HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

doktrin

6,105 karma · joined July 25, 2011

submissionscomments
doktrin··on Stripe bans Trump campaign
If I had a dime for every time I read some pearl clutching comment about the big brother slippery slope on HN, I could have retired by now.

In all these years, the only actual existential danger to society to materialize are precisely the entities that are now being deplatformed.

Excuse me if I don't take all this hand wringing on behalf of unstable insurrectionists seriously.

doktrin··on ‘Extremely aggressive’ internet censorship spreads in the world’s democracies
I don't know why you view scientists as automagically infallible. Mistakes are quite possible, as are misinterpretations.

For what it's worth I live in Norway. Neither of those domains are DNS blacklisted, nor have they ever been - with the possible exception of on one specific corporate ISP (CATCHCOM). If you disagree, feel free to show some evidence to the contrary.

doktrin··on ‘Extremely aggressive’ internet censorship spreads in the world’s democracies
If you look further down in this comment thread, that claim has been repeatedly debunked, likewise for Match.com. These sites have never been on any widely adopted DNS blacklist in Norway. It appears censoredplanet analyzed data from a corporate-only ISP.
doktrin··on ‘Extremely aggressive’ internet censorship spreads in the world’s democracies
If I'm inferring correctly from the wiki page on Norwegian internet, the DNS blacklist is not made public as they mention it was posted to wikileaks back in 2009. At the time I believe this was exclusively a CP blacklist [1]

The mandate to block torrent sites came about as a result of a court order following a lawsuit brought forth by Hollywood studios against Norwegian ISPs [2]. I tried to find the specific text on lovdata, but came up empty as they don't have a comprehensive list of local court decisions. [3]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_in_Norway#Internet_ce...

[2] https://www.dagbladet.no/kultur/the-pirate-bay-stenges-i-nor...

[3] https://lovdata.no/register/dommer

doktrin··on ‘Extremely aggressive’ internet censorship spreads in the world’s democracies
I checked as well (Globalconnect wired; Telenor mobile). It's a fairly ridiculous claim, one which if true would have attracted instant media attention.
doktrin··on ‘Extremely aggressive’ internet censorship spreads in the world’s democracies
That PIA blog post is not exactly high quality.

> Norwegian politicians from the Christian People’s Party are shocked that there is porn on the Internet, and want it eliminated – censored off all the Internet pipes as though the pornography doesn’t exist.

There's some truth here, but it's presented in a shoddy way. Yes, KrF (Christian People's Party) has at various times made noises about pornography DNS filters. I don't recall all the specifics, but various proposals have included opt-out DNS filter and/or filters in schools and such. While I don't support these proposals, I think the language used really exaggerates the reality (and few or none of these measures have ever gained much headway, either at the national or local level)

> If you read the Norwegian Christian paper, though, it is expressing itself very positively toward this censorship (which is somewhat weird for a newspaper, any newspaper – those generally oppose censorship vehemently and defend any and all freedom of the press).

They really dug deep on this one. The paper in question (Dagen) has a circulation of slightly over 10,000. That's not even among the top 20 in the country [1]. I'd be skeptical of assigning much weight to their coverage.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_newspapers_in_Norway

doktrin··on Evaluating the State of Accessibility Design in Video Games
You're not wrong. Difficulty is central to these games, and also IMO often overstated and/or misunderstood. At least in the Fromsoft titles you mentioned, pattern memorization is way more important than straight up twitch reflexes. I would bet good money that many players who have given up would find their groove if they just spent some more time on it.

All that said, I don't see why accessibility has to be a dirty word. Purposefully difficult game design does exclude players. For every inspiring story of someone completing a challenge while suffering from a disability, there are 10 more who completely miss out on what are - difficulty aside - genuinely interesting games. I personally know soulsborne fans who mainly like exploring the world, and for whom boss encounters are just a necessary evil.

That's honestly fair - these are rich worlds with interesting lore and a unique form for storytelling, so I totally get just enjoying the game(s) on those merits alone. It then follows that I think others who are similarly inclined but perhaps not quite as able should be able to enjoy the same experience.

doktrin··on The Laptev Sea hasn't frozen
So you're saying that conspiracy theorists - who regularly consume news from sources that outright fabricate stuff - are being driven to believe this literal fiction because a climate model was off by a few years?
doktrin··on Cognitive deficits in people who have recovered from Covid-19
That's not their scope of analysis, that's just the introductory sentence. It's meant to reflect on the existing body of knowledge prior to their study. To paraphrase, it's essentially saying "this is what we know already, and here is what we're adding to the body of knowledge with this study"

As always, it's best to read the source material directly but these are relevant excerpts from the abstract :

"Case studies have revealed neurological problems in severely affected COVID-19 patients. However, there is little information regarding the nature and broader prevalence of cognitive problems post-infection or across the full spread of severity...

...People who had recovered, including those no longer reporting symptoms, exhibited significant cognitive deficits when controlling for age, gender, education level, income, racial-ethnic group and pre-existing medical disorders. They were of substantial effect size for people who had been hospitalised, but also for mild but biologically confirmed cases who reported no breathing difficulty."

The last part directly contradicts the idea that this study is limited in scope to severe cases.

doktrin··on The pandemic has eroded democracy and respect for human rights
> that's the common interpretation

Hardly an interpretation, it's stated in black and white :

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

doktrin··on The pandemic has eroded democracy and respect for human rights
> Websites and their obscure “Terms of Service” and “Community Guidelines” are eroding those rights and should be fully compliant with the first amendment

This makes me think you misunderstand the first amendment. It concerns freedom of expression from government interference. Free amplification on private platforms is not covered.

doktrin··on The Problem of Free Speech in an Age of Disinformation
> Part of the problem is that so many people think it's only the media outlets that say things they disagree with that are the problem. It isn't. It's all of them, no matter what side they're on or what point of view they're advancing.

You can further reduce this to "all humans will lie and manipulate when it suits them". As a statement it's just as true, but it obfuscates the concept of scale : some people lie more, more deliberately and more frequently than others.

By declaring everyone an offender without further distinction, you are effectively excusing the behavior of the worst actors while minimizing the good faith efforts put forward by others.

doktrin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
As others have already mentioned, HN is in fact actively moderated. It's by far the most curated public discussion forum I frequent. The civil tone that prevails here is in many ways a result of the community guidelines being strictly enforced, and backed up with a banhammer.

If you were to take the above at face value, would this change your perception about the value of moderation in online communities?

doktrin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
> However, it is highly unusual for an article published by one of the mainstream popular newspapers to be treated in this way.

BBC coverage routinely, and correctly, classifies publications like the Daily Mail as tabloids - yet the NY Post is a "mainstream newspaper"? That's inconsistent.

doktrin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
Arm one man with a stick and the other with a verified twitter account, and I know who I'd bet on.
doktrin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
> Is this how it feels to live under the CCP’s control?

This is an overly dramatic comparison that trivializes the Chinese surveillance state.

doktrin··on Former NSA chief Keith Alexander has joined Amazon’s board of directors
Without addressing the specifics of IronNet, the fact that one entity adopting this strategy experienced sub par results is pretty meaningless - mostly since hiring former senior military and government figures is basically standard practice in any organization that handles (or aspires to handle) federal or military contracts. Swap out 'federal or military' for basically any other organization or entity and the practice still holds true.
doktrin··on Former NSA chief Keith Alexander has joined Amazon’s board of directors
> you're kidding yourself if you say the US is that far behind.

Living in Europe I have the pleasure of hearing these kinds of naive comparisons on a regular basis. Somehow it's always "the US is basically China and/or Saudi Arabia".

It's exhausting having to explain to people who are seemingly only capable of operating with a binary black and white worldview that there is a massive difference between certain shades of grey.

doktrin··on Former NSA chief Keith Alexander has joined Amazon’s board of directors
> Why should I stop sawing this branch I am sitting on, I havent fallen yet ?

Your argument is that we can't prove the absence of a conspiracy.

Hence, a better analogy would be

"why should i stop sawing this branch? just because gravity has never left me suspended in thin air doesn't mean it can't or won't happen in the future"

doktrin··on Former NSA chief Keith Alexander has joined Amazon’s board of directors
> This sounds tinfoil hat crazy, but here we are. Not so crazy now.

Nothing about Amazon hiring a former NSA director to its board is "tinfoil hat crazy". It's in fact perfectly rational, since Amazon is literally in the business of selling services to the federal government.

doktrin··on Feds say Yale discriminates against Asian, white applicants
> people start campaigning to no longer classify asian / pacific-islanders as a "minority".

I'm not aware of any organized campaigns to this effect, but the idea that Asians aren't "real" minorities / PoC is one that sometimes gets tossed around in progressive circles.

e.g.

https://www.insider.com/the-internet-is-debating-who-to-call...

Arguments put forth range from the purely visual ("some asians are fairer than white people") to the socioeconomic ("asians don't give back to the black communities in which they own businesses"), or variants thereof.

I guess it's a gentle reminder in these relatively polarized times that relations between minority groups in the US have historically been tense, be it black-latinx, black-asian or black-jewish. It might feel like there's a detente right now due to the focus being on the state and the white power structure et al - but the underlying animosity is real enough. Humans are tribal to a fault, and that will never change.

doktrin··on Space Jam's 1996 website is still alive
If nothing else, the soundtrack is a really fun throwback. The monstar track with coolio, busta rhymes, method man et al is super catchy.
doktrin··on Software will eat software in a remote-first world
My take :

At some point in the mid-to-distant future, most human labor (certainly white collar labor) will potentially be automated away, with remaining blue collar labor not far behind (the physical interface, e.g. general purpose robots that are superior to humans in non-static environments will probably come last).

Until that point, the demand for a technically literate workforce will continue to grow, simply because the number of potential areas of application will also continue to grow. With every new digital encroachment on our analogue lives, we find new business verticals that previously simply didn't exist. I don't see that trend abetting anytime soon. Put differently, it's not like software development ends with webapps. For every domain that gets commoditized, there will almost guaranteed be new ones in need of hands on skilled labor. There will of course be some developers who aren't as effectively able to reposition themselves for new verticals (we've all probably heard some anecdote of a C programmer who simply couldn't grok OOP, etc.), but by and large it's difficult for me to see the demand for human-generated bespoke software development dissipating until we get close to that mythical land of general AI.

Now, on the payscale side I do agree with the author that the push towards remote work will definitely have an impact on many of our salaries that are currently tightly bound to geography. That seems fairly evident, to be honest. I live in northern Europe where our salaries are quite good relative to other parts of the continent, but you can still find high quality engineers for <$100k USD - many of whom are on par with FAANG developers being paid >$200k in SFBA or Seattle and the like. The further east / south you go, the lower the current salaries are. It seems logical that decentralization of work will lead to a flattening of the income curve - raising some incomes, lowering others - as we increasingly all enter the same digital playing field. That said, wages - like housing prices - are to use econ parlance 'sticky downwards' so if I were still a SV developer I wouldn't start losing sleep yet.

doktrin··on Caffeine: A vitamin-like nutrient, or adaptogen
Without disputing your personal experience, the parents anecdote is reflective of how most people experience the addictive qualities of nicotine vs caffeine.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30061507/

"Conclusion: Dependence to traditional cigarettes and snus seem to be relatively similar while NR (nicotine replacement) was rated lower and coffee lowest."

doktrin··on MacOS Catalina: Slow by Design?
I've gone full circle. Went from desktop linux (mostly Arch) to OSX ~7 or so years ago, and now due to a combination of frustration with the butterfly keyboards and then a slew of issues with macOS itself, I'm back to linux desktop for my dev machine.

From my perspective as a quote-unquote power user, it feels like Apple just constantly insists on shooting themselves in the foot with unnecessary and ill conceived innovations. Either way, I'm happy with my new setup and probably won't go back to macbooks anytime soon.

doktrin··on YouTube removes interview with professor of medicine on Covid stats and policy
all you have to do is click on his name to see a list of his work.

https://nypost.com/author/michael-goodwin/

"Susan Rice's email exposes Team Obama's 'by the book' treachery"

"Shameful media still slamming Donald Trump during coronavirus crisis"

"Trump passes coronavirus test with flying colors"

"Deep State snakes slither back after FBI, CIA swamp draining"

yeah, definitely not a right leaning columnist.

doktrin··on Authorities say Hobby Lobby's Gilgamesh tablet is stolen, must go back to Iraq
Since the article claims the tablet was in London "in or before 2001" it couldn't have been looted during the 2003 invasion of Iraq.
doktrin··on Europe’s cities are making less room for cars after coronavirus
> I think you missed my point. If more than half of Oslo was built after 1950 it kinda invalidates that the city was built before cars.

You're missing the more germane point that the relevant metric for "built" in this context are roads, not living accommodations. More people live in Oslo than in the 50s, but the roads and city blocks within ring 3 are what they are from prewar times, i.e. tons of small 1-way streets and the like.

Case in point : many, if not most, of the apartment buildings in "Gamle Oslo" (literally "Old Oslo" - the downtown area to the east of the railway station) were built in the 1980s or later, but the roads around those new constructions are still narrow 1-way prewar streets.

To my mind the parents point was pretty clear - Oslo is an older city, particularly from an American perspective, and you have to travel pretty far out from the city center to find an urban infrastructure that accommodates cars in the way the younger and generally more modern cities in the US (outside the northeast) do. This is 100% related to the city center being built before the dawn of ubiquitous private vehicles, and not to choosing some arbitrarily different urban planning "path".

Another comment mentioned the underground highways that have in fact done wonders to move traffic away from the over-congested city streets, which only reenforces the idea that the city proper was not designed to accommodate even a modest volume of car traffic.

> But the answer your question: Vienna. Vienna has smaller population today than it did in 1910.

That's interesting, but it's noteworthy that it has a higher population today than it did in 1950, so yours is an incomplete answer. The geopolitical reasons for Vienna's population in 1910 are unique, what with being the capital of a sprawling trans-national empire that ceased to exist.

doktrin··on Europe’s cities are making less room for cars after coronavirus
> Oslo has about twice the population today as it had in 1950.

That's a weird supporting argument. Can you name any urban centers that have not seen significant population growth since 1950?

doktrin··on Uber Bookings Now Down 80%
Not the parent, but when I've had food delivered I reheat it in a new container. That + disposing of original packaging, afaik, mostly mitigates any risk of transmission which for this particular vector is low to begin with.

I havent ordered many fresh salads or sushi.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →