HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

criticalfault

269 karma · joined March 28, 2024

submissionscomments
criticalfault··on Mysterious tablet with unknown language unearthed in Georgia
I just heard a singing

Dum dum dum dum dum

criticalfault··on Microsoft is first to get HBM-juiced AMD CPUs
Maybe because of electron apps
criticalfault··on DOJ will push Google to sell off Chrome
> TLDR just be like Mozilla

Please don't.

Do we really want incompetent management going into ad business? Declining market share, while raising management salaries and firing developers?

criticalfault··on Switching customers from Linux to BSD because boring is good
I didnt know what bind mount js, so I googled it.

https://unix.stackexchange.com/questions/198590/what-is-a-bi...

There is something here that might solve your problem: nullfs. Check the stack exchange link.

I don't use bsd, so this is just me sharing what I found out.

criticalfault··on We need a real GNU/Linux (not Android) smartphone ecosystem
Banking apps come to mind.
criticalfault··on Making the Web Boring Again
What about servo/verso?
criticalfault··on Varlink – IPC to replace D-Bus gradually in systemd
This is overblown reaction t
criticalfault··on Varlink – IPC to replace D-Bus gradually in systemd
He explained it here

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41694711

criticalfault··on Poverty in Argentina soars to over 50% as Milei's austerity measures hit hard
With the feeling people dislike milei, and risking down votes, could this be 'getting worse before it gets better'? As said in the following video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18RTtDVghfw

As someone not really too informed about argentinian politics or economy, but knowing stuff only from news reports - isn't milei doing really everything that macroeconomists said needs to be done?

First of which was to reduce the public sector and subsidies?

https://apnews.com/article/milei-economy-union-protests-stri...

Reduce Inflation?

https://www.reuters.com/markets/argentinas-august-inflation-...

And it seems that poverty didnt go to 50% under milei, but actually went 10% up (saw it in a different comment here).

I'm not for milei (or against him), as I said, I don't really know or understand argentinian politics to make an opinion (although what is being done might be a bit brutal), really just asking a question here. This looks like an economic transformation or economic revolution in progress, and there will be (of course) difficulties before it goes better.

criticalfault··on Rewriting Rust
Given that your proposal is backwards compatible, what is preventing it from moving to standard language faster? Especially if it improves the situation drastically.

Also, why would pinned be a syntactic sugar for Pin and not the other way around?

criticalfault··on Mira Murati leaves OpenAI
Bad?

I just tried Gemini and it was useless.

criticalfault··on Scientists discover how many chemicals from food packaging enter our bodies
It reminds me of the DDT era, but corrupt...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CUDVuugQmxE

People were probably ignorant when they were spraying kids with DDT. Today it's ignorance mixed with greed.

criticalfault··on Twitter shut off API access; users volunteering their own data for an open API
Users should just get off this continued tragedy and API access wouldn't be an issue
criticalfault··on Intel lost the Sony Playstation business to AMD
If we are talking foundry, Intel could still manufacture amd chips in their own fab instead of tsmc. Given that 18A is good...

This would be strange, but it would show Intel will do what it takes.

criticalfault··on Oracle, it's time to free JavaScript
Maybe it's about the definition of the word 'popular'.

Dictionary.com:

1. regarded with favor, approval, or affection by people in general

2. regarded with favor, approval, or affection by an acquaintance or acquaintances:

3. of, relating to, or representing the people, especially the common people:

4. of the people as a whole, especially of all citizens of a nation or state qualified to participate in an election:

5. prevailing among the people generally:

6. suited to or intended for the general masses of people:

7. adapted to the ordinary intelligence or taste:

8. suited to the means of ordinary people; not expensive:

I have always associated popular with definition 1. Let me ask differently: do people really like JavaScript or they like web and JavaScript is forced upon them since there are no alternatives (and they actually dislike/hate it)?

criticalfault··on Oracle, it's time to free JavaScript
> JavaScript is the world’s most popular programming language

Is this really so?

I have the feeling this is 'popular' because there are no alternatives. Web is popular, this is just an accompanying disaster.

There was an argument about fragmentation so people didn't want more things as option. As an answer to that there were many (?) attempts to solve problems that come with JavaScript for years, anybody remember coffee script? The only one that worked is typescript. And typescript again transpiles to Javascript having worse performance and a bunch of limitations.

The only alternative that I saw that makes sense is dart and people crucified google for considering to include it in chromium. It is really a shame that this didn't get accepted.

criticalfault··on Building a browser using Servo as a web engine
While super excited for servo being made into a browser, I am disappointed in seeing OpenGL at the core of it.

Promising a better battery life while having better performance, better drivers and wide support, I really don't see how Vulkan is still not the first choice when it comes to GPU stuff.

criticalfault··on Gnome Files: A detailed UI examination
Nope, it was laptop (bare metal), kubuntu or fedora KDE Spin.

Player might have been installed via flatpak though. But I don't remember anymore.

criticalfault··on Gnome Files: A detailed UI examination
In another comment I also remembered kdenlive. Not even sure what gnome has since I don't edit video.

Gedit (or now gnome-text) is more equivalent of kwrite. Gnome doesn't have an equivalent to kate, me thinks.

Umbrello: https://github.com/gaphor/gaphor

I use smplayer on windows, this is a good app. Does it run on Wayland? And does it have hardware acceleration for decoding? I had issues on Wayland (gnome) with it.

Cantata is abandoned.

Files I excluded because dolphin is better functionally. It wasn't excluded because I want to skew results in my favor, but because there is no discussion. One exception: in dolphin you cannot open files directly from smb:// shares

criticalfault··on Gnome Files: A detailed UI examination
The question was a bit assholish, because rant. Fair to call me on it.

Yes, I am aware that KDE audience is broader. Just remembered an additional good product from KDE: kdenlive.

Let me try to put it in a better way: most of the time I have seen Linux in the wild (let's say companies) was Ubuntu/gnome. Even tv shows. And I don't remember ever seeing kde (LiMux aside since it is dead now). I have read that it is sometimes used in some specific industries like chemistry for legacy reasons/apps. Not sure how the automotive industry fits here, but I know they for example use qt, not sure if this extends to kde.

Based on what I have seen and read (which is not all Industries of course), KDE has a significantly smaller user base.

In a non-professional setting, I have exclusively seen gnome.

Not sure how steamdeck fits here, depends on what valve took. Last I read was a compositor. Di they actually use whole desktop with plasmoids?

Can you give an example of de-independent apps that are superior? To be clear: when talking about fitting into a desktop and talking about gnome vs KDE, it comes down mostly to the toolkit. Some examples like vlc could be considered de-independent though even though they use qt

Don't get me wrong, I don't hate KDE project. Far from it. But what they do and what I think they should do differs.

What I completely disagree with is that UX of gnome is wrong. It is opinionated and a lot of us like this 'opinion'. Many people using Ubuntu don't change a thing. Does this fit usable defaults? If things are well thought out, why do I need to tinker with the desktop to launch firefox, office, copy files or consume multimedia? Because in the end - this is what it is about, productivity.

I don't get this hostility statement. They follow a vision - their vision. They offer it for free. And people are upset because they do not work on the vision of that (minor) group?

criticalfault··on Gnome Files: A detailed UI examination
Yes, called gnome boxes.

https://apps.gnome.org/Boxes/

This was only an example. Boxes is no metric for anything, but having an app that works well in that Desktop is a good thing. There is nothing flike that or KDE. It's all for gnome. Point here being that KDE has a lack of apps.

If talking about more generic apps, gnome has better Multimedia Tools, Firefox uses gtk to better integrate with gnome... The only thing/app kde has better is krita. Or is there something I'm missing that gnome doesn't do better? (Excluding files from this comparison)

I'm just wondering who is then target audience for KDE? Only artists that use krita? Or teenagers that like to mod stuff?

Regarding wifi, given only 'standard' use, you connect to wifi and that's it. Gnome offers a password entry and done. For advanced users I don't see an issue - they can figure it out (gnome connection editor has quite some advanced options). And also, I didn't use KDE on a real machine for a while.

criticalfault··on Gnome Files: A detailed UI examination
Disaster visuals are icons in e.g. dolphin, sidebar and toolbar, but in different ways.

Sidebar are only lines and I find that the overly simplistic shapes do not represent ideas well. Example: go back icon. Similar problems exist for toolbar icons. At some point I cannot conclude if the shape is a graphics glitch or an icon. These are the icons with some shape bottom right.

Another example is sidebar consistency: recently I noticed there are 3 distinct looks in sidebars in KDE. The most modern one (kirigami I guess) looks almost the same as gnome (I think system settings have it in the last version), so here they are improving.

Another example: their logo and Startup Animation.

Buggy things: setup with 2 monitors, then 4k monitors, a bunch of this didn't work well, I opened several bugs for these things. I moved to gnome which didn't have these problems, so I'm not sure how this is behaving now.

Changing something about plasmoids / taskbar used to crash my session, but don't remember wether I opened a bug for this. I like having it at the top, so moving it up would even be a problem. After the crash, it would be fine for a long time. Also generally reordering plasmoids on the taskbar itself would be buggy.

As I said - this is how it used to be. Did not use it as a main desktop for a while, I would try to see what is new in a VM, but always got shocked how bad the design is. They are trying to improve it, but for something to make sense, radical changes are needed. For example, there were some really nice proposals for logo change for plasma 6 and nobody jumped on it. Like any other bureaucratic organization they decided not to do anything.

criticalfault··on Gnome Files: A detailed UI examination
I would disagree that gnome has terrible usability. It has a very good one. Nobody's saying it is perfect, but I and many other people can use it without issues.

KDE has more features, so maybe *some* things are a bit easier. But everything else is way worse. Including lack of certain apps like a decent VM manager.

I feel sorry for kde, the community there is way friendlier and whatnot, but this Frankenstein approach is bad for serious use. Somebody defined a compromise like a solution which nobody is happy with and KDE feels exactly like that. People adjust how it looks and feels for that reason.

They feel overly bureaucratic and and embodiment of this https://xkcd.com/1172/

criticalfault··on Gnome Files: A detailed UI examination
That's not completely true. They are hated by some users, loved by some.

For example, in general, I really like what gnome does. Desktop use is not something that is useful outside starting other apps, so I like its simplicity and the fact that it gets out of the way.

Default apps could use maybe a bit more features, but I generally don't find too much wrong with e.g. files. The only confusing thing for me is which hamburger to click when I want to create a new directory. So instead of guessing, I just right click the file list. One positive example in gnome is when you try to access e.g. smb:// shares in files and try to open a movie from the share... It works with no issues. But, kde with gazillion features does not support that.

(Opinion) KDE is not more popular since it's buggy as hell. At least it was. But not only that, their visuals are a disaster. Believe what you will, but visual consistency and attention to detail is what gnome has. They are not perfect, so there are some issues as OP points out, but they are on a different level from kde. KDE looks like it was frankensteined, while gnome it looks like it was designed. Think just login process and sddm, how many time it blinks?

KDE is proud to enable tinkering, and this is good - there are people that like to do that. Thinking back, this was when I was teenager. Now that I'm older, I want things well thought out, designed well that dont get in my way so I can do my work and not think about desktop. And this is gnome.

What I hate about gnome is JavaScript and python focus for apps. And now, suddenly we need a stupid app for everything.

criticalfault··on Rust in Linux Revisited
Nobody said he is an expert in Linux internals.

What this brings to light is the ability to compare Helios (microkernel) and Unix clone development, or how it was said in the post: reimplementing already existing design vs designing something new.

Because of this, I think his statements carry some weight.

criticalfault··on Rust in Linux Revisited
No. He himself said it here.

https://fosstodon.org/@drewdevault/113052127771211132

What he did though, he developed a Unix clone using hare in roughly 30 days.

https://fosstodon.org/@drewdevault/112319697309218275

criticalfault··on Is OpenSUSE at Crossroads?
> Oh, they would also be used by those mentally retarded zoomers who really can use GNOME without cursing every five seconds and without feeling they have zero productivity. One should be born into macOS to like GNOME, and even then.

Stopped reading after this.

criticalfault··on Ladybird Web Browser becomes a non-profit with $1M from GitHub Founder
Three questions:

Will you use Vulkan when it comes to gpu accel or OpenGL?

Will you make better adblocking capabilities by embedding faster checks and rule engines/lookups in c++ than what we have now?

How much can people who do not contribute code affect development? In terms of requests suggestions? E.g. if I would suggest to skip OpenGL and use Vulkan (so basically defining a limit on how old should the hw be), would this be even considered?

criticalfault··on Xamarin has reached End of Support
Bitwarden people had some info about it. They decided to make native apps instead

https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitwarden/comments/1b32bbz/going_na...

criticalfault··on Google layoffs hit Flutter team
I think dart was meant to be used as a JavaScript alternative. Google was working on chrome with dart VM even... But as far as I remember it got abandoned due to pushback from the 'community' due to 'not wanting fragmentation'. Obviously by people who didn't want things changed.

Web is the only place where we don't have an alternative and dart would be a great contender.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →