. On another note, Tesla wheels were kind of weirdly large, with uncommon tire specs.

I've had the opportunity to examine some more resent Tesla suspension components and they appear quite resilient. However, YMMV, I am not an X-Ray.

[0] https://www.motorbiscuit.com/this-is-bad-whompy-wheel-syndro...

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
Yes, thank you. I made an error, thanks for the correction. Hopefully people watch the DoD film linked in op :)
cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
>The countries that are going to be hurt by these US semiconductor subsidies are going be Taiwan, South Korea, Japan ... not China.

I think I may agree here, and it gets complicated -- fast.

I suspect you might be referring to larger parts like CPUs, but you should take this excellent opportunity to investigate china's semi industry a bit. China has a very interesting local manufacturing economy of parts and suppliers that is mostly invisible to outside observers.

It's fascinating that in China, there is a totally divergent supply chain to support the cheap consumer electronics industry. Granted, it isn't CPUs. However, they sure are cranking out semis, its just that they never leave China but for inside of another product. The datasheets are all in Chinese, they aren't exported, they serve to support China's unique manufacturing culture.

Here's a previous submission that delves into this: The “terrible” 3 cent MCU – a short survey of sub $0.10 microcontrollers https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20686727

You can also check out Dave from EEVblog's 3-cent microcontroller[0] video about the same series of dirt cheap micros.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VYhAGnsnO7w

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
Yes it gets rather complicated, is Breton Woods good or bad, so to speak? Well, I'd like my non-irradiated cake and eat it too.

Its mind blowing how much that the post war era is still affecting current affairs.

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
There was a shortage of materials and manpower in late Germany, that is another benefit of the forge and extrusion process.

The alternative to forging the wing spars is to create a sub assembly from a dozen or more smaller components. The fasteners, drilling, and overlapping joints create a mechanically weaker, larger, and heavier assembly with worse material properties than a one-piece forged part.

In addition, assembling a wing spar from a dozen parts creates wasted materials from additional steps in the process (machining, forging, drilling, riveting a dozen parts) which takes much more time, requires skilled technicians, and decreases tolerances in the resulting assembly.

Machining titanium has different and worse metallurgical properties than a single forged part. You can heat treat the forged titanium part which has totally uniform mechanical properties, where in an assembly each part might have different inclusions and defects that are much harder to control for in process. This aids QC as well, as you can just X-ray the forged titanium part once.

So yes, they did, but its much more than that. The forged wing spars improve dozens of manufacturing, QC and engineering problems in addition to the material savings. Even without that, the forged parts are still a prerequisite for modern air frames.

EDIT: sorry, I didn't notice your edit. It may be that the market would provide these Heavy Press machines, and I mean the DoD partnered with ALCOA and other existing experts to build and run the presses, and the private market owned and profited from them, but in 1945 there wasn't a market for this except to the Air Force. That's why the DoD funded it. I'm sure the market could have also invested the absurd dollar sums, I mean the things are still used today, what was the total ROI on the Iron Giant presses... its incalculable.

But I'm almost certain today's globalized manufacturing would do what they are doing now: Make them in Taiwan, China, developing nations, and ship them across the ocean. The point is that the Air Force recognized the value of making the wing spars in country, so you can't bomb, flood, or capture the presses. We should definitely be able to crank out i7's on our continent, I don't care how.

cartoonworld··on U.S. senators propose 25% tax credit for semiconductor manufacturing
I know this is so different, but I can't help but think of the 1950's DoD Heavy Press Program[0]. I think about these special industrial monsters a lot when I read about semi fabs.

In WW2 after examining the components from aircraft kills, german wing spars would often survive. It was discovered that Germany used unique forged alloy wing spars to achieve their excellent aircraft performance, perplexing allied engineers. These wing spars' strength and weight is critical to the structural properties of modern air frames. Without them, jet air craft like the f-15 would have been impossible.

Machining these advanced alloy parts proved difficult, expensive, error prone, and impossible to manufacture but a die forged alloy wing spar was stronger, lighter, cheaper and beyond the industrial capability of every allied nation. We did not have the metallurgical technology to create such a large forged alloy wing spar in 1945.

After the war, the US and Soviets recovered designs for the extremely large press assemblies required for advanced air frames. In the 1950s, a huge national program was geared up to create absolutely massive Heavy Press machines. The Soviets had a massive 30,000lb press for these parts, and we created a couple of monstrous 50,000lb machines[1] that are still in operation today. These things are older than we are and still out there cranking out air frame parts today for modern air frames in 2021.

Without this kind of national investment in this kind of unique manufacturing, we would be unable to fly without importing 747 parts from wherever they could be created.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_Press_Program [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iZ50nZU3oG8

cartoonworld··on Starlink dishes go into “thermal shutdown” once they hit 122° Fahrenheit
I guess you hate Phoenix? Alice cooper, the Meat Puppets, stunning desert vistas?

People should almost certainly get over grass lawns, I know there is going to be huge problems with water, but afiact Phoenix recycles a huge proportion of their greywater, and this is a perfect use case for solar, molten salt, nuclear.

Hard to farm, I guess. Isn't there gold to mine too?

cartoonworld··on Starlink dishes go into “thermal shutdown” once they hit 122° Fahrenheit
Yeah the defrost cycle limits the heat pumps heating ability, but AC units have a similar limit wrt how much they are able to lower the temperature of the air. AFIAK they can do about 20 F. At this point you need to do some math and add additional units and run them 24/7 nullifying this benefit.

Geothermal heat pumps and good insulation solve both.

cartoonworld··on Starlink dishes go into “thermal shutdown” once they hit 122° Fahrenheit
Please. The whole point of Starlink is that it's suitable for places where there is poor existing infrastructure. The desert tops the list! They also have service area restrictions for sign up.

Just say Tesla dropped the ball on this engineering prototype and V2 will work on the sun.

cartoonworld··on Starlink dishes go into “thermal shutdown” once they hit 122° Fahrenheit
* This product is not intended for sale in AZ, NV, NM, TX, Parts of Utah, California, Idaho and the Dakotas in the summer, direct sunlight, and most roofs.
cartoonworld··on 80% of orgs that paid the ransom were hit again
Yeah this is a great point, you gotta figure that armored trucks, banks, military stuff, they all have functional physical access control, clearly defined risks, established value, etc. The person wheeling the dolly full of cash and the driver of the truck... well you know those two people are going to be handling bulk cash. The MP guarding the nukes is standing at the checkpoint. Check em' because you can just move on to the next person.

But in the corporate world, theres gotta be huge variance, but so many don't give a flying flamingo who's scoping out what, unless somebody is forcing the issue (and also auditing and reporting to the compliance department, whatever thats for).

They know the people in the NOC/SOC, the C-suite has equity, there may be physical access control, cameras and proxcards out the wazoo, but when Marge from bizdev needs those emails for the marketing newsletter or whatever, she is gonna get them immediately and hand them right over to the intern or vendor or Doug, whatever his job is.

For all the obscene value that the data and access represents, its encrypted, right? What could go wrong? Want to background check the sales people? But... look at this guy's resume! He's only asking 80% of the market rate! These dialysis machines sure won't renew their support contract by themselves.

Best case scenario is that the costs mount even higher into the stratosphere and people start demanding a second look. It's been a while, Maersk, JP Morgan, TransUnion, Colonial Pipeline, Beef, Hospitals, Schools, the OPM (for god's sake...) billions or trillions of dollars. It doesn't seem to be a priority.

cartoonworld··on Amazon’s HR Failures
I strongly disagree with this statement.

Stock pump is great when you plan to sell later, realize dizzying share price gains, enjoy stock splits, and take loans against your portfolio; that's how it works now and I get it.

But something glaring about this situation makes me feel rather uneasy. Since the market has transitioned from dividends to price hikes, the price performance is fully baked into the economic equations that investors count on for profits.

I can't help but feel something is untoward about the ponzi-esque mechanics and tax sheltering implications of buy-hold-sell-buy the dip-hold. Regular (not rich) people are much less insulated to market downturns and the big players as well as corporate officers are bound to value short term performance, stock buybacks in lieu of dividends, pr-driven policies, and doesn't this even further incentivize insider trading activities and concealment of environmental issues, HR abuses, and other externalities?

What is the real point of the stock now? It is so much farther divorced from the fundamentals of a business and tilted towards this emotional stock market yearly performance corporate raider stuff. Doesn't the stock market have to keep recording historic record highs, or else this all comes crashing down? Does it really matter at all what a company is doing so long as the share price climbs at a rate above inflation? Shouldn't the smartest move now be to buy mass market ad campaigns for "Buy AMZN!"? I mean, if you squint at it just right it looks like if that works, corporations would be obligated to do just that.

If its all truly this fake (so to speak) and its gonna be fine, aren't I an enormous idiot for not quitting my job, liquidating everything, and just buying and selling shares all day long? (I suspect the answer is yes.)

cartoonworld··on Survey shows people no longer believe working hard will lead to a better life
Its especially bonkers considering this exists: youtube.com/watch?v=DSSfRUxCsG0

Search terms: one arm bandit garbage truck

cartoonworld··on Survey shows people no longer believe working hard will lead to a better life
We should also notice that in the US, garbage collectors are routinely in the top 10 most dangerous jobs. It is extremely hazardous.

I imagine the overall health impact from this occupation is large as well, considering the weird stuff that ends up in the bin, biological factors, as well as exposure to transportation related pollutants (Carbon Monoxide, NOX, brake dust, all quite poisonous)

Consider these other factors while rating the pay.

cartoonworld··on “Great resignation” wave coming for companies
A long time ago I worked for a small family business. They built their business from the ground up, the old man started it in his garage based off of his industry connections from the 70s before being crushed by more effective outfits in the area. When he got too old he retired and handed the new outfit it to his two sons.

I recall being in an all hands bi-weekly meeting on one Saturday, one of the sons stood up and addressed the entire small company:

"I called around and you know what, we pay about average for the industry. Maybe a little bit on the upper side of average. You know, I could raise my prices and maybe pay you all more, but then I would have less customers. and If I have less customers then I can't afford to pay as many of you."

He looked around with an expression that I felt like was almost contempt, but really wasn't The industry is pretty low margin and they got theirs to be very good with volume sales and very good efficiency in processes. He felt the pressure to execute their plans to expand into another, second facility while remaining profitable enough at the original to fund their plans for world domination.

Every day they had customers waiting in line for literally hours for their turn in a crappy, kind of gross facility that had been cobbled together by these DIYers over a number of years. Every day they turned away customers in droves.

I thought to myself: Old man, if you don't raise your prices, you are a priceless fool. If you can't hire enough people to handle your amazing, envy inducing volume, _and_ you have the gall to exclaim proudly that you pay a little bit better than average, then you are surely and rightfully doomed to this mediocrity until you hopefully die.

What he said next only confirmed my young ideations: "We only want the people who _want_ to work here, to work here. If you don't like working here, well you should go somewhere else."

Nowadays they are still in business. They had indeed increased their pay by over 40% in the next couple of years. They opened their second facility years later after more years of project extensions and overruns, just in time for a global pandemic to shutter their entire operation for months. I'm happy they saw the light and realized what you have to do to attract and keep quality skilled employees, but I am for more pleased to be their competitor.

cartoonworld··on Could face and voice recognition become the new 'phrenology'?
Your math is wrong. You cannot determine who to search in this way beforehand because you think a certain group might have more contraband or crime.

Aside from the trivial bypass you would introduce, that will additionally cause the survivor bias in your search statistics.

Adjusting some proportion of searches to one group or another in this way will ignore the types of people in the group. What works from NYC->Las Vegas will be absurd according to your logic when applied to NYC->Florida retirement communities. It is drugs or bombs? The results will also look different in both scenarios. The correct solution is screening.

I have news for you about drug smuggling, its the 21 year old who are caught. You should probably just let them have their MDMA.

It is all destined to be absurd, however; in the movie theater hypothetical, searching some percentage of 21 year old men is uselessly ineffective. What is the ratio of movie theater attendees to movie theater shooters? It's on the order of homeopathy. The logic and methodology in this is so tragically flawed.

> This kind of reasoning results in ... ineffective solutions (security theater)

You missed the important parts.

cartoonworld··on Could face and voice recognition become the new 'phrenology'?
>This isn't a valid argument for exactly equal resource allocation across demographics.

It is if your goal is to intercept contraband. Previous contraband seizure statistics will be skewed by survivor bias. Currently, in airports, everybody and every bag passes through an x-ray or metal detector. Airport or venue search policy is unable to affect demographics.

This kind of reasoning results in a spiral of paranoia and ineffective solutions (security theater) which is much worse than a waste of time and resources. This collective suspicion breeds the kind of resentment and distrust which I would argue contribute to the very problems they are purported to solve.

cartoonworld··on Could face and voice recognition become the new 'phrenology'?
I'd say Yes and Yes.

Granting the security theater, If your searches aren't random you introduce a trivial way to bypass the searches. A bad actor simply has to con the contraband onto an unsuspecting low-risk passenger to convert his chances to a much higher success rate.

wrt health insurance, we should properly note that health insurance doesn't exist. It is not insurance but some kind of health care subscription. I am of course speaking as US citizen. A more useful analogy might be life insurance.

The negative societal byproduct of marginalizing certain groups is clearly not justified, it is the resource wastage.

cartoonworld··on Legislation would unmask third-party sellers, but Amazon is fighting it
This is currently a big pain in the butt for me.

I sometimes buy specialized tools and equipment from Amazon due to the convenience of Amazon's great catalog and suggestion system, it can be quite useful.

However, sometimes I receive items that are clearly B-stock, returns, mislabeled defective, improperly packaged, etc from these third party sellers who "win the buy box".

The subtle difference between useful and completely useless is really hard to demonstrate to someone who is not familiar with the usage and normal appearance of these products.

When I have a problem with some of these specialized industrial products I often cannot simply return them for service or warranty to the reseller, I am required to return them to the authorized reseller (Amazon is often one of these) for warranty service.

The problem with this is that the manufacturer often only warranties their product when sold from their authorized reseller. Even though Amazon may be an official reseller affiliate, the third party reseller that I purchased it from (again, FBA, but sold by GUYA JICKSV LLC) is not on this list!

In order to get the warranty service I now have to go to the manufacturer, who is wary of theft, counterfeit, returns, and a really surprising number of times I discover that there is a part missing or duplicate parts, and this renders the warranty void.

Dealing with the manufacturers in these situations is really annoying and often fruitless. To them its just one unit and they do industrial sales volume, but to me it is several hundred dollars and days of hassle. This costs me much more money than the cost of replacing the thing.

I am now very wary of buying certain types of products from Amazon, as they often appear to be sold by Amazon, but is actually not sold by Amazon, but only technically sold by amazon because of this buy box behavior.

Its is incredibly opaque, error prone, and nobody cares except me and my customers (with whom I sure do have a relationship, unlike the Amazon seller does with me.) As a result, I have reduced my purchasing from Amazon. Cest la vie.

cartoonworld··on Avoid buying in HOA neighborhoods (2014)
The color (and much more importantly the condition) of your house certainly does affect someone else.
cartoonworld··on Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup
DCSS is one of the best managed roguelikes out there. The Webtiles client has been getting some new art tiles in the trunk branch as well. You can spectate on any player's game more of less, I have enjoyed peeking at high level play on some of the bigger servers
← PreviousPage 9 of 13Next →