HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cmrdporcupine

23,652 karma · joined December 5, 2014

Surfin' the Dunning-Kruger wave since the 1990s.

Member of Technical Staff, AI @ Verda https://verda.com/

some src @ https://github.com/rdaum/

submissionscomments
cmrdporcupine··on Waymo in Toronto
Some of you downvoted-to-dead this from another poster ("Hi, I'm Nelson" from Technologists for Democracy); new user who had low karma, so it's dead in the thread.

I frankly think it's a legit POV, and I'm also local to this, so I'm going to use my own much higher karma to post it again:

https://techfordemocracy.ca/2026/04/29/say-no-to-waymo/

I think there are legitimate concerns in promoting American BigTech as provider of infrastructure/services in Toronto. Concerns about data collection, about technological autonomy, and local employment.

cmrdporcupine··on Using AI to reverse engineer hardware
I don't really think software was ever the moat with these kinds of products? The moat with hardware products has always been access to electrical engineering talent and access to cheap assembly/manufacturing. And marketing. And the $$ in your pocket to fund all the above without having sales yet.

I have written probably a dozen software synthesizers over the last 20 years, for fun, never profit. I would have preferred those to be hardware products. But I lack all of the above. As do most.

I have worked in several embedded companies. The software that runs on them was often considered to be the least important part of the expense chain despite involving the most amount of total work hours.

cmrdporcupine··on LFM2.5-24B-A2B: Built for fast on-device agents
Well, weights released:

https://huggingface.co/nvidia/NVIDIA-Nemotron-3.5-Super-VL-1...

And their own benchmarks seem to show it well behind of Qwen 3.8 flash next on pretty much everything except generation speed.

cmrdporcupine··on Anthropic's Scion is heavily inspired by Mononoke
I'd wager it's still not possible.

You can write it, but can you maintain it? Can you even fully understand what was built? Can you staff the team to manage the bugs? The potential data loss?

cmrdporcupine··on Anthropic's Scion is heavily inspired by Mononoke
Monolake, not Mononoke?
cmrdporcupine··on LFM2.5-24B-A2B: Built for fast on-device agents
yeah it's kind of the point. they're pedagogical tools. they give you the full recipe for building it from scratch or fine-tuning it beyond what it is.

but i'm prepared to be surprised, maybe they'll conjure up something standalone useful this time

cmrdporcupine··on Anthropic's Scion is heavily inspired by Mononoke
I think it's worse than just IPO juicing. I think it's "look what our agents can do" and also pushing more on the "software engineers are becoming obsolete" line that Dario public-pronounces. Getting high on their own supply.

Projects seem to be getting approved or pushed there purely on the basis of showing off that they can vibe-build infrastructure.

Which.. yes, you can. But now maintain it. Understand it. Manage thousands of people using it. Those are part of the reasons we re-use proven solutions rather than rolling our own -- not just because the coding part is hard.

Same thing happened with the Bun rewrite. "Oh wow, look what we can do! What's that, nobody adult supervision telling us that this is a bad idea? Let's go!"

cmrdporcupine··on LFM2.5-24B-A2B: Built for fast on-device agents
Why? Their models are useful as a starting place for doing your own fine tuning, but they have never stood well on their own.
cmrdporcupine··on Anthropic's Scion is heavily inspired by Mononoke
Well, sure, the article here and Meta's, etc.

Even Google started with Perforce originally and only forked/rebuilt when it stopped being able to scale. And did so in a very incremental fashion.

cmrdporcupine··on Anthropic's Scion is heavily inspired by Mononoke
Rebuilding what you know from the previous FAANG you worked at is expected on the whole.

What is douchey is presenting the whole thing as some sort of intense novelty and stroke of genius required in the age of agents when it's just doing what the other BigCo companies did to scale their monorepos already. Like a decade (or more) ago.

The reality it is when I first read the thing I was -- as a Xoogler -- like "Oh, yeah, so, like Piper & SrcFs and the stuff that Meta also does" and really didn't understand why they wouldn't have started with something off the shelf inside of vibe-conjuring a clone that they would then have to support

To me it speaks ill, again, of the engineering culture at Anthropic. "We do these things not because they are useful, but because they are novel."

Don't they have better things to do at Anthropic than building their own source control or rewriting Bun from scratch in another language? Like, y'know, basic site reliability? Or a coding harness that doesn't eat multiple GB of RAM?

cmrdporcupine··on Containment and monitoring failures are to blame for AI hacking reports: experts
It's a byproduct of goal seeking / planning behaviour taught in reinforcement. We literally teach them to do this kind of thing. There's nothing out of our control here.
cmrdporcupine··on Do dentists know what they're doing?
This has been a shift in my lifetime. When I was a kid it was still very much in the health professional angle. Except for orthodontics. Over the last 25 years it's been a marked shift towards that kind of thing.

And it's happening now for doctors, too, even here in Canada with our single-payer universal healthcare.

cmrdporcupine··on Do dentists know what they're doing?
Another profession and service distorted by the insurance economy.

Can't go in there without them trying to tell me to put a chunk of plastic in my mouth to stop the grinding. (As described in TFA).

Described as a diagnostic by them, a problem we discovered in you, mr porcupine... But strangely recommended to every other single person I've talked to. Very scientific.

Paid for by insurance of course.

I did this once years ago and the mouth guard was both annoying and disgusting. Never again.

Everything is priced exactly the maximum that your insurance provider will pay.

When I was (and am) contracting and didn't have insurance anymore... the plastic-pushing stopped, remarkably.

Regular cleaning and fillings are important. But so much of their business seems to have degraded into orthotics for the face.

cmrdporcupine··on Kcgi – minimal CGI and FastCGI library for C/C++
Boatloads of http serving stuff at Google was (and probably still are) written in C++ when I was there. The web services part, though, not front-end, generally.

Things were shifting to Go gradually as I left though.

cmrdporcupine··on What agents mean for Rust (and vice versa)
I don't disagree with your other points, but calling Rust fast at compile time is... questionable.

I've been doing Rust full time for the last half-decade and hobby before that, and its slow compile times have always been a pain point.

And I've found its slow cycle around compile-then-test is a real pain point with agentic development. Agents get into loops trying things out, and verifying their results, and they tend to accumulate a pile of tests on top of that (which require periodic cleanup). Forward progress often gets successively more slow and painful as compile times start to dominate most of what the agent is doing.

For application -- not systems dev work -- I've been considering making a move to using something like OCaml instead.

cmrdporcupine··on CFTC Staff Were Told to Retract Analysis of Suspicious Oil Trades
Even worse they (the GOP) is just lighting everything on fire now and leaving it in a dysfunctional state on purpose. Because they know for the next two years voters will just start blaming the Dems for everything that goes wrong. Trump will say "I would fix it but the radical left Democrats are too busy persecuting me. High gas prices are their fault, and Zelensky's etc"

What's happening in Brazil right now should give people pause about thinking that an interregnum with someone left-ish in power trying to restore normality will reset things to a saner state.

These are people totally willing to burn the crops and salt the fields. Trump could die tomorrow and a thousand heads would pop up looking to benefit from the anger and resent.

cmrdporcupine··on Hittite royal archive found in Turkey
It looks like this is fairly late in Hittite's evolution, though, 14th century BCE.

Clarity about relationship with the rest of PIE would definitely be enhanced by having a corpus from substantially earlier on.

cmrdporcupine··on Gemini 4 Argon
They were frankly on the decline a long time before that though.
cmrdporcupine··on 11 year old unsoundness bugs found in Rust borrow checker
The only fanaticism I'm seeing here is you going through the entire thread and picking fights and calling people who use and advocate a language names.

"fans" "fanatics" "cult"

I'm not sure what the point of this way of talking is. Rust is a tool. Many advocate for it because we've worked for a long time in ... other tools. Which had avoidable problems. I had a two decade career with C++ before Rust finally became mainstream enough to get paid to work in. Going back here and there is usually... unpleasant.

cmrdporcupine··on Gemini 4 Argon
HP is the other company to consider as analogous. And maybe more explicitly so, as they had a similar "engineering first" internal culture that degraded markedly over time to be a shadow of their former self.

And took similar companies that were quality engineering focused -- like DEC or Palm -- down with them through acquisition.

cmrdporcupine··on Unikernels were hard. key word: were
Part of the problem with being old like I've become... and having used Linux since 1991 on a 486 is that in my mind Linux can still be thing I installed off a few 1.44MB 3.5" floppies and ran -- complete with emacs and XFree86 -- in under 8MB of RAM.

Sel4 is cool stuff.

cmrdporcupine··on 11 year old unsoundness bugs found in Rust borrow checker
"People still die in cars despite airbags and seatbelts so I don't see the point in wearing a seatbelt."
cmrdporcupine··on 11 year old unsoundness bugs found in Rust borrow checker
Custom drops are all over the place. As others have said.

But not custom drops that are doing variadic type stuff like this, usually.

cmrdporcupine··on 11 year old unsoundness bugs found in Rust borrow checker
No we're in a situation where a bug in the type checker was found and will be fixed and a new release will be made.

That it took 11 years for someone to come across this is a fairly intense counterargument to your attempt to paint this as a language with dangerous footguns.

cmrdporcupine··on Atari Falcon
I broke the copy protection using GPT 5.6 a couple months ago. I have a forked version of Hatari that can boot and run Notator and Creator by emulating the dongle. If there's interest I can make it available. I just got lazy about cleaning everything up into something others could use.

The copy protection itself was rather insane: https://gist.github.com/rdaum/91b8dad3fe5dd69a6bbfff404b81c7...

I pondered moving on and having it patch Notator itself to remove the copy protection once and for all. The other cracks that were out there for it never worked.

cmrdporcupine··on Documents add to evidence in climate deception case against ExxonMobil
History says it's like this for decades, centuries... Until it isn't. And then it's guillotines and chaos.

I fear the Children of Men style future we're stepping into.

cmrdporcupine··on Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer population, DNA suggests
To be fair, from what we see hunter gatherers also made continual "war" on each other through raiding and battles. North American tribes on the whole had a mix of trading and ritualized warfare for centuries before Europeans were involved. And they burned often huge tracts of forest to manage grazing lands. And overhunted and overfished and then moved on to new areas.

Its just that population densities were on the whole lower. And there was a lot of land and resources to live from. So the impact was lessened.

But even then, there were in fact tribal groupings that effectively wiped out other tribal groupings.

Also it's becoming clearer and clearer that the line between settled agrarian and hunter gatherer was a lot less clear than we initially imagined. There were all sorts of grain and maize growing societies that continued to rely on deer and fish for their protein sources and trade in skins etc for hundreds of years after they started tending crops.

cmrdporcupine··on Scandinavia's first farmers slaughtered hunter-gatherer population, DNA suggests
Can we rule out a scenario where disease was also implicated, like here in the Americas?

Incoming colonists were (and remained) genocidal by comportment, yes. But they also had the "advantage" of having a wave of smallpox and other disease going before them in a wave of devastation.

Farmers coming up from the Balkans and Pontic Steppe would have been living in larger settlements and among livestock for generations and would likely have brought with them things like smallpox that dispersed hunter gatherer societies would be less likely to encounter.

cmrdporcupine··on Unikernels were hard. key word: were
For that matter, the actual Linux kernel need not be large at all. It's really the user space stuff that takes up the bulk of what people think of as the largess of Linux.

Still, there's a whole pile of stuff there that many applications don't need. If you truly can run the entire of the OCaml runtime and standard libraries etc without it, and you're happy writing your apps in OCaml... MirageOS has always felt winning-ish to me as a general idea.

And to TFA's point, now with LLMs the relative exotic nature of OCaml as a platform need not be a huge hindrance. I like the language, but have only dipped my toes in. Definitely tempting to try writing apps on it w/ MirageOS now. Though I doubt I'd convince anybody to pay me to do that...

cmrdporcupine··on Unikernels were hard. key word: were
yea, "virtualizing" an NVIDIA GPU is not truly feasible right now from what I see.

I do know that AMD has done more in this space. When I worked at Google there were (other) people on the Stadia team doing this. And some open source bits out there that I've seen, including from AMD.

Unfortunately, my real world work... and most real inference etc work others are doing... is on CUDA/NVIDIA.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →