HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

danieltillett

13,030 karma · joined December 29, 2013

I am Daniel Tillett, founder and the CEO of Nucleics.

Work | https://www.nucleics.com

Play | https://www.tillett.info

submissionscomments
danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Yes, but that is where you use epidemiology. If you track down each person in the local area infected with the mutant strain and follow their clinical course you can work this out. You can also do serology to make sure the immune response is similar, etc.

There will always be the possibility that the attenuated strain varies is some major but subtle way from the non-attenuated strains, but this is not something ever seen before with other viruses. If you demand to know everything and the answers to all possible risks up front medical science doesn’t advance.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
First two paragraphs I have no issue with.

Third no. I am not arguing this at all.

Fourth is pure opinion.

Fifth the same, but as a counter argument sequencing 10,000 strains has found 69 candidate attenuation strains and that was without even trying.

Sixth no. It is actually quite easy to distinguish a harmless strain from a normal pathogenic strain as we can use the high morbidity rate as a proxy for danger.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Who is “we”? If you are doing this get in contact with me so I can give you money.
danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
We can actually sample quite a large percentage of the strains out there if we actually try. COG-UK has already sampled 10,000 out of the few 100,000s in the UK without really trying.

Can you please stop saying I am arguing for things I am not arguing for? More time spent reading and less posting would improve your argument.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Yes. The whole idea of looking for a natural attenuated strain is we can use the natural spread of this strain to prove it is safe. This is explored in a lot more detail in the other recent posts on my blog.

Yes it is possible, but the only way we will know is if we look. I am arguing we should look.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
This problem exists with or without finding an attenuated strain. A better way to think about this is let’s say we had two strains of the virus isolated - one that killed 10% of people infected and the other that killed less than 0.0001%. Which one should we use in a challenge trial?
danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
I am not claiming any of this. I am saying that the right type of mutations exist in the SARS-CoV-2 genomes that attenuated strains COULD exist.

If they do I am arguing we should look for them rather than sitting in our armchairs coming up with possible reasons they don’t and so not even bothering.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Lvs is mostly wrong. I am not claiming any of these mutant strains are attenuated, I am saying that deletion mutants exists and we should investigate them to see if they are attenuated.

I am not providing evidence that an attenuated strain exists, just evidence that it could exist because the right type of mutations are found in SARS-CoV-2. The only way we are going to find out if there are attenuated strains is to look for them which as far as I know nobody is trying.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
I think you are referring to ADE (antibody dependent enhancement). This is a function of the vaccine, not the virus. The idea here it to use a strain you know is safer than one you know is more dangerous.

For a challenge trial you only need enough virus for a few thousand people at most. It is not difficult to produce this amount of virus in cell culture.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Yes that is right. While the idea of using such a strain as a vaccine directly was the focus of my first post, this was controversial.

Even if you think it is too risky to use a natural attenuated strain as a vaccine, such as strain would be very useful as a tool to accelerate other vaccines. As I said in my first post how to use any such strain is not up to me, but if it can be used to get us to a vaccine sooner it is worth looking into.

If we are going consider doing a challenge trial we should at first make the effort to see if we can find a safer strain to use.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
It seems to be a work in progress. It might be worth sending them a bug report.
danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
The idea in this post is not to use any safer strain as a vaccine, but to use it as a tool to speed up the development of other vaccines. If we can find a safer strain then we may be able to use it in a challenge trial which we can’t do with the normal dangerous strain for ethical reasons.

This is explored in more detail in my [1] reference above.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
There is a concept of using a challenge trial, only it can only be used when the risk to the volunteer is very low.

Challenge trial are used in trials on things like the common cold. SARS-CoV-2 is considered too dangerous to use in a challenge trial.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Even if it is ethical to use a strain we know is dangerous, we would still be amiss to use such a strain just because we were too lazy to look for a safer strain. We should only use a dangerous strain if we try hard and fail to find a safer strain. We haven’t even tried yet.
danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
The reason it would be faster is at the moment it is not considered ethical to deliberately expose people to the virus after giving them a vaccine. Because we can’t do the exposing we have to use the large field trial approach and wait for people to get ill on their own (or not). These take a long time. If we had a safe strain of the virus then we could do the exposing.

I explain this much more in a previous post on my blog [0].

0. https://www.tillett.info/2020/04/24/it-is-unethical-to-not-s...

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Maybe, but the idea here is not to use any strain found as a vaccine directly, but as a tool to test other vaccines.

Instead of running a large Phase III field trial where we wait for people to get infected, we could use the safer strain to do a challenge trial where we deliberately try to infect the volunteers with the attenuated strain. This will give us an answer much sooner and avoid exposing many people to a vaccine that maybe doesn’t work.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
That is right. We don’t know what mutations might make the virus attenuated (mild), but we can use what Nature has done to tell us. We also get human data on safety thrown in for free. This makes a huge difference in how quickly we can use a new strain in people even under controlled conditions.
danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Me either, but it is considered so. Challenge trials can be considered ethical, but only when the risk to the volunteer is minimal.

Even if we (society) did decide that doing a challenge trial is worth the risk, we would be amiss to not look for a safer strain to use first. Only if we can’t find one after making a serious effort should we even think about using a dangerous strain.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
I have not suggested that "pox party" spread would be a good idea, just that it would be hard to stop if a natural attenuated strain was found and that this would influence the way the regulatory agencies viewed its licensing.

This is not really relevant to the idea of using an attenuated strain to accelerate the development of other vaccines. This would be done under controlled conditions where the attenuated strain would not spread.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
Sort of. The basic idea is that we use an attenuated strain to safely test one of the more conventional vaccines being developed by deliberately trying to infect those people vaccinated (i.e. a challenge trial).

Of course an attenuated strain may be able to be used as a vaccine directly, but this is somewhat controversial.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
I think there are a substantial number of people who think COVID-19 is a beat up and who are down voting anything that appears on this topic.
danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
I have addressed this many times before, but yes almost everyone with a mild case just has an immune system that is good at controlling the virus. This is irrelevant to finding an attenuated strain.

The real value of finding an attenuated strain (one that causes mild illness in everyone) is that it would be ethical to use it in a challenge trial of a conventional vaccine. The Oxford vaccine group for example are planning a large field trial because they don’t think it is ethical to expose people to the normal dangerous strains. If we found an attenuated strain we could speed things up massively.

danieltillett··on There are many SARS-CoV-2 strains with gene deletions
This is a follow up post to a previous post on mine on how we might look for a natural attenuated (mild) strain of SARS-CoV-2 by genome sequencing [0]. While the COG-UK has not been looking directly for such a strain, their data does show that strains with the right type of mutations do exists.

While it might be possible to use a natural attenuated strain as a vaccine directly, the real value of having such a strain may be in using it as a safer test strain in a human challenge trial of a conventional vaccine. This could shave many months off us getting an effective vaccine for COVID-19 [1].

0. https://www.tillett.info/2020/04/05/a-solution-to-covid-19/

1. https://www.tillett.info/2020/04/24/it-is-unethical-to-not-s...

danieltillett··on Dissection of COVIDSafe (Android): Australian government's contact tracing app
Not that I know of as this is hard to study. What we have is a lot of case studies that transmission can occur in much less time than this including cases where there was no contact between the parties.

The best write up on this I have seen on this topic has been in Quillette [0]. I know Quillette gets attacked here from those on the left, but they do cover a wide range of topics (not all articles I agree with). They are pro-science and generally provide good references.

0. https://quillette.com/2020/04/23/covid-19-superspreader-even...

danieltillett··on Dissection of COVIDSafe (Android): Australian government's contact tracing app
Mike my concern as a scientist about this app is it may not help much at this point. If it is only picking up people you spent more than 15 minutes talking to it is going to miss a lot transmission events.

Do we have the contact tracing people to actually make use of this data? Even if we did I can’t see how we are going to avoid the need to interview each positive case to find all the people they came into contact with for less than 15 minutes. How much value is being added?

I am not installing it purely because I am social distancing and won’t be spending 15 minutes talking to anyone face to face outside of my immediate family.

danieltillett··on What happens when scientists admit error
I am arguing that the current funding structure encourages poor quality science. Right now it is better to pump out papers as quickly as possible rather than taking the time to check the data is not flawed.

From a software perspective it is like paying developers by the number of lines of code delivered and telling them to not worry about bugs. Not an approach that is likely to deliver quality software.

What we need in science is to find a way that people have the time and incentives to publish results that are as accurate as possible.

Somewhat off topic I do wonder if we would get better software if we fired programmers if bugs were found. I suspect we would not get much code written, but the code that was written would be very high quality.

danieltillett··on There is no empirical evidence for the US lockdowns
This basically boils down to the argument that we don’t need police and courts if we all just obey the law and look out for our fellow man. Anarchism has some junior high level intellectual appeal, but out in the real world...
danieltillett··on [dead]
Has he happened to provide you with this full source code?
danieltillett··on Coronavirus testing using binary search method
Yes. There are a whole lot of approaches that are far more efficient way of doing pooled tests.

There have been around half a dozen pre-print papers published on this concept in the COVID-19 section of biorxiv in the past couple of weeks [0].

0. https://connect.biorxiv.org/relate/content/181

danieltillett··on In 4 US state prisons, 3,300 inmates test positive, 96% without symptoms
We seemed to have early fluffed the data out of the Diamond Princess. We aren’t even tracking how many people died - it seems once everyone got off the ship all interest in it was lost.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →