1,938 karma · joined February 7, 2014
,----------,
/........../ \
/....______/ \
/..../\ \ \
/..../ \ \ \
/____/ \_____\ \
\ \ /...../ /
\ \ /...../ /
\ \/_____/ /
\ \ /
\ \ /
'----------'
sebboh (registered) @ freenodedave@the-good-guys.net
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/sebboh; my proof: https://keybase.io/sebboh/sigs/esqX2ECySnczctOPm2xHjchgJ3v6SNNcENJba2SoUyQ ]
But what that doesn't show is that they then changed it back, and forth... for a while. It was just a UX issue that only affected computer literate people. THE BEST KIND. :(
I remember when some combination of Gmail features* enabled me to upload my old mbox with years of personal email into my GAFYD account... emails from before Gmail publicly existed. And now I could SEARCH them! The future was bright.
I certainly felt confident that I would be a gmail user for life. I certainly didn't consider the possibility that they'd one day just deny my access to the whole thing because I spoke ill of them in a HN comment. ;)
* access external pop3 account and auto-rewrite message headers so messages would be associated with my gmail address even though they were originally delivered to a different domain... Brilliant.
Thank you. I had wrote something about that in a comment I was working on minute ago, but it didn't make the final cut. I'll attempt to reproduce it:
ESR is so broken that he thinks being peerless is a good thing. The only time in my life when any of his writing made any sense to me was when I was myself so desperately alone that I didn't even realize what I was missing. I have considered reaching out to him, offering him a lifeline... But after reading his blog, I am sorry to predict that he would interpret any interaction with another human that results in his experience of an actual feeling to be an assault on his person, and that he is likely to respond in kind.
I saw nothing to contradict my observation when I visited MIT. (Granted, class was not in session and I was obviously part of the FSF conference, so I'm sure I encountered a very much non-random sampling of MIT folk...)
This is a great question. Possibly related: I don't know the answer. :)
I know from my experience in hwops that plenty of people on the corp domain DO believe that they are working towards a better world--and that making more money will only accelerate progress towards that goal.
The question is: are they wrong? Has Google lost its way?
Let's look not just at this IMAP issue but also at the OP as we ponder that.
My conclusion at the time was that they wanted to keep the percentage of users of the IMAP service below some value, and every time the jerked the config around, they'd see a dip in the graph on their end. My setup is currently non-functional. The maintenance cost was too high. Mission accomplished.
Note: now that I think about it, maybe the cert rotation issue was on (e)SMTP, not IMAP. Same diff.
It is a failure of ethics to then delete that indispensable thing.
There were laws in the old USAmerican West about horse theft. Strict laws! And similarly strict laws throughout history in shepherding cultures, regarding livestock.
The justification for draconian punishments for livestock theft has always been that the animals (property, items) were indispensable. You can't go around drastically changing or possibly ending people's lives by taking the things they depend on away from them. It's wrong!
Someday, maybe today, we have to ask ourselves if email (Gmail) is a public utility.
Suppose Dennis Cooper forgets his online banking password today. Does Google have a responsibility to somehow deliver the forgot password email?
Did not the initial Gmail marketing say something like "This will be free forever! Don't delete your old mail, archive it! Use search on the records of your own life!"
Sounds like a utility to me.
The law isn't always right. Times change, for example.
I believe that 1. the majority of individuals aren't TOS savvy and 2. the majority of individuals believe that they have a right to a persistent email account.
If property laws and corporate policies and user habits tend to visit tragedy on users... Well, something should change!
The USAmerican Congress does have a history of designing rules to serve the common good and forcing tech giants to play by those rules. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Act_of_1934
One rule could be that service providers must make a reasonable effort to give users their data in a functional, useful form in the event of account termination. For the good of society.
Another might be that critical services (online banking password recovery) cannot be revoked without due process.
Oh, does that one cause a big effing problem for Gmail, Outlook.com, etc? Well so be it. Online service providers made that problem for themselves when they fought tooth and nail to become important parts of everyone's lives.
This kind of thing is what Government is FOR.
Title II of the 1934 Comms Act required interoperability between networks. In modern times, that might mean implementing a open format, or open protocol. Maybe another rule would prohibit offering a message delivery service to consumers if said service doesn't implement an open protocol.
"I know I said I loved it yesterday, but looking at it now, I hate it."
I usually ignore this kind of humor, but wow, there is a non-zero chance that this is an accidentally verbatim quote of an old boss of mine.
(Before you think I am talking about you, ask yourself: has your interest level in the Transformers franchise ever exceeded healthy levels for a grown man by two sigmas? Well there is your answer.)
and https://github.com/kwonalbert/riffle (author indicates that security bugs exist)
/s
Free software has changed my life for the better. A LOT of people have had very similar experiences.
We dream and worry about and hope and fight for and code for and watch and love the future history of humanity as it blossoms and twists and writhes into everyone's lives.
Software is eating the world. Free software developers are influencing that event (a little?).
Just seeing it and knowing it changed my life. It changed the eyes with which I see the world. So I thought I knew what your post was going to be about.
Keep looking, spetz. :)
The majority of us will consider crossing the street to avoid an oncoming $category_of_person. Maybe it's black men, maybe it's police, maybe it's beggars, maybe it's missionaries, maybe it is visibly agitated men of any color, etc.
Maybe you feel like you've failed a bit every time it happens. Maybe your personality changes over time and at some point you taught yourself to abstain from such behavior. But, feelings are harder to change than behavior...
When I pass my own problematic $category_of_person on the street (on the same side, now!), I spend a few seconds with no other topic on my mind than that person.
It is because deep down, some part of me still sees that person as a threat, like a cliff or a fire or a bear.
This is terrible, I know. Look, I'm trying to explain racism. Gimmie a minute...
My mother taught me, before I was old enough to know better, to avoid some categories of people. To fear them, for my safety.
I can, do, and will continue to overcome those crappy cards I was dealt.
But don't put a badge on my chest and a gun on my hip and tell me to go talk to various categories of people in inherently heated situations and expect that evil that has been a part of me since before I can remember to never manifest itself in a statistically significant fashion. That's stupid. Police officer is not the job for me. Duh! See above!
What I'm getting at is that my own combination of upbringing and later enlightenment is not uncommon. (Said differently: it's not uncommon for a person to be less racist than their parents were, right?) And therefor some meaningful percentage of good cops who don't consider themselves racist are, in fact, racist in a statistically significant way. Stress = gunfire.
...So... can we be done resisting the Black Lives Matter meme? Please? Y'all look ignorant when you do that. :)
p.s. the fear when walking thing dissipates immediately if a conversation happens, etc. It's not that big of a deal, right? We'll all have a good laugh about it one day when I am caught off guard and mugged by a white girl... Anyway, I'm sorry. I try.
Had he asked for money, I probably would not have sent any. But he asked for something that I can provide with ease, so I did. And I enjoyed it.
Is that really what this is about? Is it wrong to do good if it might benefit the do-gooder in some way? Can we all take a collective moment to think critically about that? :)
(anyway, you're wrong(ish?). Posting an issue does not appear to have added my name to https://github.com/magcius/xplain/graphs/contributors . Though I could have sworn that I've seen what you are talking about happen before. \shrug\, that's github's fault.)
Off topic: I frequently click on ambiguous titles due to FOMO. This is exploitable; I don't like it; one solution would be to disambiguate every title. ...But that would remove the art from some cool, worthwhile titles.
NB. I am not a computer scientist.