HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

crasshopper

870 karma · joined November 8, 2010

Non-web entrepreneur, here to learn about web business models and programming.
submissionscomments
crasshopper··on Ask HN: Learn Math the Hard Way
Based on the tone of the question, this sounds way too ambitious.
crasshopper··on Ask HN: Learn Math the Hard Way
I don't have a Ph.D. and I found it a fun read. But this is why I say everyone has to follow their taste.
crasshopper··on Ask HN: Learn Math the Hard Way
I may have answered your question here: http://isomorphismes.tumblr.com/post/15431506533/i-never-did....

The benefit of DIY maths is that you get to focus on what your interest is, whether that be algebra or geometry or stats/data analysis or discrete maths or foundations or whatever. (Contrary to some answers here, I don't think trig, measure theory, or planar geometry are necessary, unless you read something and it catches your fancy.) If your goal is just to do more maths, then just throw away anything that bores you and dive into anything that interests you.

If you're interested in C.S. applications then I think discrete maths is the thing to focus on. Eg, "Concrete Mathematics" by Knuth. But you can go an even more direct route and if algorithms is your goal, there are some free courses available online that do just that.

MIT OCW and AcademicEarth are excellent for in-depth (course-length) treatments of material by seasoned teachers. Wikipedia and math.StackExchange are good for broad overviews and quick Q's, respectively.

For "proofs, and other practical applications" -- that's quite broad. OCW has a course on geophysics and a course on signal processing -- both are "practical applications" but I don't know if that's what you have in mind. Most of the OCW stuff -- whether it's chemistry, materials sci, DSP, whatever -- is aimed at engineers (other than the upper level pure maths), and therefore practical.

As for proofs, you will see them in almost any maths textbook. Spivak makes some challenging ones and if you haven't taken calculus or linear algebra then Flanigan & Kazdan might be worth a skim. But if you're interested in CS applications then you can find those kinds of argumentation in an algorithms course.

BTW, I do not recommend the Khan Academy. It gets a lot of press but I have not found it so great. (It is fine but so is just surfing Youtube -- a lot of people make videos besides SK.)

Also, if you can still edit this question, you might give us some idea of where you're starting from and how much time you expect to spend, to elicit better answers.

HTH.

PS By "the hard way" do you mean doing exercises? Because pretty much all mathematics texts expect you to do it "the hard way" if that's what you mean.

crasshopper··on The rotten heart of finance
Wait for the lawsuits.

The article says $750 trillion of transactions are indexed to LIBOR each year. The short side of those were cheated out of money.

Hence "Banking's 'Tobacco Moment'".

crasshopper··on The rotten heart of finance
why shouldn't competition produce ... financial instruments that aren't pegged to any artificial index?

There are those, too, but people want to hedge against the risk that "interest rates" move.

Then they must define "interest rate": is it mortgages in Peoria? Car loans in Manila? 30-year Treasurys? ... Well, how about we use LIBOR.

crasshopper··on The rotten heart of finance
the entire financial world is built on this rate

The Epicurean Dealmaker (@epicureandeal) posted the standard response to your comment a few days ago ("Ready, Fire, Aim"). Prices are calculated as LIBOR + spread. You and I argue over the spread meaning that if I want 185 bp then I'll either ask LIBOR+165 or LIBOR+65 if the base rate went up by a whole 1%.

Check the people who responded to his twitter comments (e.g., @dsquareddigest) for more of the standard back-and-forth here. For example Eurodollar futures hedge the LIBOR so people short LIBOR during the period in question directly lost money.

Tangent: this is something I love about twitter. I imagine the meatspace equivalent would be eavesdropping on some Wall Street people in a bar, or hoping that a variety of voices get heard in the WSJ. But today, on twitter, I can read financial market participants' back & forth to each other about the scandal of the day, using their own terminology and reasoning. Very cool.

How on earth is such a conflict of interest allowed to parade around out in the open?

It's in no-one's interest to admit that systemically important banks have lost the confidence of their counterparties.

crasshopper··on The rotten heart of finance
Regarding this part of your statement:

there is no financial incentive to act responsibly because if you go bankrupt this year last year's bonus is already banked;

it should be noted that many bankers are terrible at saving; they simply scale up their spending rather than building a cushion for themselves. A large fraction of last year's bonus may already be gone or spoken for.

crasshopper··on The rotten heart of finance
According to Carolyn Sissoko (syntheticassets.wordpress.com) this is how English banks used to operate as well. Back in the days when draughts were accepted or not depending on the creditworthiness of the bank they were written by, it would have been laughable for a banker to not be super-wealthy, because how else would anyone recover their money in case of significantly correlated demand for liquidity? (This is long before the days of government guarantees preventing bank runs.)
crasshopper··on The best way to predict the future is to prevent it
Those are both good ideas.
crasshopper··on Why do you think people are poor?
You are maybe thinking that it is difficult to identify powerlaws? (EDIT: s/identify/statistically verify/; s/powerlaws/TRUE powerlaws/)

But look: http://globalrichlist.com/how.html The bulk is indeed powerlaw.

Maybe you are thinking that a sufficiently winsorised US income distribution is lognormal.

crasshopper··on Why do you think people are poor?
Power law (Pareto distribution), not lognormal.

But you're partly right. Simulate random exchanges at random prices and the wealth distribution will come out Pareto.

However, we cannot conclude that because [a] random exchanges lead to a power-law dist and [b] we observe a power-law in reality, that [c] the real wealth distribution is tantamount to random.

crasshopper··on I don't "get" art
what city?
crasshopper··on I don't "get" art
Related: the jazz educator David Baker has described the progression of learning jazz to first, joining together big, pre-made pieces; then, joining together small pieces; finally (as a master) joining together atoms.

I think something equivalent could be said for programming (journey from modifying a script that already works to understanding the atoms of the language) and there's some close-enough statement that could be made for painting / visual art. The journey from imitation to atom-by-atom originality.

crasshopper··on I don't "get" art
Imagine this. You read a novel and really enjoy it, interpreting some facet of the work as X. Later in an interview, the author suggests (or says outright) that the facet was actually Y ≠ X. That facet=Y would worsen the novel for you.

You go back to the novel and reread all relevant passages. You decide that not only is facet=X an internally consistent interpretation within the canonical text, but that facet=Y would lead to a contradiction. (Hey, authors are fallible and don't necessarily imagine non-contradictory worlds.)

So what is the "ontological" status of the interpretation where facet=X and the interpretation where facet=Y? Throw in that possibly either the author's intention isn't easily described in extant words, or that the author had no specific intention regarding `facet`, or otherwise multiple conflicting interpretations can still claim validity. Maybe the authors, artists, musicians are smartest to let audience members enjoy the work for their own personal reasons, without ruining a perfectly fine interpretation some individual takes.

Ahem. 'Scuse me, while I kiss this guy.

crasshopper··on I don't "get" art
> I think that classical art is enjoyed by those without an artistic background because there's at least an appreciation for the time and mastery invested into each piece.

Really? I'm a non-artist and I find all that old stuff (pre Turner I guess) extremely boring. How many frikking paintings of the Virgin Mary and Jesus do I have to endure. They all look the same to me, same even with the Dutch masters fruit and skulls. (Wow, how interesting, a pear. Not.)

OTOH, maybe if I had some education I would appreciate the historical significance (see, she's raising her left pinky? That was a snub to the patron)

crasshopper··on I don't "get" art
That is not a valid deduction from what leot said.
crasshopper··on I don't "get" art
Duke Ellington: "If it sounds good, it is good."

Sculpture professor whose class I modelled for: "Most people are going to completely ignore your work [that you spent weeks on, had your ego destroyed by peer criticism, fixed, put your soul into, etc] -- or look at it for about three seconds before moving on. If you can hold their attention longer -- if you can make them pause for an extra five seconds, and notice, or feel something, then you've succeeded." (He said this to students, not pre-acclaimed people whose work you're supposed to like because it has their name attached.)

Relatedly: If you can enrol in an art class (eg basic figurative drawing) it's a great growth experience. You'll also see what I saw: many levels of skill, an array of typical growth-paths, how artists are trained to conceive of their compositions (or of the human body), how very skilled kids can create something accurate-in-detail but totally uninteresting, and so on.

What's the difference between hearing a bunch of squealing and noise and ugly chords (=jazz) as a kid versus knowing how to play horn and wondering how jazz greats composed the atoms they did? (eg "abrupt, dramatic use of silence" by Thelonious Monk -- "how can you abruptly PAUSE?" you say) -- how a human might develop to the point (other than pure trolling) that they conceive of that composition. Not to mention a lot of technical details like what's easy/hard to do with a brush/chalk/charcoal/yarn/limestone/camera.

Certainly some people play games with an open-minded (=gullible), trusting audience (of potential buyers). http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N0NIs1fOkQg There's still plenty of great, subtle modern art that a 10-year-old would not appreciate but a 40-year-old could.

crasshopper··on I don't "get" art
When M Duchamp put a urinal on display in an art museum it made a novel point that we perceive quotidian things differently just because they're in an art gallery.

When [help me here] "installed" a live donkey "to symbolise his inability to come up with a good idea" that's piss.

That said there is plenty of excellent modern art. If you live in/near a wealthy city, this is easily verified.

crasshopper··on I don't "get" art
Agree. Perhaps Tracey Emin herself is trolling, who knows. But ∃x⊂A | Sx ↛ ∀x⊆A Sx. (S is for Sucks.)
crasshopper··on NASDAQ:FB
That sounds creepy. As if emotions are some kind of enemy to keep in check, rather than the substance of life.
crasshopper··on NASDAQ:FB
Sounds Zen.
crasshopper··on NASDAQ:FB
One of my favourite HN comments ever.
crasshopper··on Ask HN: Who Is Hiring? (May 2012)
My first thought: isn't Mendeley already the academic (paper-sharing) social network?
crasshopper··on Please don't learn to code
In terms of capital + human capital multiplying your effort, programming is pretty hard to beat. Compare sales calls, meetings with important people, instructions delivered to staff, farming with tractor; even hands-free investing requires a lot of time.

I think the most similar skill to coding is writing. John Updike remarked, several decades ago, that fiction creates value without destroying anything (ok, a trivial fraction of the value). But it's clearly not just about being able to put some words on a page.

crasshopper··on [dead]
Oops - shared too early. Check later today.
crasshopper··on The Coming Meltdown In College Education & Why The Economy Won’t Get Better Soon
I was using Cuban as an example because the book cover visible on the article is so jock-ish. In the above Cuban is supposed to represent that business-successful jock archetype.
crasshopper··on The Coming Meltdown In College Education & Why The Economy Won’t Get Better Soon
Maybe the people who think college is a waste of time should try to reach young people with that message. (career day at a nearby school? online forums young people hang out on?)
crasshopper··on The Coming Meltdown In College Education & Why The Economy Won’t Get Better Soon
"it doesn't matter"

In what sense? In a social-justice sense it seems like it does matter quite a bit. In a national-productivity sense "the college question" also matters quite a bit. In what sense doesn't $trillions of spending matter?

crasshopper··on The Coming Meltdown In College Education & Why The Economy Won’t Get Better Soon
Do you think Mark Cuban was a scholarly book-learner? Or that the top Latin student from your secondary school had a successful exit?

0 < correl(school chops, business chops) < 1

crasshopper··on The Coming Meltdown In College Education & Why The Economy Won’t Get Better Soon
Cuban: "Can someone please explain to me how what is happening in higher education is any different ?

You can't refi an education or sell your education to someone else. You can't pay someone to refurbish your education while you're working at your day job. You can't rent out two thirds of your education while living in the crappy part. And so on.

I'm not saying there's no bubble, but the two asset classes are clearly different.

← PreviousPage 3 of 13Next →