1 karma · joined December 4, 2019
From where I stand they are trying to take advantage of the murky definitions around data retention and various policies applicable to personally identifiable information to side-step certain restrictions in various countries that have much stronger policies around use cases of such data.
Even if we assume that somehow all French data happened to be located on servers in France then complying with those requests would mean purging the data except it is obvious they are not doing that if a person from another country can access the data. So however you slice it google is either non-compliant or is purposefully misunderstanding what it means "to be forgotten" from their indices.
Data does not care about countries and national boundaries since clearly the google servers doing the indexing could be in space. In which case would they be allowed to not comply with any requests by people to be removed from their indices? Or would they be compliant depending on which continent the servers happened to be over at the time? Bordered data is an absurd concept and this person is being very disingenuous by framing the argument in those terms.
On a more serious note I think the article points out something that automation erases. This person wants a genuine interaction instead of a simulacrum of a human interaction.
Hamming has a great lecture series where he consistently re-iterates the point of human/machine interactions as a symbiotic relationship where the machines augment and enhance human qualities instead of just substituting for them. Norbert Weiner before him says the same things at the dawn of cybernetics and information theory. There is much potential in these machine enhanced systems but it seems like it is all being squandered.
Milo was sold to eBay, not Amazon.
The problem isn't that Amazon is doing this and that this will drive out those mom&pop shops. The problem is that people will choose to go to Amazon and willingly destroy the mom&pop shops. The consumers are more culpable for the destruction of those mom&pop shops than Amazon. By placing the blame entirely on Amazon you are taking agency away from people which in my opinion sounds more wrong than a nice neighborhood losing its charm because of Amazon Go.
What people don't realize is that economic forces are completely within their control and it's their daily choices that add up to neighborhoods maintaining their charm or turning into Starbucks and Amazon Go automation factories. There is a sustainable way to drive innovation and it requires people to be cognizant of those daily choices. I don't think you can make people come to that realization by stopping or delaying progress.
In general when I'm making these decisions it always comes down to which group of people I like better regardless of the technology stack.
I think this is the thing people don't quite get when they buy into the hype. These systems are extremely inefficient. Requiring terrabytes if not petabytes of data and basically a powerplant next to a data center to power the whole thing.
The work is valuable and pushing the boundary on what the hardware can do is great but so far all these things lack any kind of explanatory power and suck up a lot of energy to power the black boxes. DARPA recently put out a research program for making systems more efficient and adding explanatory capabilities to them (http://www.darpa.mil/program/explainable-artificial-intellig...). Ultimately that is the direction these things must be headed if they are to provide real value for the masses. Relying on a clever black box only takes you so far and is not beneficial in the long run because as these systems become more integrated into the institutions that drive large scale decision making they'll need to be held accountable for those decisions.
Converting to pictures is unnecessary. It makes the processing harder. The pooling should just happen on segments of the wave form instead of the fourier transform (frequency-domain) picture spectrograms.
The cycle times make no sense to me when it comes to big companies. I don't know how Amazon hires and retains programmers.