1,168 karma · joined January 30, 2009
Email: cody@codyrobbins.com
Web: codyrobbins.com
Twitter: twitter.com/codyrobbins
GitHub: github.com/codyrobbins
AngelList: angel.co/codyrobbins
Facebook: facebook.com/codyrobbins
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/codyrobbinsI just asked four non-engineer, non-technical, non-mathemetician friends the following fill-in-the-blank question: ‘The radius of a circle is the distance from the center to the edge. If there are two circles, there are correspondingly two ______.’ Three said radiuses. One said radii, however they pronounced it ‘ray-di-eye’. I asked a similar question with corpus and all four said corpuses.
There is also probably at least some effect due to age here. I'm in my late twenties and my social circle is as well. If you're twenty years older than me, where your language is is twenty years behind mine.
And sorry, data was a stupid example, it doesn't really have anything to do with what I was talking about. Data is already the plural form and I banged it out because nobody really uses datum as the singular. But data seems like a mass noun since the way it’s typically used you don’t really have a single ‘data’. We use a counter, as in piece of data in the same way we say grain of rice.
I don’t have the book with me so I can’t find the exact reference, but if you’re truly interested there is an entire chapter in ‘An Introduction to Modern English Word Formation’ by Valerie Adams that talks about how these plural forms arose in English. They were basically made up by scientists and philosophers during the Middle Ages who felt that any English word with a Latinate or Greek root should use the corresponding root language’s plural form, because Latin and Greek were more ‘pure’ languages. (No doubt this attitude contributed to the fact that they continued writing in Latin in general for a thousand years after Rome was no more.) These forms became fossilized in English because the people using them were educated and therefore part of what was considered a prestigious class. That is, using them makes you sound smart, and that’s why they’ve persisted. By my own judgment, though, they certainly sound more out of place to normal English speakers today than the corresponding standard English plural. (I last read this book six years ago, so this summary is from memory—the details may be slightly different but I’m pretty certain that is the general gist of it.)
The reason this irks me in general is because we speak English, not Latin. Unless you speak Latin you probably don’t know how to correctly form Latin plurals, which follow a relatively complicated scheme depending on the class of noun, its grammatical case, person, and number. See http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/000814.h... for a discussion. Japanese doesn’t have a plural form—does that mean we should say in English things like, ‘Hiroki is holding three kimono in his arms’? The only reason it sounds remotely acceptable is because you interpret kimono as a mass noun that doesn’t have a plural form (like rice), but physically speaking kimonos aren’t like rice in that they are actually countable. The sentence ‘Hiroki is holding three kimonos in his arms’ sounds much better.
Modern English has a very simple pluralization rule. There are three allophones of the plural morpheme: the unvoiced allophone –s is suffixed to words ending with an unvoiced phoneme (t, p, k, f, etc.); the voiced allophone –z is added to words ending with a voiced phoneme (d, b, g, m, all vowels, etc.); and the allophone –əz is added to words ending with a phoneme that is similar in articulation features to s and z (s, z, sh, ch, j, etc.). There are exceptions to this rule that show extreme resistance to degradation (such as children and teeth), but in general the exceptions are slowly being replaced by the standard plural in normal speech. If someone said ‘Look at all those oxes over there,’ most people wouldn’t blink an eye.
Finally, I wasn’t trying to correct the OP. My point was simply that the jokes where you make up a funny non-standard plural are lame. As mentioned in the excerpt from the Jargon File that someone posted above, hackers (and railroad enthusiasts, among others) have been making these same jokes for decades. A variation over and over again for fifty years of the same old joke about a funny fake plural—enough already, ya know? Of course I’m aware that everyone’s sense of humor is different, so I can’t tell someone something isn’t funny because it’s a subjective assessment. So I’m just pointing out that these jokes aren’t funny to me, because the people making them might not realize how overplayed and unfunny they are to a lot of people.
And please don’t get me started on made-up fanciful names for groups of animals…
EDIT: See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_plural#Irregular_plural... for more discussion.
Thanks for pointing out so many things in such an objective fashion without getting into any political rhetoric. I definitely agree that no matter which way you do it, pretty much any taxation scheme is going to be unfair from one perspective or another, and I largely concur on all the issues you bring up. That's why I hate to see Warren Buffet make these simplistic claims that people can rabidly latch on to, rather than a real discussion of the constraints and trade-offs involved like you've done.
Wikipedia says [1] that the top 0.1% of gross earners pay out almost 20% of total federal revenue, the top 1% almost 40%, and the top 5% almost 60%! The bottom 50% of earners pay 3.3%.
So while Buffet may be paying a smaller percentage than his secretary, it’s fifth grade mathematical knowledge that percentages are normalized values. When you look at the total magnitude of taxes paid, the rich are paying a massively disproportionate share. The Wikipedia article says that when the percentage of revenue from each bracket is compared with the wealth distribution rate, it lines up very closely. That is, the top 5% pay 57.1% of the taxes and have 57.2% of the wealth. Lining the two curves up in such a way would seem, to me, a reasonable approach to taxation.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taxation_in_the_United_States#T...
You’ll note that I haven’t made any statement one way or the other regarding the treaty itself. You shouldn’t infer that I am for or against it based on what I’ve said. Yes, I do know the details have been leaked. You’re missing my point entirely, because the content of the treaty is completely irrelevant to what I’ve said. My point is simply that the fact that the treaty is being negotiated in secret has no bearing on the relative merits of the treaty itself. The secrecy is just an irrelevant procedural technicality of the negotiation process that’s being framed as some nefarious underhanded move that should invalidate the treaty. It’s being used as a scare tactic in place of debating the treaty itself. Argue for or against the treaty on its content, not how it was arrived at.
I’m perplexed at how it isn’t clear to people that the treaty is being negotiated in secret precisely to prevent just such a mob backlash as is occurring. And it’s not to prevent a backlash because there is some corporate/government conspiracy to control the masses at work. It’s because there are concrete procedural difficulties in negotiating something like this when the parties involved aren’t able to speak freely without having 6 billion rabid critics jump down their throats at every proposal.
The representatives of the people in this process are the democratically elected Senators who must ratify the non-secret finished treaty.
In all likelihood it’s probably both, with feedback going both ways.
Snarkiness aside, I do care about what the non-glowing part looks like. The aesthetics of the space I’m in materially effect my general mood and productivity level, and having control over that environment is one of the reasons I’m self-employed, because I can’t stand being surrounded by plastic, linoleum, and carpeted cubicle walls.
Objectively, it looks no different than any other piece of consumer electronics. But that’s the general problem I’m lamenting. If I’m spending $1,300, can’t they spend some money on the product design and make it look sleek, sexy, and expensive? For $1,300 I want to be proud to have it on my desk! Of course, since most people don’t care what the housing looks like, that’s exactly why they don’t, so I don’t blame them.
http://sitb-images.amazon.com/Qffs+v35leraEu3x8Au9mv9K/rTAZQ...
It shows various analyses (phonological, syntactic, semantic) of the sentence
The little star’s beside the big star.