HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cltby

57 karma · joined August 10, 2020

submissionscomments
cltby··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
> There is no scenario in which any citizen with a gun in any country defeats their government

Imagine writing this not one month after the Taliban wins its war against the US.

cltby··on Census Bureau’s Survey Shows Significant Increase in Homeschooling Rates
Even more unpopular opinion: genetics is destiny, so we'll never find a systematic effect of teachers on student learning.
cltby··on Census Bureau’s Survey Shows Significant Increase in Homeschooling Rates
I think a better analogy would be the resistance to teaching intelligent design. Why make space in the curriculum for faith-based, clumsy, ad-hoc ideas?
cltby··on Census Bureau’s Survey Shows Significant Increase in Homeschooling Rates
> The big reason for homeschooling is that you can push your own politics or religion on school more

As a descriptive claim, this might be true (wouldn't shock me if the bulk of parents choose to homeschool for religious reasons). But if it's prescriptive, it's horribly wrong. A moderately intelligent child with moderately thoughtful parents will learn far more outside the school system than within.

cltby··on Census Bureau’s Survey Shows Significant Increase in Homeschooling Rates
> like teaching kids that the US founders were slaveholders and that owning slaves is a bad thing

That stuff has been taught forever, and nobody objects to it. The objectionable stuff is teaching myths like "systemic racism" and "white supremacy" as fact.

cltby··on Census Bureau’s Survey Shows Significant Increase in Homeschooling Rates
The biggest problem with public schooling is less political indoctrination and more the lack of actual schooling. When educators themselves claim “there is no such thing as learning loss," we should take them at their word. School has very little intellectual content, and many parents are simply starting to recognize that.

https://www.lamag.com/citythinkblog/cecily-myart-cruz-teache...

cltby··on I Got a 'Mild' Breakthrough Case
Simple and easy and, given the miniscule risks to all but the unvaccinated, completely unreasonable to impose on others.
cltby··on I Got a 'Mild' Breakthrough Case
The disease is significantly (primarily?) spread via aerosol. Against which officially sanctioned masks are a pretty marginal intervention.

https://uwaterloo.ca/news/media/study-supports-widespread-us...

cltby··on I Got a 'Mild' Breakthrough Case
At this point, the burden of the disease falls almost exclusively on unvaccinated adults. For everyone else, the risk is same order-of-magnitude as the flu. It's pathological and innumerate to obsess over COVID when we unthinkingly accept similar or greater risks. If you're afraid, stay home. Don't saddle the rest of us with the cost of your neuroses.
cltby··on Tyler Cowen is a curator of talent
It's called an apprenticeship. It already exists; it's widely used; and it's wildly better for most kids than every other extant alternative.
cltby··on MacKenzie Scott’s Money Bombs Are Single Handedly Reshaping America
She earned her half only in a narrow legal sense. No one would seriously assign more than \epsilon "real" credit for her contributions.
cltby··on Wealthy people are renouncing American citizenship
> avoid paying for the infrastructure and management of the country

The premise here is dead wrong. The top 1% pay ~40% of taxes; the top 5% pay ~60%. So not only do these people create the wonderful consumer goods that enrich your life; they also provide the roads, police, fire fighters, etc. Show some gratitude!

cltby··on Ian Manuel, survivor of excessive child punishment, tells his story
> how little this society cares about those that need the most compassion.

Two college professors are walking along and chatting when they come across a man who has just been brutally beaten. He is bloody and groaning with pain. The professors look with horror upon the sight. Finally, one turns to his friend and exclaims, "We need to help the man who did this!"

cltby··on Ian Manuel, survivor of excessive child punishment, tells his story
Public safety. Commission of violent crimes is a strong signal of underlying violent tendencies. These are largely congenital, and there is no known social intervention to fix them. The rest of us benefit when such individuals are warehoused, preferably for the rest of their lives. Their moral claim to a second chance counts little against my right to not be brutally victimized.
cltby··on Six charged in Silicon Valley insider trading ring
In light of the AP's new policy on minor crime reporting, I was curious how they would treat this story. Unfortunately, their website has no coverage. However, they did report today on another (alleged) insider trading case, and they use names liberally.

[1] https://apnews.com/article/nyc-state-wire-ny-state-wire-new-...

cltby··on King County, WA bans facial recognition software
Sad news, if not unexpected. Yet another municipality prioritizes ginned-up grievance over the actually existing harms of unchecked criminality.
cltby··on Reaching ‘Herd Immunity’ from Covid Is Unlikely in the U.S., Experts Now Believe
The governor isn't the bad guy here. It's the supposed experts whose "neutral" opinions are politically contingent.

Parents: open the schools.

Experts: no, it's unsafe.

Progressive politician: open the schools.

Experts: great idea sir, just as we've been saying all along!

cltby··on Reaching ‘Herd Immunity’ from Covid Is Unlikely in the U.S., Experts Now Believe
The data didn't evolve, though. The only thing that ever changed was the political winds. Throughout this whole pandemic, experts have bent over backwards to defend and justify political decisions--and most humiliatingly, decisions that _directly_ contravene their prior advice. Two examples:

- Experts encouraged the George Floyd protests because "racism is the real virus," despite their prior anti-protest stance. Given the apparent magnitude and seriousness of the problem, it's curious they only noticed in May 2020.

- In Washington, there was a big battle around opening schools. Public health authorities insisted that this was a verrryyy fraught process that needed to be handled veeerrrryyy slowly and veerryyy carefully. In the middle of this, Gov. Jay Inslee suddenly demanded that the schools be opened in a matter of weeks. The authorities weren't perturbed in the least: after all, they suddenly claimed, "we've known all along that the risk to children is very manageable".

Most people understand that mistakes happen, and they are generally forgiving when those mistakes are acknowledged and corrected. But it's plain to see that the sort of "expertise" that's being held up is deeply and pathologically broken.

cltby··on Reaching ‘Herd Immunity’ from Covid Is Unlikely in the U.S., Experts Now Believe
> Is this an education problem?

A number of reporters have gone out and talked to vaccine skeptics, e.g. [1]. They don't appear to be suffering from a deficit of knowledge or "false consciousness" or whatever. Their beliefs are reasonable and their preferences are internally consistent.

[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/05/the-people...

cltby··on The rich shouldn’t feel like the enemy’: Is New York turning on the wealthy?
Better than sending them to grievance peddlers and commie sympathizers!
cltby··on Binance investigated by CFTC over whether US residents trade on platform
> For a global exchange to not risk blowing up means to gain affirmative proof of a user's legal identity, jurisdiction, tax residence

Financial stability is totally orthogonal to KYC. Exchanges that allow leveraged trading protect themselves via margin requirements.

cltby··on Ask HN: How do I learn drawing?
Take a serious drawing class, specifically in the classical academic tradition [1]. As a beginner, you need:

a.) theory to simplify and organize the visual information in front of you

b.) immediate and rigorous feedback on your mistakes.

The realist ateliers make a point of doing both and are incredibly effective at teaching. Don't be put off by the classicist dogma. It really is the best art instruction you can get today.

IMO the independent study route is a poor use of time. It is indeed very important to "learn to see," but you probably won't achieve this by staring at an object and trying to reproduce it. You will definitely get better if you do the exercises in e.g. "Drawing on the Right Side of the Brain," but you'll still be pretty bad, and what's worse, you'll have no idea how to improve.

[1] https://www.artrenewal.org/Atelier/Search

[2] https://grandcentralatelier.org (which I can personally vouch for)

cltby··on Pfizer Vaccine 92% Effective Two Weeks After First Dose
When First Doses First was being debated, many insisted that there was “no evidence” a single dose would work. Well, this paper is a post-hoc analysis of data already submitted to the FDA. In other words, the evidence was there for anyone who cared to dig.

Some of the firmest FDF opposition came from the public health types, further adding to their field’s horrendous record during the pandemic. I hope in the coming years we strongly reconsider its existence. I’m coming to doubt it contains any legitimate expertise at all.

cltby··on California’s affordable housing problem is really a national one
The structure itself does depreciate (ask any landlord!). It's the land value that's surging.
cltby··on UC Berkeley Library acquires FBI records of surveillance of Black leaders
I wonder if any of these documents will shed further light on MLK’s alleged participation in a violent rape [1].

[1] https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2019/06/martin-luther-king-f...

cltby··on John McWhorter: The Neoracists
> This article is the very definition of a straw man. Absolutely no one subscribes to the position it critiques.

The article critiques a position that consists of multiple beliefs. While it is true that ~nobody subscribes to all of them, each individual belief is very well-represented amongst the "anti-racists." As a consequence, to anyone under attack by a Twitter mob, the situation looks exactly as McWhorter describes: you're being hit from all directions by the entire span of mutually contradictory nonsense.

cltby··on 2020 Saw Unprecedented Murder Spike in Major U.S. Cities
It should be noted that nearly the entirety of the increase in murders happened after the BLM protests began in May [1]. Before that, 2020 was on track to be an unremarkably violent year.

Given that this is exactly what happened in Ferguson and Baltimore after those cities’ riots, the increase was sadly predictable. Baltimore’s experience bodes especially poorly for the country; its homicide rate has stayed elevated ever since.

The slaughter of an extra 3000-4000 people in the span of seven months is a colossal tragedy. I hope that the cheerleaders of future racial reckonings will do all in their power to prevent similar disasters.

[1] https://www.thetrace.org/2020/12/shootings-data-philadelphia...

cltby··on Capitol Attack Was Months in the Making on Facebook
Any rational definition of terrorism (lives lost, property damage, etc) would implicate BLM/Antifa orders of magnitude more than the Capitol rioters.
cltby··on Are Experts Real?
> I'd be totally for splitting society into those who respect science and experts, and those who don't

Science not as a search for knowledge, but as a search for daddy figures to respect and obey. Nothing is as harmful to progress as this blind devotion to expertise.

cltby··on Are Experts Real?
Many argue that the experts ultimately got it right (and are thus redeemed). I strongly disagree. Even when the public health types corrected course, their behavior left a bad taste in my mouth. There was no acknowledgement of having been wrong, no introspection on how their errors came to be, no discussion how they could be avoided in the future. Just aggressive enforcement of the new party line couched in appeals to authority. The whole enterprise reeks of blind dogmatism.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →