833 karma · joined May 25, 2026
These days? Not so much. I’ll never be able to be sure I can play GTA VI in twenty years. It just sucks not owning anything anymore. I know why they do it, it’s a massive profit difference.[1]
On the PC end of things, it’s not as bleak. Services like GoG let you download the standalone installer, DRM free. I try to get any single player games I can from GoG, you should too.
Support the corps that give you ownership. Buy those Blu-rays of your favorite films. Either to support physical media or to ensure you will have it until data degrades.
> In the near term handling the transition. Jobs will be lost, careers ended, people won’t be able to reskill quickly enough. At the same time AI is an enormous opportunity to uplift living standards, but nobody has the logistics of this figured out.
> We need to figure out how to restructure the global economy. How does UBI work internationally, if the AI companies are taking revenue in the US? What’s the tax base for it? What does that say about international trade and protectionism? Do countries end up splitting into different trading blocks based on their level of access and legality of AI (I assume some will ban it outright)?.
UBI in the United States is never going to happen in time. If it happens at all. We don’t even get universal healthcare. I think people who think AI will be a net positive for humanity are also in some sort of denial.
In a different US political climate I would entertain it. If these frontier labs weren’t so clearly going after the money, I would entertain it.
LLMs are clearly a step up for capitalists so I just can’t see any inclusion of LLMs move towards more progressive ideologies.
If they instead read it, and distill it down to “have you checked X?” Someone with the full understanding can easily go: “Yes, X doesn’t fit because of this other reason.” within seconds. Sometimes this happens without asking a teammate. However, when I do ask I’m not asking for you to ask Claude and paste the results, I have my own tokens for that. I’m asking you because I think your knowledge will be helpful in finding the answer.
I strongly disagree. I used this strategy for learning how to reverse engineer and hook functions in a game with C++ and learned a ton.
I also used this strategy to learn Imgui and it worked great. Before LLMs I did this when learning from books too.
> This is the same level of arguing that only painting is the real art and photography is just clicking the button
And my point was that these two comparisons aren’t the same. They aren’t the same because photography is an art form and so is painting. They both have essence that I think AI generated art won’t capture.
For example, if someone showed you a photograph of a buffalo that had a bird also in the frame on a fence post. How would you react?
Then let’s say they go “oh well, I actually photoshopped that in from another photograph I took.”
You might be a little less impressed but they still took this picture of a bird.
Then instead of them saying they cut and paste the bird in they say “Oh Photoshop generatively added that in.”
I think many if not most people would think that’s far less interesting than the other two scenarios. Maybe you don’t, and that’s fine.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-45202-3 is a good read on this with regards to the “value” of art.
I've been trying to generate concept art for a game idea. I figure, I can't draw so why not have something else bring my vision to life. After dozens of failed attempts and burned tokens I decided to just hire someone. The experience was night and day. They provided thoughtful details to help tell a story in the image. They got to tell me what they added and why, etc. This isn't even their project but their passion for it showed in the end result.
These models are impressive, but I think people watch movies because of the essence as much as the movie itself.
Let’s take Backrooms for an example. In the interviews with the cast, Kane, and others they usually all hit on “so and so was so passionate and added X”. Hearing about everyone’s passion and seeing the end result reflect that makes the experience of watching it so much more enjoyable.
If someone generated a Backrooms film, there would be none of that.
I’m not saying you’re wrong for liking machine books or anyone should be wrong for thinking that, but I just can’t imagine them being equal in the view of the arts.
> I think detractors believe you should just let AI do the job blindly instead of leveraging it as a tool to accelerate you.
However this is how it’s marketed. C-suite is telling people eventually you won’t need to read code, frontier labs saying programmers won’t exist etc.
The reality is like you said, a tool to accelerate you.
I’ve been sort of viewing these sites in a similar way I view generated advertising posters. You have no brand, you have no identity. You’re just another business in the crowd that hasn’t put any care into showing who you really are.
It makes those that put the care in stand out more. On the flip side it feels like swimming through an ocean of slop trying to get your precious attention. It’s tiring.
Most definitions I’ve seen of the dead internet are in areas where generative content can be posted wholesale. Mostly everything you see when you google something.
However the main counter to this is as you mention: “We surround ourselves with good people and good online experiences.“
If we’re to assume these are 100% real people, then there has to be some sort of gatekeeper. These closed off communities become what Maggie Appleton calls the Cozy Web.[1]
That’s great, but it still makes it look like the internet generally is dead.
I’m sure there’s a lot of objective ways to rate fonts. I just like it because it looks nice to me :)
As opposed to what? This is usually a sign of quality. If it’s in chalk it’s because it changes as the restaurant experiments and tries new things.
Maybe I’m misunderstanding but I haven’t seen many that I’d say look “good”. Especially food related ones.
There’s a big reason more expensive restaurants don’t have pictures on their menus, even when they’re the best equipped to ensure your meal matches the picture.
I’m not sure it’s net negative or not. I’ve found that it’s reductive though. We have this really broad field of artificial intelligence reduced down to at worst a “slop machine” and at best a single tool.
Imagine being a CS professor that studied AI in the 90s and how you have to over explain you don’t mean LLM chatbots to a layman.
I’ve found them to be unavoidable to some degree.
So all people that don’t understand the thing being hyped.