HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cataphract

954 karma · joined May 30, 2014

submissionscomments
cataphract··on Microsoft offers mass buyouts for roughly a quarter of its workforce
You are missing the point. You're allowed to think highly or lowly of whomever, for whatever reason. That's your business (freedom of thought). It's more problematic when you express, overtly or not, such low opinion, as you will cause resentment. And there is the risk that the mere request is seen as a "correction". In our society, it's not generally polite for adults to correct other adults' speech.

I would also take issue with reasonableness of the request. You concede it does not offend you, and that it's merely a preference. I also have a myriad of preferences about speech: the intonation, accent, the grammatical constructions, the words, etc. To ask of other people, whom I don't even know intimately, to match my preferences is something else altogether. It's to impose my preferences over that person's dialect or ideolect, which is also rightly frowned upon.

cataphract··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
He, I never really got a satisfactory explanation as to why she started (I think it some objections to the meat industry), and or to why she changed her mind. It's certainly more convenient, since vegetarian options in traditional restaurants are basically nonexistent. But the trigger was a desire to sample the local cuisine when travelling. Started with fish, then birds, then, in Valencia, where it's traditional in paella, rabbit.
cataphract··on The 1.5°C goal of the Paris Agreement is no longer viable
I'm glad it works for you. I've rarely tasted a vegetarian dish I really liked except maybe chili made with granulated soy protein rather than minced meat.

My girlfriend was vegetarian for many years, and she put the effort to make tasty dishes (tofu, specifically, always had some marinade). Once she started eating meat again though (and we're talking only white meat like chicken, rabbit, duck, not pork/beef), she almost never eats a vegetarian dish.

cataphract··on Composite objects and C++26 the std:polymorphic type
Yes, the article covers this (mentions the std::variant). This makes it a closed set though. Other differences is that your Event here is as big your biggest event type, and it doesn't go through normal inheritance mechanisms. With polymorphic you could just have an abstract Event and implement your subclasses normally.

A way to see it is some sort of type-erasure over destruction and copy-construction (plus another corner case for mismatched allocators).

The constructor of polymorphics captures the type of the subclass during its constructor (they didn't make the same mistake as with shared_ptr of giving it a pointer constructor, like the UB in case the destructor is not virtual in Base *b; shared_ptr<Base> sp{b}). With this, it can instantiate a template (a control block) where the subclass is known.

cataphract··on Rabbits were a medieval royal luxury in England until the Black Death
Around Lisbon, it's usually stewed with red wine and tomato and spices (coelho à caçador). It can also be fried or grilled but I rarely see it cooked that way.

It's the kind of meat that is, generally speaking, better prepared in more rustic versions as you move inland, though -- see e.g. [1], where it's cooked in clay, together with kidneys, heart, liver, and the head.

[1]: https://maps.app.goo.gl/imK78soKt6ruLNZH6

cataphract··on Were software engineers blue-collar workers all along?
That really doesn't speak to the usefulness of the distinction. To the extent that workers, as a whole, have common goals (like capturing a bigger share of the productivity gains, for instance), it probably make sense to organize as a single group to pursue those goals.

The right also organizes humans into us-vs-them: the natives versus the immigrants, the faithful versus the infidels, and so on. Whether those make sense depends only on the values, way of living or material conditions you want to protect and whether the other group is a menace to them.

cataphract··on Your Big Mac might cost more if McDonald's AI thinks people nearby can afford it
Can't they just do it with personalized discounts and other loyalty programs? That's what everyone's doing around here.
cataphract··on U.S. appeals court upholds designation of Anthropic as supply chain risk
You mean like pharmaceutical companies refusing to supply chemicals for lethal injection?
cataphract··on Mom gets 6-month suspended sentence for letting 5-year-old walk to the pond
Really depends on the kind of upbringing of the child. In Mongolia 5 year olds are teaching their younger siblings how to ride a reindeer.
cataphract··on Mark Zuckerberg attacks 'closed' AI rivals as Meta returns to open models
Only the AI labs are really interested in closed models. Google, Facebook, Microsoft, ... they'd rather go back to doing stock buybacks and being ridiculously profitable rather than raising capital for all this research and datacenters. They only do it because they think they have to.
cataphract··on I made tinnitus my friend, then it disappeared [video]
I have both as well. Floaters are mildly annoying, but at least when you lie in bed at night you don't see them in the dark.
cataphract··on We replaced Redis with MySQL for inventory reservations and it scaled
In every AI-written post, we have the script: some top post complaining it's AI-written, someone cluelessly saying they don't see it, and another person pointing out the claudisms. Sometimes someone posts a link to pangram.

I think we need the moderation team to set up some policy. In which direction idk.

cataphract··on Not hiring junior engineers won't solve the problem you think you have
Right, SO was always better at answering beginner questions then advanced ones, except if the complex question had a broad appeal. Part of it is because the format is not good for asking a context-heavy question. Another part because you were dependent on the pool of people answering, and the more niched the question was (using a library not very popular, for instance) or the more expertise it required, the less likely you were to find someone.
cataphract··on C++ float-to-int conversion can be undefined behavior
I appreciate the correction. Although it should be said that modern implementations tend to opt to assume that UB never happens.
cataphract··on C++ float-to-int conversion can be undefined behavior
Undefined behavior is not the same as implementation-defined or unspecified behavior. A program with undefined behavior is by definition an incorrect program. But there are cases where the spec actually gives some margin to the implementation. Programs relying on the choices of the implementation may be correct, even if non-portable.
cataphract··on Why we write our own C and C++ inference engines
Just from the subtitle, you can already tell it's likely AI-generated. Maybe you're lucky enough not to be exposed to claude/codex output your whole working day.
cataphract··on 'Crush this lady': how eBay harassment campaign led to $56M payout
I don't think that's the lesson. What I take from that is that people adapt to norms and incentives they have.

Despite all the talk about "academic integrity" and whatnot, very rarely were there punishments for people who cheated. For every professor that wrote FRAUD in the grade sheet and escalated to the Disciplinary Committee, there were 100 that turned a blind eye or at most confiscated a paper being passed around when the exam was being administered. This hypocrisy irked me much more than the cheating itself, in which I didn't partake mostly because 1) I thought it was kind of beneath me, something only mediocre students did (which I came to realize was not really true) and 2) I didn't care that much about the grade.

cataphract··on Has the New Cocaine Arrived?
Caffeine withdrawal symptoms don't last more than 1-2 weeks. And we're talking about headaches, feeling sluggish... not dying, like other drugs.
cataphract··on UEFA and its national associations will not participate in FIFA competitions
That's a stretched interpretation. The first sentence says the interval does not exceed 15 minutes. The most natural way to read the last sentence is that the competition rules state how long the half-time is under those parameters (i.e., the rules can state that the interval is 10 minutes, but not 1 hour); likewise, the referee can allow the competition organizers to change the duration of the interval -- the competition rules notwithstanding --, but still within the parameters of the 1st sentence.
cataphract··on 2x, not 10x: coding with LLMs in 2026
Producing the desired output is the purpose of the program, but it's not the only consideration: there's performance, maintainability, security, and so on.
cataphract··on UEFA and its national associations will not participate in FIFA competitions
So it's OK if FIFA breaks the rules of the game "only in the final"? (yes, I know FIFA says they didn't but their reading of Law 7.2 is not plausible)
cataphract··on UEFA and its national associations will not participate in FIFA competitions
One of the least corrupt countries, whose attorney general had secret meetings with Infantino when in charge of an investigation of corruption in FIFA.
cataphract··on The new rules of context engineering for Claude 5 generation models
Yes, which maybe is a disadvantage because it limits the speed I read to the speed I can articulate the words in my head. But most of the time I'm not consciously aware of it, just like people who go one step further and move their lips are usually not aware (I assume).
cataphract··on AI companies are shredding rare books
The post doesn't call for the sympathy for the publishers, so I'm not sure what you're responding to.
cataphract··on The new rules of context engineering for Claude 5 generation models
What about when you're reading? You don't have a voice in your head saying the words?
cataphract··on Judge approves $1.5B Anthropic settlement for pirated books used to train Claude
It's not a small fine. It's much more than what each title could be bought for in the market.
cataphract··on Judge approves $1.5B Anthropic settlement for pirated books used to train Claude
> But if I'm reading the ruling correctly, Anthropic might have been fine even with feeding pirated books into their LLM (as long as they planned to eventually deleted them afterwards)

The court says otherwise.

> Such piracy of otherwise available copies is inherently, irredeemably infringing even if the pirated copies are immediately used for the transformative use and immediately discarded.

Then it says it doesn't need to decide on that basis because they kept it not just for training LLMs, but also for building a central library. Which seems a bit ridiculous, because the sole purpose of the central library is to train LLMs.

cataphract··on Apple defeats liability for not scanning iCloud for CSAM
It surely is, but that doesn't change the fact that many cases are not about distribution and the harm is frequently more of a legal fiction, unless by harm you mean something other than suffering inflicted on the victims. I don't necessarily think it's wrong for society to ban certain acts on purely moral grounds (another example: incest between siblings), but let's not pretend it's something else going on.

> Non-consented distribution of sexual images (eg: revenge porn) is also a crime.

There is very compelling empirical evidence that this causes actual harm (suicide ideation in a very big fraction of the victims), even if it is fictional, so here there is no question about the harm.

cataphract··on Apple defeats liability for not scanning iCloud for CSAM
Like when Google got tired of handling geofencing warrants.
cataphract··on Hacker wipes Romania's land registry database
> If you purchased a piece of land and that wasn't recorded in the registry, you are SOL because registration is what conveys title.

Sort of. The registration is what provides opposability against third parties. But between buyer and seller, the transfer of ownership happens by the contract itself. You'll have a harder time against creditors of the seller placing liens on the property, or other people claiming to be owners (e.g. if they bought the foreclosed property); how hard a time depends on the country.

And there may be still be encumbrances/claims to the property that are not subjection to registration like adverse possession or rental agreements that can be asserted against the buyer and for which the buyer's only option is to sue to the seller.

Page 1 of 10Next →