HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

citrablue

366 karma · joined May 1, 2018

submissionscomments
citrablue··on Too Many Companies Drain Value from the Economy
I think people bring out the population or area size in order to explain where facile comparisons fall down. Scale matters.
citrablue··on HTML is the Web
Because there's already an element for that. Putting a click handler on a div is a hack.

In a clean (from scratch) dev situation, when would it make sense to use the div option?

citrablue··on Lyme Disease Cases Are Exploding
Minor nit, the feeling of awfulness from the flu is the effect of your immune system kicking in. The feeling of relief is when it kicks out, because the tide of the battle has turned.
citrablue··on We tried to hustle our way into YC after we got rejected
While your tone is a little off-putting, I totally respect your decision to go this route. It's not for everyone.

Do you mind if I ask what your independent success trajectory in your own business has looked like?

citrablue··on Maker Faire halts operations and lays off all staff
Because investors are paid for taking risk, that decision has to happen at the point of investment. Or, the entrepreneurs would have to be willing to massively sacrifice their upside for their vision.

The exit clause is "don't take VC money if you want to run an ongoing business". Otherwise, the buoyancy of a somewhat profitable business is sunk by the history of leverage, debt, and expectation.

citrablue··on Ask HN: Why did your startup fail?
We built a huge dataset that we thought could be usedfor supply chain management, but the only successful p/m fit was by putting it on the web and putting ads on it. Even when we got to 5 figures/mo in ad revenue, we insisted on a different model.

So we ignored the thing that was working in favor of our "vision".

Ended up in an acquihire for garbage money.

citrablue··on The multi-armed bandit problem (2012)
What you said is correct, but I'd like to point out that controlled scientific experiments may not be the right approach for e.g. optimizing conversions on a website.

The reason is that websites are a dynamic environment. All things equal, better controlled experiments are great. However, visitor behavior, especially when from dynamic sources (google serps change weekly), changes all the time.

And that's why I prefer MAB over A/B tests -- A/B tests don't adapt to a dynamic system, so we often wish away the changes in the system to use it. Does anyone go back and re-test their biggest wins?

citrablue··on The Troubled History of Psychiatry
My point is that I believe even though very smart and dedicated people work in the field, and research it, the "state of the art" seems to be little more than opinion anyhow.

That is to say, it appears to me that even "dense scientific books" are either sharing opinionated descriptive analyses or just making this shit up.

While I can appreciate you trying to defend a field of research, I am also OK with keeping my own mental model of operation.

citrablue··on The Troubled History of Psychiatry
My uneducated guess is that therapy's effective mechanism is related to the placebo effect. There is a line of thought that the placebo mechanism may be related to reduction in stress, because something else will take care of the problem.

If I go to a therapist, and they put time in to help me get better, my stress response decreases, and I feel better.

Completely made up, in case that wasn't obvious. But that's my guess.

citrablue··on Facebook has struggled to hire talent since the Cambridge Analytica scandal
Perhaps in some countries/demos. I'd bet Instagram and WhatsApp for free, basic communication are seen as much higher utility in a significant amount of the global population.
citrablue··on Facebook has struggled to hire talent since the Cambridge Analytica scandal
Google also sees pretty much every website visit for every website in the world, through Google Analytics.
citrablue··on “Users want control” is a shoulder shrug
Perhaps I am thinking too narrowly, but I think the algorithm-driven approach is much less hubris than someone at the company making a decision. These models reflect what users do -- isn't that much more democratic than employees deciding?

There is an orthogonal argument that this is also harmful to some people's aspect, but "give the people what they want" doesn't seem like it's reductive. Especially when it seems like people in our society can be clustered and have some clear groupings occur.

citrablue··on Facebook's Zuckerberg Preaches Privacy, but Evidence Is Elusive
Does your reasoning apply to other companies? Coca-cola, for example, is very interested in building profiles and modifying behavior. I estimate they're much less sophisticated w/r/t building profiles (although if you think in terms of flavors, instead of demographics, perhaps not...) They are definitely very effective in terms of behavior modification. The product does significant harm. It also hijacks an evolutionary flaw (people like other people's feedback=FB, people like sweet things=CC).
citrablue··on Permafrost collapse is accelerating carbon release
Dumb question, but how can you assume the ranges offered are a normal distribution?
citrablue··on Apple has removed or restricted several screen-time and parental-control apps
Not all that strange -- the decision was more "we have a security issue, but banning these apps would create a screen time issue". Framed that way, it made perfect sense they waited until they had a long term solution finalized.
citrablue··on Google search only has 60% of my content from 2006
It's because Google's constraint is number of engineer-attention-hours. This kind of thing probably just isn't a priority, when they have a billion other things they could work on.

Keep in mind that Google is not a product company, they are a data company. They work on the biggest most impactful items, and don't have a lot of time for one-offs.

Finally, it might not be clear at all that these sites should be removed from the index.

citrablue··on James Webb Telescope will run a proprietary JS interpreter by a bankrupt company
I think the apparent hubris is what they're referring to, and that it is a negative indicator of developer self-awareness, while humility and willingness to acknowledge past mistakes are positive signs.

Honestly, if you've always delivered rock solid software, you're some sort of mythical creature.

citrablue··on How much can forests fight climate change?
Could it also be possible that the current rate of emissions beefed up the planet's scrubbing capacity, and the climate return to pre-civ levels even faster?
citrablue··on Can Antitrust Law Rein in Facebook’s Data-Mining Profit Machine?
it was a checkbox in a training ledger that nobody else cared about. People were passing around unencrypted csvs on flash disks, sending them to their gmail accounts via email. Parent company at one place (healthcare provider) couldn't even reconcile how many patients they had each year. (It was under 15k, so we're not talking like millions of patients)
citrablue··on Can Antitrust Law Rein in Facebook’s Data-Mining Profit Machine?
In your opinion, have HIPAA laws been a success? I've worked in 2 roles where I was the part of the technical implementations of compliance... and man, the stories I could tell.
citrablue··on Nothing Fails Like Success
Humans used to resort to physical violence as well as name calling. Rome had a series of senators brutally murdered in session, even before Cesar. Andrew Jackson used to physically attack opponents. The whole Aaron Burr story.

My unsupport theory is that we've pacified to the point where anyone can say anything without getting beat up or killed, which allows people to push the envelope.

I'm not suggesting we should go back to violence, but i think the lack of direct violence in a person-to-person setting have enabled more and more wild speech.

citrablue··on Employee Wellness Programs Yield Little Benefit, Study Shows
Knock 5% off my insurance premium for every trip to the gym and you better believe I'm going to the gym every day...
citrablue··on Hollywood Upended as Unions Tell Writers to Fire Agents
The problem here is that who knows if your listing price was optimal. I know some real estate agents who would argue that in a hot market, you should list for significantly less in order to create a bidding war.

It doesn't make sense to compare this outcome to what you -- an amateur -- would have done.

citrablue··on New paper quantifies how quickly Southern planters recovered from the civil war
Regardless of the merits of your statement (although tbh it's more of a rant than a cogent argument), I caution you not to take the downvotes as a sign you are correct. The downvoting may reflect how people received what you said, but does not address anything about the accuracy/correctness.
citrablue··on Berkeley HS student tried to rig his own election, exposing cybersecurity flaws
Punishments are effective at teaching people to not get caught. They put the offender on the defensive, which is a hard place to learn the right lessons from.
citrablue··on Mission to find never-contacted Amazon tribe to stop “catastrophic” jungle war
There's a great sci-fi world based around this premise, called The Culture Series by Iain Banks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Culture_(series)
citrablue··on Tell HN: Google removing Gmail access from IFTTT
Maybe they want to get in front of a possible backlash, like what happened to Facebook when it was revealed that 3rd parties you used to send messages through... had access to the messages! (gasp)
citrablue··on AdNauseam – clicking ads so you don't have to
Has anyone reported that they stopped seeing ads because nobody wanted to bid on them? You'll always find a bidder if the CPM is low enough.

I think if anything, you'll see more and more shady ads because you are now remnant inventory. Ads for scams, targeted to super cheap RPM groups.

citrablue··on I interviewed at six top companies in Silicon Valley in six days
This assumes that FB is harmful to everyone, instead of a subset of people. I don't think that's very well proven. The mental health studies also have a bit of a correlation issue, similar to drug use.

I think sugar is a more apt analogy than smoking. Facebook, like sugars, provides a source of a required human input. (Calories/human connection). Overdone, both are harmful.

Tobacco is a much more charged analogy, and is more extreme in terms of positive/negative balance. I think it reveals more about the biases of the person making the statement than it does about social media.

citrablue··on AI Can Detect Alzheimer’s Disease Six Years Before a Diagnosis
You missed some downsides: anguish, more tests for something that isn't a problem, costs, possibly suicides. You may want to read up more on the downsides to breast cancer screenings for reference.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →