HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dustfinger

930 karma · joined May 26, 2016

submissionscomments
dustfinger··on Ring has partnered with 400 police forces
The first product that popped into my mind when I read the subject's name in the title was Gnu Ring. My jaw dropped several inches before I remembered that Gnu Ring changed its name from Ring to Jami in Jan of this year.

> https://blog.savoirfairelinux.com/en-ca/card/ring-becomes-ja...

dustfinger··on Using bacteria to make self-healing cement
That is really interesting. I didn't realize that corrosive oxidation would become concentrated and react at a higher rate if the point of exposure was limited.
dustfinger··on Using bacteria to make self-healing cement
I never considered the potential social side to this problem. Thank you for commenting.
dustfinger··on Using bacteria to make self-healing cement
> the failure mode of rebar rusting is usually visible to inspection and slow enough that action can be taken to ensure that the structure remains safe. The failure mode of a brittle reinforcing member suddenly failing is much more worrying from a safety perspective.

That is an excellent point!

dustfinger··on Using bacteria to make self-healing cement
It looks like some effort was made in 2010 to coat the reinforcing steel with a porcelain enamel [1]. I believe the enamel's primary function was to provide a bond with the encasing concrete. Naturally, it would also help to protect the steel from water and oxygen.

There must be a reason why ceramic cannot fully replace steel. Cost perhaps.

Maybe these technologies would be better combined.

[1] https://www.ceramicindustry.com/articles/90943-improving-ste...

dustfinger··on Using bacteria to make self-healing cement
I wonder if it would be feasible to replace the steel reinforcement rods with ceramic? No iron no rust.

I also wonder if concrete might bond better with ceramic. My understanding is that concrete does not bond well with steel.

dustfinger··on Software was eating the world – now landlords are eating everything
Thank you!
dustfinger··on Software was eating the world – now landlords are eating everything
What is the origin of the meme "X is eating the world?" I seem to see these titles posted fairly regularly now.
dustfinger··on Introducing nushell
This project has goals similar to GNU eshell [1]. Great ideas, thank you for sharing.

[1] https://www.gnu.org/software/emacs/manual/html_mono/eshell.h...

dustfinger··on Don't bury or cremate – soon you may compost your corpse
The nitrogen in our DNA, the calcium in our teeth, the iron in our blood, the carbon in our apple pies were made in the interiors of collapsing stars. We are made of starstuff.

~ Carl Sagan

dustfinger··on German city offers $1.1M to whoever proves it doesn’t exist
It wouldn't be a theory if they had proof, it would be a fact ;-)

Of course you are talking about evidence which is not the same as proof. However, if we do think in terms of proof for a moment and following that line of reasoning, is it even possible to have a fake conspiracy theory? That is to say, is it possible to have a fake theory? I think the notion is absurd. The moment someone makes a hypothesis the theory is real and by definition, pending proof to qualify as fact. If someone provides evidence disproving the theory, then the theory would be wrong, but not fake.

I like your comment though :-)

dustfinger··on The body is the missing link for truly intelligent machines (2017)
>In order for the experimentation to lead to higher levels of enlightenment an intelligent agent must be able to take past knowledge and hypothesis yet unobserved outcomes.

hypothesis => hypothesise

dustfinger··on The body is the missing link for truly intelligent machines (2017)
>That’s either dismissing or handwaving a lot.

Yes it is, but see my comments above. Thank you for your thoughts.

dustfinger··on The body is the missing link for truly intelligent machines (2017)
> I think you're severely underestimating the importance of emotional intelligence.

I don't mean to suggest that social intelligence didn't play an important role in the evolution of real general intelligence as we know it. (I define RGI as a GI that evolved through natural processes and without direct intervention of higher level GI). I wanted to keep an open mind about things though. My goal was to try and reduce factors that relate to intelligence on earth so that I might be able to say something about what factors are in fact a prerequisite to AGI.

Do you like sci-fi? Have you read Pandora's Star? If you like sci-fi, but have not read said book, then I recommend that you consider putting it in your queue. You might find the Primes to be a believable vector to RGI. A vecto that I believe challenges human bias about GI and what it takes to reach past a class I civilization.

Love the discussion, thank you for your thoughts.

dustfinger··on The body is the missing link for truly intelligent machines (2017)
>I don't believe AGI is ever going to happen

Do you mean to say that you don't believe artificial general intelligence will happen for a specific reason, or that you hope that it will never happen for a specific reason? I am curious either way. Thanks for your thoughts.

dustfinger··on The body is the missing link for truly intelligent machines (2017)
>How many senses humans have depends on how you define it

That is true, but considering only the well known 5 senses simplified the correspondence and seemed practicable. My thoughts were focused on reducing the number of sensors and physical capabilities of a known embodiment of real intelligence to say something about what might be a prerequisite for acquiring similar intelligence in a different body. However, I acknowledge that doing so might cause me to overlook something subtle, but necessary. You made a good point, thank you.

dustfinger··on The body is the missing link for truly intelligent machines (2017)
> The big question is "How much of a body does the AI need?"

Our bodies give an upper bound of five sensory inputs. With a little scrutiny we can reduce that even further, since we know that a portion of our population are born with less than five senses and exhibit comparable intelligence. Some people are borne blind, deaf, mute, anosmic, or with ageusia. Others are even born with rare sensory deficits such as the inability to feel pain. Although I have not read any studies on the subject, I suspect that being borne with none of the five core sense would have a serious negative impact human intelligence.

There is more to the problem though then just the ability to sense our environment. I believe that for an agent to acquire human level intelligence, it is also necessary to have the ability to explore and manipulate the environment in complex ways. It must be able to experiment by making observations, evaluating the outcome and thereby advance its knowledge. Knowledge of course must be retained to be of any use, so it must have memory efficient enough to be practicable. In order for the experimentation to lead to higher levels of enlightenment an intelligent agent must be able to take past knowledge and hypothesis yet unobserved outcomes. This should serve as motivation for further experimentation.

Human's have this notion that a per-requisite to real intelligence is to be able to express ones self with a language and thereby share your ideas with others. Communication with language seems to result in social beings, and it is widely believed that social beings do best if they have emotional intelligence, otherwise they will likely be outcast from society.

so, I think AI needs a body that at least allows it the following:

- Ability to move

- Ability to move objects with enough accuracy to assemble or disassemble complex structures

- The ability to know the physical properties of objects (maybe through one or more of our five senses, but not necessarily)

- Ability to retain knowledge

- Ability to hypothesise

- The ability to communicate with another agent to share information (helpful, but maybe not necessary)

I am not as convinced that emotional intelligence is required, so I left that out of my list. For example, consider that highly intelligent beings could be of a different nature than humans and form societies without emotions or politics. An excellent example are the Primes from Pehter F. Hamilton's Pandora's Star where (motiles) are controlled by the commanding caste (immotiles) [1]

Of course I am bias since I am human, so I am looking at what is required to achieve intelligence as I know and understand it.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commonwealth_Saga#Pandora's_St...

dustfinger··on The body is the missing link for truly intelligent machines (2017)
> Maybe we just haven't reached the level of complexity needed for human-level AI. A hint that this might be the case is that the current excitement with ML seems to be fueled by algorithms that were mostly known by the 80s (sure, with lots of recent incremental improvements, but no new big idea). What made a difference was the computational power and datasets that became available in the 2010s. I suspect the next leap will be of a similar nature. "More is different".

Regarding the nature of complexity and the notion that "More is different", I am reminded of the emergent behavior of vivisystems [1] as described in Kevin Kelley's book Out of Control [2] -- an insightful exploration of the emergent behavior expressed by complex self sustaining systems. If you have not read Out of Control then you might want to put it in your reading queue. I found it highly engaging and thought provoking.

[1] https://www.everything2.com/title/Vivisystem

[2] https://kk.org/outofcontrol/

dustfinger··on The Most Dangerous Writing App
Well then you are already writing in plain text. Why not use git for committing revisions rather than making backup copies on the file system?
dustfinger··on The Most Dangerous Writing App
Consider using org-mode [1] as your primary word processor and committing revisions to git. I recommend org-mode because org documents are saved as plain text and therefore can be easily diffed. org-mode can also be exported to many formats [2]. If you are concerned about how the look and feel of writing in plain text might impact your experience authoring a document, there are lots of editor specific tutorials for beautifying the presentation of org documents. Here is one such article on beautifying org documents in emacs [3]. Also, if you choose emacs as your editor and you are uncomfortable using git, then I recommend magit [4] because it makes git functionality highly discoverable.

[1] https://orgmode.org/

[2] https://orgmode.org/manual/Exporting.html#Exporting

[3] http://www.howardism.org/Technical/Emacs/orgmode-wordprocess...

[4] https://magit.vc/

dustfinger··on Tech Interview Handbook
> Everyone has the same canned answers to the stupid behavioral questions.

If the person conducting the interview thinks the behavioral questions are stupid, then perhaps they are. In that case, don't ask "stupid" behavioral questions.

> Resumes are meaningless, and often re-written by recruiters to match the job anyway

Was the position entry level? Students coming right out of compsci often have little to no practicable experience. They may have difficulty thinking about what to put in their resume. After one or two years of full time experience that should no longer be an issue.

> For all I join in when complaining about irrelevant algorithmic questions, I have to admit that they at least test something, even if it's just willingness to study for the interview.

Asking those "stupid" behavioural questions and receiving the same canned answers also demonstrates a willingness to study for an interview.

The coding problem should be testing a candidate's problem solving capabilities as practicably required by the role being interviewed for. The chosen problem should reflect the types of problems that they will actually need to solve if hired. For example, you could select a small PR from one of projects being actively developed by the company. The selected PR should involve only one or two classes (assuming a language with classes) and require improvement. You can look through the history of a PR and just pull out a segment that was selected for improvement by the reviewer(s), or have the team select it for you. Then ask the candidate:

- to conduct a code review of the PR

- to improve the code

dustfinger··on Tech Interview Handbook
> And as for the code, we included what we thought was a trivial nested for-loop problem and virtually nobody could even get started on it.

> Is this kind of code problem too complicated in your opinion?

May you please post the problem so that we can provide you with meaningful feedback regarding said problem?

dustfinger··on Tell HN: Danny Cohen Has Died
RIP ... so say we all.
dustfinger··on The 1619 Project
>"American slaves were enslaved in Africa"

No, this is what was written by nilkn in the parent post above:

> many of the first slaves imported by Europeans were already enslaved in Africa

Which means something very different then what you quoted. Maybe those quotes were intended to paraphrase, but with topics like this it is important to not change the meaning of someone elses words.

dustfinger··on Major breach found in biometrics system used by banks, police and defence firms
The title could be improved. There was no major data breach, unless you consider the researchers that discovered the vulnerability to be perpetrators of a data breach as a result of their research. That is not normally how security research is interpreted. They found a vulnerability, not a breach.

The title would be less like click-bait if it simply said: Vulnerability Found in popular Biometrics System allows access to gigabytes of data including unencrypted passwords.

dustfinger··on Alan Kay's answer to ‘what are some forgotten books programmers should read?’

  Assembly Language Step-by-Step
  second edition
  Programming with DOS and Linux
  Copyright © 2000 by Jeff Duntemann
  Rev. ed. of: Assembly language, © 1992
  ISBN 0-471-37523-3
dustfinger··on New York City Neighbors Build Cheaper Way to Connect to Web
By that line of reasoning it might be good etiquette to make assumptions about an article and the contents of an article provided that one does not include a disclaimer about not reading the article :-P

I did make the disclaimer that I have not read the article for the sake of transparency and humility. I probably will later this week, but the only spare time I have has been spent responding to this thread :-P

dustfinger··on New York City Neighbors Build Cheaper Way to Connect to Web
An application can be designed to communicate over more than one protocol. There is more than one transport protocol used on the internet. For example, the UDP protocol may be used for for P2P / mesh networks. Applications that support UDP may also support TCP. TLS runs "on top of some reliable transport protocol (e.g., TCP). UDP is not a reliable transport protocol. There are also transport protocols other than TCP / UDP [1].

Anyway, if you are making your own mesh that does not require you to have access to an ISP, then maybe you make that mesh over something other than IP. If you did use something other than IP, that would not prevent any of the nodes from including IP in their networking stack. In that scenario, a human user of the mesh might believe that they are completely off the grid / internet, but surprise, all their traffic or leaked metadata is actually being aggregated over the internet because one of the nodes is connected.

I mainly brought this up because it popped into my head and I thought it might make for an interesting discussion. Also, because I have thought about making a distributed mesh network that does not use IP where nodes communicate via HAM radio.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transport_layer

dustfinger··on New York City Neighbors Build Cheaper Way to Connect to Web
I wasn't making the assumption that their mesh was based on TCP. I should really just read the article and linked materials, but I am trying to ingore that temptation since I am supposed to be working :-P
dustfinger··on New York City Neighbors Build Cheaper Way to Connect to Web
Do these mesh networks support TLS? Even if they do support TLS, it might be possible for a node on the mesh to successfully carry out a SSL strip attack. Or aggregate leaked metadata from the requests that pass through it. I am not familiar with these mesh networks, there may be many lurking attack vectors if the creators are not particularly concerned with privacy / security.
← PreviousPage 8 of 14Next →