HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

davvolun

271 karma · joined May 9, 2013

submissionscomments
davvolun··on US energy department rebrands fossil fuels as 'molecules of freedom'
> Judges make jokes in court opinions all the time.

Yep. And sometimes they get punished for it, for example when they cross a line.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...

davvolun··on Netflix Has 175 Days Left to Pull Off a Miracle
I should have known better than to click on a click-bait article like this.

Even if Disney+ enters the market and immediately dominates, that doesn't mean Netflix is dead. They'll have to (continue to) adjust and maybe their stock won't be competing with Amazon, but that's far from dead.

Netflix managed to turn a dvd-rental-by-mail service into the first majorly successful streaming service, and they are using that to pivot into creating competitive original content.

Netflix may survive, it may not, but this article was trash.

davvolun··on DeleteFB: Selenium script to delete all of your Facebook wall posts
Point being, the ability to edit and view edit history changes very little with regard to the courts. Instead of needing to present Facebook with a subpoena for information from e.g. logs, you're able to simply view history. It doesn't change anything whether you can delete the data or "delete" the data, it just changes how accessible it is.
davvolun··on Netflix Has 175 Days Left to Pull Off a Miracle
> If I remember correctly, plots and artistic decisions are made by committee

This is an extremely important point, needs to be backed up with some citation.

It's the exact condemnation of "the suits" making decisions in cable's heyday. FWIW, I've heard the opposite, that Netflix has an almost completely hands-off approach -- the Netflix execs find creators and give them a budget, then move on to finding their next creator. I don't know if that has any more truth, but I'm inclined to think so.

davvolun··on DeleteFB: Selenium script to delete all of your Facebook wall posts
I'm still not following -- in court for what?

This is information that you originally put out, wrote down on Facebook, so it's not that you're hiding something you didn't want anyone to know originally. If it was libelous or something so you wanted to delete it after the fact, it's still likely possible to get it back -- even if Facebook deleted the actual message in the database, there's likely a number of methods -- server logs, db logs, cached resources, db backups, or even a simple screenshot -- that would likely be sufficient proof.

davvolun··on The Reason Fans Hate the Last Season of Game of Thrones
Really?! I'm not saying we should have all expected it or something, but there were decently strong hints in retrospect she wasn't what we all wanted her to be, whereas Jon was what we wanted but lacked the ambition or whatever -- which almost perfectly mirrors Ned and everyone else in the story.

The only thing I can't believe is that the prophecies were pointing toward Arya as Azor Ahai, or the (apparently now) more likely theory that the "darkness" mentioned in the prophecy didn't have anything to do with the army of the undead (http://time.com/5589654/game-of-thrones-jon-snow-azor-ahai-p...)

davvolun··on DeleteFB: Selenium script to delete all of your Facebook wall posts
> Since they store edit history, too, replacing it with other text would simply be an indication that you’re trying to cover it up.

It's text you wrote, why would there be any problem "covering up" your own text?

Note that, I'm not arguing you should have a right to use Selenium to scrape their site and replace the text, but if you went through every post in a non-automated fashion and changed the text, from a perspective of "covering up" the text, the purpose would be the same. Facebook almost certainly has an interest in keeping 100M users from scraping with Selenium, that's a separate thing entirely.

davvolun··on After suggesting a developer drop Linux support, Vivox have released a statement
For the first half of that, I was pretty sure you were still talking about Visual Studio. That's...pretty much what I'm looking at with VS on my computer right now.
davvolun··on NSA Recommends Dropping Phone-Surveillance Program
I think you're talking about a different class of problems, though. The NSA is going to be focused on larger, sophisticated groups; Chinese government intrusions, multi-state-sponsored terrorism, coordinated Russian attempts to influence U.S. elections. Not the type of thing that's going to get caught in a police interview.
davvolun··on The Mueller Report [pdf]
You know who should determine if prosecution has basis to pursue? The courts, not the prosecution.

Mueller and his team attempting to be neutral, in this case, plays into Trump and the GOPs side and thus the outcome becomes partisan, despite the intention.

davvolun··on The Mueller Report [pdf]
If you only knew...
davvolun··on The Burden of Proof: Why People Must Support Their Arguments
> incredibly ignorant and hopelessly entitled

Sure. Thank you for staying away from personal attacks during the debate.

I explained why a random person on the internet doesn't get the benefit of the doubt -- particularly when you raise a point and the other person turns around and claim you're being ignorant or entitled.

> In science, theories can never be proven

That's not really accurate. Within a reasonable set of assumptions, I feel pretty confident I can prove to most people that 2+2 = 4. That doesn't mean it's not "proven;" it just means there are conditions on the proof -- reasonable conditions.

> Mandating people never form an original opinion without first proving it to you

That just grossly misrepresents what my argument is. Further evidence that random people on the internet need to demonstrate they are making good faith arguments, otherwise you get this nonsense. So... thanks for making me feel more certain I'm right on this issue.

davvolun··on The Burden of Proof: Why People Must Support Their Arguments
A "strong assertion" versus a "weak assertion" has no bearing on the burden of proof. An assertion requires evidence.

This isn't a communication issue. If I make an assertion, and someone asks me where I'm getting that information from, if I can't or won't provide an answer, it's not worth your time to debate.

If you make an assertion in a debate, you need to be able to back it up. Period.

When Trump says "many people are saying," he doesn't get a free pass on providing evidence to support his case because he said it first. This isn't the playground.

davvolun··on Why It’s Easy for a Bounty Hunter to Find People
> They're not going to expend real or political capital to worry about Joe Whomever.

Except we know that's not entirely accurate. The Russian propaganda effort in 2016 really needed to know a lot about a few hundred thousand or million Joe Whomevers, they did, and they were able to use that information fairly effectively. I think it's arguably easier to get a decent amount of information on a lot of random people which is actionable as opposed to a lot of information on one person that is actionable, regardless of their relative wealth and power.

Jeff Bezos actually, recently, makes a good case for this. If you had, for example, a compromising picture on Joe Whomever, it could be useful, used correctly. Jeff Bezos on the other hand, can likely go toe to toe with you.

This doesn't discount your argument, but I think we do have something to fear with the complete loss of privacy we now have from both domestic and foreign powers.

Note: I'm not interested in having a discussion here about Comey, collusion or any of that, just noting that Joe Whomever does matter, in aggregate.

davvolun··on The Burden of Proof: Why People Must Support Their Arguments
I don't know that I can entirely agree. There is a nuance to sealioning that the comic doesn't get into.

I think the difference between reasoned discussion and sealioning is beginning from a good faith argument versus bad faith. If I say "sealions suck," and you ask me "what's your evidence for that," you aren't necessarily sealioning -- yet.

I will agree there is a thin line, but that's how trolling works across the spectrum. If it was actually easy to troll well, it would probably be easy to block or filter.

I think there's also a problem in the comic with the premise that isn't entirely explained -- "Sealions suck" wasn't an invitation to debate the issue. For a more real situation, if I see a feminist on Twitter exclaim "men suck!!!" and I respond with "well, what's your rationale for saying that" then I think I can definitively say that's sealioning, right off the bat. Sometimes you just need to blow off steam, and I think that's as okay to do on social media as it is anywhere else; not everything is an invitation to debate.

davvolun··on Finland’s Basic Income Experiment Shows Recipients Are Happier and More Secure
Right? If anything, it should be very clear at this point, once a person has some money, they almost inevitably want more money.
davvolun··on The Burden of Proof: Why People Must Support Their Arguments
I'm gonna have to disagree with you there ;)
davvolun··on The Burden of Proof: Why People Must Support Their Arguments
> either cannot find the energy to do their own research

So person 1, who made the assertion, gets a free pass on doing research, but person 2, who doesn't know the basis for the assertion is being lazy? Nope, no. This is shifting the blame.

If you make a fact-based assertion ("access to guns saves lives"/"access to guns kills more people"), you need to be prepared to back up that assertion to give people a starting point. Is your assertion based on opinion, are you saying that based on a survey conducted by viewer on Fox & Friends, or was it a formal study conducted by an accredited researcher?

davvolun··on The Burden of Proof: Why People Must Support Their Arguments
> ask a proper question kindly probing for specificity or help with understanding

"Can you back up your statement with a source" is insufficient?

> in the spirit of science, you will independently attempt to reproduce the experiment or research

In the spirit of science, I need to know your prior assumptions, sources, previous work in the area, ...

I get where you're coming from, but I need to know your starting point, otherwise we're as likely as not to be arguing past each other.

I absolutely disagree that those are your only "good faith" choices -- like I implied above, before I'm going to get deeply involved in a discussion with some random person on the internet, I need to know that you're coming from a good faith place too.

davvolun··on The Burden of Proof: Why People Must Support Their Arguments
I literally could not disagree with you more.

Arguing with someone on the internet (while almost always pointless) means I'm talking with someone whose motivations I don't know. Are they being disingenuous, trolling, are they quoting something exactly but missed the context?

On the internet, you don't get the benefit of the doubt -- you need to prove to me that you're making an attempt at having a real conversation, and if you can't provide a source that you presumably have already seen -- but I haven't -- that is nearly the lowest barrier of proof I can set.

davvolun··on Russiagate is a death-blow for the reputation of the American news media
Personally flagged this article. This is incredibly hyperbolic and ignores some very important facts. What surprised me was that the title here "Russiagate is a death-blow" may have been slightly less hyperbolic than the article's title.

If the purpose of journalism is to sort fact from fiction, and we clearly have a President that thrives on providing "fiction," seems to me journalism is doing alright here. Maybe a C+.

davvolun··on You probably don’t need input type=“number”
No, disagree.

> input type="number" is fine. Please don't stop using it.

Agreed

> The problem here is a bad input device

Part of the problem is the input device, but, as is stated around here, a "Social Security Number" is NOT a number. A number is an object that we can reasonably expect +-*/ operations on, within the context of mathematical feasibility (i.e., yes, there are some issues with division under the integer set).

I saw stated elsewhere something like, a Social Security Number is an identifier which happens to be limited to [0-9]. It should be treated as such -- an input field with a limitation on valid characters. Same with a phone number or a membership ID. No matter how sensitive the input wheel, you should not use input type="number" for a non-number, no matter how much it really, really looks like a number.

davvolun··on Russiagate is a death-blow for the reputation of the American news media
> I think the real problem in the US media is political bias.

Absolutely not. As someone else notes to your comment, everyone is biased. I'm "biased" that people not dying is a good thing -- some would argue the universe would be better off without humanity. Bias is inevitable, and not the problem; the problem, as you state, is "letting that bias color their views." Or, rather, not so much "color" your views, but letting your personal bias override any other interpretation.

I personally believe Trump has done some very illegal things and it's just a question of finding a smoking gun. That doesn't mean he has done anything illegal regarding situation X (I don't know, let's say promoting Mar-A-Lago after he started running for office), and that's something I need to keep in mind when I read articles about him.

davvolun··on You probably don’t need input type=“number”
Scroll wheel is used to zoom in a number of applications, and I find it to be very useful.

I'll admit, I prefer something like CTRL+<scroll> or something to trigger it as an alternative behavior, but that's a minor qualm, really.

davvolun··on The most important software dev skills aren’t technical
Still requires syntactic correctness to be interpreted. The fact it doesn't generate compiled objects is pedantry.
davvolun··on Cars are killing us. Within 10 years, we must phase them out
I don't think that's really "ironic," and I don't just mean as a pedantic "what is the definition of irony" thing. The easiest way to see the problems with, say, airline travel is to travel by airlines. I don't know about "Africa" (and, what part of Africa -- last I heard, Africa is a pretty big place...), but in most places in the U.S., like it or not, you would very likely not be able to make a living without a personal vehicle.
davvolun··on EditorConfig: Consistent coding styles across various editors and IDEs
I hate to respond with just 'this' but this is the correct response.

The problems we've had are all because we can't get consensus to auto-format, but then someone gets frustrated because they can't understand the code they're reading after someone committed mortal indentation sins, so then they auto-format and bam, history is worthless again.

davvolun··on Middle School Misfortunes Then and Now, One Teacher’s Take
> Tell them to go outside and explore the real world. Childhood is fleeting. It shouldn’t be spent staring at a screen.

Because every single kid in the history of the world hasn't heard that, either from their parents, on TV, from a teacher.

davvolun··on Middle School Misfortunes Then and Now, One Teacher’s Take
WTF.. Because bullying that ostracized certain kids didn't exist before social media -- that's why Columbine didn't happen?

We have got to stop this "good old days" nonsense. That doesn't exclude or excuse the real problems that social media and always being online can cause, but stop pretending that dad wouldn't have been reading the paper or rushing off to work, or otherwise disengaged from Brian in the morning, his sisters wouldn't have heard from the school grapevine all about him falling down.

How about the kinda weird, quirky kid, who finds that putting videos of himself on Youtube helps him deal with his problems, like ADHD or dyslexia? Maybe without those videos, that kid would never have the confidence to succeed in the classroom.

> Teach your children that boredom is important.

Give me a fucking break! Exactly how does that lesson go down -- I imagine it's pretty similar to abstinence-only education. Some kids will listen, and it will probably screw up their lives anyway.

Why do people think kids are a blank canvas they can paint on? Were you when you were a kid?

davvolun··on Feds Can't Force You to Unlock Your iPhone with Finger or Face, Judge Rules
That's my understanding as well.

https://www.hg.org/legal-articles/is-a-polygraph-test-admiss...

← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →