HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cjhopman

8 karma · joined April 6, 2023

submissionscomments
cjhopman··on Flatten the Curve of Armchair Epidemiology
> Notice that it is the highlighted part they want you to tweet out.

You mean the highlight that medium applies automatically based on user behavior and the author has no part in controlling?

cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
> But communities, including HN, do often tend to have particular inclinations and behavior as a group, even if there are many individual members who diverge.

And I'd rather see people seriously discuss the groupthink of those communities rather than just dismiss it due to the fact that it isn't completely universal.

cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
Huh, the point of the bias towards noticing things that we dislike is interesting, and there's good research backing it. I don't think that it necessarily affects much the comparison of one community against another, though, as one wouldn't be particularly more susceptible to it than another. Still, it likely means that the negatives are not as pronounced as they are perceived to be.

> The HN community doesn't think anything. It's a collection of millions of people.

You could say the same thing about r/The_Donald. And it would be true there, too. But communities, including HN, do often tend to have particular inclinations and behavior as a group, even if there are many individual members who diverge.

cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
As an example, Amazon is fairly well-known in the industry as having a set of principles and with the fact that those are often described as having been weaponized to support people's positions. I actually think that weaponization of principles or slogans or mottos is not uncommon. Different principles, though, have different flexibility on how far they can be used to justify things (i.e "focus on the user" has different flexibility than "move fast and break things" or "don't be evil").
cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
That's a good point. The stated goals or objectives or values of a community or collective actually do have significant impact on the behavior of that community. It's too bad that HN generally doesn't recognize that when looking at things like Google's "Don't be evil".
cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
> Specifically, once the proportion of recovered in the population reaches 1/(1-R_0), there are no longer enough vectors (infectable indviduals) remaining for a serious outbreak to occur. It’s worth noting that this is the same principle that vaccination relies upon; vaccination is just an artificial way to build immunity without having to undergo a full infection.

I should learn to never read anything from random people working in areas they don't have any expertise in. This whole section is wrong.

The idea that vaccination and epidemics need the same percent of immunity is completely 100% wrong. An active epidemic is going to infect way more people before dying out than the simple, naive herd immunity calculation will give you. In fact, while an r0 of 2 indicates that you get herd immunity with just 50% of the population, a typical active epidemic with the same r0 would infect 80+% before dying out.

This is clear when you think for about 1 second about it. The `1/(1-R_0)` value gives you the point where infected people infect 1 more person, it doesn't give the point when the infection stops spreading.

cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
> This error is repeated throughout the document where there's this idea that the changes that we've seen are due to lockdown and will just go away otherwise

For these, it could be good to compare what has happened in countries or areas with different responses to these. I.e compare sweden vs norway.

cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
> we wouldn't pass a law ordering people to not drive around in normal times,

We absolutely pass a ton of laws to make driving around safer, including restricting driving around when it's particularly dangerous (for example, when a person has had a bit to drink).

cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
Here's more random stream of consciousness about this:

> Pareto Mitigation: An evidence-based approach

I love how this uses "evidence-based" as a dogwhistle followed by proposing an approach without providing any sort of evidence about the efficacy of the approach.

> Those who have lost their jobs tend to be those workers who are in a lower socio-economic bracket and have jobs that do not allow one to “work from home”.

This is presented without evidence. I think there's a reasonable chance this is the case, but many essential businesses/industries employ primarily lower socio-economic classes so who knows. This is just presented like you should agree with it.

It's also not clear that those that are more disadvantaged are actually worse off here. There has been a very large increase in the amount and accessibility of unemployment benefits.

There seems to be excessive use of bolding random segments of sentences. I don't know if this is just a stylistic thing, but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.

On suicides, it seems like most of the argument should be verifiable from data (i.e. by its claims, we should be able to see an actual increase in suicide deaths). Is that data not available yet?

> A preventable decline in preventative care

Even the (supposedly evidence-based) proposed approach would likely lead to exactly the same decline in preventative care. This error is repeated throughout the document where there's this idea that the changes that we've seen are due to lockdown and will just go away otherwise (except, of course, for when the change is positive and, clearly, the not-quite-lockdown approach recommended would continue that positive change).

> Be wary of “hero culture”

This is maybe the strangest section. Why does this just talk about a hero culture related to real scientists? Do we think that people are more likely to think some nerdy scientist is a hero rather than our heroic manly president? This seems like it should be a point in support of lockdown to me (tbh, it seems like it shouldn't be a point at all, it's just an attempt to discredit experts).

> The Soul of the Country is at Stake

OMG. I skipped this in first skim. Yeah, this makes me think I've wasted my time even thinking about this thing, this is clearly a plea to the emotions of a specific subset of the population. I'm done.

cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
> I'm disappointed with the HN community. The past few weeks, most of the medical articles to hit the front page have been written by dabblers.

Honestly, that shouldn't be surprising. AFAICT, the only way in which the HN community exceeds some random subreddit is in thinking highly of itself.

HN itself combined with hckrnews.com provides an okay enough ui and mix of random interesting articles that makes it still beat out reddit for me.

cjhopman··on A case for ending lockdown
I'm sorry but I can't take serious something that claims to take an impartial look at all the evidence related to the lockdown but then tries its damnedest to present all possible negatives it could without doing the same for positives. For example, there's clear evidence that the lockdown has decreased lives lost to traffic accidents but that appears nowhere here.

And then when actually looking at it, it's full of pleas to emotion and claims without any data backing them. Take "Addiction and Overdose", there's no real data discussed (other than historical data about deaths unrelated to lockdowns or distancing or economy). Is there no data that supports the implication (if not outright claim) that lockdown will increase the cost or deaths from addiction/overdose? For anyone reading this, if it feels like it's a good, thorough examination you should absolutely discount any points like this where there's no supporting evidence presented.

Or look at one of the following sections "General vaccination on the decline". This is a wonderful example of the only looking at negatives. Imagine that flu vaccination dropped 90% and that flu cases dropped 99%, this thing would report that as a negative because, "hey, look at how many people aren't getting vaccinated".

This thing is so littered with bias and lack of facts that it is not useful for any serious consideration of this. I'm sure it's great for people who already have their mind set in one direction, though.

cjhopman··on YouTube removed a viral video of two doctors calling for an end to quarantine
AFAIK, there is not a single study that "[shows] infection rates for Covid-19 are far higher than official numbers indicate". There is no place in the world (again, afaik) that is attempting to report the number of infected people, all the "official numbers" are roughly either "confirmed infected" or clinically-confirmed infected. All health experts (as far back as early january when we just had numbers from Wuhan) were saying that the actual number of infected will be much higher than those confirmed infected. There are a lot of studies that indicate that those experts are correct (and I am, maybe unfairly, assuming that those are the studies that you are misrepresenting).
cjhopman··on SF vs. Uber Eats: Service stops food delivery to Treasure Island citing fee cap
I think it would be really interesting to see what would happen if cities explored more of using their regulatory powers to get better deals for their citizens.

You may initially recoil at that framing of it, but really most regulation can be thought of in those terms. Look at environmental regulation, which forces a cost on companies that they wouldn't otherwise be paying to serve some area's interest in protecting the environment. Look at licensing for any profession. Take contractors for example, the people of an area, via their elected representatives, decide that they want to force all contractors to meet some form of licensing (and insurance) requirements if they want to serve any of the people in that area. Now, particularly the insurance one, puts a burden on the contractors who wouldn't otherwise get it, but it protects the ones who would (from being undercut in an unsustainable way) and it leads to an industry that serves that area better than it would otherwise.

cjhopman··on SF vs. Uber Eats: Service stops food delivery to Treasure Island citing fee cap
Yeah, and a group of people in a common geographic area are free to bargain collectively to ensure that businesses don't take advantage of them. In fact, it's so core to human society that the idea is universal.
cjhopman··on Preliminary test results suggest 21% of NYC residents have Covid antibodies
Sure, but a person who goes to the store 7 times a week is ~7 times as likely to have been sampled compared to someone who goes only once a week. They are also ~7 times as likely to have contracted covid-19 at the grocery store. It's likely that they are also, in general, isolating less than the other.

This sampling would have a (possibly slight, but still unknown) bias towards people who are isolating less (who you would expect to then have a higher than average percent positive for antibodies, assuming isolating is helpful).

I don't think anyone knows whether or not this is a more representative sample than the stanford study.

cjhopman··on Stockholm to reach herd immunity in May?
That herd immunity equation is really only useful in the context of vaccination when there's no active epidemic.

With an active scenario like this, it's just the point where the number of people infected per day stops going up. You still end up with like 90%+ of people getting sick before it finally peters out.

cjhopman··on Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry
Because in the real world those scenarios don't happen. We can go all day making up ridiculous wild scenarios and working out the math of how they compare, or we can stick to what people actually experience when buying cars.
cjhopman··on Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry
> I just care about the final bottom-line price

Then you are making bad decisions by not considering the time value of money. And I think it's obvious that that's the case and then you can adjust your position to take that into account.

Consider. I have a car that I will sell to you for $100,000. Alternatively, I will offer you a financing arrangement where you get the car today and in 10 years you pay me $105,000.

Now, in this scenario, two things are immediately obvious. First, I'm really dumb for making this offer. I have little to gain and it's a super risky loan for me and it gets really bad over time. Second, you'd be dumb to accept the pay now option over the financing, despite the fact that the final bottom-line price is higher for financing. Even a ridiculously conservative, barely over inflation, adjustment of 4% per year gives you an extra ~$43,000 at the end of that 10 years by taking the financing.

cjhopman··on California, Oregon and Washington announce western states pact
Yeah, the west coast's virus outbreak is primarily traced to European sources, the bigger east coast one probably more so (but idk the data to support that). The China travel ban was not an effective measure of control, and experts knew that it wouldn't be. So either (1) whoever did it didn't listen to their experts or (2) it was intended to punish China, not as an effective measure of control.
cjhopman··on The Global Dollar Short Squeeze
No. Because Bitcoin has no use in legal industries.
cjhopman··on Hydroxychloroquine Probably Isn’t the Answer
Ah, I had misread that.

That statement didn't clearly say whether they were going to donate those that they haven't produced yet. If they aren't donating that, this donation is like a ~10% discount (compared to the ~66% discount I had originally interpreted it in that case).

cjhopman··on Covid-19 twice as contagious as previously thought – CDC study
The usefulness of that approach decreases as people's behavior otherwise changes. For example, accidents account for ~10% of deaths. It's quite feasible (and I think we already have data to support this) that that has dropped a lot due to people's behavior changing in response to covid-19.
cjhopman··on This Video Has X Views
There are 3 big problems with open APIs

1. they enable people to do things that other people think shouldn't be done

2. people get upset at companies when (1) happens

3. people get upset at companies for removing or restricting apis when, or in fear of, both (1) and (2).

cjhopman··on Why SpaceX desperately needs a government bailout
> During SpaceX's funding round last month, they raised $500M [1], $250M more than they were seeking (raise when you can!).

This was addressed in the article. While they initially claimed they wanted only $250M, they actually approved and tried to raise $500M. I don't know where you got the idea that they actually raised that much, they failed to hit their goal and were only able to raise $221M.

cjhopman··on Hydroxychloroquine Probably Isn’t the Answer
A proprietary drug whose maker has said they will donate all 1.5 million doses that they currently have. That's more than they'll be able to produce over the next year (1 million) even after greatly increasing that production capacity.
cjhopman··on Zoom rolled their own encryption scheme, transmit keys through servers in China
Skype had 500 employees in 2010 a year before they were acquired. 700 doesn't seem clearly out of proportion.
cjhopman··on Where is everyone getting all of this sourdough starter?
Why would you even think to blame the site for that? It's almost certainly a problem with the reader mode you are using.
cjhopman··on Coronavirus outbreak won't peak in every state at once
Testing is not that constrained. Here you can see stats for both positive and negative: https://covidtracking.com/data/state/oregon/

Oregon is doing roughly 1400 tests/day, with ~5% positive rate. Places that are more testing constrained see 20+% positive.

cjhopman··on Amazon, Instacart delivery workers strike for coronavirus protection and pay
> it is common for kitchen staff to pool tips at a restaurant

I'm not sure where you got the idea that that is what I was talking about?

Do you not understand what an earnings guarantee means in the context of a tipped job? It means that you have a base pay + tips. If those tips end up not meeting the earnings guarantee, the company will pay you extra to hit that guarantee. That effectively means that the first $x of your tips are going to the company to cover the earnings guarantee. That's what doordash (and most restaurants) are doing.

The US federal minimum wage laws require a minimum wage of $7.25/hour. Tipped employees only require a base rate of $2.13/hour but the employer must guarantee that they earn $7.25/hour w/ tips, if they make less, the employer must pay them the difference. Effectively, the first ~$5/hour of tips goes to the employer.

cjhopman··on Amazon, Instacart delivery workers strike for coronavirus protection and pay
> If you did a poll of 100 people ordering on DoorDash, and asked them "when you tip on your order, where does the money go", what do you think people would say? 99/100 of them would ABSOLUTELY say "to the driver" and that is everything that is wrong with what DoorDash did.

How is that different from servers in a restaurant? If you asked that question of people who give a tip to their servers at a restaurant they would also say that that money goes to their server, despite the fact that the federally mandated earnings guarantee (assuming the restaurant doesn't have its own higher one) means that that money, effectively, might just be going to the restaurant.

> it's ordering food for delivery to your house and then giving cash to the driver

And would you be upset if Domino's gave an earnings guarantee to their drivers?

← PreviousPage 2 of 12Next →