HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cucumber3732842

1,063 karma · joined January 20, 2026

I'm not so vain as to put contact info here.
submissionscomments
cucumber3732842··on Investor-owned utilities charge 23% more for electricity than public providers
Yeah, they should be like those nonprofit hospitals.....

Which is to say if the solution was that simple and the fruit that low hanging it'd be done already.

At the end of the day whether profit or not the problem is that there's no consequences for sucking and no reward for not sucking. Government agencies tend toward fiefdom expansion, amassing power and graft. For profit entities tend to try and create situations where they can extract rents on the flimsiest of pretexts. They both seem to suck for energy though perhaps government sucks a tiny bit less. Neither "solves" the problem because neither seems inclined to steadily march toward cheaper/better/faster/whatever-er energy. They both seem to try and increase the suck if left to their own devices.

cucumber3732842··on No Need for Retirement When Utopia Is Around the Corner
Listen, I love a good chance to call the US undeveloped as much as the next ideologically motivated POS but the reason the US got off of pensions and onto 401ks is because of how many pension funds had serious issues with mismanagement and inability to provide payouts over the years. And this change happened during the arguable peak of the US public's support for regulatory solutions so it's not like they said "oh we can fix this we a few rules but we're not going to because reasons", they legitimately didn't think they could fix it. So far the 401ks and IRAs that replaced pensions have been decent. And as the other guy says, you can argue that Social Security is basically a public pension.
cucumber3732842··on New York bans horse-drawn carriages after 160 years
I don't disagree that there could be some problems here but my point is that the problems (horse shit, potential for animal cruelty) are surmountable problems with known solutions, not a fundamental tradeoff.

I don't like these sorts of exclusionary type arguments. We should strive to include all users or as many types as possible, not kick some varieties out for others except where truly necessary (e.g. there is no vehicular through traffic).

Look at the arc of state forests, watershed districts and conservation lands over the past 20-50yr. A lot of them (especially in the northeast) follow the following pattern: First they kicked out the Jeeps and whatnot. Then they kicked out the ATVs and dirtbikes. Then they kicked out the hunters and fishermen. Then they kicked out the mountain bikes and kayakers. Then they kicked out the dog walkers. Then they closed it to the public and gave a megacorp permission to clearcut it and build a solar farm or something, i.e. it goes to shit and nobody can enjoy it.

I know central park isn't exactly the same but with these sorts of things that don't "actually" affect the detractors in a serious way (it's not like stepping around horse crap will ruin your finances for the month or cause you a risk of developing cancer later in life or something) there's a lot of potential for the same sort of purity spiral where once you start picking and choosing who and what's allowed you whittle down your potential user base and with it political support for keeping whatever your subject is from going to shit (IDK what "going to shit" looks like for central park). Like this is supposed to be a common good. I think some level of niche touristy commerce here is what you want.

It's not like the horses were thaaat detrimental. They surely weren't so numerous they were clogging it up to the exclusion of other users. Like at best they were a minor inconvenience, but one that brought a lot of paying customers entertainment and employed some people so I think it's worth having. If they're causing solvable problems solve those problems, don't just kick them out.

cucumber3732842··on New York bans horse-drawn carriages after 160 years
Oh piss off with the hand wringing. National defense. Health, cleanliness and sanitation, having effective courts, those are "overwhelming public interests". Some tourist attraction horses in the park is not an "overwhelming public interest".

Congestion in the lower loop? Rofl. It would be the same without the horses. Hire a guy with a shovel and a rolling trash can to deal with the horse shit.

cucumber3732842··on New York bans horse-drawn carriages after 160 years
You can't regulate away abuse that isn't happening without writing rules that cause some stupid enough to cause pushback consequences elsewhere. Also it might start a regulatory turf war depending on how the state of NY claims such things.

These conditions are a literal walk in the park compared to pulling a chord of wood off road in the rain or the 90deg sun because winter's coming and fuel must be stocked regardless of weather and the other "real work" these animals were meant for. The horses doing these jobs are borderline pet animals that have a job to subsidize themselves avoid the hoofed equivalent of a working dog that tears things up from boredom. Doesn't surprise me that they keel over on the job sometimes. Horses are both stupid and fragile.

The vibe I'm getting here is "sir the latest poll says you're losing the crazy cat ladys" "ok fine, ban the carriages and call it an animal safety thing and see if that gets them back"

Unless there's overwhelming public interest or overwhelming industry interest/corruption the government almost never takes it upon itself to regulate minutia like this, the downside is just not worth it unless you think you can pander to some demographic.

cucumber3732842··on Every AI model has the same "controversial" take on humans
Garbage in, garbage out. Modern commercial AIs have eaten a lot of garbage takes peddled by garbage people, both in HN/Reddit/whatever comment sections and dressed up in the language of corporate puffery and academia.

So it's no surprise that they levy this judgement. It's the perfectly correct judgement to levy based upon their inputs.

Heck, plenty of "smart enough their opinion is worth considering" humans have reached the same conclusions just from reading the HN comments.

cucumber3732842··on Where Wealth Is Moving in America (2023)
Just bout every state has a homestead exemption but IIRC Florida's is one of the few/only where it's unlimited on your primary residence so you "lock in" all your gainz by moving there before the "oops I'm bankrupt" drops.
cucumber3732842··on Where Wealth Is Moving in America (2023)
>But companies aren’t exactly flocking there.

Taxes are the least worst part of doing business. It's all the other subjectively defined and capriciously enforced regulatory BS that drives business away. You can't run a business let alone get financing to create one when a huge chunk of your costs are a question mark.

cucumber3732842··on I told people I'm a convicted felon after 20 years of hiding it
You forgot the other part which is most important to the government that runs the system.

By fining the crap out of these people and putting them on the treadmill of poverty we intentionally economically marginalize them so they with near certainty can't amass the wealth or power needed to threaten the system. Sure, you could go all in on a life of crime, become a drug kingpin, whatever, but in doing so you've also given the state an easy button to come after you if you get uppity. It's intentional. The system does not want these people to go on to be wealthy and powerful decades later. The absolute last thing the system wants is one of these guys going on to run some regional business empire or whatever and going all in on some political candidate that's gonna screw the jailer's union or apply more transparency to the courts or whatever so the system intentionally saddles them with this debt burden when they're rebuilding their lives.

cucumber3732842··on Whatever Happened to Fire Escapes
> It's an engineer's job to follow those codes, for better and for worse. On the whole I would say that is for the better, despite any corruption inherent to human processes.

So we should all just bend over and take it quietly when the requirements are not just stupid but stupid for bad reasons? Everyone saying "welp, not my money, I get paid either way, gonna keep my mouth shut" is the problem.

>I do suspect what we're missing from the article is a real sense of the time it took to make the transition away from this building design towards multiple distributed closed-door stairways with noncombustible finishes, including the elevators that make such designs palatable.

About 50yr. So for ~50yr they were GTG for new construction

cucumber3732842··on Texas data center boom could erase decades of progress on air quality
Grid stuff is 5yr out everywhere, including my "we don't even have datacenter projects to speak of because out power is just that expensive" region. That's just how the industry moves.
cucumber3732842··on Oregon lawmakers approve money to buy an iconic waterfall listed on Redfin
>This sort of cynical catastrophizing isn’t really helpful. If you have a concrete example that applies to this situation, please share it, instead of gesturing vaguely in the direction of “government bad.” (Buildings in prime locations aren’t equivalent.)

This has nothing to do with government and a lot more than nothing to do with sneering jerks who dismiss the potential for systemic failures and stupidity by handwaving it away as "catastrophizing" enabling the systems to produce exactly those sorts of failures. Any bureaucracy can screw up in the manner I'm describing, insurance, bankers, it's not just government.

Bad outcomes are very, very, very sticky because the people that rise to positions that could undo them don't get there by being disposed to such actions. Some non-standard organization (a bunch of monks who aren't pro RE developers) with a nonstandard situation are high on the list of places these failures will happen. They submit something to some agency and use the wrong words, some dude who doesn't see many of these cross his desk denies it on some grounds and you've just locked in a problem that's gonna cost a lot of money to undo and monasteries aren't typically engaging in the sort of high dollar economic activity where they can just fight through it knowing it'll be paid back later.

I'm not saying that's what happened here but this is exactly the kind of place it could happen.

>(Buildings in prime locations aren’t equivalent.)

There are old mills on the outskirts of town and then there are historic mills on the river on main street.

There are overgrown farmers fields and there are forests with waterfalls in them.

See what I'm getting at?

cucumber3732842··on Oregon lawmakers approve money to buy an iconic waterfall listed on Redfin
>Probably they had been trying to sell it to the state for months/years/decades

Third option:

Monks want to put up some minor tourist attraction, put in some parking and hand rails or engage in literally anything, doesn't really matter what since it's all invariably regulated near water. Bureaucrat who doesn't "get it" says no this is a special site if you want to do that you need to do XYZ first or GFY. Monks say we can't afford XZY, that would make this whole thing a nonstarter or defeat the point. Site languishes for a decade or two because while the subsequent bureaucrats may know what's right they can't necessarily ignore what the first guy said without sticking their necks way out. Eventually the monks find someone to help them out who gets the state to take it off their hands. Maybe they monks get a fair deal, maybe they're losing their ass, who knows.

This fact pattern is really common with redevelopment of eyesore unoccupied buildings in prime locations so it wouldn't surprise me to see it going on with some natural site like this.

cucumber3732842··on Oregon lawmakers approve money to buy an iconic waterfall listed on Redfin
> Its owner, a nonprofit that supports a community of Benedictine monks, put it on the market earlier this year.

>The foundation put the property up for open auction in early February, meaning there was no minimum or maximum bid, she said. It accepted the offer the state made under the bill that passed.

>The listing worried fans of the natural wonder. But at the tail end of the legislative session this month, a bipartisan group of lawmakers stepped in and approved $2.1 million to buy the falls and its surrounding land.

Zero chance this wasn't arranged in some capacity off record. The state doesn't "just" buy waterfalls without such plans being tacitly agreed to beforehand or at least deemed viable by people who "know things".

cucumber3732842··on Whatever Happened to Fire Escapes
You can't honestly write about the Kennedy family without at least touching upon machine politics and drunken shenanigans.

Likewise you can't honestly write an article about what's arguably a boondoggled peddled at great expense by fire code without at least touching upon the topic of financial iterest.

I'm putting GFCIs in everywhere before I put put AFCIs anywhere. Maybe that's just because I'm too poor for brushless everything though.

Regardless, I only mention them because they're a texbook example of a code inclusion that's "sus" in all the same ways fire escapes were then and obviously are now.

cucumber3732842··on Whatever Happened to Fire Escapes
>This requirement is a contributor to US apartments being ugly.

US apartments look ugly because the IBC has been picked over by every flavor of money grubbing business interests masquerading as concerned do gooders. Once you filter out all the options rendered financially noncompetitive by each of their bought and paid for rules there's only a few paths to a viable building. You might have a dozen megacorps buying windows from a dozen suppliers but those dozen times dozen theoretical options are the same thing in practice because that's what it takes to hit Leed Platinum (TM) or whatever.

Seriously. Go watch some 80s/90s movies that were set in the then present day. Those cube farms have more diversity of style and material than anything today.

cucumber3732842··on Whatever Happened to Fire Escapes
If one can have an entire 20min piece about how bad fire escapes are and how bad they were from the start it kind of begs the question as to why they were allowed on new construction to begin with. Surely somebody was in favor of them?

Perhaps a comparison to the current breaker requirements in the electrical code and other "industry excess" shall we say, in the IBC is in order.

But Grady isn't gonna make that comparison because when a man's salary depends on not understanding something he won't understand it.

Building code is a very, very, very dirty sausage factory and dirty factories produce a lot more "oops we were doing it in a way we knew was wrong for 50yr" outcomes than the clean ones. It's a disservice to everybody to just hand wave that all away at a dozen points like is done here.

cucumber3732842··on Show HN: SimCity, but with Permits
>The various decisions/petitions that pop up can break the immersion by mentioning details that don't fit the city(petitions with signatures from >250% of the town population, traffic issues at the "4-way intersection in front of the feed store" when no such place exists, or the new building causing shadows when there's nothing around it).

This is how real life works when when your proposed development doesn't fit the vision some random unaccountable bureaucrats and/or institutions you have to go through have for the vibe of the community.

cucumber3732842··on The fire retardant in the seafood chain
People will whine about anything if it keeps them from having to consider that resources are not infinite and that advancing one metric (fire resistance in this case) must happen at the expense of others (environment and cost in this case).
cucumber3732842··on France's supermarket fridges were vulnerable online for months
>are you saying you shouldn't be able to build templates to deploy

There's making a meeting out of something that should have been an email and then there's making a software project out of something that should have been an email.

The email is gonna go to the managers DL and it's gonna say "hey assholes the new temp is X set your shit to that" but in professional corporate speak and the managers will use their screwdrivers, take off one access panel and turn a dial ever so slightly" and I'll be able to see they've all done it right from my read-only monitoring system. And this has the side effect of keeping food from going bad in bulk because of a bug or fat finger or "Russian hackers" or whatever. The cost of the labor will almost certainly be cheaper than the cost of the software project amortized over its life.

cucumber3732842··on France's supermarket fridges were vulnerable online for months
Not having to pay some token fine multiplied by however many times your employees didn't perfectly pencil whip the temp checks in the 3yr record retention period when you sell some bad fish and get audited as part of the investigation into that.
cucumber3732842··on The fire retardant in the seafood chain
"If the conditions are right" is doing a hell of a lot more work than 99.99999% of people who say this are letting on. Your really are threading a needle of air supply for combustion vs insulation/containment to build heat. The same goes for spontaneous combustion of rags/paper products.

Anything even slightly warm and moist will "steam" (you're actually seeing condensation but that's beside the point) if it's cold (or at least not warm) and fairly humid out. Nobody's wood chip pile is steaming in the august sun (well it is but you're not seeing it condense but once again, beside the point). And even if it was boiling it'd still be a couple hundo degrees away from anything catching on fire and even then the same containment that let the heat build typically precludes oxygen. If a tree falls in the forest and nobody hears it does it make a sound? If the core of some material pile reaches combustion temperature but there is no oxygen for it is it on fire?

cucumber3732842··on Documents: Police officer gave her Flock login to her ICE agent husband
Political will.

The rules and numbers are allowed to be what they are so long as mass tasteful/mild noncompliance is tolerated. The second you start robotically (electronic robots vs meat robots in uniform does not matter in this case) fining people for taking lefts on red arrows at 1am or exceeding the speed limit a bit in the base case you will see politicians pandering to voters by changing those rules such that the typical person can behave typically without any particular care to abide by them and generally not break them.

cucumber3732842··on Ousted Savannah police officer gave ICE agent husband access to Flock system
>what happens when society solves its issues and theres no need to 'keep them busy' :(

Look at the engineering and surveying firms over the past 50yr. Cops will likely see something like that. Like they'll get written into all sorts of laws and processes despite the scope of the "value" they provide being narrower than ever.

It'll turn into a low effort make-work job. Like Realtors(TM) with extra steps to justify their existence.

Like no amount of 1080p Ring footage of your door getting kicked in will suffice, the insurance company will not believe your house has been broken into until a certified license holding cop shows up and signs off on it.

cucumber3732842··on How Quickly Can the DoD Rebuild and Recast the Munitions Industrial Base?
On one hand you've got "what we procure needs to work for earthly climates with some error bars so that we don't wind up with a million dollars of stuff that doesn't work in Alaska"

And on the other end of the spectrum you've got "my company makes .001% of widgets that do X but we make 50% of widgets that do X at -200deg F so we'll have our lobbyists wine and dine the brass until that number starts showing up in the technical standards forcing anyone who's submitting an RFP to use our product".

And of course the latter always tries to pretend like it's the former. It's not an easy problem. Sometimes concerns are valid. Sometimes they're bullshit. Usually the peddlers of bullshit believe their own bullshit.

cucumber3732842··on Ousted Savannah police officer gave ICE agent husband access to Flock system
I've said it before and I'll say it again, the abuse is tangential to the fact that "the system working as intended" is designed to comprehensively and cheaply subjugate us all to the whims of whoever or whatever has the ear of government at any particular minute.

If you wave a magic wand and fix the abuse you will not fix the very nature and purpose of these systems. 1984 would not magically become acceptable if cops couldn't stalk their girlfriend or creds could not be shared among agencies off the books.

A large enough to be a problem subset of the people decrying abuse fancy themselves an armchair central planner (the more self aware ones fancy themselves armchair despots). In the back of their mind they're thinking "if only we got rid of the abuse then the public would buy into this Orwellian system then I could get the government enforce my pet policies with an iron fist and get minimal pushback". Beware of these people. They are the true evil. They all seek to take a bite out of your day to day freedom and it doesn't take all that many of them getting their way before there is nothing left. The politicians feeling emboldened to sign contracts with Flock or any other surveillance vendor only feel emboldened to do so due to the existence and frequency of these people.

Abuse or not these systems are rotten and incompatible on a fundamental level with a free society.

cucumber3732842··on How Quickly Can the DoD Rebuild and Recast the Munitions Industrial Base?
That's the magic of it. When someone says "why should I have to pay X?" all the useful idiots can come out of the woodwork to spew things that aren't technically lies in abstract about how X is insulating against some failure mode that hasn't happened in 50yr and is probably cheaper to mop up every now and then to pay every time.
cucumber3732842··on Florida's HOAs and condo associations are making the housing crisis worse
We all wanna blame HOAs. Nobody asks why HOA? The legal BS to set one up isn't free, so why?

The near universal proliferation of owner's associations and management groups and whatnot for developments larger than ~1ac (the EPA threshold, some states/towns have lower) is something you can lay at the feet of the Clean Water Act and it's implementation and precedents over the following decades.

Developers don't do anything that costs money, like set up an HOA, without a reason. The developers create the HOA because you need your >1ac residential development to pass stormwater permitting. While you theoretically could make each individual .25ac parcel you're putting a house on compliant as a standalone it's infinitely cheaper to just ignore all that, grade everything toward the road, dig a ditch, send the contents of the ditch through your stormwater treatment features, build in a little margin to those items, show the permitting authority the numbers that prove it passes with flying colors and when some jerk says "but what if X Y Z changes" you point to the excess you built in and tell them to GFY.

Now, where it really gets evil is when you start really pinching pennies or where the rules change over the course of the process making your numbers not work. Say you've got a lot of grade, a lot of rainfall, a lot of stormwater you gotta "treat". Well, you start adding rules to the HOA. Require certain parts of the lots remains grass or planter or whatever. Disallow patios, but do allow wood decks because the municipality considers those pervious, etc, etc. Or maybe the results you've got are marginal but you throw the bureaucrats a bone by saying you'll disallow car-ports and sheds in the HOA rules to prevent people from adding impervious surface. Or maybe you're uphill of some wetlands but not close enough to be regulated by default you promise to disallow working on cars and require people pick up their pet waste and not use lawn fertilizer or some other laundry list of certain things in order to make the local town's wetlands people comfortable not raising objection and claiming jurisdiction.

And of course, however these rules and plans shake out, the HOA is responsible for enforcing whatever those rules and requirements are in perpetuity so it's not like a pissed off majority can show up to vote "ok, this has gone too far, pack it in boys"

But nobody wants to talk about any of that because it's uncomfortable.

cucumber3732842··on Dam removals are bringing fish back across the northeastern United States
>One, you are obviously incorrect per the other reply

Amazing how people just believe assertions because they like them. Anyway, as I told him the typical dam we're talking about here is some mill pond dam that's too small to be federally regulated.

> Two, theres a lot more DuPonts "dying the river blue" than there are good samaritans building fish ladders

If you'd put down your ideology for a second you'd realize that there's more BigCos running through the approval processes to do their sketchy things because the process was built for them. The fish ladder people see the requirements (like non-starter remediation bonds) and realize it's not for them.

cucumber3732842··on Dam removals are bringing fish back across the northeastern United States
You are the one who has no idea what you're talking about and you're misleading by omission because I dared say anything negative about government.

The mean, median and modal dam being removed is a low head dam constructed in the early 20th century or before to create a mill pond for some factory. They are almost never federally regulated because they almost never meet the height/size requirements.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →