HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dolni

1,294 karma · joined October 13, 2020

submissionscomments
dolni··on Ask HN: What's the most life-changing blog post you've ever read?
I think at least some of the battlefronts talked about by this blog post were started by the ultra-wealthy in the US to draw the peasants attention away from Occupy Wall Street. That was the last "big thing" before identity politics took center stage. It pits us all against each other instead of pitting us against the rich.

China and Russia are likely responsible for some of these battlefronts, too.

dolni··on Do Best Practices Matter?
What if everything were written in C? Or Python? Or Java?

We'd have massive consistency across the software industry and yet that would be an absolutely terrible idea.

dolni··on Quality is a hard sell in big tech
> Quality is expensive. Even a fairly minor improvement in basic Quality can double the cost of implementation.

Quality is expensive, but lack of quality is also expensive.

Low-quality software causes customer churn, increases implementation time for new features, causes more incidents, negatively affects your reputation, etc.

Moving fast is the right thing sometimes. But overall, quality is the way.

dolni··on Python types have an expectations problem
I have written type-annotated Python for as long as type annotations have been a thing.

"Number of bugs will drastically increase" is simply wrong.

Type checking prevents bugs before they ship.

dolni··on Ask HN: Can we do better than Git for version control?
I think there are two things being conflated here.

One is: how do you effectively manage changes to a codebase over time? Git has a model that, for day-to-day use, has primitives like "commit", "branch", and "tag". You also have to understand the difference between your working copy, what is staged for commit, and any other commit in history. These, in combination with the operations you can do with them is actually somewhat complex. This is the thing I am saying people need to learn. And people quite often complain about it.

The other is the organization of git's porcelain layer, the arguments and flags each subcommand takes, and how stuff is presented back to the user. I think git stands to make significant improvement here. Be that as it may, the tool exists as it is. So your options are to use a different VCS entirely, use a different frontend, or learn how to use git as-is.

If you choose to use git but deliberately avoid learning e.g. what a rebase is and why it's useful, you are choosing to be an ineffective developer. Could it be better in some ways? Yes, but it isn't.

I don't think the car analogy is particularly compelling. The "primitives" of a car are already much simpler than git's. The fundamental primitives of a car are "go faster" and "go slower", along with some supporting things like managing your headlights, windshield defrosting, wipers, and horn.

While additional tools are being added to cars to make them safer (e.g. a backup cam or collision detection), the complexity of those tools is increasing rapidly which makes them more prone to failure. And a driver is absolutely not excused from causing an accident just because one of these safety tools failed. You still have to know how to safely operate your vehicle in a variety of conditions.

dolni··on Ask HN: Can we do better than Git for version control?
> IMO the largest share of developers today are doing brick-laying work (which of course takes skill, I am not underestimating it) and would benefit a lot from having simpler tools - they don't need to know how to use an oscilloscope at all.

They're doing brick-laying work until they aren't. Most problems are easy to solve and don't require very much fussing over. The expertise comes in knowing which problems are worth fussing over and which aren't.

Technology is becoming ever more present in our lives, not less.

Reducing software engineering to a low-skill trade when there is, in fact, mountains of complexity is surefire way for software to be a heap of shit. And in a lot of ways it already is.

dolni··on Ask HN: Can we do better than Git for version control?
Merge commits mostly solve this problem if you use them.
dolni··on Ask HN: Can we do better than Git for version control?
There has been a lot of push to commoditize software engineering. Unfortunately that has resulted in a swarm of people who want developer salaries without the work or expertise.

Git definitely has some warts but you are right. It is an industry tool for expert, professional use. Some complexity is inherent to the problem of version control.

Learning how to use your tools is part of ANY trade.

dolni··on Ask HN: Can we do better than Git for version control?
Giant PRs that are squashed into one commit are an anti-pattern. Every commit should contain exactly one logical change AND a descriptive commit message.

Unfortunately a good chunk of the industry doesn't have the discipline to do this.

If you have ever worked in a project where there was discipline around committing, you know there is lots of value in doing so (rebasing becomes easier, you unlock the power of bisect, log is actually useful).

dolni··on There's an uptick in Amazon employees quitting
Is it very valid if they hired you as a remote employee to start with?
dolni··on Why we’re dropping Basecamp
If this is the bar for “harming your wife’s mental and emotional state”, I bid you the very best luck working through literally anything difficult. And all relationships eventually do encounter difficulties.

Something being uncomfortable and something being harmful are very different.

dolni··on I hacked Magic the Gathering: Arena for a 100% win rate
The halting problem does not forbid us from discerning if SOME programs will ever halt. It says that there are definitely programs for which we cannot know.

I suspect most of the MTG infinite loops are something like "A triggers B, B triggers C, and C triggers A". Asserting that the loop will never resolve is not a violation of the halting problem.

dolni··on Why we’re dropping Basecamp
As this applies to DHH, are you suggesting that having and expressing an opinion can cause "harm"?
dolni··on Why we’re dropping Basecamp
You are implying here that having and expressing an opinion on social policy is worth "holding someone accountable" for. Be careful with that hammer. It feels righteous to wield until the acceptable opinion changes in a way you don't agree with.

Also, this kind of thing may be a net benefit for DHH. It's publicity. Time will tell.

dolni··on Why we’re dropping Basecamp
I don't label myself conservative. Conservatives also exhibit this behavior, but it is seen as more "socially acceptable" to do this under the banner of liberal values.

To address your point, I am not disputing Duke's _right_ to make purchasing decisions for any reason they like.

But it is still stupid and childish. I'm calling that out.

> Why should you care about Duke’s organizational disruption anyway? It’s a private school and you don’t work there.

Because Duke is attempting to normalize toxic behavior. They think this is going to help. It won't.

This behavior might achieve "compliance" but it doesn't actually move the needle. It's why places like San Francisco appear to support underserved communities, but when push comes to shove they blockade housing initiatives.

This is almost certainly some liberal, white woman's way of looking like a good person without having to risk anything. After work it's back to the gated community!

dolni··on Why we’re dropping Basecamp
One of the things that has always tickled me about this bent of "liberal thinking" is that they generally believe two things at once:

1. people who commit crimes -- even heinous ones -- deserve a second chance and reintegration with society (except, perhaps, for a select few crimes which may not even be especially heinous in the broader context)

2. people who hold unacceptable opinions are irredeemable

Regardless of what you think about DHH's opinions, it strikes me as magnificently childish to cause this kind of organizational disruption because of an opinion. The guy isn't funneling money to Nazi concentration camps. He has an opinion, and it's different from yours. Grow up.

dolni··on A peculiarity of the GNU Coreutils version of 'test' and '['
I much prefer Linux but having used Macs a few times for work, I absolutely cannot recommend making GNU coreutils the default option on Macs.

If you make GNU coreutils the first binaries in PATH, you can expect subtle, _very nasty_ issues.

The last one I encountered was `hostname` taking something like 5 seconds to run. Before that, there was some bug with GNU’s stty which I don’t remember the specifics of.

dolni··on FCC Is Trying to Stop Discrimination in Broadband Deployment. Telecoms Are Mad
I don't think people here have sympathy for ISPs. I sure don't.

I'm still against this particular rule because it sets a very problematic precedent.

There are other non-problematic ways to hold them accountable. Like fining ISPs for the taxpayer dollars they were given, plus interest.

dolni··on FCC Is Trying to Stop Discrimination in Broadband Deployment. Telecoms Are Mad
Even from the "underserved people" standpoint, most of the people who have shit-tier internet are people living in very rural areas (read: overwhelmingly white).

There is no valid reason to turn this into yet another performative piece of race-bait.

dolni··on FCC Is Trying to Stop Discrimination in Broadband Deployment. Telecoms Are Mad
If you wanna go down that road, compel them to build the infrastructure where it was promised. Or issue a fine for the amount they were given, plus interest.

We don't need to play silly "affirmative action" games to keep them accountable.

dolni··on Lost "Doctor Who" episodes found but owner is reluctant to hand them to BBC
The loss here is the psychological impact of knowing your home has been violated, and thereby feeling less safe. Which is quite substantial for many.
dolni··on It's OK if your code is just good enough
Done is not always "better than perfect". A bridge that is done isn't better if it collapses due to poor engineering and kills people.

All software is not life or death. But software can be something people come to rely on.

If I choose (unknowingly) to rely on software not done well and it bites me, I personally would rather not have relied on it at all.

dolni··on Now we know how Covid attacks your heart
It is specifically able to replicate when plaque is present in the arteries.

With America's obesity problem, maybe China thought this virus could knock the US down a peg or two.

dolni··on Ruff v0.1.0
Yes, and what I am saying is that if people on your team cannot let a trivial, unimportant technical detail go, that is a people problem.

You may have avoided the silly argument about code formatting. But if that tendency lives in your engineers, they will find another nit to pick somewhere else.

In my opinion this is not a problem best solved by technology.

dolni··on Ruff v0.1.0
Isn't this a people problem and not a technical problem?
dolni··on Comcast squeezing 2Gbps internet speeds through decades-old coaxial cables
> You don't want to impact their service, period. No calls, no truck rolls.

From my experience this is absolutely not true. Comcast had zero issues intentionally crippling my internet connectivity because the modem I owned only supported DOCSIS 2.

I received letters for months that I needed to upgrade my modem to support a “the best speeds”. Then I didn’t, and my speed dropped to less than a megabit per second.

I could have waived it off as a coincidence, except a couple of months later I was telling the story at a happy hour and it turns out the exact same thing happened to another guy right around the same time.

Comcast does not care if you have a shitty experience. They don’t care if you call. Me not upgrading and calling support about it is just the cost of them doing business.

dolni··on Anything longer ago than yesterday should just say the actual date
If precision isn't needed, why do you need to know it was last week? Why can't the precise date be displayed for those who need it?
dolni··on Valve says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS not happening, there aren't enough players
What I said was accurate. _I_ can play on whatever device _I_ want. :-)

I take your point. Even so, Steam is leagues ahead of everyone else in this regard. I have Steam games I bought 10 years ago that I can still play on my current desktop PC. That is absolutely not the case with consoles. It isn't even the case for mobile for me, since I switched from Android a few years back.

dolni··on Valve says Counter-Strike 2 for macOS not happening, there aren't enough players
That might be useful if iPhones and iPads weren't gimped platforms.

There is no Steam (let alone any other game store) on iDevices. Just Apple's store.

As a consumer, I don't wanna pay for a game on Apple's store just so I can have a shitty iPhone experience. Especially when nearly every other game I have is on Steam and I can play on whatever device of mine I want.

dolni··on Humans are biased. Generative AI is even worse
I think the real problem is that human beings are biased and have a very strong negative reaction to things which are actually unbiased.
← PreviousPage 3 of 18Next →