HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

diminoten

1,949 karma · joined May 15, 2009

submissionscomments
diminoten··on Why the Boeing 737 will never take the place of the 757
The FAA's goal is to prevent aircraft related accidents. While you may not agree about the sharpness of their pencils or the color of their uniforms or some other tangential nonsense, flying is insanely safe in America because of them.

They're so good at their jobs, you should be asking what they know that you don't when they make decisions, not trying to correct them.

diminoten··on Why the Boeing 737 will never take the place of the 757
Boeing fucked up, not the FAA. The FAA is the one preventing Boeing from flying these planes because they're not safe!
diminoten··on Why the Boeing 737 will never take the place of the 757
I'm generally blown away at the audacity people have to suggest casually changing any FAA regulation, considering how good they are at their jobs...
diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
You're right, none of this is in question, because copyright laws exist.

Are you from the moon?

diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
> Our society is based on the idea that the public in fact does have an entitlement to all IP except trademarks.

You need a citation to demonstrate that you aren't entitled, legally, to all IP? That's sad.

diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
No it's not and no it doesn't. You are 100% wrong.
diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
Yep there it is; I don't feel bad because I'm hurting bad people. Thank you for saying it, but it's no excuse.
diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
Why should I care about any of that? I just want to watch 30 Rock, not run an A/V store.
diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
You could run it off of a laptop sitting in your closet and be able to support 3-5 simultaneous users no problem. It'd be a benefit if you had 1GBPS symmetric fiber, though.

But yeah, RPi is rough because you do need legit CPU to transcode on the fly, which is what Plex does, and the more users the more transcoding power you need.

diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
Sorry, I'm not, and there simply is no moral argument for pirating content, because no, if you believe in intellectual property, the is nothing whatsoever different about stealing a laptop and downloading a movie.

If you believe in intellectual property, piracy is amoral. It's not pure evil incarnate, but harms more than it helps.

And yeah, of course I would download that laptop. Doesn't mean I should!

diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
Works great, until you realize the "alley" is a metaphor for doing something that harms the content creators...
diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
That's the rub; it's not showing in the park, because that's only possible if the park got permission. It's being shown in an alley
diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
The internet is a free space, but so is reality; there's nothing actually physically preventing you from walking into a store, grabbing whatever you want, and walking out. You're not violating the laws of physics if you do that, in other words. However, laws apply, and on top of reality we've created a set of rules that are enforced, ultimately, by big burly people with guns.

Nothing, to me, makes the Internet any different from that. There are a set of immutable properties of the Internet, akin to its "laws of physics" (ultimately they still are the laws of physics but I digress), and in that sense yes, the Internet is a truly free space, just like physical reality is. However, just like reality, we've also laid on top of those rules a second set of rules that are enforced, ultimately, by big burly people with guns.

Not to say that laws are a perfect mirror of morality, but why would a rule (moral or legal) that exists in physical reality not also exist on the internet? If you believe in intellectual property in physical space, why wouldn't that belief hold over onto the Internet?

diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
I agree, I don't think the individual pirates are ever going to be in any real trouble. HOWEVER, while it's impossible to find every person who improperly listened to a concert without paying for a ticket, it is not impossible to find every person who improperly obtained a video file for content they haven't paid for.

Just something to keep in mind as we talk about this; you can actually find the people who did it, and there's actual (digital) evidence, if the government ever decides to change its mind on the issue.

Let me be clear; I don't give a shit if someone pirates digital media. But I do think it's a personal failing of mine that I don't care.

I do, in principle, believe in the concept of intellectual property, and I do, in principle, believe someone who owns an idea can decide to only give it to people who have paid. However, on a purely practical level, I cast no judgement towards anyone who violates that belief, even though I do understand that it does cause real, tangible harm.

diminoten··on Friended is a new social network that wants to get real
Not always.
diminoten··on Friended is a new social network that wants to get real
I would suggest armoring our cars if it were anything but absurdly impractical.

Getting to know yourself better, and understanding how bullying is a projection of others, and not related to who you are as a person is immensely practical.

diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
You couldn't be more wrong. You do not have an entitlement to intellectual property, our entire society is built on top of that concept.

It's more like you're saying you get to use any logos you want because you can download the images for them on their website.

The only reason you can listen to a concert outside of the venue is because there's no way to stop you that's also in any way proportionate to the crime.

Edit: I'm rate limited so here's a clarification.

My point is that just because it's available doesn't mean you ought to have access to it. You do, no arguments there, but should you? No. You are not entitled to that media by virtue of the fact that it is available to you, much like you are not entitled to the contents of someone's home just because their door is unlocked.

You're not satan if you download a TV show, but I hate it when people try to rationalize that behavior with a moral argument.

diminoten··on Netflix, HBO and Cable Giants Are Coming for Password Sharers
He's (possibly) overselling his accomplishment here a little bit. You can achieve what he's describing using a combination of Plex, Sonarr, Jackett, and a private torrent site. You also need a torrent client that can work with Sonarr (Synology's torrent client works great in "watch this directory" mode).

It's a truly self-running system. Other than the upgrades, you're able to select whatever shows you want to follow, and that's it. They automatically get downloaded, sorted into the right directory structure, picked up by Plex, and on-demand streaming around the world is yours, with all kinds of cool features like bandwidth optimization, offline show downloads, etc. More or less feature parity with Netflix, without any of the restrictions.

Of course it's 100% illegal, though honestly I've never heard of a prosecuted case in the US.

diminoten··on Friended is a new social network that wants to get real
A lot of "ought" in what you're saying, but there's a stark reality that clashes with that ideology, and it's how little you can control others.

You shouldn't have to deal with people being assholes, so when they are you should let yourself get hurt? You shouldn't have to deal with drunk drivers, so you shouldn't wear your seatbelt?

diminoten··on Friended is a new social network that wants to get real
Because a) it is the state of the world, and dealing with reality is important to living a healthy life, and b) controlling how others effect you is a tried and true way of maintaining happiness when you're not in control, which you rarely are in life.
diminoten··on Is Inequality Inevitable?
An assumption is a prior, which necessarily means it can't be challenged, as in there is zero doubt about it, in the given/specific conversation.

Also, as a smell, when you say "I think most people" you're often just trying to mask your own biases.

diminoten··on NSW Digital Driver Licence
Real ID is completely different from this, it's totally unfair to compare the two.
diminoten··on Friended is a new social network that wants to get real
Fine, then adults need to learn how to handle a bunch of anon/pseudo-anonymous trolls piling on.

Myself probably included.

diminoten··on Thousands of Facebook internal documents and emails published online
We the people? No. Pass a law first before you claim "we the people" want anything.

And "we the people" wanted internment camps for the Japanese, and believed in the racist philosophy of Manifest Destiny, so maybe "we the people" shouldn't be in charge...

diminoten··on Thousands of Facebook internal documents and emails published online
The Facebook breakup is vindictive. What monopoly do they hold?
diminoten··on Bypassing GitHub's OAuth Flow with a Head Request
Yeah the "if GET" code raised my eyebrows a bit, I know rails can handle separate GET and POST funcs.
diminoten··on Is Inequality Inevitable?
Would it help you to replace those phrases with, "Let's assume" because that's basically what they're saying, in a way.
diminoten··on Ask HN: What would it take for you to buy this service?
Lots of clicks but no inquiries might mean the hook is solid but the actual pitch is lacking.

Could you post the pitch here, so we don't have to log into fiverr to see it?

diminoten··on Stretching, Executing, Coasting – and Pacing to Avoid Burnout
The key difference here (well a key difference) is the coaching. Having a 3rd party who isn't your boss (the competition) or you who looks out for your longer term health and ability is incredibly valuable.

In software, I guess we call that a mentor? But a mentor is much less involved, day-to-day, than a coach is, so I'm not sure the metaphor translates. Could a great (not just good) boss play that role?

diminoten··on SQL database of prominent Neo-Nazi forum hacked, published
Times like these I have to remind myself that it's never the right thing to do to punch a Nazi, but boy would it feel good (metaphorically; literally physically punching a Nazi/anyone is probably not something I have in me).

Honest question for the folks of HN: would it be ethical to violate these Nazi's privacy, de-anonymize them, and contact their family/employers based on this leak? I think the easy (and probably correct) answer is no, but I'm curious if anyone has a nuanced view here.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →