HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

catshirt

2,358 karma · joined July 29, 2010

submissionscomments
catshirt··on Electron is flash for the desktop (2016)
yep definitely. and there is definitely a cost and effort required to make Electron feel as good as native. depending on your feature requirements, this can get really hairy.

i'm just exhausted by the "web apps feel so much worse than native!1" argument which is an over simplification and not a rule.

catshirt··on Electron is flash for the desktop (2016)
seriously. and skype is a grand example of how shitty a native client can be.

tired of this argument. if you put in the proper effort, your users won't care or notice.

catshirt··on Is Matter Conscious?
great analogy. also does a good job pointing out the type of vagueness and subjectivity in meaning that makes it hard to pin down consciousness.

the vagueness- which parts can you remove from a car before you wouldn't call it a car anymore?

the subjectivity- which parts can you remove from a car before I wouldn't call it a car anymore?

bald is another funny example of emergence (though not my own). how many hairs must one grow before they are no longer bald?

catshirt··on Is Matter Conscious?
for our purposes, to solve is to understand.

is there a single physical process or entity we can attribute consciousness to?

our high level understanding of consciousness is that it at some point emerges from physical processes.

this emergence is the interesting problem that we have essentially no grasp on.

we obviously have broad understanding of emergence, and pragmatic intuitive applications of it, but consciousness is not one of them.

if we understood when, where, how, or why consciousness emerges, we'd be intriguingly close to creating it.

I mean, you are making claims (roughly "we understand consciousness"). And I am just asking for some research that supports this.

catshirt··on Is Matter Conscious?
a name of any person or paper which claims to have solved consciousness is probably sufficient.
catshirt··on Is Matter Conscious?
just because these things can conceive consciousness does not make them consciousness.

unless you can tell me exactly why and when in these processes consciousness arises, were not having the same conversation.

catshirt··on Is Matter Conscious?
we're on the same page. and you shine some light on OPs point that I now see more truth to- poetry parading as science.
catshirt··on Is Matter Conscious?
good point! I just don't want the false positives to discourage us from trying to share our feelings just because it's difficult.
catshirt··on Is Matter Conscious?
"I think it's well understood how consciousness works"

care to expand on this at all? it completely contradicts most everything I've heard.

saying consciousness is just a neural reaction could be right but it's by no means an understanding.

catshirt··on Is Matter Conscious?
I'm reminded of people talking about tripping. we don't really have the vocabulary or knowledge to talk about certain things and they end up sounding wishywashy.

but I don't think it means we can't try, or hypothesize...

catshirt··on New York City bans employers from asking potential workers about past salary
i'm not saying it has to be true, but there is more incentive to create a fresh account to post that information than there is incentive to lie about it.
catshirt··on Fact Check now available in Google Search and News
can someone fact check this?
catshirt··on New York City bans employers from asking potential workers about past salary
care to share your position and some discreet information about the company (size, industry?)
catshirt··on Glimmer – Fast and light-weight UI components
i'm less concerned with what "looks" easier than what's actually easier.

i just can't convince myself "it looks less scary" is worthy of the technical tradeoffs (for me, at the very least).

catshirt··on Glimmer – Fast and light-weight UI components
"The fact that Glimmer templates are "just HTML" makes them accessible to people like designers who may not understand all of the fancy destructuring or array mapping happening in your JSX."

isn't this like, at least a little backwards? JSX is HTML and JS. templating languages are HTML with some custom DSL.

destructuring and especially mapping are pretty simple concepts. creating a new syntax to cater to people who couldn't learn one in the first place seems counterintuitive?

is teaching someone a for loop really at all (let alone significantly) easier than teaching them to map an array?

edit: "creating a new syntax to cater to people who couldn't learn one in the first place seems counterintuitive?" on second read this seems thoughtless. isn't that almost the whole point of a DSL? i think you and i have convinced myself to stop hating on templates.

catshirt··on A researcher's response to people pointing out 150 errors in four of his papers
you got the question backwards.

if enough subjects don't care about confidentiality you could use only them and publish the data.

catshirt··on A linguist on Arrival's alien language (2016)
hm. well, i can't argue. i'm not the expert on the aliens we haven't found yet.
catshirt··on A linguist on Arrival's alien language (2016)
seemed like joke not a criticism. I laughed.
catshirt··on Deep Photo Style Transfer
no, don't, please. programming is a means to an end.

programming is fun the same way long division by hand is fun.

i can't wait for the robots to release me from the monotony.

catshirt··on StarCraft: Remastered to be released Summer 2017
> For a few years I followed SC2's e-sports scene, but my interest slowly died out.

if it's any consolation your interest died with the game. :(

still one of the greatest games of all time. just always had a hard time finding traction in the west where players and fans seem to prefer games like Dota/CS. i'm not sure why exactly.

catshirt··on FBI Arrests Man For Allegedly Sending Journalist Seizure-Causing GIF
hm. i think we're seeing eye to eye. you seem more willing to speculate but that is not an offense. the only points i wanted to make are:

1. first amendment does not mean you can say or do whatever you wish 2. if the we can assume the facts are correct, the guy should be punished accordingly

which, if i understand correctly, are two points you'd not even disagree with, barring any new evidence.

catshirt··on FBI Arrests Man For Allegedly Sending Journalist Seizure-Causing GIF
to get this out of the way: if he lied, that is a completely different subject. nor is it for us to judge. nor am i interested in speculating.

> It's not reasonable to introduce additional first amendment restrictions or award damages in response to targeted prank tweets by internet trolls.

the medium is irrelevant. the first amendment does not cover all forms of expression and speech. period, man.

> Why wouldn't he take precautions if he knew using a computer could cause a seizure?

it's like saying, why cross the street if you know you can get hit by a car? obviously there is a statistical difference, but that would suggest a slippery slope. other posters in this thread have given less extreme examples of this spectrum.

you have to look at it from the perspective of intent.

honest question: if yesterday i'd asked you "some guy maliciously and willfully gave another guy a seizure, should he be punished?". would you respond, "depends, how'd he do it?"

catshirt··on Michael Seibel, CEO of YC, is doing an AMA
hi Michael, thanks!

considering the 1% rule, do you think our culture of media consumption is in our nature or something we've created? is it a trend? do you think there will be more room in the future for companies that serve amateur producers? can we create more producers?

sorry for so many question marks. it's a single question- poorly formed. :)

catshirt··on How is team-member-1 doing?
> He was a 'junior operator' in a computer room .. you know, in the good ol' days, where the computers lived. (Before they escaped and attached themselves to your wrists.)

i hope one day i can tell a story like you. that intro is a work of art. :)

catshirt··on FBI Arrests Man For Allegedly Sending Journalist Seizure-Causing GIF
my point is simply that many types of expression and speech are not protected by the first amendment. period. there is nothing contradictory or ironic of a journalist challenging the first amendment in court.

break it down this way: some guy literally tried to give another guy a seizure. are the means by which he tried to induce the seizure even relevant? would anyone really suggest taking action with this intent should not be punishable?

a lot of people want to say "oh but free speech...?"-- as if to imply you're free to kill someone as long as you only use words to do it.

catshirt··on FBI Arrests Man For Allegedly Sending Journalist Seizure-Causing GIF
> "challenge the first amendment"

sorry, what? i don't think assault is protected by the first amendment. at the risk of sounding naive i have to ask why Manson wasn't protected under the first amendment?

catshirt··on GitLab acquires Gitter, will open-source the code
i was just hating on GitLab here a few days ago so i will take the opportunity to say this is really cool on a bunch of levels.
catshirt··on Show HN: An HTML/CSS/JS toggle switch with happy and sad emojis
what is a "slider toggle"? sliders should be used for ranges of values. checkbox for toggling values.

we could argue it's unfortunate that iOS(?) decided to start making their "checkboxes" look a little like sliders, but they still only toggle values thus you don't slide them.

in any case, i get where you're coming from. using mousedown instead of click or up maybe kind of solves both use cases?

catshirt··on Show HN: Every Day Is Pi Day
well that's just the most obscure date format i think i've ever seen ? ;)
catshirt··on On Programming Languages: Why My Dad Went from Programming to Driving a Bus
1. if you've let it go on for months you can probably afford to wait A Little Longer.

2. because everything is relative i take "for months" to mean "for a dangerously long time". and this is what i mean by cutting your losses: it's hard to know in the moment when to fall on plan b.

everyone agrees they could train any decent programmer- no one really does it. i'm not trying to defend any practice, just trying to reconcile the contradiction.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →