HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cmyk_student

162 karma · joined November 29, 2024

submissionscomments
cmyk_student··on Photo GIMP – A Patch for GIMP 3 for Photoshop Users
Far from it - we even have a dedicated design site where we ask for UX-specific bug reports and improvement requests from users: https://gitlab.gnome.org/Teams/GIMP/Design/gimp-ux/-/work_it...

We then discuss and test with the reporter and volunteer designers, and try to implement once some consensus has been reached. We welcome feedback from more users, so feel free to contribute your thoughts and design/workflow issues!

cmyk_student··on Photo GIMP – A Patch for GIMP 3 for Photoshop Users
GIMP has a Python console, and several built-in plug-ins are written in Python: https://docs.gimp.org/3.2/en/gimp-filters-python-fu.html

We want to make macros simpler (some of the work I helped out with for GIMP 3.0 was to lay the groundwork for automated/recordable operations), but as with all the things on our roadmap it takes time and developers.

cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.4 Will probably draw circles
And rectangles, triangles, and other custom shapes too I hope! :)

I'll do my best. I might actually finish cleaning up the code for the version in the video and post a WIP merge request so people can start trying it out and designing how the interactions should work.

cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
That's up to you. Right now filters work the same way - you can merge them automatically on creation, merge them at some point while working, or merge them on export. For formats like PSD, we'll eventually add the option to export as non-destructive filters as well.

We don't want to take away choices - we just want to add more options for people's workflows.

cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
Yes, it's planned for transform tools and already possible with filters. Technically our transform tools are already capable of this (they use GEGL operations the same as our non-destructive filters). We just need to tweak it to not immediately commit the transform, and then implement a UI.
cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
Ah, hey! We've been busy with getting 3.2 finished, but I plan to go back and read over your latest message once we've recovered a bit. :)
cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
That was a feature in GTK2 (the GUI library we use) that was removed in GTK3. We could try to fight the library and reimplement it ourselves, but it'd take a developer dedicated to do it. I miss the menu icons too. :(
cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
If you mean the color icons, you can easily switch back to those in the Welcome Dialog that appears when you first open GIMP (look in the Personalize tab). It's the first thing I do when I install GIMP on a new machine. :)
cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
I can't speak for all of us, but generally no (in terms of GenAI at least). There are concerns about generated code not being compatible with GPL, and honestly a lot of the drive-by GenAI coded merge requests tend to not work.
cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
The current non-destructive UI is a bit of a compromise - we can't really mix layers with NDE filters in the layer dock until GTK4 (from what I understand), so the pop-up menu is what we had to work with.

You can check "Merge filter" at the bottom of the filter dialogue though, and it will automatically merge the filter like in 2.10 (and the setting is remembered going forward)

cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
Hi! What was the last version of GIMP that you used before 3.0?

We get an equal amount of "GIMP's UI never changes!" and "You changed too much of the UI in the latest version", so it's difficult sometimes to figure out the specific issues.

cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
There's always the GFig filter, which has existed in GIMP for a long time. :)

GIMP 3.2 actually adds vector layers, which are the basis for a shape tool (it was my "big project" for this release). We have a GSoC project idea for doing the last bit of work to make a dedicated shape tool: https://developer.gimp.org/core/internship/ideas/#implement-...

cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.2 released
It's because each transform was "destructive" (like filters use to be by default). What link & vector layers do instead is store a transform matrix, so each transform just updates the matrix instead of actually re-rasterizing the layer each time.

We were hoping to expand that feature to all layer types for 3.2, but we ran out of time to properly test it for release. It'll like be finished for the next minor release.

cmyk_student··on Interview with Øyvind Kolås, GIMP developer (2017)
Do you happen to have a reference to GTK implementations of pie menus? The challenge we've run into is that newer versions of GTK "streamline" and remove features, so we have to either discard things or build our own replacement (as one example, we've received many complaints about icons no longer appearing in menus in GIMP 3.0, but that was due to the feature being basically removed in GTK3).

We currently have over 13,000 user-requested issues resolved in our issue tracker, so I don't think we're opposed to user requests. :) I think that's a holdover from an earlier group of developers (there's been a lot of people coming and going in the 30 years that GIMP's been around!). We're also just limited by how fast we can implement certain things due to the number of developers. For instance, I focused on vector layers for GIMP 3.2 - a feature requested by many users! But that meant that I wasn't working on other features requested by other users.

cmyk_student··on Interview with Øyvind Kolås, GIMP developer (2017)
There's a third-party theme called PhotoGIMP which changes the layout and shortcuts to match Photoshop: https://github.com/Diolinux/PhotoGIMP

Longterm, we have a roadmap item for an Extensions platform: https://developer.gimp.org/core/roadmap/#extensions

So basically, you could download plug-ins, themes, shortcut presets, etc, directly into GIMP. We have a lot of pieces done - we just need someone to focus on it to finish.

cmyk_student··on Interview with Øyvind Kolås, GIMP developer (2017)
I can't speak for everyone, but as developers we are trying to emphasis UX/UI work more. We have a dedicated repo now for user feedback, designs, and proposed solutions: https://gitlab.gnome.org/Teams/GIMP/Design/gimp-ux/-/issues We implement from there as we can, once consensus has been reached.

We also highlight UX/UI improvements in each new release post. Just like with coding, we rely on volunteers to help with this (you definitely don't want someone like me deciding on interfaces!) We have a couple active designers assisting us, but we're always looking for more feedback!

cmyk_student··on Interview with Øyvind Kolås, GIMP developer (2017)
It's funny to hear that, because we get a large number of complaints that we haven't changed GIMP's interface at all from 2.10 to 3.0 and that's why we're "failing".

We try to be respectful of existing users (and again, we get lots of complaints that doing so "holds GIMP back"). If you have some examples of massive changes you've dealt with (and from what version to what version), I'm happy to look into them further.

cmyk_student··on Interview with Øyvind Kolås, GIMP developer (2017)
We do now have a UX repo to ask for user UX/UI reports and feedback - anyone can contribute, no coding required: https://gitlab.gnome.org/Teams/GIMP/Design/gimp-ux/-/issues

Our release posts now regularly feature a UX/UI section where we highlight the work being done. We've implemented a lot of low-hanging fruit and localized fixes, while we continue to grow our design volunteer group and build larger designs.

cmyk_student··on Interview with Øyvind Kolås, GIMP developer (2017)
They weren't published because the person who interviewed everyone is now the project maintainer, and ran out of time to do transcriptions. :)

I volunteered to help with transcription, so I was given several audio recordings and started working on them. The first "resurfaced" one was Simon Budig: https://www.gimp.org/news/2025/11/01/simon-budig-interview-w...

There's about 4 more from another event which I'll be working on between coding and other things. There's definitely some material that's a bit dated (for instance, the comment about non-destructive editing), but I think it's still interesting insight into development.

cmyk_student··on Gimp Source Code
No need to wait! In GIMP 3.0, you can shift-click multiple layers in the layers dockable, then drag them around on the canvas with the Move tool.
cmyk_student··on Gimp Source Code
For batch operations on GIMP 3, I've heard great things about Batcher: https://kamilburda.github.io/batcher/

Macros are on the roadmap (https://developer.gimp.org/core/roadmap/#macros-script-recor...), and in fact we did a lot of prepwork for them during 3.0's development (internally, several features like filters and plug-ins now have configs that store settings, which will be used by macros in the future to repeat operations).

cmyk_student··on Free Software Awards Winners Announced: Andy Wingo, Alx Sa, Govdirectory
I can't speak for GNU Guile, but I wasn't even aware I was in the running for the "Outstanding New Free Software Contributor Award" when I got the email, and I didn't know anyone on the committee. So I don't think there was a conflict of interest.

There's definitely plenty of people out there who were equally deserving of the award!

cmyk_student··on Programmers and software developers lost the plot on naming their tools
For what it's worth, we're trying to encourage more feedback from designers and users to make GIMP better. We have a public repo dedicated to UX/UI discussions: https://gitlab.gnome.org/Teams/GIMP/Design/gimp-ux/-/issues

We've implemented a number of items from the issue posts once consensus was reached, and we hope more people will participate and help improve GIMP further.

cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.0
If I understand correctly, "omnisearch" would be pressing a button to pull up a box to search through all the menu options? If so, then yep, GIMP's had that for a long time by pressing "/".
cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.0
Right now you can import/export CMYK JPEGs, TIFFs, PSDs, and JPEG-XL. You can also soft-proof to simulate print, and the color picker/selector can be set to show CMYK values for your assigned profile.

A full CMYK mode is on my TODO list now that 3.0 is out. :)

cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.0
Unfortunately we don't have as many macOS testers so we tend to get less feedback. However, it looks like it's an issue in one of the dependency libraries - there's discussion at https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gimp/-/issues/12736#note_2372...
cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.0
We actually set up a dedicated UX repo for people to present design issues and discuss. The goal is to develop good designs that can then be implemented by programmers. If you're interested in contributing to the discussion, the repo is here: https://gitlab.gnome.org/Teams/GIMP/Design/gimp-ux/-/issues
cmyk_student··on GIMP 3.0
Just FYI, changing icons/themes/tool groups is even simpler in 3.0. In the Welcome Dialogue that pops up on start, you can change all those settings in the Personalize tab.

You can also access that dialogue under Help.

cmyk_student··on Writing a Gimp 3.0 Plugin
You can change both if you like (it's one of the first things I do whenever I install GIMP on new systems)! In 2.10, you can change the icons in Preferences under the Icon Theme section, and remove tool groups in the Toolbox section.

In 3.0 it's even easier, as both options are available in the Personalize tab of the Welcome Dialogue. I'm hoping this will help make that feature more discoverable. :)

cmyk_student··on Writing a Gimp 3.0 Plugin
Hi! Would you be willing to post more details on your drawing tablet (either here or on our issue tracker https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gimp/activity). We've gotten a lot of reports that tablets have better support in 3.0, so if there's some regression we'd definitely like to get that fixed.

Are there specific areas of the UI that are less space efficient? One of the big changes was switching our GUI library to GTK3, which is suppose to scale better on HiDPI screens. But we had to recreate our theming system as a result, so if we need to tweak something we can try.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →