HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dustball156

0 karma · joined May 2, 2020

submissionscomments
dustball156··on Why SARS-CoV-2 Bluetooth contact tracing apps are a tremendously stupid idea
> The question is whether you can get that without a huge false positive rate. My guess is that you can

No, you can't. The virus spreads exponentially and the app is suppose to keep up. In other words, you get an exponential number of alarms.

> On the cost issue, the obvious solution is to make testing free and easy

Cost is not the limiting factor. Equipment, reagents and time is. We could have easily beaten the pandemic by now if simply going from door to door and taking a smear test was an option.

dustball156··on Why SARS-CoV-2 Bluetooth contact tracing apps are a tremendously stupid idea
Actually no and no.

Having been in the same cell (potentially several square miles) as the murder victim is not quite the same as having been in tracing distance (4m²).

That's quite a strong argument/pretense, why law enforcement would immediately lobby to get the system changed in their favor. Don't you agree?

dustball156··on Why SARS-CoV-2 Bluetooth contact tracing apps are a tremendously stupid idea
The point of the article is discussing why the system can't work as promised ("anonymous", "voluntary") and has to devolve from "decentralized and privacy aware" to "shit in a bun".

Yes, you need a key and the article explains why that's the case and why you don't want one.

dustball156··on Covid-19 Immunity Passports
What a piece of crap.

"An immunity passport is the same thing as ICVP"

No, it is not! To get the Immunity passport, you have to suffer through the decease. To get an ICVP, you only need to get vaccinated. There's quite an obvious difference in the mortality rate, let alone that vaccination doesn't cause you to spread the virus.

The only reason why anyone would want an immunity pass is for the benefits it promises. It's quite irresponsible to give people a reason to seek an infection!

Oh, by the way: do you know what's also immune to the virus? Doorknobs! Doesn't stop them from spreading it, though.