HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

csydas

4,075 karma · joined August 9, 2015

on HN, I use they/them for myself

if you really want to write me for some reason, stallmanniquin at gee mail dort corn

I don't check this often though so please don't be upset if I don't respond fast.

submissionscomments
csydas··on France fines Microsoft €60M for imposing advertising cookies
But they did inject countermeasures; the fines.

The relevant governing bodies need to crack down on companies that are violating the rulings and ensure that it's understood this is a requirement for doing business.

If you've ever been in a position to write policy, you know the adage that if you design something to be idiot-proof, they'll just design a better idiot. Same rule applies for bad actors.

Laws don't try to predict everything, that's why the spirit of the law is just as important as the letter. What the law means to accomplish is just as important as what is actually written, and persons who violate the spirit of the law while not explicitly violating the letter should not get a free pass; this is not how law works, and it's why despite the hundreds of thousands of laws on the US books, there are still courts to interpret laws and make rulings on situations.

Corporations can kick and scream all they want while writhing through to meet the letter of the law, but that doesn't make them right, it just makes them desperate.

csydas··on France fines Microsoft €60M for imposing advertising cookies
That's because the cookie dialogues as they are now were never part of the original GDPR and other privacy related bills/acts/whatever.

GDPR requires that consent is as easy to withdraw as it is to give. [0]

That companies have dragged their feet and gone kicking and screaming with cookie banners is irrelevant to the actual law; the EU needs to start cracking down more and more on this to show what it actually means, since it's quite clear that companies are not going to willingly comply with the data consent laws.

So don't blame the politicians on this one, they never gave any requirement for such banners, and in fact specifically mentioned that it must be simple to revoke/deny consent. Companies that didn't want to comply with GDPR and other privacy laws decided to make it as painful as possible for you and I and blame it on the privacy rules.

[0] - https://gdpr-info.eu/art-7-gdpr/

csydas··on Promotion of alternative social platforms policy
This doesn't hold to scrutiny.

Excuse the gross comparison, but if a serial public pee-er moves to the same area I live in and pees wantonly all over the place, the answer isn't "just move somewhere without people peeing in public", it's to take some action and complain loudly about the fact I don't like that someone is peeing all over where I live without any repercussion.

Elon Musk has too much in the game to both participate on and run Twitter. The bans in the last weeks are far too convenient to simply be the new moderation staff finding abhorrent persons when there are reporters, parodists, and just general Elon Musk objectors being banned from Twitter without any oversight or reason. Mastodon is not a good alternative, as nice as it might be; the on-boarding and the concept is too much for most people, and ultimately moving to Mastodon is just conceding Twitter to Elon Musk, when openly defying and degrading all stores of value that Elon can influence are a real way to enact change.

Already the biggest Tesla investors are calling Elon Musk out as detrimental to Tesla stock because of his performance on/with Twitter. I do not desire punishment or pain for anyone, but I also don't want someone to be able to manipulate public discourse like I understand Elon Musk is currently doing with Twitter (for my perception, the bans are just far too specific and vague; the tweets and their content are completely non-offensive and the rulings from Twitter are far too specific to be afterthoughts of safety)

Elon Musk is not a great person by any means, he just has money; money should not be a reason to elevate an opinion above another by any stretch of the imagination. The sooner that the world accepts this, the better, and if it means that Elon Musk's valuation tanks, then so be it.

csydas··on Windows 11 update added 'Search' label to taskbar search button – how to remove?
Well, except the article and the argument aren't what we were talking about.

You were talking about % of users using an option and the cost of using it, to which I argued that it's quite difficult even with perfect telemetry to know whether people are not using an option because they don't want to use it or they just cannot find it. Telemetry data like this just tells you N% of users do X; you don't know why just from the fact that they do it. The user base for my product does X which is contrary to the intended design all the time, and we don't know why until we get to one on one discussions as to why they tried it that way, and even that is very difficult data to get.

Your article here is not really related, it's about choices in UI that are confusing (and also cannot be enabled/disabled from the UI), and in fact I even understand this point to undermine the first; even if Microsoft continues to do large amounts of user testing, are they doing anything meaningful with the data if they continue to have too many choices?

I don't think there's a lot of sense to speculate on why Microsoft made a choice unless they publish a claim as to why they made a choice; we can point to data and anecdata endlessly to support positions but it doesn't actually make a case for the affirmative in either way.

What I am to say is that even with user testing, countless options, and so on, at best you can say that on a vanilla installation, N% of a sample group did X. With extrapolating statistical math, you can assume with a margin of error that if N% of users from Z sample set did X, then Y% of users will likely do the same with some margin of error.

From anecdata I can know from other persons who call themselves Windows power users and/or technical persons, I know that the common response to most Windows changes is not that it's good or bad, but that you just learn to deal with it after awhile. Personally I take this as more negative, that is it's not active adoption it's begrudging acceptance, but that's a personal take.

csydas··on Windows 11 update added 'Search' label to taskbar search button – how to remove?
It's the wrong way to Fram the question.

If I have a program that emits a painful audio bit every time the user does X and only 0.05% of users disable it by going to a configuration value they need to search for through dozens of (my own) SEO'd results, that doesn't mean that only 0.05% of users want it disabled, it just means that only 0.05% of users were able to figure out how to stop my program from doing X.

I work on a product where our power user base is known for requesting registry options to change/disable feature x/y, and our market research has consistently shown a registry value doesn't enter most people's minds; to further this point, our user base is specifically IT persons. Even our Linux user base (actual day to day linux users) don't consider asking if we have a config file to edit somewhere in any overwhelming way.

The point I take from this data (which I know is anecdata for you) is that most users assume software "out of the box" is what you see is what you get. Making these changes and options and not including a way to remove them is not a good way of tracking interest since the sample size that is actually willing to take the time to complain and post compared to those that just look at other software entirely are far different. You're dealing with a complete unknown in the Power User space; regular users are even less inclined to see how to disable it and hiding it behind registry edits is actually a dissuasion.

csydas··on Airlines lobbying FAA to have only one pilot in the cockpit
Not in the least.

A future where the baseline minimum isn't homelessness and suffering in the street simply has not been done before.

Remove the need to struggle for a basic comfortable life, a new world has a chance to thrive.

The past has the burden of dealing with the fact that the difference between a day-labourer and a wealthy elite is the former has to struggle to meet basic survival and participation in society is eliminated the the basic day-to-day is already met.

Human nature will adjust, just like it did to the industrial revolution, to the digital revolution, and so on. Hundreds of thousands of data entry specialists were replaced by digital automation; even more land-laborers were replaced by farm automation.

The difference with the future I want is that there is a guarantee of a good and basic living, whereas the past had no ability to guarantee this.

Human nature doesn't enter into it; when anyone can travel anywhere, can replicate the same food or goods the wealthy elite currently enjoy exclusively, there is no practical separation between them. It becomes a non-issue; just like some years ago emoji were a status symbol (remember, you used to need to _pay_ for stupid emojis), they're a standard now.

The world can be better, we see this everywhere even today with municipal and community efforts, with OSS, and so on. It's already here in many spheres, it's just a matter of accepting that there's no harm in a percentage of society taking advantage of such a system.

The points you make have no relevance in a world where you don't need oil workers, arctic fisherman, day laborers, and so on.

csydas··on Airlines lobbying FAA to have only one pilot in the cockpit
You're absolutely missing the point.

This is _my_ fantasy world, not bound by the history of Star Trek; the show itself in later series got ruined by awful writers who couldn't figure out how to make a sci-fi utopia fun to watch and instead made a faux-military/action drama for no reason. I want no part in that future.

Second, I think you actually miss the point of these episodes; the challenge in the Cardassian border wars and issues was "how does a space utopia exist with a (comically) fascist regime?" Debatably, the actions of the Maquis and other border colonies were persons stuck in a land ownership mindset which is exactly what I think we need to avoid. Data even proved this in the episode with the Sheliak to convince the people of Tau Cygni V that a place is just a place.

I have no idea what you're referring to about a trailer in a desert, but in actual Star Trek, everyone had a home, had food, had a place to live.

Regarding luxury apartments and vineyards, I must ask: why would you care? If you have a spacious and great apartment that meets your absolute every need for you and your family, why would you care if someone has more square meters or a higher floor on a high-rise? In a world where transporters and shuttlecraft and replicators exist, why would you care where your home is located except that it meets your personal vision of a perfect home? You can live in the middle of the alps and have every modern convenience at your fingertips and just enjoy the snow.

As for the vineyard, again, I think you're looking at this from a very current perspective; in a world with replicators and synthehol where only a few specific snobs care about real alcohol versus replicated alcohol, owning a vineyard and manually tending to it likely is just something where everyone goes "right, have fun with that." (Also, Picard didn't own the vineyard, his brother did. I guess in the Picard series he controlled it also? But never watched it)

I really cannot take the comment seriously as I think you both miss the point of the episodes regarding property/land and also are not considering how people might view apartment sizes and such in a world when transportation, knowledge, information, energy costs, food, basically everything is already taken care of. Remember, even humble Scotty thought he was being given an admiral's treatment in TNG when he got a _basic_ quarters for his stay.

Try to imagine that's what your normal life looks like, and then ask yourself how much you would care if someone has a few extra square meters.

csydas··on Airlines lobbying FAA to have only one pilot in the cockpit
I'm not sure why you're taking this as victim blaming. _Everyone_ needs to change, including the corporations and the very society we live in to make it a goal.

If it wasn't implicit in my fantasy world, there is no more class difference. Everyone has a very good baseline, like _VERY_ good. Clothing, food, transportation, energy, housing. When this is all taken care of in a great way, what exactly will corporations have to sell anymore to have the power they have now?

Personal gain doesn't just mean exorbitant wealth, it means the entire style of life we've built modern society around. Yes, I work for personal gain because I want to travel, eat cool food, and get nice things to make my life better. Everyone does this because they have to. That's not victim blaming, it's a fact of life that everyone does this. Many have to work harder and struggle more because of the inequality of the system that forces the only means of living as "work towards personal gain."

