HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dmarchand90

1,343 karma · joined May 16, 2019

submissionscomments
dmarchand90··on AI researcher Geoffrey Hinton thinks AI has or will have emotions
My original writing: I'm still not totally persuaded. Firstly I don't think we really can ever be objective regarding the consciousness of external beings. Secondly, I'm not convinced of any your stated requirements being required for consciousness.

Quick example against continuity of learning: many patients lose their short-term memory, e.g. Alzheimer's, patient HM (worth a Google). They only have short term memory but are still conscious.

dmarchand90··on AI researcher Geoffrey Hinton thinks AI has or will have emotions
I appreciate your perspective, but I must respectfully disagree. The primary contention here is the assumption that we have an absolute understanding of what consciousness, emotion, and sentience entail. Given that these concepts are primarily based on human experience and understanding, I believe we should maintain a degree of humility about our ability to fully understand or define them, particularly when it comes to other entities.

Firstly, I want to address your point on objectivity. True objectivity, particularly regarding consciousness, is a lofty goal that we may never fully achieve. Our perceptions and understanding are inherently limited and colored by our human experiences and biological constraints. We're attempting to understand a subjective phenomenon using subjective means, which inevitably muddies the waters.

Secondly, while you've mentioned certain prerequisites for consciousness, I'm not entirely convinced these are universally applicable. I'm particularly skeptical of the notion that 'continuity of learning' is a necessary condition. Many medical conditions, such as Alzheimer's disease and anterograde amnesia (as famously experienced by patient HM), disrupt the continuity of learning. However, it would be a difficult argument to make that these individuals lack consciousness entirely. Their experience of the world may be different from the norm, but they still seem to possess self-awareness and emotions.

We must be cautious about creating restrictive parameters based on human-centric understanding to define complex phenomena such as consciousness. By doing so, we may inadvertently limit our ability to recognize these traits in diverse forms. (Cleaned up version by chatgpt, my original writing is in the response)

dmarchand90··on AI researcher Geoffrey Hinton thinks AI has or will have emotions
Certainly, you can frame an argument around the perspective of more advanced beings viewing human behavior as somewhat algorithmic or non-sentient. Here's a suggestion:

"It's quite fascinating to consider your perspective on the current state of AI, and you make a strong argument. However, I'd like to offer a different lens through which we might view this issue.

Consider, for a moment, a hypothetical race of beings far more advanced than us. Let's assume their consciousness, sensation, and understanding of emotions surpass ours in ways we can't even begin to fathom. From their viewpoint, our behavior and responses could appear as automatic and "pre-programmed" as we perceive AI's responses to be today. They might observe how we eat, sleep, work, and reproduce, and conclude that we are merely 'optimizing' for survival and reproduction.

Furthermore, our reactions to environmental stimuli could seem simplistic to them, akin to how a software program's responses are viewed by us. Just like how an AI responds based on its training data, we react based on our life experiences and genetic predispositions, which are nothing more than 'biological training data'. Our joys, fears, love, and anger might all seem like programmed responses to these hypothetical beings. Does that make us non-sentient?

While it's valid to consider that AI, as we know it, doesn't experience emotions or sensations like humans do, one could argue that sentience is a matter of perspective. The question then becomes not whether AIs are 'conscious' in the same sense as we are, but whether their ability to mimic human emotions and responses is sufficiently advanced to warrant a redefinition or broadening of our understanding of consciousness." (My idea, chatgpt used for phrasing, unedited)

dmarchand90··on Exploring Linear A
What kind of corpus do we have? Is it largely fragmented segments with a few symbols?
dmarchand90··on GPT-4 details leaked?
Can anyone provide an alternative link to https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1678545170508267522

I haven't registered for Twitter since it started and I'd rather not now (though I probably will if it's the only way to get leaked gpt4 training details)

dmarchand90··on The WHO is about to declare aspartame can cause cancer
As others mentioned it's being placed in a very low risk category, which you probably can safely ignore (and, I suspect, is probably only of interest to researchers)
dmarchand90··on Ask HN: What stage of grief are you at regarding climate change?
When I check per capita for the US(1) and countries in Europe(2) you can see it is droping rapidly. Yes increases in overall gdp is causing overall increases in co2 but we have grounds for optimism.

I really do want to emphasize that we need to do something about the situation. But, my view is more of being in a house with hundreds of dirty dishes with more piling up by the minute. Yes if we did nothing about it the house would fill with rot and insects and we will all die. But, much is already being done and my suspicion/delusion is the amount of effort will only increase as the problem gets worse.

1 https://www.statista.com/statistics/1049662/fossil-us-carbon... 2 i looked at Germany and France.

dmarchand90··on Ask HN: What stage of grief are you at regarding climate change?
I'm also in the 'denial' stage(1). Cars are quickly electrifying, CO2 consumption per capita is dropping. I'm also totally convinced we can find more extreme solutions (solar reflection, nuclear powered co2 absorption, etc, ) if we get really desperate

(1) I don't deny the potential impacts of climate change and the need for something to be done, rather, I'm in denial that there will be a catastrophe (and very selfishly I acknowledge that it will be a catastrophe for others).

dmarchand90··on Anti-ageing protein injection boosts monkeys’ memories
I was thinking of more of a "i have no mouth and yet I must scream" or a black mirror "white Christmas" scenario

Edit: to be clear I would still take the immortality like 100%

dmarchand90··on Anti-ageing protein injection boosts monkeys’ memories
Oh yes please. I look forward to being kept alive forever by a machine god with incomprehensible motivations.

Lol jk I still don't want to age and die to be honest

dmarchand90··on Anti-ageing protein injection boosts monkeys’ memories
I used to be more worried about an anthropic argument that we are living in end times. (If population growth is exponential then you are most likely to be born near end times)

But, most people have already died https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12288594/#:~:text=Assuming%2.... And population growth is shrinking. So I think we're safe

dmarchand90··on Ask HN: Are people in tech inside an AI echo chamber?
Yeah I've never gotten this argument at all. "Humans aren't actually intelligent they're just machines designed to optimize their probability of reproducing "
dmarchand90··on Workers with less experience gain the most from generative AI
If I understand it would be something like. You used to get a dedicated secretary. But now most of those roles are now handled by computer. So in a sense everyone has had their workload mildly increased. But worse than that the workload is typically of a different nature so, for example, excessive meetings are now easy to generate.

I would also add that it may be of a net benefit that fewer roles are needed. But that net benefit overwhelming goes to the owners of the company. And that's what we've been seeing the last 30+ years the very wealthy have become much more wealthy while everyone else is worse off. ()

() growing wealth inequality is very complex and I'm sure would be happening anyway. I'm not saying computers cause wealthy inequality but they don't seem to be doing much good in fixing it either

dmarchand90··on Workers with less experience gain the most from generative AI
If you work in the US for fang or similar your life is probably much better. I love computers. I love what they do for recreation and keeping in touch long distance. But work hours are longer. Education and housing is no longer affordable for most people. In the US life expectancy is beginning to drop. You would think people would have easier less stressful lives with greater financial security. But it's not the case for 99% of us.

Quick example. A doctor in the 90s would expect to look forward to less time wasted on paperwork thanks to computers but administration work is increasing. Likewise most professors at most universities will tell you they spend more and more time on administration. Shouldn't this be one of the primary things a computer could address.

My point is great gains brought by a technology such as computers may not translate to great end user benefit. Largely due to compensating inefficiencies elsewhere in the system.

So for example. It may be that chatgpt makes people 10x more productive. But if management gives bad direction it doesn't matter. If most software being developed is redundant then it doesn't matter. If most software is just making ads run faster then it doesn't matter. The technology needs to be appropriately directed to be of noticeable social benefit.

dmarchand90··on Workers with less experience gain the most from generative AI
I dunno computers should be world changing. And they are. Yet the lives of ordinary people have hardly improved and are arguably worse since the 1980s
dmarchand90··on The Little Book of Deep Learning
I was his TA a couple times at EPFL. He provides a really fantastic set of resources for anyone who's interested in the topic
dmarchand90··on Russia 'Coup' Live Forecast
There is precedent for hackernews covering unusually large and important events. Covid, Jan 6th, the start of the Ukraine War. I don't see the problem with some general news of large scale importance, e.g., a hostile mercenary force is a 4 hour drive away from the capital of the state with the largest supply of nuclear weapons

Agree we shouldn't lose focus but this seems rare and important enough to be worth discussing.

From the guidelines of what is off-topic "Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, or celebrities, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon."

dmarchand90··on Nigerian engineering students’ favorite teachers are Indian YouTubers
For me it's been the opposite. Though in my case it's been more Indian professors who often give extremely good (though sometimes perhaps a bit dry) lectures.
dmarchand90··on Open LLAMA 13B released, trained on 1T tokens
I don't understand the negativity. They are giving a complex piece of technology away for free. They choose to simplify the problem. So what?
dmarchand90··on GPT-4 apparently can't recite the litany against fear from Dune
The "we have no moat" essay predicts your behavior very well. The community is now hungry, ready, and primed for a napster/pirate Bay of LLMs. I suspect it will be these sketchy versions that will push the hardware even further (Do you think most people filled their ipods with hundreds of gigabytes of music they purchased)
dmarchand90··on Infinite Photorealistic Worlds Using Procedural Generation
Demo video is very impressive. I thought it was yet another GAN, but, no. It's something "mathy". I'll need to read the paper for sure!
dmarchand90··on Infinite Photorealistic Worlds Using Procedural Generation
https://infinigen.org/
dmarchand90··on MrBeast has become a viral sensation for his acts of altruism
Girl scouts are children selling sugars to adults. Mr beast is an adult who sells sugar to children.

Anyway, I don't think he's a scumbag. I think he's a nice guy and I'm sure I would be his friend if we took the same pottery course or whatever. I just don't think trying to "cram one more treat into America's already bloated snack hole"[1] is very 'cool'.

[1] Simpsons, season 8, episode 164, The Twisted World of Marge Simpson

dmarchand90··on MrBeast has become a viral sensation for his acts of altruism
I thought he was cool until he launched a chocolate line. Really? Is that what we need? Most of his audience is young gen z, and I'm sure the last thing the most obese generation ever needs is someone pushing more sugar on their diets
dmarchand90··on Hacker News evading criticism by selectively adding noreferrer to certain links
What beef does jwz.org have with hackernews?
dmarchand90··on Why do recipe writers lie about how long it takes to caramelize onions? (2012)
Could you recommend such a "proper" cookbook
dmarchand90··on ПП-BESM – a Soviet language (1955)
Last update was in 2018. Would love to know how far the guy got https://xav.io/posts/besm-update/
dmarchand90··on The Great CPU Stagnation
Nice processor choice... vrchat in mind? Haha
dmarchand90··on Ask HN: What 60 folks can give career and general life advice for 40 folks
Japan is a bit tricky to analyze because they tend to have higher dividends than US stocks. And yes even though their total returns have been bad the point is you wouldn't lose all your savings. (Though you certainly would have been better putting your money elsewhere)
dmarchand90··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
The problem with vr is it is extremely good for cyberpunk raves but very so so at everything else
← PreviousPage 4 of 12Next →