HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dirkgently

372 karma · joined March 23, 2013

submissionscomments
dirkgently··on A Look Inside the Tactics of Definers, Facebook’s Attack Dog
Not sure if I understand you here.

Google, for all the negative press and bashing they are getting lately, has not hidden what they collect, how they collect. They also do not sell user data (that's not their business model). Sure, they have had their share of issues, but I don't think they are systematic or intentional. They are happy if you want to take your data and go to someone else - they released takeaway tool more than 10 years ago.

Fb, on the other hand, never were trustworthy, even before any of the recent scandals became public. They have had history of changing things around that led to users unknowingly expose their details they thought they had locked down, more than once. They have been caught lying to advertisers about clicks and views.

But those finer points are lost when they have successfully dragged Google in the mudbath with their smear campaign, irrespective of the scale or intentions at Google.

dirkgently··on A Look Inside the Tactics of Definers, Facebook’s Attack Dog
Key takeaways:

1. Before Ms. Sandberg’s Senate testimony, Facebook lobbyists pushed lawmakers to refrain from questioning her about privacy, censorship and other issues, and to stick to election interference. The committee’s chairman, Senator Richard Burr, Republican of North Carolina, was swayed and warned members to stick to the hearing’s planned topic, The Times reported Wednesday.

2. Facebook had also lobbied for the hearing to include a Google emissary of similar rank to Ms. Sandberg. Mr. Burr invited Larry Page, a Google co-founder, but he did not show up.

3. In an email days before the hearing, a Definers employee pressed a Times reporter to write that Facebook was taking the senators’ concerns seriously while Google was irresponsible for skipping the hearing.

4. The day before the hearing, NTK Network reported that Senator Marco Rubio, Republican of Florida, had suggested that Google was possibly a monopoly.

5. Those pieces were just two of at least 11 negative items NTK has posted about Google since late March.

Facebook really seems butthurt about Google. Instead of learning from Google about being transpernt on how they use user data, they basically dragged Google in the controversy, and I would say they have been pretty successful.

dirkgently··on Facebook hired PR firm that wrote negative articles about Apple and Google
Not only WSJ, but a lot of anti-google articles by other publishers are doing rounds of YN and most of them get upvoted right here.

The only balanced coverage I find is nytimes. Sure, they are critical of Google when there is a reason to be, but they aren't printing them either because somebody paid them to do it, or for hype train click-baits.

Also, they are the only ones who has balls to call out Apple.

dirkgently··on IBM acquires Red Hat
Good on Google.

Besides the kernel contributions, Google has a long list of open source projects: https://opensource.google.com/projects/list/featured

For all the hates Google gets on HN, they have been at the forefront of supporting OSS.

dirkgently··on So, today, for the first time in *25* years of Apple, I downgraded
Ugly Black Slab over Shiny Aluminum Thing any day.
dirkgently··on Did Facebook’s faulty data push publishers to make terrible decisions on video?
Right on.

In other words, fb measures were correct for "people watching videos for 3 seconds or more". But they didn't: 1. Qualify their numbers with that. 2. Disclose how many people were NOT watching videos.

Without these two critical details, the numbers represented "all Facebook users".

dirkgently··on First analysis of how Uber and Lyft have affected roadway congestion in SF
Typical HN reaction - smug intelligent-sounding question to doubt the validity of a hypothesis backed by data and detailed analysis, by completely ignoring the details in a given linked article.

Your question is answered on page 15 (How Do We Determine the Causes of Changes in Congestion?) of the report you are happy to debunk so eagerly.

Link (PDF): https://www.sfcta.org/sites/default/files/content/Planning/T...

dirkgently··on Facebook lured advertisers by inflating video ad-watch times: lawsuit
And another discussion where Facebook does something wrong and HN immediately starts talking about Google.
dirkgently··on Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe
AOSP is completely open for anyone to work. It's as simple as that. Nobody is forced to use Google apps. They are free to fork and come up with a way for people to install apps from their own app store.
dirkgently··on Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe
> What would they accuse Apple of...using their dominance in iPhone operating systems to force themselves to include their own store?

Yes, why not? Or that rule only applies to Google?

dirkgently··on Dear Spotify, please let me unlink my Facebook account
Google Music does that already. But I know, Google isn't fashionable on HN. In fact, there will be another revolt - Google is creepy!
dirkgently··on Facebook Says Hackers Stole Detailed Personal Data from 14M People
1. The problem isn't Google. It's those companies that make your details available on internet.

2. Your personal data is already collected meticulously by companies like Acxiom and Equifax for anyone who is ready to pay. You would be amazed how much information they have on you already. What are you going to do about it?

dirkgently··on Apple's Proprietary Software Locks Kill Independent Repair on New MacBook Pros
After upgrading every older family member to Chromebook, I have had zero calls for support.

Apple isn't the only game in town.

dirkgently··on Cloudera and Hortonworks merge
> surplus

Define surplus. Why having 3 or 4 companies in 1B plus market is surplus?

dirkgently··on SEC Sues Musk and Seeks Ban for His Tweets on Go-Private Deal
Like that guy Elon accused of being a pedophile in under 30 seconds?
dirkgently··on SEC Sues Musk and Seeks Ban for His Tweets on Go-Private Deal
> I hope for Space X and Tesla's sake that the reports of a directory and Executive ban don't come true.

Why? Because Elon is a special snowflake and deserves a different treatment than other white-collar criminals?

dirkgently··on Motorola Razr V3 Cellphone: The trend-setter that shouldn't have existed
T9? Yes, that's exactly how Android dialer works.
dirkgently··on The sunk cost fallacy
But it wasn't _your_ fallacy.
dirkgently··on The sunk cost fallacy
> But TV shows, films, books, games... they've all got many examples of works which either start out terrible and get much better

But for one good example, how many bad examples are there? You are willing to sink your cost by betting on, say, 10% chances that a dud movie is going to turn out to be better.

dirkgently··on Motorola Razr V3 Cellphone: The trend-setter that shouldn't have existed
> I miss phones that let you dial the letters of the contact name to pull up that contact.

Not sure if I understand this. If you mean start dialing by name or number, I can do this on my Android.

dirkgently··on Modern Code Review: A Case Study at Google [pdf]
Unless companywide guidelines are agreed upon, and published.

E.g http://google.github.io/styleguide/javaguide.html

https://github.com/google/styleguide/blob/gh-pages/pyguide.m...

dirkgently··on Self-Driving Cars Can Handle Neither Rain nor Sleet nor Snow
YN is so full of Google FUD. How is this comment not voted down to oblivion is beyond me.
dirkgently··on Writing a simple SQL interpreter in Julia
Neat, but..

> Cause it turns out, hey, a join is really simple! All it's doing is basically computing the Cartesian Product of your two tables, and then filtering out rows based on how you specified the query. No big deal.

Was this a simplification or that's how you think JOINs work? In either case, it's an extremely misleading statement.

dirkgently··on GIMP receives a $100K donation
That's true, but my comment was more about the HN crowd which is primarily (or exclusively) from programming background.

Professionals will always go with a well-marketed and popular option and they don't care about paying 500-1000$ for an image editing program. They don't care (or know) about open source. But I expect better from HN crowd.

As for GIMP and its features, well, when Photoshop firdt mentioned about the new Content Aware feature, there was a collective orgasm, but GIMP had that feature (by sheer virtue of the scriptability and flexibility which is inherent in its design) in a script format at least a year or two before that.

I don't expect GIMP to win hearts of professionals and their shiny macbooks, but for a casual heavy job, GIMP is more than capable, and expect programmers to appreciate it for what the GIMP project has achieved. But all we get here is "but but Photoshop!"

dirkgently··on GIMP receives a $100K donation
Simple answer is that those bitching about lack of features want GIMP to provide exact same features as Photoshop with exact same workflow.

I wonder if these same people also bitch about learning new languages or frameworks when technology moves on.

dirkgently··on Google Titan Security Key now available
And here they are. Every time. Without fail. Without any data to backup FUD. The Apple fanbois. The Google haters.
dirkgently··on Cost of a Join
> I've seen MySQL do a lot of fairly dumb stuff with temp tables and order by.

I too have seen front end of an application do a lot of dumb stuff with state of my requests.

The point is, don't confuse PEBKAC with an issue with a tool.

dirkgently··on Cost of a Join
You are only thinking of just an application. No offense, but this is a classic case of app devs not realizing that databases exist for more than just storing data.

Ever thought that databases are so used to generate reports, dashboards? What about a data warehouse? OLAP? Cubes? Aggregates? What about feeding other systems (e.g. A third party downstream system)?

dirkgently··on Cost of a Join
Because enums only work for the simplest use cases.

If you replace status_id with country_id, where each country_id has more than one property (country name, ISO alpha 2 code, ISO aplha 3, currency_id etc), you can see why enum isn't good enough.

dirkgently··on USA Temperature: can I sucker you?
To generalize, "why such vitriol again science-deniers?".

It's one thing to talk to Bible thumpers, but science-deniers are not Bible thumpers. They use pseudo science to discredit science. They gave an agenda against science. And in the USA, they tend to align well with alt-right.

They deserve all the vitriol they get, and some more.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →