263 karma · joined March 17, 2024
I never said they did. Hell, print publications were nearly as bad as the internet has become—marketing is simply a large societal problem we have no solution for. I still place the blame for lack of other funding models squarely on them—any other funding model would have undercut their entire existence, and no other company has had such a profound impact on the web (particularly with the demise of netscape).
The texts are quite different, this is true, but I don't find them contradictory. Whereas Tractatus was almost a facetious or flippant rejection of the millenia-long project to agree on a philosophical subset of language suitable for rigorous philosophy (although it continues today in the form of analytical philosophy), PI basically says "well we don't need to throw the baby out with the bath water", which I think is a fantastically mature response to a flawed tool that's still the best we have to reason about the universe. So: not contradictory in evaluation of fundamental compatibility of non-formal language for the formal needs of propositional philosophy, but perhaps contradictory in implied reaction to this realization.
Granted, they weren't making their wealth available on a market in a way european capital would prefer, but that's a rather different situation than, say, iceland, where the disenfranchised from colonization were a handful of irish monks.
What I'm pushing at is not that this linguistic ability naturally leads to the LLM behavior we're seeing and calling "hallucinating", just that LLMs may capture some of how humans process language, differentiate semantics, recall terms, etc, but without the mechanisms that enable rationally grappling with the resulting semantics and propositional (in)coherency that are fetched or generated.
I can't say this is very surprising—most of us seem to have thought processes that involve generating and rejecting thoughts when we e.g. "brainstorm" or engage in careful articulation that we haven't even figured out how to formally model with a chatbot capable of generating a single "thought", but I'm guessing if we want chatbots to keep their ability to generate things creatively there will always be tension with potentially generating factual claims, erm, creatively. Further evidence is anecdotal observations that some people seem to have wildly different thresholds for the propositional coherence they can spot—perhaps one might be inclined to correlate the complexity with which one can engage in spotting (in)coherence with "intelligence", if one considers that a meaningful term.
They're legally enforceable in the sense that the scraped services generally reserve the right to terminate the authorizing account at will, or legally enforceable in that allowing someone to scrape you with your credentials (or scraping using someone else's) qualifies as violating the CFAA?
(The only answer that makes sense here is supporting legacy devices, which will probably be a problem we'll have to deal with for the rest of our lives. Thankfully I don't appear to have any such devices on my network!)
Anyway, corporations still engage in slavery with open endorsement from major powers including the US: they just launder it through supply chains that are broadly outside the reach of states with leverage over them. See eg the supreme court's repeated endorsement of slave labor outside the US (thank you Nestle & Neal Katyal).
It's not "strictly" down to this; even if you want to implement interfaces that fit in with native ones, web browsers simply don't expose many native features via the DOM/CSS. It's a question of actual capabilities, not of this hypothetical design process that doesn't care about native integration.
(Of course, there will always be terrible native interfaces. Arguably Apple is the worst offender here!)
Compared to what? I honestly don't know what other people consider state of the art interfaces if native apps are excluded.
Granted, at least the browser code uses native widgets, but the look/feel and layout still tend to be way off.
You can't leave everything up to individual decision making or the results are collectively irrational. Notably, dieting and alcoholism are major problems we haven't had much success in addressing on a cultural level. Smoking is probably a better guide given how much rates have dropped in the last century.
I understand this fear when posting on reddit (or other social media) itself, but I am absolutely confused where this idea that this applies to reality comes from.
Is this supposed to be a marker of something meaningful? General Mills is not exactly a brand that exudes trust or consumer loyalty.