Now just try to imagine for a moment what your life would be like if you didn't have to focus on personal gain, you just implicitly had a guaranteed stable and nice and comfortable life; what would you do? Would you still try to chase only ventures that secure your future further, or would you maybe start to consider more passion projects?

To be perfectly clear, I absolutely understand that this is not as simple of a matter of "hey everyone, let's just be nicer" and then we will have utopia. Far from it, I understand there are deeply entrenched systems that force this way of consumption and struggle on the entire planet.

The first step towards something better however is to accept that it can be possible; as long as we're telling ourselves it can never be better, naturally it's going to be stuck this way. You can see small examples of this everywhere; municipal ISPs versus the incumbent ISPs are a perfect example of a community saying "hey, the corporation is bullshit, let's do our own thing", and this works out pretty well, results in better and cheaper service for communities, and ultimately weakens corporations as they have to play nicer in order to play at all.

What other elements in your life could be improved like this? That is all I'm asking you to think about.

csydas··on Airlines lobbying FAA to have only one pilot in the cockpit
Automation doesn't need to have The Matrix as the end result; it could be a Star Trek utopia.

If automation was truly in the spirit of freeing people from having to struggle to survive, imagine a system build around an automated future where because everything is so efficient and there's no need for menial labor, you can just kind of do whatever you want; art, research, gardening, you name it. Freeloaders in the system sum up to a rounding error for the resources needed to support them because the system is efficient. Enough people like the system that they willingly work to maintain it and improve it (it's even exciting for them to study and build new and better ways of providing the resources than the existing way), but ultimately you just have time to do the things you tell yourself right now you can't do because you need to take meetings/clean up the house/work 8+ hours a day to sustain a basic living, etc.

It's likely going to be a tough transition as long as we still think in terms of "I as a person must maximize my gains and protect them from everyone else", but automation could easily provide such a life for everyone if it advances enough. That transition is gonna be a hard one though as the habit of personal gain is a tough one to break after living in it for so long.

csydas··on Sign Everything
I actually don't see how signing everything solves the problem of AI generated essays unless you build a submission system that doesn't allow copy/pasting over a certain amount or that somehow assesses whether or not the 2000 words it just received were actually written by the user holding the keys or not.

Signing just is a means of asserting an authority over an item and then tracking that item once it's in the chain. The original validity of the authority isn't guaranteed just because it's signed; that was a non-trivial part of the debate over NFTs, wasn't it?

So I don't think signing really proves anything about the authorship or authority over the content written, it just tracks the content. The author's example that you can know they're the one who posted it doesn't really have anything to do with generated reports, and it doesn't even prove that they were the ones who uploaded the content any more than a classic blog with a username/password system. It just means that someone with access to the keys to upload provided content, not _who_ uploaded it. It's presumed it's the author as hopefully they kept their secrets safe, but that's not a guarantee.

csydas··on The clever reason scammers can’t spell (2019)
I'm not sure it's the case with the type of scam that the article is talking about. Phishing credentials and getting people on the phone to buy gift cards and transfer money require a vastly different approach I suppose.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18bovtIlrpI

Skip through the hot parts of the video per the graph and just see how the scam actually works, and I think that for all the social engineering steps required and the sheer amount of time spent on the phone, most people would just give up even if they maybe fell for the initial well designed email.

I don't really want to speculate on the spelling/email of scam emails as I think short of some reporter just finding a spam-house and asking, it will all be senseless speculation. The article theory has plausible theories, but might very well be specious. I don't buy that it's due to poor English skills, as spellchecks are plentiful and I have no doubt that the spam-houses could easily pirate older copies of Word and get a decent looking email.

Similarly, if it was effective, I have to imagine that this is the format they'd pick.

The simplest explanations of the poorly formatted/written emails and chats for me are:

1. The targets that have the highest chance of success don't care about the emails

2. The formatting of the initial emails doesn't impact the scam in a significant way

From a more personal perspective and the people I know who continued with the scam past its initial stages, they didn't pay attention to the formatting, just the general idea behind the message was more their concern. The IRS scams, giftcard scams, etc, put some sort of pressure on the people in a way that they truly stopped thinking about the content and were more worried about the idea behind the message: they would get in trouble if they didn't comply, and the financial concerns were the driving force.

csydas··on How hospice became a for profit hustle
Unfortunately, I cannot read the article in full because of the paywall, but before I entered into the tech-sphere, I had a brief stint in vulnerable persons hospice.

It was a nightmare fueled by the $15/hour wage in 2011 wages. While the price was right for my needs, ethically I could not sleep at night.

My first night involved:

- Persons unable to cleanse themselves after normal bodily functions

- Several dead persons

- Said dead persons and many others who took the time to edit their living will to reflect me because for the few nights I kept this job, I treated them like human beings needing help

I walked away from this job after a week and lawsuits followed from the bereaved and the business itself because I was named in the living will. From my perspective, these were persons who had no business signing a contract and by any medical definition were not fit to determine a reward in their living will. I am not here to pretend I understand the nuances of law and why such an action was allowed, but after quitting and outright telling my boss I was not up to the mental stress of seeing people die on a nightly basis and waiting for (US) medical services to arrive and literally kick a body around, I ended up with very little faith in the hospice system.

My coworkers openly bragged about the "opportunities" they found for themselves with persons who couldn't even figure out the current date without someone holding their hand and writing the date for them. This was abhorrent to me in ways I don't know how to put into words, but I have images of the nearby dog kennel and such persons taking advantage of the patients.

US hospice is absolutely an under-studied and over-abused factor in US life. To make matters worse, as I understood it from discussions with colleagues, far too many people see the abuses as a necessity or "fair trade" with the alternative being that persons who need hospice rotting in the street.

The irony kills me at a core point that so many people in the training accepted this as a sensible truth instead of being upset that those in need have the choice of total abuse or rotting in the gutter.

I will write that I am sickened by this environment, but sickened doesn't come close to describing the filth and awfulness I felt in such an environment.

csydas··on Twitter in chaos as employees accept Musk’s invitation to quit their jobs
For me it's not so certain; I think that most of the devs/engineers at Meta, Twitter, et. al., might get a bit of cold feet with the biggest tech companies and with Silicon Valley in general.

I think smaller companies and upstarts have a chance to get some great talent that will be strongly considering their living situation and looking for something more stable, but I'm not so sure that Twitter is going to have its pick of the litter for a long time until it demonstrates a stable and mature environment to work in.

I have no doubts some persons will be very nervous and take the opportunity, and I wish them luck. I'm not so sure others will be as eager.

csydas··on DeviantArt upsets artists with its new AI art generator, DreamUp
I believe I understand what your position is regarding the concept of art vs non-art.

However, I think the main argument is less about the artistic merit of AI generated art and more about the impact on the ability for artists to be artists when one of the means of generating a means for a living is removed from them. The elevator music and office artwork pieces were the means for income for many that allowed for the pursuit of more complex and long term projects. It was art insomuch as it was a creative endeavor, but I'm not sure how many artists believed that such pieces were their true expression.

A lot of that is now quite easily replaceable by anyone with a bit of time, a few source sample images, some keyword manipulation, and a computer as "simple" as a MacBook. Music generation likely isn't far off, and I think Meta even demo'd some AI-Video generator.

Automation should serve the people, and I have no doubt that at some point in a nicer future it will be a boon where we can have "nice things" and a lot of expression that wasn't previously possible. In the interim, there is a slew of people whose living means are heavily at risk. Patreon, et. al., aren't going to be enough to sustain every single artist, and like a lot of automation advances in the past, it will disenfranchise a rather large population. Besides that, not everyone can just draw furry porn for big commissions.

I think that this should concern a lot of tech persons also who imagine themselves protected from this as the human element of programming, technology design, etc, simply "cannot be replicated", but I think that projects like Co-Pilot are showing that there is a huge focus on replicating AI-Art in the same way, and similar to artists, a lot of programmers are having their code forced into the system to remove their agency, and with no compensation. The very act of producing something in order to sustain one's self is now also an act of self-destruction as the product feeds the AI more data.

I think the technology and the potential benefits of AI generated X is great and it's a step towards removing a lot of the petty grunt-work that is required to make the world work. The big question is how are we going to keep the lights on for people if there isn't a system in place to ensure that people can sustain themselves? Current social safety nets don't cut it, and socially there is still a huge opposition towards creating better safety nets.

I suspect that's why there is such concern over AI-Generated anything; the classic thinking and creative work that was a safe place from automation is now automated, and the world doesn't look ready yet to make the leap to societies that have automated away the need for menial tasks for everyone and provide everyone a pretty nice standard of living.

csydas··on Why is every layoff 10-15%?
Yes and no.

When COVID more or less "left" corporate culture, a lot of US businesses wanted to go fully back to work or to make remote work a benefit, i.e., you'd take cuts elsewhere for the privilege to work remotely/from home.

While some of it is likely power-tripping on the part of managers, I suspect some of it is more complex involving expensive building leases and trying to justify costs, fear of "what happens if the culture shifts again and we need to find office space", which I do think is a reasonable concern, but not to the point that it should shut down remote work entirely.

Anecdotally, I do know quite a few higher management ones who were very upset by remote work; they liked the idea of having "their" employees in a single spot so they could check it at any time for various projects; some relented when after an honest talk they conceded they never really checked in person and did everything by chat/call/email anyways, but there were a few sticklers that just honestly believed "butts in chairs or we lose all productivity", even though 2 years of data from COVID times shattered this belief entirely.

Part of why I think the position was so predominant in the US was that the job market power was so vastly different there; in European countries, it was far more competitive for a company seeking candidates and this gave a lot more negotiating power for employees I think since there was certainly a job lined up for them, whereas in the US it was a bit more uncertain that you could get a position since there were so many more candidates than positions in many cases, so businesses had the ability to be far more exclusive and demanding.

csydas··on What to blog about
I think you're conflating SEO blogspam with genuine passion for writing.

One claims to be the other in order to shield itself from accusations of being SEO blogspam, the other is just a person wanting to share their experience.

I have no issues reading about how someone discovered how TTL can help in a Wireshark investigation, even though I already know it. I do have issues with someone's blog showing in online searches simply because they figured out which keywords to place (and where) in order to get to page 1 of Google, displacing actual articles of relevance to what I'm seeking. It's an absolute shame that actual companies have fallen to the same trap and even intentionally push preferable articles that result in fewer Support cases while burying the actual issue under SEO'd garbage. (The less said about Microsoft "dead-links" where they retroactively remove the content, the better)

I would love to read about a first timer understanding recursion; my hopes would be either that I would learn a new way of understanding it myself because of the enthusiasm they had as a result of their moment of inspiration, or I can add to the discourse on my own understanding.

I want to read about discovery and education! I don't want to read inspirational articles or how to monetize/appeal to investors when I'm looking for technical things.

My favorite part of mentoring is seeing my mentees make it work by their own inspiration and mental skill; I don't care if it's inefficient as long as they did it on their own. We can discuss optimizations later, I just want to see people pushing themselves to a new level and be excited about it. They can write an entire Russian-Novel length post as far as I'm concerned, I will read and revel in every word as long as it's their excitement because of their success.

csydas··on Ask HN: How to deal with my team speaking a different language?
Just talk to them. In English.

I've worked in a multi-language business for many years where I did not speak all the languages, and there are two points I think you need to take to heart

1. No one can guess what you're feeling/thinking, you need to tell them

2. Don't take it personally if people are doing what comes naturally to them

Your comment on benefit of the office is understood, but misguided; your colleagues don't have an obligation to speak a specific language to you and make you feel better, that's not their job. I am not trying to be harsh, but you need to understand that your personal desire and comfort is not their responsibility. If they aren't being hostile to you or any other workplace violation, they're not doing anything wrong.

My guess is you feel left out because you _don't know_ whether you're left out or not. Even if they talk about your project in Mandarin, can you be 100% sure it's something relevant to you? Or even really about the project? Can you be certain that one of your colleagues wasn't just talking about how stressed they are about something and just wanted to vent? I'm not sure you can know this unless you ask them or learn the language, and in fact, both will help you feel a bit more included.

Overall, just talk with the colleagues in a private way and just mention your feelings and how you really want to join the conversations with them on the project but cannot if they converse in Mandarin; after that it's up to them.

For yourself, understand that you don't need to be part of every conversation and your colleagues don't have an obligation to you or the company to hold every conversation in English. The steps you can take are to just calmly tell that you want to join the conversations about the project (or others), and also learn some Mandarin. It's honestly not _that_ hard to pick up languages at least at a rudimentary level. Probably you will sound funny at first, but everyone does with a new language. Use it as an icebreaker to get in and just own it, and soon you will all find a middlepoinn that works for you.

csydas··on On Feeling Competent
I'm not sure it's exclusive to Universities -- consider that the majority of jobs that don't require higher education typically have a very direct focus on "success" and this is the metric used for performance, I think it's just generally pervasive in business to want to see a specific desired outcome. "Line goes up" is a meme, but this is what runs a lot of businesses.

I left University with a research mindset, which was further developed by living with a bunch of people in deep sciences who thought very research-like about everything in life (to a fault I'd say), but the end result was I ended up becoming a lot more analytical whereas I had entered University very outcome oriented. As I transitioned more and more into technical items, I understood how this approach was so much more useful. My classes in University were not technical but more research oriented, and while there were deadlines, there was not a specific outcome sought, just present a position, research it, and defend it. I believe this has done pretty well for me.

It becomes a lot easier to solve issues (technical or otherwise) by understanding the full business rules of a situation and not being attached to specific outcomes but instead just implementing what makes sense. When I still did support and research, it became a lot easier to understand very challenging issues and getting time to research more by simply explaining how I understood the issue so far, what I had researched, why I thought this was relevant, and my next steps. The hardest clients weren't ones with very difficult and complex issues but instead the outcomes oriented ones that needed a solution X by Y date, Y being arbitrarily picked. The answer given in most cases was not to these clients' satisfaction ("we can make "something" by Y, but understand it will be a kludge. Or we can find the real answer, and I can't tell you when that happens since we don't know what the answer is yet."), but typically there is _someone_ at the client org higher up that understands the options and wants the real answer and stamps out any idea of arbitrary deadlines and instead accepted reasonable and proper updates on the investigation. It's not always the case as sometimes Outcome Orientated is just an institutional pillar for a company, but often it worked.

My favorite part of actual research is realizing in situations when Z is not working, do you really need Z at all? I've solved more coding issues by simply not trying to shoehorn in Z or battling with Z's nuances than I have by writing novels of code to work with Z. The owners for Z typically get grumpy about the situation, but it's understandable they have an investment in their item, so they tend to be defensive.

csydas··on Available Today: Windows Dev Kit 2023 a.k.a. Project Volterra
I don't think MS needs to push this if they want to succeed, they need to start making a consumer friendly machine that Windows runs fantastically on.

For an "acceptable" laptop, the price point is already pretty close to $1000, and before I would have a tentative recommendation of MacBooks/Macbook Airs because of the learning curve of MacOS. With M1/M2 and how much better it is than anything else on the consumer market, I openly recommend it to anyone in the market for a new consumer machine. Gaming isn't even that much of an issue anymore, so for casual players it's pretty fine.

I was discussing this with a colleague last night, but the M1/M2 chips and complimentary hardware let Apple do some amazing stuff out of the box without adjustment that Windows simply has no answer for. The integration of the complimentary hardware with the M1/M2 chips is so strong that I stumbled onto features I completely missed announcements on, and it legitimately "wow'd" me.

- Live Text caught me off-guard while drag/drop-ing an image to a chat app. I couldn't stop testing its limits and reading the dev docs

- I took surprise calls from really crowded + noisy places and was in disbelief that my call partners couldn't hear anything but my voice in crystal clear quality

- I ran games and software that just weren't possible on Intel Macs through Rosetta at pretty fine FPS/quality without incident

- I didn't need to change a single program from my workflow

Microsoft can likely do the same but they need to put the legwork in to make it happen. Personally I understand they have no interest in this and it makes sense -- they want you on Azure with your server workloads and this keeps the lights on at Microsoft, and as best I know the consumer market (not considering gaming) still favors Windows. But I guess that's why projects like this confuse me a lot since it must be a pretty substantial RND and manufacturing cost, neverminding advertising, but Microsoft doesn't seem to have their heart in it.

It's not about backwards compatibility - consumers don't need to keep Windows 3.0 apps running, not a statistically significant portion anyways, they just need modern apps to run fast and well, long battery life on portable devices, quiet machines, and that's it, but seems that this just isn't something Microsoft is interested in taking over.

I really can't think of Windows features in decades that "wow" so much as you just know what you get with Windows regardless of the version in terms of basic features; what worked on Windows XP probably works on Windows 11, but even that is starting to erode in a slow and painful way. There are quite a few programs on Windows I get the impression that Microsoft just doesn't want me to be running, but things like the Windows Store, Windows' implementation of security for unsigned apps, etc, these all feel like Microsoft isn't confident enough to fully invest into these new features or to drop them in order to advance.

Microsoft definitely has the talent and cash reserves to pursue a strong consumer laptop to compete with Apple; for whatever reason, they don't seem to have the interest though for consumer devices. Probably the simplest reason is the server market is theirs and this is plenty of money, but I just can't get why they continue with such forays then.

Edit: just elaborated on price point for consumer laptops and recommending machines.

csydas··on Tell HN: I was tired of being a perfectionist so I built an app within 24 hours
I just tested on M1 Pro with Safari, and it loaded great even on really lousy internet where I'm at. So not sure if your optimizations are already in effect, but I'm not having the challenges others mentioned with the current version of site.
csydas··on On finally learning to program at the age of 40 (2020)
I disagree.

The point at which the author actually "gets" programming and felt comfortable with the idea that given a task they could write something to solve it appears to be when the author determines their real start with programming.

I'm not sure it makes sense to really get into the debate of what constitutes programming as like a lot of skills there's a strong personal aspect to when you actually have some skill in it. Many people are this way with cooking, singing, or other creative/practical endeavors, and I see it similarly with programming. Personally I think the drive to get people to coding is a bit too generous and supportive in the wrong way, for example, promoting that Excel users are programmers/DBAs because Excel is essential a database with a well documented UI. There is definitely truth to such a statement and the intention is good and comes from a place of support; however I would wager most Excel wizards without coding/DB knowledge would not feel comfortable or a desire to step further since they personally don't get the connection and can't conceptualize how to translate those skills into what they consider programming.

I had a very similar programming history to the author -- as a child I could write very simple programs in BASIC (needed something to do during study-hall on my TI-89) and also had spent a lot of time following guides to hack trial programs on MacOS to extend the trial period on games/programs indefinitely. I could put together a basic website to share ROMs with my friends, but I absolutely could not figure out anything I thought was 'complex', and thus I didn't 'get' programming in my mind.

It wasn't until my late 20's when at a tech support job, I got absolutely fed up with a specific type of case that required a lot of specific hardware information from client servers which my colleagues and our clients never collected correctly; the cases were simple if you had all the information, but after multiple attempts to get the information, both the support team/client would be frustrated and the case would needlessly get escalated to me. After dealing with a particularly abrasive client on a case like this, I finally said "enough is enough" and that night rage-coded a very simple tool to ensure all the system info was collected with the click of a button; my frustration fueled me through all the bumps and pitfalls of getting this info and voila, 12 hours later I had written what I consider my first program. Months later, I even solved my first bug in it all on my own, and that's when I considered myself legit. After that, I couldn't stop myself from finding nails to smash with my new hammer, programming.

It's all about when you 'get' that moment and feel like given a task you can actually figure it out. That one moment that lets you realize "you can do this, given enough time."

csydas··on Remote work changed their lives. They’re not going back to the office
I realize you're being catty, but the stigma towards in-office work isn't towards people who enjoy it, it's towards the idea that everyone _must_ enjoy it.

COVID proved that many businesses can survive a hybrid or even remote-only environment easily. Being told that employees must come back to office or altering the salaries/benefits of employees who chose remote work is what people are against.

If people want to be in office, let them. And for those who remote is more convenient, let them.

csydas··on More U.S. companies charging employees for job training if they quit
Your point is understood, but at the same time, if it's not a recognized certification that is applicable to other jobs and positions, then it's a preference of the business, not a business need. The employer decided to make this a requirement for their employees, that is their decision and they should accept the cost.

More simply put, if it's not something that is readily verifiable and accepted by any other business in the same category, then I understand this as the employers' _choice_ to give their employees this business.

Would we consider the same reimbursement scheme for coffee/snacks and restroom breaks? These also are on paid time which costs the employer, but I don't think (yet) employers are trying to recoup such costs.

If we were talking about professional certifications, I would maybe understand some commitment agreement from the employees, but the trainings described are shop specific as per the article. I would not agree that this should require repayment, and seems the courts agree as well.

csydas··on Ask HN: How to learn to sell?
fwiw, during my tech support days, I "sold" more by never trying to sell anything because I had no interest in it. What I was interested in was problems, and seeing me solving their problems with the different tools our company had made a ton of sales apparently.

So agree with the above; don't try to convince them they want your product, figure out their issues and exactly how your product solves those issues

csydas··on A rash of nearly lethal mushroom poisonings in Ohio
I dunno, watching the video linked by this use [0], I think the apps (aside from Google Lens) do a fairly okay job of being clear that they aren't as sure on their identification and that they're about casualness, not "safe to eat or not safe to eat."

While the article cites some persons who ate poisonous mushrooms because an app said they weren't poisonous, ultimately it will come down to "Did the app sell itself as telling you what's safe to eat and what's not?"

From the video, I'm particularly harsh towards Google on this as it doesn't seem to include the confidence level or analysis process and instead focused on showing a result and even trying to sell you something based on the result. This does seem like it's the wrong approach that will get people killed, with thoughts like "well Google thinks it's this, and it's even trying to sell me some, so must be okay."

For the others, you can see warnings in the apps about eating identified stuff, you can see how confident it is in the analysis, and they at least appear to be considering things like the region you're in when making an analysis.

I think it would be fairly defensible based on the warnings and preparation that a reasonable person would not be expected to take the identification as a go-ahead to eat something. That unreasonable persons take unreasonable actions as a result of these apps wouldn't really change the legal interpretation, but of course maybe it can be persuasive in other directions.

At first I shared the same opinion as you that these are dangerous apps, but watching what the apps do in the linked video, the non-google ones are actually pretty acceptable in my opinion. I would prefer they include a few more warnings though when there is low confidence matching or when there is conflicting matching just to remind the person using the app "hey, btw, a lot of plants can kill you. Don't eat this, I'm just an app."

[0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33220688

csydas··on Ask HN: Where do you escape for non-clickbait thoughtful/informational content?
Create your own stuff and curate what you read/watch yourself.

You don't need to be a content creator to create good stuff, and unsurprisingly, you find a lot of great things when you have a specific topic you're trying to get information about/research.

Filler/white-noise/empty content is inevitable on any source. HackerNews has tons of advertisements that masquerade as thoughtful posts and the comments aren't always gold. (though the HackerNews moderators deserve huge credit for maintaining a pretty nice balance of freedom to say whatever and maintaining civility/reasonableness)

The best articles I've read have come from non-content creators, just some person somewhere that decided to write or do a video on a subject they happen to be really passionate about. The quality of videos isn't super high (talking about production value), but the content is solid. Not every release from the same person needs to be a million+ views piece, just understand that they have some good thoughts on some subjects and are worth checking in on.

When I'm doing some research for something I want to write about or share or learn, these pieces usually come about somehow after sifting through forums or the 2nd/later pages of search results.

Click-bait articles/videos are not new by any means, it's just easier to publish them now. It was always necessary to sift through it before, and learning to sort such information is a skill that you need to practice. But I can almost guarantee you that trying your own hand at creating something helps reduce that pressure of "it's all clickbait". Don't just copy and summarize, try to make something and just dive in on the process, even if no one ever sees it.

csydas··on Claims AI can boost workplace diversity are ‘spurious and dangerous’
I understand your point, but I disagree with it.

Just like there are different versions of "good" leaders and "good" workers in any given field, there are different types of "good" in sports.

Similarly, sports has a much more straight-forward rewards system; score a point, prevent the opponent from scoring, immediate result and reward.

For anything technology related, the action => reward system tends to be far more delayed and requires a different approach and type of patience. Whether it's Devops, Programming, Administration, or Support, even if you do everything right, the reward might be delayed or sullied by negative rewards. (e.g., network is never fast enough for users, it's still too complex to use your program, the solution is just not desired by the user)

Again I do understand the premise of your statement, and for some situations I can agree there is crossover, but my experience in hiring for technical positions is that sports participation has been a non-factor at best. Too often, it's been a negative one because the rewards for technology related challenges tend to be very delayed or difficult for the participant to recognize. Success in Technology is very personal and goes beyond the tangible result, and instead is a victory of the self as you grow intellectually and better understand something. This does happen in sports also (you train yourself to recognize openings that maybe didn't exist for you before or you couldn't act on due to physical limitations), but there are other rewards that make sports more compelling.

csydas··on US airport websites under DoS attack
I'm not trying to prop up the Russian military here, but I feel that your statement of "if they could have they would have" doesn't follow to logical conclusions.

Keep in mind, the common attribution of the supply chain attacks across a number of vendors was Russian actors.

Also keep in mind that large scale attacks have typically started with thoroughly unconvincing "Hey Bob check this out" emails with a malicious excel doc.

The point here isn't to say that the Russian government has mastermind hackers, but instead to understand that an actual and effectual attack doesn't need elite skills, just a few gullible people and known exploits on unpatched servers.

I find it far more likely that any world government has the traditional hacks playbook and still get over .500 in most environments they attack without a single novel zero-day.

The attack described in the article is to antagonize, no doubt, but I wouldn't be very fast to describe the abilities of someone based on how they troll people. This is not the same as an assertion of "they are the best hackers", it's more I just don't think this is representative of the actual capability of any state actor, the Russian military included.

csydas··on Dutch employee fired by U.S. firm for shutting off webcam awarded €75K in court
I'm actually shocked that so many companies handle performance improvement and coaching so badly.

We implemented a coaching system for our support team about a year ago with the explicit purpose that individual coaching does not directly affect KPI, and that as much coaching can and should be done freely without worry of impacting the support team. The system tracks both the person being coached and their team lead who does the coaching. The coaching is directed to be as instructive as possible, that it's not about punishment, but better ways of handling specific technical situations or adherence to the support policy.

Long term reviews consider not just the person being coached, but also the leader as well, as a high number of coaching options across multiple persons on the same team would suggest an issue with the leadership as the root cause, and more qualitative reviews focus on that element as well. The entire point is to ensure that Performance Improvement Plans don't have to be a thing, and that there is constructive feedback flowing into the system.

Adoption was slow, but with strict adherence to what a coaching instruction must include, we've seen exceptionally high improvement and much calmer conversations when mistakes are made since the support persons realize "this isn't a KPI penalty or a PIP; it's just trying to prevent that." Having the system "open", i.e., the support persons can see every entry they have at any time with a few clicks of a button means no secrets.

It's a lot of documenting, but so far we're seeing a ton of success with it and positive feedback to having this process for constructive criticism, and the focus on also considering "this might be a leadership issue" also helps add some comfort.

csydas··on Magic Leap 2
I'm not yet convinced Augmented Reality has proved its case for people and that AR is chasing big numbers and companies without showing what they would actually use it for every day.

I will give Magic Leap some credit on their marketing for the article link in that they show some persons in non-office settings such as laboratories and what presumably are hospital settings.

But for me what's missing is seeing it actually used productively by the persons or testimonial stories about how AR integrates into their workflow.

People are resistant to change even within the face of pretty cool technology. I would position many people don't know what they want to improve their workflow and can only define such wants as complaints about the current workflow. That's my experience working with customers where they have a complaint but just don't know what to search for to see if there's a solution.

To show how I think this should work, when I add a new tool to my workflow usually I can pinpoint exactly what I don't like about something and I have specific terms that help me find it. For example, my org uses Teams, and Teams is unfortunately linked by the hip to Sharepoint which I cannot stand. There are many reasons for this, but the biggest issue is that Sharepoint tries to load everything in-browser, even if it cannot. Eventually it will show you a download link, and for the content I am working with, I don't want Sharepoint to try to load it, I just want to download the file and use the appropriate app to work with it. In business rules, I want all Sharepoint links to automatically convert to download links.

Armed with this, I could search for browser extensions to redirect links to another link, and I found Redirector: https://github.com/einaregilsson/Redirector I cannot sing the praises of this tool enough, and it saves me tons of clicking and waiting by letting me write rules to handle specific link formations and redirect them to another. It was a perfect fit because I could _describe my annoyance_ and the preferred behavior, and armed with that, I could know whether a tool met my needs or not.

This is what is missing for me with AR. As someone in tech, I can describe a ton of my issues with daily workflows quite easily. I can define my problems and how I prefer it works. What I can't see is how AR helps me. Like many, I imagine that persons like technicians, mechanics, anyone who needs their hands available to work on complex hardware/items might benefit from AR, but what I don't see are testimonials from these people that some AR company demoed their product with them and found a way to make their workflow better. I'm not a mechanic; I can do basics with cars or house-hold appliances, but I'm not a professional, and I imagine the AR companies out there aren't either. Why there aren't field tests with discussions and interviews with the proposed target audience for AR is beyond me.

Instead I see people in offices on conference calls, I see random stock photos of people in lab outfits, and I see marketing copy telling me that AR is limited just by my imagination. Thing is I can imagine quite a lot, and I don't see proof AR can do any of it.

If AR has a product ready for betas, this needs to be in the hands of people who might actually use it and developing case studies. The technology is interesting, I'm not denying that, but I want to read stories about actual use cases and testimony from someone who honestly feels "this made my life better." Until that happens, I'm not confident AR is going to take off in a meaningful way for work related purposes instead of recreational.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →