HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dalek_cannes

737 karma · joined August 8, 2013

Developer of various things
submissionscomments
dalek_cannes··on Capital Man: Thomas Piketty is economics’ biggest sensation and fiercest critic
> He's pointed out that capitalism is flawed -- that inequality is not an unintended result, but rather an inherent feature of it.

One could argue, though, that the flaw is not in capitalist ideology per se, but that you can never fulfill its requirements perfectly:

1. Market information is never disseminated perfectly, i.e. to all parties, equally, at the same time with full accuracy.

2. Human beings are not rational.

3. Human rationality takes a nosedive if a person's wealth vs. time curve take a sudden upswing.

dalek_cannes··on Greed and the Wright Brothers
> “That is, of course, the irony of the patent system. Without patent protection, a competitor can simply replicate an invention and undercut the inventor’s price — which necessarily includes all the time and expense of research and development — so the incentive to experiment and create is severely inhibited. But if innovators such as Glenn Curtiss cannot build on the progress of others without paying exorbitantly for the privilege, the incentive to continue to experiment and create is similarly inhibited.”

That's not really irony. The patent system exists (or did exist) not to benefit the inventor, but to provide a mechanism by which he may share it with other people who want to build on it. The alternative was keeping trade secrets.

dalek_cannes··on Quantum Entanglement Drives the Arrow of Time
Do we need entanglement to explain the Arrow of Time? Even though in classical mechanics, the past and the future are both equally observable, we remember the past and not the future because the future does not contain certain information yet -- the information to be introduced into the universe in the form of quantum fluctuations. One could even argue that all information in the universe was created at some point in time due to one quantum event or other.

I may have misunderstood though (I'm not a physicist). Entanglement does however, explain why systems tend to equilibrium rather than any other type of state as it evolves forward in time.

On a related note, I found this quote interesting. It reminds me of how HN comments about quantum information theory has a tendency to get downvoted:

> The idea, presented in his 1988 doctoral thesis, fell on deaf ears. When he submitted it to a journal, he was told that there was “no physics in this paper.” Quantum information theory “was profoundly unpopular” at the time, Lloyd said, and questions about time’s arrow “were for crackpots and Nobel laureates who have gone soft in the head.” he remembers one physicist telling him.

dalek_cannes··on Be Glad That Corporate Liability Is Limited
I believe liability must rest on he who makes the decision.

Will the following work?

1. An executive must carry some personal liability for the decisions he took during his tenure.

2. If the decision was made with the knowledge of the board of directors, directors too, carry some liability.

3. If you are an investor, you carry the same percentage of liability as stock. E.g. if you own 10% stock, you are directly liable for $1 million of a $10 million liability (financial or legal).

4. Investors are expected to do their due diligence before buying stock in a company that may be exposed to liability.

5. Investor liability for decisions made in accordance with corporate policies is unlimited.

dalek_cannes··on Gunshot victims to be suspended between life and death
Perhaps I did not phrase this question properly, hence the downvotes. Let me retry:

Consider a situation perhaps 5-10 years from now when this procedure is widespread. A critically wounded person has two treatment options: the best is this procedure followed by repairs. Second best is traditional surgery, which carries some risk. If the person is unconscious and cannot give consent, are we going to treat this as just another procedure? In which case the doctor can make the decision.

I ask because humans tend to identify themselves with an area localized somewhere in the space behind their heads. The do not identify themselves with exact mental replicas of themselves. This has never been a problem in history because such replicas do not occur in nature and we never had the technology to create them. But this procedure may -- I repeat may -- produce a virtual replica of sorts by putting a pause in between brain activity.

Like I said, people have already asked this about cryogenics, but no cryogenically frozen person has ever been reanimated. This procedure, however, is viable.

dalek_cannes··on Gunshot victims to be suspended between life and death
That's quite understandable. But this is a question that's going to have to be answered at some point in the future, especially for legal reasons. I'm sure someone's already asked it with regards to cryogenics. I would personally prefer the procedure to death, but if it becomes widespread enough to be used for life extension, I'm not really sure.
dalek_cannes··on Gunshot victims to be suspended between life and death
But will it be the "same person"? Does cold-starting from the same neural network give you the same consciousness or a copy? Does consciousness require some form of continuity that's lost if you lower neural activity beyond a certain level?
dalek_cannes··on What’s gone wrong with democracy?
And that is what has gone wrong with democracy -- the ability to buy power with money. So long as that is possible, democracy will always have a half-life.
dalek_cannes··on After 400 years, mathematicians find a new class of solid shapes
1. The original article: http://theconversation.com/after-400-years-mathematicians-fi...

2. It actually looks more like a redefinition than a new discovery: "It may be confusing because Goldberg called them polyhedra, a perfectly sensible name to a graph theorist, but to a geometer, polyhedra require planar faces "

dalek_cannes··on What the Heck is Happening to Windows?
> Windows 8 is supposed to fuse desktop and mobile, but, that is a problem for Microsoft, not their customers

Sounds like classic architecture astronaut thinking (http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/fog0000000018.html)

dalek_cannes··on French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL, later fined $4,000+
Excellent.

Although I'm not sure the correct word here is "hacking". Law and government should stop using the word to mean "any adept use of computer knowledge or skills that result in undesirable effects for some party". That could be used to accuse anyone with a computer and an opinion. There needs to be a proper legal definition (similar to how we distinguish between degrees of murder, manslaughter and involuntary homicide).

dalek_cannes··on ICE/ISEE-3 to return to an Earth no longer capable of speaking to it
I believe this lady may be particularly helpful in this endeavour: http://www.windytan.com/2014/02/mystery-signal-from-helicopt...
dalek_cannes··on Scenes from a militarized America
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peelian_Principles come to mind. It's a British idea -- that police officers are citizens in uniform and police by consent of their fellow citizens.
dalek_cannes··on Your most important skill: Empathy
This sentence stood out for me:

> The reason crowds of people exhaust me is that I am constantly trying to read and understand the feelings and motivations of those around me.

To me, this is a symptom of a poor Theory of Mind, or a conflict between the consciously held theory of mind and the internalized one. For the author, it looks like that latter -- he's exhausted because he has to consciously re-process his perceptions of others, perceptions which his internal ToM has already processed but has output conclusions that he might not consider acceptable (which implies a mismatch between the two ToMs).

What he's suggesting as a solution, in my opinion, is an attempt to suppress the symptoms, when the problem is the ToM. The correct way -- or at least the way that worked for me -- is to learn to see other human beings as different versions of myself, with different experiences and neurological makeup. In order to understand a person's behavior, especially negative behavior, I try to first imagine a situation where I would behave in a similar manner (e.g. the boss just yelled at me; I could conclude he is an asshole, or I could try to imagine a situation where I have yelled at someone in my team). Then I try to remember my state of mind from a similar past situation. Then I imagine the other person being under the influence of those same emotions. Suddenly it is easier to understand the person's behavior (but not justify it). Sometimes I ask myself "Had I been born with the same type of central nervous system, had I gone through the same experiences as this person and if I were in this person's situation right now, would I not be behaving in an identical manner?"

To oversimplify: empathy starts with a habit of stepping into other people's shoes. The other habits will follow.

I have a favorite saying:

Tout comprendre, c'est tout pardonner

(French, meaning "To understand all, is to forgive all")

dalek_cannes··on Rare color film shows what London looked like in 1927
I'm more surprised by the frame rate than the color. It seems to have been enhanced. Everything looks smooth, but there's something peculiar about the way people walk, for example, notice the pedestrians' feet at 1:54. Either way it's beautiful.
dalek_cannes··on [dead]
It takes luck to be in the right place at the right time, but it takes something else to recognize the fact and exploit it. A lot of other people with a similar level of education were in the same right place / right time situation as Gates and Jobs were back in the day, but many of them (particularly in large corporations) failed to recognize the opportunity even when it was poking them in the eye.

And on that note, unless one is superstitious, "luck" is just another way of saying "random or unpredictable variables favorably aligning with your goals". If it's coin-flip-like random, then there's nothing you can do to foresee it or influence it. But in technology and business, many things are not like that. The fact that you cannot predict something usually means you have insufficient information (even for a coin flip, if you knew the exact force vector your thumb imparted on the coin, you can in fact predict the outcome). Or, more likely in the case of startups, the information is already available, but you fail to recognize its significance because it's buried in an avalanche of information.

dalek_cannes··on Amusing ourselves to death
> ultimate driving force behind both authoritarianism and consumerism that continues to rule the world, money and capitalism

I would say the problem is any social structure that allows money to buy power, i.e. that allows the translation of economic power into political power (and vice versa). Either we should prevent that, or consider placing a cap on maximum per-capita economic power (preferably as a factor of the average, not unlike the Swiss proposal for CEO salaries).

A person should be able to buy as many yachts, castles or private jets as he wants, but using his money to lobby, campaign or otherwise influence political process -- perhaps that should be severely limited?

Civilization and technology today allows individual human beings to wield far higher concentrations of power than our psychology evolved to deal with. A good social system should cap it below the threshold where people go crazy (i.e. where our brains malfunction).

dalek_cannes··on Burglars Who Took on F.B.I. Abandon Shadows
> The bigger question now is whether his revelations can create any change.

It will. It will change the acronym involved. First from FBI to NSA. Now from NSA to something else.

Edit: not a statement of cynicism; merely predicting what the government will attempt to do.

dalek_cannes··on Why I want Bitcoin to die in a fire
> Deflation... leads to a slowdown in the real economy

A fundamental, but slightly tangential question: is that a bad thing?

What if modern societies are running too hot and need to cool down? 'Reduction', 'slowdown', 'productivity loss' -- these are negative in a purely economic context. But economics is a means to an end, not an end in itself. The end, I believe, (to borrow an American term) is the 'pursuit of happiness'. I don't think modern, developed societies are doing very well in that particular pursuit. It feels as if we're on a treadmill -- try to run faster and it turns faster, and you need to keep running faster just to stay on it.

This may not apply to developing societies, who are still grappling with the lower layers of Marslow's hierarchy like food, health and education, but doesn't it seem like we have overshot? When we can afford to obsess over the number of cores or dots per inch on a handheld device, I think we can afford to slow down a bit. Perhaps a deflationary economy is just what we need.

People shouldn't feel pressured to keep producing despite having ample savings just to keep up with the wealth erosion caused by inflation. /opinion

Also: if the Bitcoin unit had been redefined so that the maximum number was 21 quadrillion, we might not have this debate. Nothing's changed fundamentally, but it is a number that for a laymen is a lot closer to infinity than 21 million.

dalek_cannes··on I Am Not Satoshi
"I Am Not Satoshi" is also an anagram of "I, Homo Satanist".
dalek_cannes··on End the N.S.A. Dragnet, Now
Surveillance.

It always starts with a desire to be safe. And that comes from fear. It seems Americans today are afraid of more things than ever: pedophiles, guns, terrorists, lawsuits. Some news reports are ridiculous by foreign standards: teachers not being allowed to shake hands with students out of fear of sexual harassment allegations, boys suspended from school for drawing guns, bystanders not administering first-aid to accident victims out of fear of lawsuits, and of course the terrorism hysteria for which I have no words. I'm fortunate enough to have visited the US and have met mostly great people, but going by news reports the entire society seems paralyzed by fear.

I always thought of freedom as inversely proportional to safety. If you want to be perfectly safe, you'll never leave your house in case you catch a germ, get in a car accident or even slip on a banana peel. You'll never eat store bought food without first running it through a spectrometer. You'll want everything controlled, predictable, seen ahead of time so that nothing unexpected gets thrown your way.

I guess this is what surveillance is trying to do. Rather than accepting a level of risk as the price for being free and handling disasters when they do occur, we seem to be increasingly trying to avoid danger at all costs. And the cost seems to be freedom.

It's almost as if the author of the US national anthem knew this when he ended it with "land of the free and the home of the brave" (correct me if I got that wrong). Maybe he knew you couldn't have one without the other. I guess the brave isn't home anymore...

/disjointed philosophical rant

dalek_cannes··on Recursive raytracer in 35 lines of JavaScript
I just checked out the author's site. He seems much higher up that wall than grandparent poster :)

- born in uruguay

- worked his way up to google

- learned BASIC at 5 (and made childhood drawings that included handwritten basic code)

- read First Blood at 9

- wrote first short story at 7

Meanwhile I go to grandparent poster's site and find... well. I think I sort of understand where the criticism is coming from.

dalek_cannes··on An open letter to the media, by Anonymous
Let us take iPhone-carrying anti-corporate protesters. Should we attribute the iPhone to 'Apple Corporation' and shun it, or to the individuals -- designers, engineers, accountants and managers -- who made happen? Corporations are a means of bringing these people together to work in a coordinated manner. I don't think anybody (except communists) says that people with skills working together for financial gain is a bad thing. It's the prevailing model of doing that people are objecting to. It has no safeguards against corruption.
dalek_cannes··on The API-ization of everything
Unix had this right decades ago, in the form of text-in-text-out commands, pipes in between + text-based terminals in between machines. OS's like Windows broke that. It's good to see the philosophy returning. As long as everything is represented as structured text!

And an side: API's should not be patentable or copyrightable, no more than a language is. Because that's exactly what API's are. Common languages for machines to speak to each other.

dalek_cannes··on What Long Hours Really Mean
I've done almost 90. I don't recommend it!
dalek_cannes··on What Long Hours Really Mean
I love my job, and I love working extra hours on it. But on my own terms and as a means of building something more, not compensating for lack of planning or management.

> why the hell wouldn't you want to stay a few more minutes?

Strawman. Everyone stays that extra few minutes. Sometimes even a few hours on occasion. That's not what 'long hours' here refer to.

dalek_cannes··on What Long Hours Really Mean
Don't take the numbers literally, and read it as "I believe every man deserves...". Merely an unscientific three-way split of a 24-hour day, with a liberal sleep quota and a traditional weekend. It's also the most defensible scheme against the old guard.

Commuting is a different problem.

dalek_cannes··on What Long Hours Really Mean
Every human being deserves an average of 8 hours of work, 8 hours of family/leisure, 8 hours of sleep and 2 days a week free. Even a doctor on whom many lives are depending. Lives of critical employees are just as valuable as the lives of those who are affected if they don't work harder. The whole "if I don't do this, the project will sink / things will be destroyed" is a self-imposed ransom situation that managers count on.
dalek_cannes··on The Strategic Consequences of F-22 Termination (2009)
The article repeatedly claims: "The F-22A Raptor is the only US fighter aircraft design in existence or planned which has the capability to penetrate and survive the advanced air defence weapons now proliferating globally".

I'm no air defense expert, but why do I have a hard time believing this? Existing fighters, bombers and drones seem to work fine with most of the countries the US is dealing with right now. If the US has to go to war with a Russian or Chinese armed adversary, would small fighter planes play a huge offensive role anyway?

dalek_cannes··on It's 100 years since Fritz Haber found a way to synthesise ammonia
Well here's something I didn't know about this story: apparently Haber was a German nationalist of Jewish descent who was also responsible for the world's first major chemical attack, which killed about 6000 allied troops.

"A week after [that] attack, [his wife] took Haber's service revolver and shot herself, dying in the arms of Hermann, their only son."

Edit: oh god, this is the Zyklon B man.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →