3,210 karma · joined June 17, 2013
Aid should be merit-based. Both statistically and in my experience growing up at average and poor public schools <5% of the population is gifted and talented at the level where going to college would be a value gain for both them and society. Giving ~50% of youth a perverse incentive towards higher ed is obviously turning out to be destructive for both them and the institutions.
Sometimes less is more. What was originally meant to help the <5% of the non-elite youth who were intellectually gifted or uniquely driven has mutated into a destructive-for-all-parties incentive pushed on 50+% of the population to follow. Quality of output requires quality of input, so returning to merit standards is a must.
Prospective students are not shopping with real prices in mind - if there is a choice between a university with big names, shiny amenities, and attractive dorms the sticker price difference doesn't mean much. Gradually, all schools give up their frugality and delude themselves into mission drift. Arbitrarily cancelling loans now without scaling down new loans is multiplying the subsidy distortion effect, as new borrowers are increasingly convinced they too may not have to pay back the loans they're freely given.
In my opinion, subsidized loans need to stop entirely for a period of back-to-essentials relative austerity for university budgets before we bail out and calcify the current bloat with a new benefit. Then if we really need a new benefit it can look like a leaner amount-capped voucher and not a state inflated debt balance that may or may not go away. The voucher could scale on merit, a guaranteed partial scholarship as long as you meet certain standardized test/grade levels (without the need to apply and be chosen amongst a limited pool).
But really, the best policy would be constant social and educational emphasis on device parental control feature awareness - similar to drunk driving campaigns. Get parents and guardians in the habit of taking 15 min to set up basic parental controls BEFORE handing devices to kids. Rather than the all-too-common mess of reacting to a problem by taking the kids phone or making them manually show everything after the damage is already done. Maybe also compel device manufacturers to incorporate a first-time-setup flow that has a specific soft ask of "Will this device be given to or borrowed by a child?" that then handholds the owner through setting up controls.
The obstacle is human nature and ease-of-use friction - taking responsibility for maintenance and innovation and imposing a participatory need requires a modicum of awareness and willingness to contribute - even if only with pennies. This is annoying and wasteful red tape for most, and so corporations with strong advertisers and investors who can provide it cheaper or for free are obviously seen as the better choice. Co-ops and communes have this problem.
https://www.courthousenews.com/argentines-feeling-unsafe-des...
Hopefully the new crackdown on crime will also help temper inflation. My Argentinian colleague was kidnapped on the street and taken to his Buenos Aires apartment where he was robbed of a big chunk of his savings back in 2015/2016. If organized crime has been operating like that the threat and fear must put a damper on everyone's productivity.
Interestingly, soon after Seligman left Sony Entertainment in 2016 it started compelling PlayStation devs to censor character depictions and dialog - by 2018 this policy from California HQ was even imposed on long-loyal Japanese studios who made games solely for the Japanese market. I wonder what her opinion is on AI bias/safety given what happened at her old company.
The models with issues appear to be the older ones with retrofits. Perhaps there are failure vulnerabilities when mixing today's computer-reliant design into past institutional-knowledge-reliant human design.
To the khanate's credit, there were periods of relatively exemplary tolerance towards conquered people - if and only if they were fortunate enough to have local leaders who immediately, unconditionally, and pro-actively offered surrender with tribute during those gracious moods. Otherwise, you know, skull pyramids and whatnot.
And they do shoe tying: https://www.fieggen.com/shoelace/knots.htm
Knots in general: https://www.animatedknots.com/complete-knot-list
The economic efficiency and technological leaps that come with increasing the number of productive people would mitigate, slow, and potentially reverse climate change much more than surrendering the world to those who refine metals by mixing mercury over burning tires and will continue to reproduce without care for Malthusian handwringing.
Note how the US reduced carbon emissions despite an increasing fertile population and concurrent deregulation. While others who focused only on limiting their status quo increased emissions. Human society is dynamic, not static, and linear projections and limits do not play out so simply.