HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dognotdog

678 karma · joined January 11, 2014

submissionscomments
dognotdog··on What Pro Computing Could Be
> What’s more, we lack the innovative institutions that previously provided cover for the future to take shape: PARC, Bell Labs, et. al.

We may not have as large corporate sponsored basic research, but we do have the Internet. We should be able to leverage that advantage to some effect :)

dognotdog··on Return of the Mac (2005)
A wild rant appears.

The negative reaction is not because the new MBP is terrible when viewed in a vacuum, it is because people who would like (or actually need) more powerful hardware than the one-size-fits-all approach that seems to be Apple's current course are no longer catered to, or so it seems.

Personnally, I don't really care about the touch bar one way or another, but what I do care about is that I would like to have one machine I can do all my work on, which involves a wider range of things one a daily basis than is typical (e.g. video/image editing, GPU powered number crunching, coding, and sitting in moving vehicles plugged into a bunch of stuff). In the past few years, the 15" MBP has been the machine to do it all, but in it's newest incarnation(s) I am no longer sure it would still be the best tool. It seems like gimmicks are added, but useful extras are stripped away. Maybe it's just in the uncanny valley of progress with USB-C, but for the moment the way they went about it all or nothing seems like a major inconvenience, with all the "legacy" hardware I need to attach. And there's minor things like removing the power brick's cord.

As such, my first instinct is also to bitch and moan, as now it looks as though I need to find a new setup in the near future, and damn Apple for building something for the median user, but not for me. I, too, like to think that though I have an atypical usage pattern, what I do and how I talk about it benefits Apple enough that they should at least invest a bit of effort to try and keep me on their platform.

dognotdog··on Total Nightmare: USB-C and Thunderbolt 3
Personally, I am rather sad to see the Magsafe connector go, and having to sacrifice IO for charging while mobile seems like quite the headscratcher.

It's somewhat funny that not only will you have to carry dongles for everything for a few years time, but also make sure you carry the right USB-C cables, as your friend's might not work. Yay we have superlight laptops, but need to carry a backpack full of spaghettied cables.

dognotdog··on Trans-Neptunian object discovered in the outer solar system
Sadly, they have a video embedded in the article that at first glance seems informational, but it's really just an "action" animation of the solar system. They could really just have shown the orbit this thing in a diagram or something.
dognotdog··on Save Netflix
> I'm glad cars never quite got to the same homogeneity or we'd all be driving a Datsun Sunny or something equally horrific.

Well, cars are incredibly homogenous ( https://medium.com/swlh/the-zombie-mobile-b03932ac971d#.mu5k... )

Some niche markets exist, but 98% of what's being bought is a completely interchangeable middle ground compromise, made by huge companies that are only looking at maximizing short term profits, without care for technological, economic, or sociological advancement.

In every industry that requires large up-front costs for economic mass production, this is true. Hopefully, 3D printing and its sister technologies will make manufacturing many things on a smaller scale more affordable, and disperse the (mass-) consumer-producer dichotomy once again, in favour of local on-demand production of everyday items.

Only with such a level and flexible playing field can you expect innovation to thrive: if it becomes affordable to buy (or create) the best tool for the job, instead of relying on mass-produced mediocrity because one-off items increase one or two orders of magnitude more in cost than in marginal utility.

dognotdog··on New Metal Can Become Soft and Stiff Like Human Muscles
Is there a more detailed explanation of this somewhere, and what range of stiffness variation can be achieved?

From what little can be seen in the video, it looks like the main spring is divided in half, and the center plane is variably tensioned perpendicularly, with the leaf springs so acting variably against the lower part of the string.

dognotdog··on BMW Australia Refusing to Comply with Terms of GNU Public License
At this point in time, having the software available would do more harm than good, considering that 90% (or more) of software development in the auto industry seems to be done by electrical or mechanical engineers with little to no training in software development, and even less knowledge about security and vulnerabilities.

The auto industry does have a plethora of coding standards and software processes, but not enough institutional knowledge and foresight to produce secure software for connected devices. The fact that it hasn't been too catastrophic so far is more a testament to the technical limitations of the bus systems and ECUs than real security, but that is rapidly changing with the advanced hardware being put in cars today.

dognotdog··on GPL Violations Related to Combining ZFS and Linux
The amount of collective brainpower being burned on licensing issues for supposedly free (as in speech) software is astonishing.

I do symphatize with the sentiment that an author does not want his work to be a source of illicit gains for someone else, etc, neither do I, but at the same time find that the usefulness of a piece of code for other open source developers is (figuratively) inversely proportional to the length of the license, while the real abusers don't give a damn.

dognotdog··on Patent Owners Can Prevent You from Owning Anything
You are not alone, I also do not understand much of my patents after they've been lawyered up. I attribute it to a) them trying to change the language to be as broad as possible, while b) making it also deliberately hard to figure out what the damn thing is supposed to do in the first place.
dognotdog··on Static, Ahead of Time Compiled Julia
Considering that Matlab, which is supposed to be a stable platform, seems about as buggy as Julia with a lot of regressions, API changes, and new bugs every release, I, too, prefer Julia, as it's not only a nicer language with better programmer and execution efficiency, but it's also open source.

I'd rather try to fix a bug in some undocumented codebase than wait 6 months for a new black box.

dognotdog··on Dear GitHub
If I read it right, they're not asking for a more complicated default for all projects, just that they can customize it for their projects.

And I agree, simple is good... but simple is also bad for large projects, as while it makes it easier to create a ticket, it makes it harder to track for the maintainers. They are (rightfully) looking to ease their work, and I do believe it is a net win for both sides if filing a bug is made a little harder, but it becomes a lot easier to manage.

dognotdog··on New development could lead to more effective incandescent lightbulbs
How does remote phosphor help with color rendition? After all, white LEDs also use blue light + phosphor, so how do the remoteness help?
dognotdog··on How 3D printing threatens our patent system
Interesting twist, as data itself is not under copyright, but a compilation may be. Is a CAD file such a compilation, or just data formatting? I'm not sure.

(However, I do blame The System for this uncertainty. I wish it'd err more often favouring the copier, instead of the rights holder, if that would make everything simpler.)

dognotdog··on How 3D printing threatens our patent system
It's odd that a CAD file is made to seem equivalent to the actual physical object.

A CAD file should, under the current system, be copyrightable, which it is. However, it is nothing more than a description of an object. A patent is also a description of an object, with the only difference that the former is interpreted by computers (or humans with the aid of computers) and the latter is interpreted by lawyers.

As mentioned in another comment, patents should contain relevant CAD files to better describe the invention, instead of obfuscated legalese prose that nobody understands. Patents are supposed to create a legal monopoly for the price of disclosing the invention. If the inventor does not wish to disclose details, the invention can remain a trade secret instead, but granting both secrecy and a monopoly does nothing for innovation.

Clearly, 3D printing makes it easier to replicate physical objects, but as the patent system's stated objective is to further innovation, maybe it's time to relax patent licensing instead, as 3D printing giving the ability to tinker and create to "the masses", and will undoubtedly produce a lot more innovation than locking down patent law.

dognotdog··on Introducing new open-source tools for the Elixir community
The amount of traction Elixir has gained in the last year is amazing, but not completely surprising, as it's fullfilling its promise of being a better Rails, in which Erlang's scalable parallelism model plays a big role.
dognotdog··on Introduction to Ada and SPARK (2009) [pdf]
Disregarding that it's not a solution to the DoD's problem as such, does Ada/SPARK have merit for writing embedded software?

I am coincidentally researching if I could rewrite parts of a personal project in Ada (from C) to improve reliability, and so far have failed to conclude either way.

dognotdog··on More Apple Car Thoughts: Software Culture
All big players in the car industry have a research center in SV nowadays, it seems, not only the Germans. There is undoubtedly a lot of talent in the Bay Area, yet the rush of the car industry to SV smells of cargo culting.
dognotdog··on 'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch
Hah, nice! Looking at it now, of course it makes sense. I guess I just short-circuited by thinking of the polarizer as blocking light only, and not that the reduction in intensity is the result of the projection of the previous wave direction onto the new wave plane!

EDIT: not that this makes the quantum effects any clearer ;)

dognotdog··on 'Zeno effect' verified: Atoms won't move while you watch
Er, I am fairly sure that polarizer example doesn't work, and still no light gets through, as polarizers don't rotate the light, but simply cut off components that are orthogonal to the polarization direction. So stacking slightly rotated filters through to 90 degress would still leave you with no light.

EDIT: On second thought, it might just be you wording making it seem weird. The analogy works if you don't look at the whole stack, but the after adding each polarizer. Still, the same effect is had as simply gradually rotating the 2nd polarizer.

dognotdog··on The Zombie-Mobile: Car brands no longer reflect differentiation
Aerodynamic shapes may be well known, but can still be very dissimilar, and counter to what we perceive as "aerodynamic."

Point in case: the Citroen AX has a drag coefficient of 0.31, which apparently is the same as for a Porsche 997 Turbo. The AX looks like a box on wheels.

We aren't the slaves of the wind tunnel, as in that case we'd probably have some pretty mad shapes driving around, but slaves of wanting to look, well, the same as everyone else, to avoid any risk. But this is more a feature of entrenchment in the car industry than anything else. There is really no incentive for the big OEMs to do anything risky.

dognotdog··on A Little Gear That Could Reshape the Jet Engine
Thanks, that article was indeed much better to understand what's going on. Still, as mentioned, high-speed gearing of the kind does offer some design challenges, but apparently its all secret sauce.
dognotdog··on A Little Gear That Could Reshape the Jet Engine
It'd be interesting to know what exactly they are doing in the gearbox, apart from the flexible mount to absorb excess torque. New materials? Surface treatments? Special lubrication?
dognotdog··on The magic kernel
When seen as a [1 3 3 1] (the 4th row of Pascal's Triangle) kernel, it is more easily revealed as a discrete Gaussian kernel, which is for example used in scale-space representations in image processing.
dognotdog··on Tesla Model S Autopilot Features
It's no problem to autopilot on the highway today, 90-95% of the time. But that number needs to go even higher, still, before it can be unleashed on the public. And for that last edge, sensors and software have to get better. As a guess, going from 90% to 99% is the same effort as going 0% to 90%, software and hardware wise. Luckily, these diminuishing returns are (somewhat) offset by more resources being poured into development, and hardware costs coming down due to volume manufacturing.
dognotdog··on Tesla Model S Autopilot Features
It's not as simple as that. NASA can update software on the mars rover or interplanetary probes, but that's one device at a time, and the amount of effort put into it is staggering.

At the same time, consumer electronics are routinely broken by OTA updates.

Cars fall squarely in the middle, high volume and high price. Additionally, failures carry a high risk. Nobody will die if your webshop goes down, but if your car decides to steer into oncoming traffic, well, bummer.

The support beam analogy is flawed in the sense that the beams are simply made bigger to ensure they're strong enough even with considerable material defects, but this doesn't work for software, where a single little bug can lead to a catastrophic failure.

I am not aware of anything other than cars where such a high number of devices carries such a high risk factor. Certainly doing OTA car updates in a commercial environment is possible, but there is not yet a relatively foolproof way to do it.

dognotdog··on Tesla Model S Autopilot Features
The cameras can and do detect if a sign isn't stationary, etc.

For speed limits, the obvious technical problem is knowing when they end, if they apply to your road, or maybe a parallel road or an off-ramp, which is mostly easy for a human to tell, but much harder for a camera.

Even though the camera may be better on average processing all this information than the average human driver, it's an unanswered question, from a legal point of view, who's responsible when the camera is wrong.

Volvo has recently taking a stand proclaiming legal responsibility, but it remains to be seen if that's even a possibility in many nations.

dognotdog··on Tesla Model S Autopilot Features
Long story short, it's both hardware and software holding things back. On the hardware side, there is a lot going on with solid state radar and lidar sensors improving by the minute, while prices are down a factor of 10-100 from even 5 years ago. There are now sensors available for research and product development that in 5 years time will allow a semi high-end production car to robustly drive all traffic conditions on a highway.

Car makers (and suppliers) have to learn how to make software to make optimal use of the existing hardware, but they've got a long way to go, still. Every major player nowadays has a research center in Palo Alto or whereabouts, seemingly trying to learn how to do this via osmosis, but it will take some time until they really understand how to keep pace with information technology, and how to bring it into their mammuth manufacturing and legal frameworks. Nevermind the necessary mindset to pull it off.

dognotdog··on Tesla Model S Autopilot Features
While the over-the-air update is novel, these features all exist on current luxury and even some middle class vehicles as part of driver assistance option packages.

They're typically called Lane Keeping Assistant, Adaptive Cruise Control, Blindspot Warning, Automated Parking, Traffic Sign Recognition, etc.

The emergency steering bit is interesting, though no further details are provided, as it requires the car to ensure that there is a safe space to steer into, which is dicey for a forward collision emergency braking system, so I'd conjecture it is connected to the side collision warning, and allows collision avoidance if there is enough space in the current lane.

dognotdog··on The International Flag of Planet Earth
That one is a lot more interesting, though it's basically just a map, which is atypical for flags.

The OP's flag is very abstract. Presumably, any other alien race also strives for unity and lives.

It's hard to create a better flag without actually knowing aliens and having some idea of commonalities and differences with humanity. Indeed, maybe we need a flag for humanity, not planet earth?

dognotdog··on GitHub threatens to shut down a repository for using the word 'retard'
For those people (like myself) not wanting to be dependent on github and similar hosting services, there are alternatives to git+github that can do distributed bugtracking and are easily self-hosted, such as Fossil ( http://www.fossil-scm.org ).
← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →