HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

degamad

717 karma · joined April 10, 2025

submissionscomments
degamad··on Uncrossy
> It's easy to assume making a word disappear is always the right choice, but you forget it changes the word it leaves behind as well. Very clever.

It's also easy to make the opposite assumption, that the goal is to change the other word. I initially felt weird about changing from a letter at position 3 to the same letter at position 1, but eventually realised that the goal is just to slide the word around, not necessarily to make a new word.

degamad··on Package managers keep using Git as a database, it never works out
> > you will rewrite huge chunks of your massive codebase

> You're not rewriting Unreal

Do you consider the Unreal engine code to be part of "your codebase"?

degamad··on We pwned X, Vercel, Cursor, and Discord through a supply-chain attack
> That's 1-2% of an annual SE salary for someone with similar skillset.

So commensurate for approximately 2 days of work, a little high for two hours of work, and a little low for 8 days of work.

degamad··on AI Isn't Just Spying on You. It's Tricking You into Spending More
> A better business would be some kind of product review magazine, where they research products and write articles about them.

Australia has https://www.choice.com.au/ - a subscription non-profit product review website & magazine.

degamad··on AI Isn't Just Spying on You. It's Tricking You into Spending More
Observational psychometrics over a long enough timeframe (e.g. social media profile lifetimes) probably include periods of challenge or stress, which may help the predictive behaviour.
degamad··on Developers can now submit apps to ChatGPT
2024's GPT Store, killed 6 months ago, is back?

https://openai.com/index/introducing-the-gpt-store/

degamad··on Fixing Venture Capital (2003)
With all the talk of how there must be something to new tech because of the VC money that is being funnelled into it, it's worth revisiting the insane misalignment between VC's incentives and what the rest of us are looking at.

Especially when analysts throw out incredibly optimistic estimates for the future of a technology, the expected value of a 0.1% chance of success in a potential trillion dollar market is a billion dollars, so of course it makes sense to have a stake in that, backed by a properly diversified portfolio.

degamad··on AI will make formal verification go mainstream
> 1. First, I use the assistant to come up with the success condition program

> 2. Then I use the assistant to solve the original problem by asking it to check with the success condition program

This sounds a lot like Test-Driven Development. :)

degamad··on Metacode: The new standard for machine-readable comments for Python
Looks interesting - is there a PEP [0] for this?

[0] https://peps.python.org/

degamad··on In the Beginning was the Command Line (1999)
Those terms of service used to be "you should keep your eyes on the road, we are not responsible if you have a crash while playing with your satnav/entertainment system" and "you're responsible for where you drive, so we are not responsible if the satnav tells you to drive off a cliff or into a closed road".

But now that we've trained users that they'll need to click accept on the screen, we can sneak any conditions we want in there about how we collect and use their data...

degamad··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
That's because free markets don't always result in competitive industries.
degamad··on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices
What you are describing the best-case scenario. They happen.

What also happens is, they take operating businesses with reasonable returns, buy up all it's supply chain or it's competitors to reduce costs or enable monopoly pricing, then load the company up with debt, squeezing it into a terrible company. That is the bad scenario which people object to.

An example: https://pluralistic.net/2024/02/28/5000-bats/#charnel-house

degamad··on Netflix to Acquire Warner Bros
If you want some considered thoughts on consolidation and antitrust implications, Cory Doctorow's writings are interesting. Some relevant examples:

"Hate the player AND the game (10 Sep 2025)" https://pluralistic.net/2025/09/10/say-their-names/#object-p...

"The one weird monopoly trick that gave us Walmart and Amazon and killed Main Street (14 Aug 2024)" https://pluralistic.net/2024/08/14/the-price-is-wright/#enfo...

"End of the line for Reaganomics (13 Aug 2021)" https://pluralistic.net/2021/08/13/post-bork-era/#manne-down

"10 Oct 2022 Antitrust is – and always has been – about fairness" https://pluralistic.net/2022/10/10/play-fair/#bedoya

And his archives for more:

https://pluralistic.net/tag/monopoly/

https://pluralistic.net/tag/antitrust/

degamad··on Reverse engineering a $1B Legal AI tool exposed 100k+ confidential files
Or you need to guess that it exists, or you need to scan for places it exists.
degamad··on Reverse math shows why hard problems are hard
Specifically, reverse math (a subset of metamathematics which looks at swapping axioms and theorems) allows us to show that some hard problems are equivalent to each other.

EDIT: I think this line is the most telling:

> But he cautioned that the reverse mathematics approach may be most useful for revealing new connections between theorems that researchers have already proved. "It doesn’t tell us much, as far as we can say, about the complexity of statements which we do not know how to prove."

So, at this point, it helps us understand more about problems we already understand a little about, but nothing yet about new problems.

degamad··on Show HN: I wrote a minimal memory allocator in C
> author might be a very good programmer, just not familiar with this particular area

Or even, they may be familiar, but challenging their understanding or using simplifying assumptions to reduce complexity.

degamad··on What they don't tell you about maintaining an open source project
Exactly!
degamad··on Garfield's proof of the Pythagorean Theorem
Yep - I'm just not sure if any of those proofs implicitly assume Pythagoras, and haven't thought through them properly.

I was initially going to say we know that det R = 1 by using the trigonometric identity cos²x+sin²x=1, but then found out that all the proofs of it seem to assume Pythagoras, and in fact, the identity is called the Pythagorean trigonometric identity.

degamad··on Garfield's proof of the Pythagorean Theorem
You're assuming that we know that the length of vector (a, -b) is a²+b². We don't know that.

We start by assuming that the position vector (a, -b) has length c. This implies that we can rotate that vector until it becomes the position vector (c, 0).

As you note, we can create the two vectors above from (1, 0) using linear transformation matrices [(a, b), (-b, a)] and [(c, 0), (0, c)]

So we could create the position vector (c, 0) by starting at (1, 0), applying the linear transformation [(a, b), (-b, a)], then applying a rotation to bring it back to the e1 axis.

Thus for some rotation matrix R,

R × [(a, b), (-b, a)] = [(c, 0), (0, c)]

The determinant of a rotation matrix is 1, so the determinant of the left side is 1×(a²+b²), while the determinant of the right side is c², which is how we end up with a²+b²=c².

Now the only thing which I'm not sure of is whether there's a way to show that the determinant of a rotation matrix is 1 without assuming the Pythagorean identity already.

degamad··on Molly: An Improved Signal App
Cellbrite exists...
degamad··on 250MWh 'Sand Battery' to start construction in Finland
Not wearing out increases the time frame across which you can amortise the costs.

If option A costs $100,000/unit and needs to be replaced every 10 years, while option B costs $300,000/unit but lasts 50 years before replacement, option B is still cheaper in the long run, even factoring in interest rates.

(You can substitute "time until replacement" in the above with "time until maintenance costs exceed the original capex", and the logic remains the same.)

degamad··on What they don't tell you about maintaining an open source project
I'm almost certain there is a way to get the company to pay for pizzas for a staff meeting which doesn't involve any legal contracting bull.
degamad··on What they don't tell you about maintaining an open source project
> The tax office will bother you...

This is entirely jurisdiction specific, so I can't say for certain, but in almost every country I've looked into it for, there is a set of paperwork that an individual can use to independently invoice for work, without the effort of setting up an incorporated company. You will definitely need to record the income you received, and declare it on the relevant tax forms.

There is often a scale variance too - in Australia, "hobby" income is treated differently from "business" income. [0]

In Germany, there is the concept of the "Freien Berufen" ("liberal professions"), in which you can freelance without a company. [1]

> ... the client also will demand...

The client may also demand these things of you.

They are certainly capable of dealing with sole traders, and will have some services provided by people who do not have those things. (Your boss does not check if the receipt you submit for the new bookshelf for the office comes from a registered company or a sole trader carpenter.)

Depending on the scale of the services you are providing, they may prefer to deal with a registered entity, but for small one-off things, that may not be necessary.

If you are regularly working with large businesses who are funding your work, it's worth looking into the most effective tax and legal structures for you. But if you just need to send the occasional invoice off to someone who wants something quick done, it's useful to know what your options are.

One final thought - even when dealing with organisations who prefer to deal with registered businesses, you have options. You can choose to be employed by a company which does that on your behalf. Either a business which you have a good relationship with, and is willing to enter into a casual employment contract with you and bill for your services, or a dedicated contractor management company. Either way, you give up a percentage of what you bill, but in exchange, they take the paperwork and liability overhead.

[0] https://www.ato.gov.au/forms-and-instructions/trust-tax-retu...

[1] https://handbookgermany.de/en/self-employment

degamad··on My Life Is a Lie: How a Broken Benchmark Broke America
80k for a family of 4?
degamad··on My Life Is a Lie: How a Broken Benchmark Broke America
The problem with the "adjust for inflation" methodology, is that inflation is not equal for all components of the basket. The CPI measures the average inflation of the basket, but if some components have grown significantly differently from others.

In particular, some components of the current household budget were not included in the the original cost estimates. So the "inflation adjusted cost of living" doesn't incorporate those aspects, which is why rebuilding the number from scratch gets a result so wildly different from the inflation adjusted number, instead of being a few percent off due to a different methodology.

degamad··on My Life Is a Lie: How a Broken Benchmark Broke America
He isn't arguing that they do that, he's saying that if we accept that that remains a reasonable methodology to extrapolate the data, then we can use that methodology to get an updated estimate. He gets his estimate a couple of different ways, and they end up similar.
degamad··on MCP Apps: Extending servers with interactive user interfaces
> button that has indeterministic actions

google.com (1998-present)

    [I'm feeling lucky]
degamad··on MCP Apps: Extending servers with interactive user interfaces
> automatic API discovery and integration

So, WSDL?

degamad··on After my dad died, we found the love letters
Some people don't really get to "decide" for themselves.

FTA:

> my parents were not a love match. at 27 and 26, they were embarrassingly old by the standards of their small chinese port town. all four of my grandparents exerted enormous pressure to force them together.

degamad··on Nano Banana Pro
> Power plugs are not people.

Agreed. So the "obvious" meaning of left and right differ depend on context, which is what pphysch was pointing out.

← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →