Not such bad advice here, especially consider that it is coming from a service provider (i.e., corporate attorney). My own opinion is that realistically, the only startups that could close an investment deal in 2010 are mature companies that have demonstrated a robust revenue model and are in need of money (and only money) for expansion. My advice to them is the same as what I received in 1999 after I secured my first term-sheet. After almost three years of hard work I finally had something to show to my attorney friend and I asked him what to do next. He said, “now go out and get another one just like it.” In other words, getting a term-sheet is only the first measurable step and to close any deal, you must have competitions. But all entrepreneurs should remember that “Every problem in a startup (including funding) can be solved with the timely arrival of a PO.” So even if you can't close any investment deal in 2010, as long as you have sustainable revenues, all other problem can be solved. In other words, focus on "value creation" and the "valu-ation" will follow.
My best advise from a friend who is a successful entrepreneur is that "legal issues that are unimportant to you when you are successful are also unimportant to you when you are unsuccessful." Interestingly, the opposite is also true. For example, vesting of Founder stock is that one issue that is important whether or not you are successful. Ownership needs to be earned and there has to be a vesting schedule even for the Founders' stock. It matters a great deal how you can discharge a partner if they don't perform. This is true if the partnership is a success and interestingly even more true if the partnership is a failure (since you would need to restart the company with different partners). Over-protecting yourself is counter-productive but not protecting yourself adequately is irresponsible ... true for sex, true for startups.
This is a six-month old article but I still enjoy it. What I have learned in my last two startups is that diversity is really important for success. Ultimately, your co-founders are the ones who would protect your proverbial back and the more that they bring to the table (that are not already on the table), the better. In fact, the less that you have in common initially with each other, the less baggage that you each would bring to the partnership. Over the years, I have learned painfully that in addition to learning to work with people who are different from you and would initially make you uncomfortable, we need to refrain from starting our company with family and friends. Starting a company together is the quickest way to destroy friendship. Starting a company with family (or hiring family into your company) is the surest way to alienate your business partners.
Sex and startups, two things in life that are best to pursue outside your gene pool.
For all first-time entrepreneurs, first read the original post and then remember the following as your first lesson of 2010. Whatever you do, don’t post on the web immediately after you fail. Don’t try to make yourself look smart. Don’t try to rationalize your failure. Talking about failure doesn’t make failure go away. It just opens yourself to saying things you will surely regret in later days. Instead of talking, you would be much better served if you just shut up and peddle like hell. Now is not the time to seek fame and recognition. With success, you will have both. It is much more fun to do a Blog when you fully recover and share your hard earned experience from the vantage point of sweet success. Otherwise people would make the obvious observation that you are nothing but a wannabe. However, if you inadvertently discover you have a knack for on-line comedy, then you should give up being an entrepreneur. It is a much better career anyway.
They are not what they used to be. In the 2000's, during the telecom bubble, they were basically god. In 2003, they were still somewhat credible among the VC's. Today, I am guessing that they are basically irrelevant.
Being an entrepreneur is a tough business. My own experience is that it is even tougher if you have no co-Founders. It is really true that it takes two pieces of wood to sustain a fire and perhaps even a third to light the fire. One of my favorite scenes from my collection of Woody Allen movies is the one where after sex, his date compliments him on how great a lover he is. Allen smiled with confidence and uttered, "I practice a lot when I am alone." Very often, as entrepreneurs, we prefer to practice alone and to execute alone. We will do everything and anything possible to avoid confronting our worst nightmare which is to get in bed with the wrong people. Our excuse is that we are not ready. Our business plan is not ready. Our elevator pitch is not ready. Our prototype is not ready, etc. Having partners allow you to diversify your gene pool and having partners allow you to try different positions. It is true in love as in building companies. It is a scary world out there but you must take a leap and share your dream with someone. Good luck everyone.
I enjoyed the article very much and I have the same experience. The reason that my previous startup was successful was the fact that all of my co-Founders had been long-time veterans of their own industry (which they help built in the past 20+ years). No one couldn’t have gotten that important product insight by just talking to customers. Customers know what to object and what to improve when you present them with an imperfect product but not when you present them with a perfect PowerPoint. Henry Ford had said that if he had listened to his customers, he would have built a faster horse because that was what his customers wanted. Similarly, Steve Jobs could not have designed his iPod (and iPhone) had he not been a music fanatic. Entrepreneurs must learn to listen to our hearts if we believe that we are the perfect "surrogate" customer. Good luck, everyone.
A great perspective on a series of great articles by Mark. My own experience is that there is no sure way of knowing when to stick and to kick. The key is not to over-compensate. It is similar to riding a bike. Just because you fell on the left last time doesn’t mean you will fall on the left again. Sometimes entrepreneurs over-compensate by learning their mistakes all too well. If they failed because they had too much money, they will try to do the next one bootstrapping. If they failed because there wasn’t enough understanding of the market, they will try to do the next one with a bunch of salesmen. We need to learn from our past but we need to keep in mind that every opportunity is different. Time does not stand still and the rest of the world does not wait. Don’t be a victim of your own experience.
Having wasted $65M of VC money and failed spectacularly on my first startup because I managed to execute flawlessly on a flawed business plan, I can completely related to this video. Time is different now. What I have learned from my second and successful startup is that entrepreneurs need to defy Silicon Valley VC myths. Instead of innovating, we need to "nanovate". Instead of vision, we need to have peripheral vision. Instead of thinking outside of the box, we need to think inside the box. Instead of supersizing our business with VC money, we need to sacrifice growth by making sure that our early-adopter customers are extremely happy. VC's always want us to aim high, but for bootstrapping entrepreneurs, it is best to shot low. Focus on our current customer base and make sure everyone is happy. The cost of acquiring a new customer is extremely high in a down market. A perfect defense is our only offense. We must ignore our competitors and focus exclusively on our existing customers. Don't look for the knee of the hockey stick. Instead, wait for the pivot that would get us onto a different game. No sailboat ever won a contest by staying in the dry dock. Got to stay in the game before you know what the real game is.
My own experience is that entrepreneurship is a character flaw. Entrepreneurship is not something that can be rationalized and easily explained away. Entrepreneurship is a deep desire to create and destroy at the same time. It requires simultaneous distain for authorities and respect for past artisans. In fact, if I thought there was a cure, I would have taken the blue pill. Therefore if one could accept entrepreneurship as what it really is, then there is a much less immediate need for acceptance and validation (except in the marketplace). The end result is that entrepreneurs would have a very different perspective on listening to unpleasant truth, that rejection is not an undesirable and unavoidable side product, but in fact part of the journey.
Bottomline is that entrepreneurs must bootstrap their companies through the R&D phase by forgoing salaries. By recruiting a small number of like-mind co-Founders to fill out the initial team, and convincing each to not take salaries, you are essentially making your own "pre-tax" investment, leveraging many-to-one. Since you don't need to put money in anyone's pocket (including your own), you don't need to raise lots of VC money. You might need a few tens of thousands of dollars. But no one needs a few millions or tens of millions to build a company anymore. My own experience is that if you can bootstrap your company to the point where your are generating sustainable profits, then you are in a seller's market. VC's will be kicking down your doors wanting to buy shares from the founding team, taking money off the table but yet allowing the company to continue to grow.
When going after VC money, entrepreneurs should understand that while the financial interest of VC’s can be aligned with that of an entrepreneur, they can never be identical. VC's portfolio is much more diverse than ours. Therefore, after we take VC money, it is not enough that we succeed; we must succeed big enough to make up for their other losses (or losses by other partners of their firm). In general the VC's and their partners are willing to take much greater risk than entrepreneurs alone since in their eyes, succeeding small is as bad as failing big (“go big or go home”). So by taking money from VC, we will substantially increase our own risk profile and force our financial outcome to be binary, either a small piece of a big pie or nothing. My own experience is that with VC investment, your probability of having a zero outcome is not only real but common.
This is a fun article to read. The central question is, "Is this a good time to start a company?" My own experience is that anytime is a good time to start a company because paradoxically, for a struggling entrepreneur, anytime is a bad time. When the economy is doing well, everyone is doing well and there are a lot more competitions for your customers' limited resources. When the economy is doing badly, as it is now, few entrepreneurs could afford to start companies. That's the good news. The bad news is that customers are really struggling so you must have an exceptionally compelling solution that could save them money and help them survive before they would listen. So in summary, unfortunately, the World basically conspires against an entrepreneur irrespective of the economy and it would be like asking, "Is this a good time to fall in love?"
There are infinite number of ways to fail a startup but in my experience, there is only one way to recover which is similar to getting up after a fall from riding a bike. You must first decide if you want to ride again. In another words, you must first make a binary decision, which is whether or not you want to try again. If you believe that being a successful entrepreneur is in your destiny, then there is no point of crying in the dirt (or even writing a post-mortem). But on the other hand, if you believe that you have had enough and don’t want to be an entrepreneur again, then you can do whatever you want and heck with what other people think. Either way entrepreneurship is a lonely business. Good luck, everyone.
Great article. Similar to the author's observation, my own experience is that consumer patterns have changed dramatically in recent years and a new generation of entrepreneurs is now at the best and unique vantage point to visualize what their peers need and want. So this is not about solutions looking for problems or problems looking for solutions. It is about creators of solutions being also the consumers of solutions ("entre-sumers"). There is much less need in gambling lots of money and wait to see "if the dog would eat the dog food". Entrepreneurs are the "alpha" dogs. We are our own "surrogate" customers which means that we don't need a lot of money to "supersize" our company anymore. As struggling entrepreneurs, I agree with you wholeheartedly that our first directive is very simple which is not to get funding but to acquire customers.
When it comes to releasing products, the toughest lesson to learn is to "Go Early, Go Ugly." Most first-time entrepreneurs prefer the opposite because their DNA is to avoid rejection. Their primary focus is to seek validation, from their peers and from their mentors (in time also from their customers). In their mind, rejection is merely an undesirable outcome, which they unfortunately tend to take very personally because they think of it as a failure and a painful reminder to be more prepared the next time around. So they naturally prefer to get their product as perfect as possible. But rejection is NOT a failure. We don’t learn much from positive feedback. We learn a whole lot more from negative feedback. Entrepreneurs who avoid rejection are essentially depriving themselves of important “learning moments”. It's like learning how to sail, you don't start learning until you start to get wet. It seems obvious but for me, it was a tough lesson to learn. Good luck, everyone.
I believe we are in total agreement. My experience is that as an entrepreneur, it is tough to get up in the morning if all I want is to make incremental change. But being audacious and being practical are not necessary mutually exclusive of each other. We need to be both.
As I have written in the past ... “Entrepreneurship is all about creative destruction. Entrepreneurs exist for one purpose and one purpose only which is to destroy status quo, complacency and mediocrity, thereby giving renewal to excellence. But the successful entrepreneurs are the ones who actually respect the environment that they do determine to destroy. Without respect, they can never levitate themselves by the forces embedded in their hearts. Without respect, they can never learn from the mistakes of their elders. And without respect they can never stand on the shoulders of the giants who marched before them."
Regardless of your political conviction, there are definitely plenty of lessons that entrepreneurs can learn from our Upstart-in-Chief: product Simplicity, operational Agility, customer Intimacy and financial Leverage (SAIL).
“It’s the simplicity, stupid”.
Don’t try to change the World. Don’t attempt to “fly a new engine with a new air frame.”
Minimum Viable Product is indeed the key.
If your idea is a new product, don’t try to force a change on consumer habit. And if your idea is a new distribution scheme, don’t try to use it to introduce a new service.
While VC’s have become our favorite punching bags, it is important for entrepreneurs to understand that VC’s are “agents” no different than any other agent who gets a cut on the transaction. Whereas we are expected to put in our body-and-soul and our angel investors to invest their own cash, VC is all about making use of someone else’s money. So unlike us, VC’s financial interest is coupled with their professional interest, i.e., their career WILL come before ours. If they are not a partner of their firm, their personal goal is to make partner and if they are not a managing partner, then their focus is on raising the next fund and becoming managing partner.
They are not evil. They are simply an agent with different set of priorities.
In my own experience, I have learned that there are two kinds of decisions in startups. Any CEO who is capable of trusting his/her own instinct tends to make the right life-and-death decision, which is like avoiding a car accident that never happens.
Decisions that are not life-and-death are much more difficult to make and are in fact more important to the success of startups. What I have learned is that the key is not in making the “right” decision but making any decision right.
As technologists, we prefer to make the “perfect” decision, which means that we would have to have “perfect” data. Typically, in a startup, there are two ways to compensate for the lack of perfect data. One is to wait for more data and one is to seek consensus.
CEO who procrastinates hoping to get incremental data is as deadly as a CEO who jumps to the wrong conclusion before enough data is in. Similarly, a CEO who is afraid to make tough and unpopular decision and hides behind the shield of consensus will almost always lead a startup to the proverbial cliff.
A very short and very instructional video, from someone who has been in the trenches.
My own experience is that most entrepreneurs do not understand is that building startups is not just about building products and features but about mitigating risks for your customers. Until you can successfully do that, no one can put their career and their families at risk by buying your products.
So the best way is to get all your co-Founders and early employees together and have them focused on what it takes to best serve your customers. When you can do that then you will find that customers do expect a CEO and a bunch of VP's because their managers (who must approve the purchase) expect the same. So this is about helping your customers who are becoming your champion within their organization.
But the trick is to make sure that everyone on your team knows that their titles and positions are only temporary (including the CEO) and their job is to build the company to the point when they can find their own replacement.
My experience is that most first-time entrepreneurs confuse action with activity, one is a vector and one is a scalar. If we start with a technical solution and then look for a problem, we are a scalar looking to become a vector. If we focus on a problem and a set of customers who are willing to pay for a solution (any solution), we start with a definite direction and will succeed when we can get enough wood behind that arrow.
Unfortunately, it is too easy to keep yourself intellectually occupied with scalar activities. I should know, I have spend way too many years being a pure technologist looking for a problem.
In retrospect, wealth creation is a vectorial activity.
She is one of my favorite writers, someone who has actually been an entrepreneur, echoing a lot of what I have written recently about struggling entrepreneurs, especially the part about ... "How do you fund an early venture?" The answer is "You don't."
I agree. I have written about my own experience which is for an LLC to elect to file tax as a S-Corp (filing a Form 2553). It is the best of both Worlds.
For a bootstrapping entrepreneur, LLC is clearly the way to go. If and when you do receive VC funding (which is difficult if not impossible to do these day), you can do a tax-free transfer from a LLC to a C-Corp. In the meantime, it allows you maximum flexibility. The only big concern with LLC is that any income is taxed as personal income (not investment income) and therefore you would need to pay payroll tax (about 15%, before Federal and State tax). Also, the annual franchise fee is calculated based on "gross" income and not "net".
This is an important subject. For those of us who are interested, I have written more on that in the following.
I subscribe to TWIT and Macbreak Weekly. I enjoyed the panel members (which are differently for the two shows, both the regular ones and the occasional). But what I enjoy the most is Laporte himself. I like his style and the effort that he puts in day in and day out to understand the technology. But mostly he is a very generous person, never cut off his guests and always let them be the experts. This is the first time that I have seen him standing up for himself and I like it. Good going, Leo.
@apsurd, I am glad that you said it. This is my motto as well, don't explain, don't complain, true for an immigrant, even more so for any aspiring entrepreneur.