HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

craigdalton

13 karma · joined July 7, 2018

meet.hn/city/-32.9272881,151.7812534/Newcastle

Socials: - x.com/craigbdalton

---

submissionscomments
craigdalton··on California's Covid-19 positivity rate drops below 3%
So you are right, you have to know a bunch of other things to put it in perspective, but its mainly a guide first to how sensitive your surveillance system is for cases and then if all else stays stable (testing rates) it is a guide to disease activity. I am working on COVID-19 in Australia and monitoring stats like this. You can look at total cases and total deaths to understand the sensitivity of your surveillance system for cases and then look at positivity. If you have a high case to death ratio (setting aside clinical performance/or adjusting for clinical performance), you have an indication of sensitivity, but you also know that if you are testing adequately, i.e. testing all the mild cases then the % positivity should be low. In Australia we would be very concerned with a 3% positivity, suggests not enough testing is happening. Over the last 2 weeks our % positivity in NSW has been 0.002% and 0.009%. I know WHO recommends that % positivity should be less then 5% but that is a very low bar for low income countries. High income countries should be able to keep it well below 1%.
craigdalton··on Anyone else noticed that the top comment is always trying to one up the poster?
that is a great guideline that I forgot about. I wonder if this should be reposted when appropriate.
craigdalton··on Anyone else noticed that the top comment is always trying to one up the poster?
Yep, think this is often the case. One interesting habit is to distort the intention or cite an extreme example of the original post to something ludicrous and then ridicule it as... ludicrous.
craigdalton··on Ask HN: Thai Cave Rescue – tech to elicit/rank rescue ideas?
No, that's not my idea. They would be silly to ignore what they know to be true. But they might be open to hearing about new/prototype technology they do not know about. And conditions/local knowledge could be shared. Lastly I have been involved with emergency humanitarian crises where the national team did not have access to information they needed. Agree, you don't want every thought bubble funnelled into an overwhelmed operations centre. Perhaps a gated entry into the system based on expertise through snowballed invitations could optimise input. Again, maybe the cave rescue is not the greatest application, but there is a great need for better expert elicitation systems.
craigdalton··on Ask HN: Thai Cave Rescue – tech to elicit/rank rescue ideas?
An example below of admittedly last resort option :

Idea Title: Anaesthetise boys and remove from cave.

Idea Description: The boys would be anaesthetised, intubated (tube down throat to protect airway) placed in waterproof bag and pulled from cave by diver. Portable battery operated ventilators can ventilate a sedated patient for well more than 3 hours required to extract them. Ideally a long acting sedative/anaesthetic could be used and readministered at the rest spots on the route out. This idea would be a last resort for boys who were unable to use scuba equipment.

My level of expertise: While I am a doctor I am not trained in anaesthetics and have forgotten everything I learned in a PADI diving course 25 years ago.

Gaps in my knowledge: 1 I don’t know what equipment would be required to ensure stabilisation of an endotracheal tube in a patient being dragged through a cave. E.g. If the endotracheal tube leaked or came out of the trachea, then 1. The patient would no longer be ventilated and would die within minutes, and 2. The thick plastic bag they are held within would begin to inflate making them difficult to manoeuvre and potentially trapping them in narrow crevasses. 2. Susceptibility of battery operated ventilators to minor water infiltration is an unknown. 3. Availability of large thick waterproof vinyl dry-bag required to protect the patient.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2