HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

craigsmansion

2,304 karma · joined August 20, 2016

submissionscomments
craigsmansion··on Bye, Amazon
> There's no basis in evidence

It's hard to rise to the top in a morally lax organisation without making some compromises on the way there.

Furthermore, it's easy to take a stand when you're financially secure because of those compromises.

So in my opinion the OP is right: it's good for Tim to take a stance if truly, deep down, he feels this is morally wrong, but ultimately him being outspoken means little when compared to those who did the right thing from the start and as such never got a position to make a headline on HN in the first place.

Tim is assured of a cozy job with a "good guy" startup regardless. If genuine, it's certainly a personal victory for him, but it doesn't mean much for the rest of us (except, cynically, that selling out and then raising your profile by denouncing the party you sold out to is a valid career path).

craigsmansion··on SICP in Python
> Back in the 80s, most programming was done from first principles

That's one of the secret revelations in SICP. If you go in with some knowledge of assembly or C, you can quickly feel it's really high-level and not all that fundamental.

That is, until it addresses your precious "fundamental" bits and bytes, and you suddenly realise the model it is showing you is a model you can build computational platforms with, including your up-to-then understanding of registers and ALUs, and it illustrates that computing essentially has nothing to do with any specific hardware: all you need is pencil and paper and the command of a natural language, but with some parenthesis, you can optionally instruct a machine to do it for you as a bonus.

> it is not what beginners need because most of them will never end up programming like that.

which makes any "SICP in X" effort so useless: "let's make SICP understandable for people who do not want to understand it."

craigsmansion··on The SF Anti-Mask League of 1919
> 99%+ of viruses are either harmless or symbiotic

There is no such thing as a symbiotic virus.

craigsmansion··on A Genealogy of the Idea of Universal Basic Income
Yes. I'd say:

No UBI without good affordable health care for all.

No UBI without good affordable education for all.

No UBI without humane unemployment benefits for all.

No UBI for all, because you already managed it.

craigsmansion··on A Genealogy of the Idea of Universal Basic Income
I'm about as "red as they get" and there's something really grating about US citizens talking about "UBI", and pointing to a variety of social policies in various European countries.

These policies are hard-fought and need to be well balanced to be effective in the long term. You can't just implement them without thinking about repercussions and side-effects.

I'd say, if you're a US citizen, forget about "UBI" as a simple answer to the various social wrongs within your country, and focus on your healthcare; that's where various European models could be used as a partial model, and it's a very good and achievable first step towards a fairer and healthier society.

craigsmansion··on Emacs: The most successful malleable system
What is really an "external package" in emacs?

There should be nothing stopping someone just copying and pasting an entire elisp source text from a website into scratch, evaluate the buffer on the spot, and have the exact same functionality as installing the package would.

I'm not saying that retrieving an external package isn't easier, but due to emacs' nature there isn't really sort of delineation based on how the elisp got into the emacs.

craigsmansion··on TclSqueak – IDE for Tcl
In a thread about a free software IDE for Tcl, which might mean a lot of exposure for what seems like a small project, you write what amounts to how you don't like the look of it and promote a proprietary alternative.

I don't feel that's right.

craigsmansion··on TclSqueak – IDE for Tcl
The IDE you linked to seems to be proprietary software.
craigsmansion··on Stop the Apple and Google contact tracing platform
> There are always people who see a tragic pandemic and just see a chance to use the concern and attention to highlight their own cause

You say that like it's not a PR exercise for large corporations.

> the ones who fight against the efforts to mitigate the suffering

There's more than a few billions floating around off-shore that could have helped establish universal healthcare and social safety programs, but just being a good corporate citizen doesn't get headlines, so let's focus on panic situations and instead sell our new slogan:

"Nefarious, for good!"

("good" defined as "not as evil as a global health crisis"; disclaimers may apply)

craigsmansion··on Why We Should Teach Python instead of Racket
> By your logic

That does not follow, in any shape or fashion, from what was stated.

craigsmansion··on Why We Should Teach Python instead of Racket
Unfortunately SICP isn't really all that suitable for learning Scheme (or Lisp).
craigsmansion··on Why We Should Teach Python instead of Racket
> Save whatever functional nonsense you want to teach for “Obscure Languages 401” class.

Do you also talk to your students like that when, say, one of them mentions an interest in different languages or mentions anything that doesn't agree with your "mindset"?

> using languages that they can actually do stuff with

Didn't you just state: "The fundamentals of programming exist in all languages." ?

I was only commenting on your "minimal friction" that scheme naturally provides and how elegantly fundamentals can be demonstrated by it (right up to and including meta-circular evaluators).

craigsmansion··on Why We Should Teach Python instead of Racket
> It’s like teaching someone grammar by forcing them to use Esperanto

Or Latin, which for the longest time wasn't called "Latin", but simply something that was taught in "grammar school", because it addresses the underlying fundamentals quite clearly without getting bogged down with semantics. Latin is still used for that, btw, but only in "top schools".

>Teach students using languages with the absolute minimal friction

Say, something with a trivial syntax; something that is easy to express any construct in without too many preconceptions of what a programming language should look like.

If only there was a language like that!

craigsmansion··on GCC 9.3
At the very least GCC is keeping llvm permissively licensed.

llvm is partly a product of Apple's dislike of copyleft licenses. Without gcc there is no reason for llvm's large proprietary contributors to stick to the "more permissive license" and simply close it down and distribute it as "value added" binaries.

craigsmansion··on OCaml 4.10
If you're competent in Haskell, and you've ever done any lisp, you should feel right at home with ocaml.

The other posters mentioned good books already. Another resource is Emacs + merlin, it really is magic when working with ocaml.

craigsmansion··on James Gosling on Richard Stallman [video]
> I found these two guys who ran this little company called Unipress, it was literally two guys in a garage, and I said, "Look, this needs to be free for universities and not ridiculous for everybody else."

Gosling sold them Gosling emacs. Before that he apparently "distributed it freely with no copyright notice."

Although Gosling wrote Gosling Emacs, it was based on the plans he and Richard Stallman had developed for a new, widely portable Emacs.

> And, you know, I realize I'm a radical. I like to actually have a bed to sleep in and food and I will occasionally sleep in my office, but not as a regular thing.

Gosling made millions at Sun Microsystems. That's a little more than needing "food on the table" and "a roof over one's head". Stallman also could have made similar money, but didn't because he thought other things were more important. That's everyone's choice to make, but putting down others because they approached something differently is just bad form.

(edit: spelling name)

craigsmansion··on Tesla Model 3 represented over 15% of September new car sales in The Netherlands
> braking and steering should be dependent on software.

That's an opinion and that's fine, but I was wondering if it was the case, i.e., they are dependent on software.

> This is the case in most modern cars

By `this' you mean "basic steering and braking functionality depending on upgradable software", right?

craigsmansion··on Tesla Model 3 represented over 15% of September new car sales in The Netherlands
Tesla also has a final assembly plant in the Netherlands[1], nominally making the brand "native" (like Volvo before them). That usually results in better brand recognition and higher sales as well.

I recently saw a post on social media where someone couldn't go to the dentist because the car was updating software.

From the discussion I understand there is a "grace period" of 2 weeks before automatic updates, and that the software is needed for advanced features.

It was also mentioned that basic braking and steering functionality were also dependent on updatable software, making it unsafe to use it as a regular car when a software update is occurring.

Does anyone have more information on this?

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_facilities_in_Tilburg

craigsmansion··on A New R6RS Scheme Compiler
I always thought that was the best feature of scheme. Nobody agrees on anything, except mainly R5RS, keeping it from going down the path of "one implementation for everything, always" that most languages suffer from once they become a little popular. Scheme is one of the very few languages that has resisted accruing a lot of bloat throughout its existence (R6RS never was very popular because of that)

People underestimate the upside of being able to paste any example snippet into your repl and have it work transparently in almost every scheme, without having to worry about libraries or eco-systems.

For anything more exotic, you grab the nearest SRFI and squeeze it around until it works in the scheme you're working with.

Scheme: it's so simple, any subgenius could use it!

craigsmansion··on Richard Stallman steps down as as head of the GNU Project, effective immediately
> he at least had the courage to sign his name to what he had to say.

Which is neither here nor there, but thanks for playing.

craigsmansion··on Richard Stallman steps down as as head of the GNU Project, effective immediately
No, I think it's cowardly regardless to spout his grievances at this particular moment. If he did not ask him to leave, that would make it despicable in my eyes.
craigsmansion··on A Prison Lifer Comes Home
> Being 17 or acting as part of a group don’t make you less culpable.

Yes it does. Boys do strange things, boys in groups do stranger things, like not testifying against each other, especially if they feel society has abandoned them and the world is against them.

Normal societies are set up to deal with that or prevent it.

Fix your bloody society.

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
Sorry about not finding myself in agreement over what would be a "real revelation", but I might have misunderstood. My apologies.
craigsmansion··on Do we need to rethink what free software is?
Absent is any mention of the Affero GPL.

And that's the problem. Who is trustworthy?

> "The priority of the board right now should be to restructure itself to ensure that it can legitimately claim to represent the community"

Who is this appeal to, and what is it for? Is it genuine or an attempt, in the current upheaval, to have the board restructured to make it less effective?

> "and play the leadership role it's been failing to in recent years"

Failed in what? In "Representing the community"? What community should be represented here? Is the timing accidental? What is being sold to whom, or who to what?

Meanwhile rms is looking for new accommodations[1]:

"There should not be ... a digital listening device such as Echo, Siri or "Hello Google", or a card lock that records who opens the door. I will ask about cameras."

If nothing else, rms is trustworthy when it comes to software freedom. I'm not so sure about any new pretenders.

[1]https://stallman.org/seeking-housing.html

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> 1. The point is that an integer person

Most people are irrational.

> Watch any interview with the guy

Interviews he's been invited to, where calling the operating system GNU has been stipulated beforehand.

rms is involved in GNU and has no involvement in "Linux". Not in the development of the kernel, nor in the philosophy behind the various "Linux" operating systems. What would you expect him to say about "Linux"?

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> being told to get with the times or adapt your core ideas to a changing world

Because getting with the times and adapting to a changing world require proprietary software and the dilution of privacy?

> genius misanthropes

Yes, rms the misanthrope...

Maybe stick to "kewl stealth mode startups", or at least try to make it less obvious you're just looking for excuses to dislike the man. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
I'm sorry, but:

"I hosted rms many years ago in the 90’s, what was supposed to be hosting your hero for a ~3 day thing became a ~2 month nightmare."

Did Miguel ask him to leave? Or did he just sit around passive-aggressively for 3 whole months? Also, rms called Miguel "a traitor to the Free Software community" at some point, and now with the whole MIT business, he gets in with the twitter defamation league spouting off his grievances. That's pretty much beyond cowardly and into despicable territory.

Jillian's story is pretty much the entire problem in a nutshell:

"an older female colleague recommended at a whisper that I lock myself in my office."

"She later told me it was because he gets touchy"

"Over the years, I heard all sorts of things of this nature, and warned women who might not be in the know"

Maybe this older female colleague was told the same things at some point? Why is every single allegation hearsay from twitter?

"instructing them on how to properly make tea"

Yes, rms can be very particular about minor things. If you did not know even this, why are you writing about "things about rms others should know"?

Also, again EFF connections. Do they even want to pretend to be useful anymore, outside of cluelessly abusing people on twitter for kicks?

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> (there is no fucking way you are oblivious to people being coerced into sex this visiting Epsteins Island, just none).

That seems a particular American hangup.

If people would visit the mansion of a skin-magazine tycoon on invitation, and one of the many women around there would approach them, very few would assume this was a genuine romantic interest, but there would be little reason to doubt if they were being set up for blackmail instead of straight-up prostitution.

Whether you are revolted by prostitution, or whether you would find it inappropriate for an older man to sleep with a significantly younger woman doesn't matter.

> (fuck rms for shitting on singular they) [..] you know he'll throw a huge tantrum if you don't.

Terrible thing that, people throwing tantrums when others don't see things their way.

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> Have you seen the "pleasure cards"?

Yes, having been asked "business or pleasure" countless times during his travel, his "pleasure card" is a nice pun on "business card". Of course, some might not like puns, so this reduces to "guy uses corny joke to introduce himself." I'm sure that never happened before.

https://fossforce.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/RMSleisure....

> I can testify of him harassing people privately over public discussions on mailing lists.

Taking disagreements off-list is now harassment instead of good form?

Feel free to reproduce exactly these harassing private exchanges here. I'm fairly sure rms wouldn't mind, so there is nothing stopping you from providing actual evidence for this particular accusation.

craigsmansion··on Stallman Still Heading the GNU Project
> I think if the job description itself, prior to you taking it

The job the description would pertain to didn't exist before he created it by filling it.

I don't think any of the more palatable audience-friendly "FOSS" luminaries are going to decline being flown business-class, and then ask for the price difference to be donated.

Open source opinion maker is a solid career path now, and will attract the sort of people interested in making careers.

rms has shown through example to be incorruptable. That's the only requirement, but it's hard to find. All the rest is nice-to-have.

← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →