900 karma · joined July 19, 2011
> How do you figure?
From https://illumos.org/man/3C/putenv:
> The putenv() function can be safely called from multithreaded programs
I think it's pretty hard to have a career where you are constantly involved with software that is better technically, and have worse alternatives constantly "winning", and not be a little arrogant sometimes.
>the only hyperscaler with a good ASR is Azure
How would you say the non-hyperscalers compare? Speechmatics for example?
Your worst case is you lose the deal and the time and money you spent on it, and their worst case is they are fired and lose their healthcare (that is how it works in America right?), is that correct?
If libraries get regular updates even if they are minor, it indicates they are in use. If they have inactive repositories and low hex.pm download numbers, they may have been abandoned which can mean you have to maintain it yourself in the future, or the people behind the library found it's not such a good idea after all. This doesn't have to be the case, which is why I asked.
You mean you don't use a mouse or use it infrequently?
As an outsider myself, it certainly looks like something is going on as more than 20 Nixpkg maintainers left in a week: https://github.com/NixOS/nixpkgs/issues?q=label%3A%228.has%3... It's fine to ask if someone can explain what is going on, it's a waste of everyone's time to say you have no clue and you haven't read anything and it's probably nonsense.
Yes, which is why it was a stupid thing to say. If our enemies simply capitulated we wouldn't have to wage this war.
>Not sure why, you don't give any reasoning, but ok.
Because one of the concerns in the letter is that he has _informal_ authority. By the way, if you go to https://nixos.org/community/teams/nix/ it says "Team lead" so he does have more formal authority. A title he added himself by the way.
>It sounds to me like the open letter should have listed specific action items they wanted to see, if they wanted to be taken seriously.
The letter said they want Eelco to give up his leadership roles. Then it lists why, which you don't need to read the contents for, just the table of contents is enough. So if he doesn't want to resign, there is for example "Ignoring people then relitigating", which he could work on trying not to do. "Avoiding giving away authority" is another. There are many items like this. Not resigning and choosing to just work on specific concerns may not make all the signatories happy, but it would probably be acceptable to some.
>Doesn't this by definition mean he doesn't need to do anything else? I'm confused.
Yes it does mean that he needs to do something. Sometimes in a leadership position people question what you're doing, and there are ways to address their concerns without changing what you're doing. If you succeed then your community can stay together. Most projects benefit from being larger.
>I don't understand how you can expect someone to "reach out" to invisible people who won't make their concerns heard clearly (this letter is not that IMO).
I mean reach out in a sense of: acknowledging that some things may need to change in a way that reaches people. For example in a blog post. I don't mean send people private messages. I don't understand what you mean by "invisible people". Clearly Eelco wrote a response to a long letter that has signatories. So which invisible people?
>I don't see where specific wrongdoing is called out, or any suggestions for improvement.
I think you're being deliberately obtuse. Specific wrongdoing is called out in the original letter and you may not agree that it is wrongdoing but it is specific. You may disagree that improvement is necessary or that the suggestions are any good but that doesn't make the suggestions not exist.
>What is "this"? How has this directly affected you? To me there is no "this" or even a "him" without very specific concerns called out.
"This" is drama. It has not directly affected me because I don't use Nix, but the project requires contributors who for example package software. Seeing the #4 contributor to Nixpkgs, and several others leave, as well as the indefinite "experimental" status of Flakes, makes me question the longevity of the project.
If you simply all agreed with me we wouldn't have all these important community members getting in fights and leaving.
"I am just one member of the five-member Nix team and hold no more formal authority than the others in determining the direction of the team"
Thought the inclusion of the word "formal" here was was pretty funny.
Both the letter and this response are pretty disappointing. The letter was too long and didn't make a great case even if it was ultimately probably right in many ways. And Eelco did not attempt to understand the writers, choosing to simply deny every single thing, which is not great leadership.
Even if he did nothing wrong at all, he makes no attempt to reach out to people who feel he has, to reconcile with them. To people who feel, justifiable or not, excluded he simply says: I've always done my best to create an inclusive environment. He doesn't seem to comprehend that one can try, but fail.
For someone with some interest in Nix but never having tried it, this has done enough to turn me off it for a few years. Who knows if it will still be around by then, considering the leadership and community.
With respect to the xz stuff I simply don't agree. Are we never adding new maintainers to open source projects anymore until xz is no longer top of mind in a couple of years? Note that a commit bit does not imply the ability to make a release in many cases. The complete release can still be done by a smaller group.
>certainly not when that reluctance is in the face of a coordinated pressure campaign complaining about a lack of speed.
The screenshot is from before the xz backdoor so it definitely wasn't top of mind for them. And they (including Eelco) even agreed in a previous meeting to add more maintainers: https://discourse.nixos.org/t/2023-06-02-nix-team-meeting-mi...
It's not about security, it's about being in charge. I don't think the letter is very good, but even before this letter and without ever using Nix, I knew about the Meson PR, and many other things that are taking a very long time in Nix.
I see no real reason to doubt that one guy is holding the project back. You are talking about "rampant bad behavior" but that is not necessary to severely frustrate a project. Simply bad leadership is enough. I don't think the letter means to convey there is rampant bad behavior either. I wonder if there is anything except blatant bullying that would convince you that Eelco needs to relinquish his position.