HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dylangs1030

2,946 karma · joined October 29, 2011

dylan.sacco@yahoo.com

Security researcher residing in New York.

submissionscomments
dylangs1030··on Show HN: BoundIt CAPTCHA: highlight objects in photos to prove you're human
For everyone who seems to be getting false negatives, it's because you're tracing a space too large.

I was initially getting robot returns, but it seems to have a higher tolerance for not binding the entire target, rather than trying to get the entire thing and having non-target space in the enclosure.

With that out of the way...this isn't safe. Interesting idea, but not safe. All that's needed is an algorithm that finds the object existing in both images. This is trivial with your current setup because size doesn't matter, recognizing two clocks is pretty easy even if one takes up a full picture and the other takes up a corner.

Some possibilities, and problems with each:

1. If you try a more rigorous system, where there's two pictures full of images in both, then you might have a better chance. But you'll still be giving text instructions to specify which image is the one you need to trace, and this can be automated as stated above. As soon as you state the word of the image, it's going to be algorithm-able, unless you make the image so blurry or incomprehensible as to fool both machines and humans, which defeats the purpose.

2. You could specify nothing, and instead tell the human to trace two matching objects. Regardless of whether or not there's more than one matching set, you can still automate this and pass with a machine.

I think this is an interesting, and perhaps capable idea, but it's far away from having any practical or secure utility.

dylangs1030··on Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network
This is ridiculous. They're not part of a conspiracy. They're businesses that sometimes have a strategic advantage for the government, for which the government requires a legal precedent to access. That is all. Stop with the dramatic hyperbole.
dylangs1030··on Facebook Is Not Blocking Tor Deliberately
The worst part of that life cycle is being one of a minority group trying to explain what's really going on. I had the top comment on 3 different NSA stories at one time, correcting misinformation in each. I still don't think it helped.
dylangs1030··on Buying the new MacBook Air
Thanks for this insight from your experience. I was going to comment question this takeaway from the OP:

"Apple recognizes what few other retailers do: customer satisfaction starts even before a product is purchased, and it is customer satisfaction that makes companies great."

I had expected this was just an idiosyncrasy of that particular salesperson, but you make a good case that Apple intends for this behavior to be common. Thanks!

dylangs1030··on Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator
pg, I humbly submit that it's time to make a "subreddit" of sorts for politico-technical discussions, and moderate what is submitted to it. I know this might sound distasteful, and I'm not suggesting we go down the slippery slope of becoming like reddit, but I think the events of the past week have shown that it's necessary for change.

I'm not a particularly old member here by any means, but it's become very obvious that this community is too large for the current constraints on it. Minor changes, like implementing a separate area for political discussions would act as a sort of "release valve" without sucking up precious real estate on the front page.

My reasoning is as follows: there's no stopping wave stories like the NSA scandal from being submitted to Hacker News, people are too invested in hearing about it. Besides, there's some justification for it, being that it has a technical basis despite being political.

Moreover, it would lessen the impact to the front page for polito-technical debate to have its own "arena" of sorts. I would also motion for these to have separate karma/upvote/"staying power" treatment, similar to Ask HN: threads.

dylangs1030··on Choosing Hong Kong Is a Brilliant Move by Edward Snowden
Hey rayiner, if it helps at all, I frequently follow your comments on Hacker News, and I've been able to grasp all your (very cogent) examples of how the government was worse in the 20th century. So it's not falling on deaf ears.

Just wanted to give some encouragement since you seem really discouraged by HN this week. It's been straining on the whole community, I think.

dylangs1030··on Ask HN: Should I include my GPA and/or transcripts when applying for jobs?
Cover letters are the most important part of getting an interview. If you can find the right balance of assertive, interesting and enthusiastic, you're almost guaranteed a response at the minimum.

By contrast, resumes are spam. I've gone through most hiring processes on my cover letter (and tech interview of course) alone, without ever being asked for a resume.

dylangs1030··on Ask HN: Should I include my GPA and/or transcripts when applying for jobs?
I'm a bit late to this, but I'll give you my experience. It echoes what others have said to some extent.

In every instance I've applied for a job, it began with my casually (but assertively) stating interest. Here is the process I go through (you could call it my job hunting "workflow"):

1. I read about an interesting company or meet/talk to someone with connections to an interesting company.

2. I learn what I can about them, researching for a few hours, deciding if I'd enjoy it (on a cursory level).

3. I contact people with decision making ability and politely but assertively state my interest. Note - I don't send a resume (you can, I don't).

4. Most cases, I've gotten through an entire hiring process without being asked for a resume. If they happen to ask, it generally suffices to show them my portfolio of prior work. This is in fact as simple as linking the list of projects I've authored on my blog with corresponding code.

5. Technical interview(s). Negotiation. Wrap up. Bam, you're done.

I highly, highly suggest you read patio11's "Don't Call Yourself a Programmer"[1] and "Salary Negotiation"[2]. No, really, read both. Absorb every kernel of knowledge.

The importance of a resume is grossly overestimated, as is the importance of a transcript. Don't show a piece of paper, show the knowledge that your education provided you with. Connections are important, and will field you the most significant leads in finding a job.

[1]: http://www.kalzumeus.com/2011/10/28/dont-call-yourself-a-pro...

[2]: http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/01/23/salary-negotiation/

dylangs1030··on Living in a Startup Bubble
Medium blog posts are basically roulette when it comes to quality. This particular one is trash. It uses the keyword startup a lot, talks about how they're risky, and gives some paltry relationship advice. It's not written well and basically compiles the most general facts known about startup culture, consolidating all of them into a vague article that's all over the place.

This post reads like one of those keyword articles that only exists to collect hits for a website. It is utterly devoid of any depth, and lacks the substance to really portray any meaning to startup life.

In fact, reading this it's almost as though she wrote this as a book report. It's badly written and conveys nothing about "startup life" despite the fact she repeats that phrase over and over.

Here's a few sentences that should clue you into this:

1. "Add to this our four young children (6, 4, 2 and newborn), and you’ll understand our startup life is pretty full on."

No, I don't understand. What does having children have to do with your husband and you having a "full on" startup life? If anything, that would make it more difficult for you to commit yourselves to startups. If you tried to convey that you must be uber-committed to startups because you're doing it despite having children, it didn't work.

2. "Startup life is so part of our life that it is far more than just our work, it is our life."

Badly written. And I don't mean this in a pretentious, grammatical way, I mean the word "life" is repeated enough times that this sentence doesn't capture any of the passion you're trying to portray. It's empty.

3. "The more I’ve tried to explain things to friends and family, the more I’ve realised that startup life is a bubble and really not like other ways of living and working."

You didn't explore the bubble bit, which is arguable and by no means widely accepted. You also didn't justify a connection between a bubble and being different; there's no inherent correlation.

4. "It often feels like the startup is everything and far more important than our relationship. There have been so many times when I’ve felt like a startup widow. I think we are getting better at making sure that doesn’t happen. Changing some of the ways we work for a start. And having great communication is key to relationships and family life working together with a startup."

You lost track of your central point here. Are you talking about startups or your relationship? You began this blog by talking about how different startup life is, yet you have not defined it at all. You just keep reiterating the effect without tying in a relevant cause.

Furthermore, communication is important in any relationship. That's just another platitude; this is full of them. Again, meaningless.

5. "Startup life takes a huge amount of belief in what you are doing and belief that you have what it takes to make it happen, or the skills/sense to hire the right people to make it happen."

The next three paragraphs go on and on, repeating the same idea: startups are hard, you need to be committed. Got it, but we all know that already. It's self-evident.

6. "Startup is a process"

I don't even know what this is supposed to mean, and the consequent paragraphs in this section fail to give me any clues.

I can go on and on with these. Literally every other sentence is written like an ezine article. It's crap, and doesn't stimulate meaningful discussion.

dylangs1030··on A new lightweight lift cable will let buildings soar ever upward
I love when scientific interest articles pop up on the front page like this.

It's really amazing to me that one of the things that holds skyscraper maximum height back is the practical concern of lift height. That's simply not the first thing I would think of if someone asked me the question.

But while that's cool, I don't think we necessarily should be building taller skyscrapers. They're not very practical. If they were, we'd have quasi-Coruscant cities where all the buildings were as tall as the Empire State Building or Willis Tower.

Instead, what tends to actually happen is the buildings become landmarks that attract a lot of attention but comparatively little real estate. Furthermore, when cities expand they generally need to build upwards quickly and forsake extravagance for practicality. If it takes 10 years to build a monolithic structure higher than the skyline, that's a project that's burning money for a long time until it's profitable.

dylangs1030··on The Worst Startup Idea
I'd argue that you can start smaller than that if you want to get in with decision makers.

Let me give an example. Typically, when people need a software solution and they are not executives, they go to whoever is in charge of such things and ask for a budget to acquire that service. The Human Resources and Accounts Payable departments deal with it, but an employee initiates the prompt. This is the underpinnings of SaaS models, and how they market to a lot of companies.

Let's say I was a waiter in a very inefficient restaurant, or better yet, I had experience for a few years in different restaurants. Let's say our waiter also happens to be a talented software engineer doing market research. He's well within a degree of separation from his boss, presumably, even if the restaurant he works at is part of a huge chain.

If he can justify solving a very important problem that's hemorrhaging money to his immediate superior, his immediate superior can go one step above himself and make a case for the software.

Not only is this possible, I have literally done this, which is why I have such a detailed example. You can go up the chain link by link without having to wait until you've physically climbed to the top.

Now, that said, I also don't agree with the premise of even needing to get in touch with decision makers. As long as you can verify there is an existing problem, and you can verify that it exists for a legitimate group of people who'd throw cash at you to solve it for their own business, you have a business model. Granted, that is not easy, but it's certainly an alternative to needing connections.

I think the author understands this and realizes that he's not suggesting startup ideas require people with extreme levels of experience. He didn't mean that you need to get in with the C level executives of a corporate culture just to be relevant to them - the entire argument about how easy it is, how blind they are to talent, etc. is irrelevant. He's not recommending that. He just wants people to have practical field experience so they understand their problems from the perspective of the domain - whether they are in the top, middle or bottom of that domain is not necessarily important.

dylangs1030··on The Worst Startup Idea
I'm almost positive that was dry humor, but in case it wasn't, and for other peoples' benefit (namely the parent), it's called building a strawman argument[1].

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strawman

dylangs1030··on Why Doesn't Anyone Give a Crap About Freedom Zero? (2008)
The problem with marketshare is that it's a cycle. Getting marketshare requires those kinds of features (generally), which requires paying your engineers a better salary (again, generally, there are exceptions). But that won't happen without a marketshare to bankroll better engineers. And at that point, you might as well be proprietary.
dylangs1030··on Why Doesn't Anyone Give a Crap About Freedom Zero? (2008)
This expands on my point really well. Designers, more than anything else, have to 1) know the problem better than the user, and 2) interpret what users say they want/need to ascertain what they really want/need.

They also know how to differentiate between what users want, what users need, and what users think they want/need, but which they really don't. It's a practical difference that goes beyond what's merely possible in programming. It also includes what's feasible and targets the problem most successfully.

Designers have the burden of preserving coveted features, furthering a competitive advantage, and removing features that confuse users.

It doesn't help users to give them everything they need, it only obfuscates software for them. A minimalist program that perfectly achieves what one group of users wants is superior to large software loaded with every feature requested ever catering for the entire market.

It's like buying a suit. It's better to get one tailored to your exact measurements (needs) than to buy a suit mass produced in the most popular, requested sizes.

In theory, proprietary software cannot fulfill this function as well as open source, because a programmer could just identify his own problem using his own experience and solve it. But in practice, this doesn't scale to anything larger than an individual, so proprietary software comes in, where skilled designers are paid heaps of money to do all of the aforementioned.

If there's one thing that kills open source software, it's the amount of decision making it places on users. Good designers (which cost money) know which decisions to make themselves so they don't confuse users.

This also goes hand in hand with freedom zero. Users don't want freedom because they don't want to make decisions. They want a problem solved but they don't care if they're "free" while it's done. They just want it accomplished so they can be on their merry way.

dylangs1030··on Why Doesn't Anyone Give a Crap About Freedom Zero? (2008)
I wasn't trying to imply OS X or Windows are a "bed of roses" - frankly, they're not.

I agree with you that the euphoria comes with freedom of a linux distribution. That sentence was a bit of dry humor on my part.

But my point still stands, and it's not black and white. Windows and OS X aren't perfect at all despite being proprietary, and linux isn't terrible for being so open. In fact, I'd recommend every programmer be comfortable with linux and navigating the more complex advantages it presents, especially server-side.

But I really can't honestly say it's more convenient, or that the software you run on linux will typically be as well-designed and as useful as a proprietary system. It just isn't. And that's okay, but it's a self-perpetuating cycle because people don't want to break into linux and make it better without higher benefits and salaries, but those won't come without associating linux with quality, open software (and getting past the whole non-profit issue).

dylangs1030··on Why Doesn't Anyone Give a Crap About Freedom Zero? (2008)
But that's not true, what if I want to install third party applications not listed in (for sake of example) Ubuntu's app store?

Sure, Firefox and popular community apps will always be either pre-installed or easy to install with a GUI.

But what about fringe applications that not enough people use to merit a spot in the repository of available apps?

dylangs1030··on Why Doesn't Anyone Give a Crap About Freedom Zero? (2008)
I'm glad you agree with my conclusion.

What you said about drivers is defensible; it was just the first thought that popped into my head. Nowadays linux has progressed enough to bypass that usually - but what about being required to use the terminal just to install?

Most users don't know what sudo, wget, make, or apt-get commands are, just to start. Most users don't know what commands are, in fact. They don't care about root access or custom options. They need and expect a graphical wizard to walk them through the core basics of their programs, and even then they shouldn't try to perform anything other than the checked box "basic installation". Perhaps that's a better example?

Now, you can blame this on third party developers not packaging their applications as handily as they do for Mac or Windows, forcing people to gather and compile sources themselves. But this doesn't change the bottom-line - linux is not convenient (which we agree on).

And I have used iTunes on Windows, and I found it wasn't bloated. It seems to be more or less on par with my Mac to be honest, though frankly I haven't used it for that platform except to help other people in the past year.

dylangs1030··on Why Doesn't Anyone Give a Crap About Freedom Zero? (2008)
I'm not really sure where you got this from...? In fact, whether or not it's pre-installed is irrelevant altogether.

Ubuntu comes pre-installed with Rhythmbox. Mac OS X comes pre-installed with iTunes.

But iTunes > Rhythmbox, still. It has nothing to do with whether or not it's easy to install, that's one small fragment of what I said about open source being hard to figure out which string of letters/numbers version to install.

Pre-installing packages so the user doesn't have the find and compile them on their own helps, but the utility and design of one program is still superior to the other regardless of whether it's pre-installed or not.

dylangs1030··on Why Doesn't Anyone Give a Crap About Freedom Zero? (2008)
This is again a case of apathy. How many users care about DRM and the integrity of their data, let alone its freedom and exportability?

Most users are not power users (else the term would be redundant). Most people who use computer that I know simply log on, surf the web, check email, etc. In fact, most users spend almost all of their time on a web browser, to the point that different systems seem pretty much the same.

Most users cannot quantify the difference between Mac OS X or Windows beyond the hardware differences, and even that's just a momentary thought. They don't care about data because it's not relevant to their lifestyles.

Corollary to this point is the fact that many hackers attribute malice and spite to companies that don't allow data freedom. But honestly, it's not profitable for most companies to serve that small subset of users in the mass market because their voices aren't loud enough. They have more profitable things to worry about - their users couldn't explain what RAID is or DRM to save their lives.

So they don't invest in you - the customers who want these features (or lack) because it's not relevant to mass producing machines for everyone. This goes hand in hand with perpetuating the ubiquity or proprietary software.

dylangs1030··on Why Doesn't Anyone Give a Crap About Freedom Zero? (2008)
I love this post intellectually, but I believe it has a fairly simple answer - convenience and design. @patio11 also discussed these on his blog[1], which I'll get into:

Most people (users/customers) don't give a crap about freedom zero because most people aren't hackers. Most people want things to "just work." Most people don't want to tinker and screw around hunched in front of a lit screen for a few hours just to set up their drivers in a specific way.

On the other side, most employees don't care about perpetuating freedom zero or that philosophy because it's not as rewarding. I mean, yeah, it feels good to have open source projects and contribute to the community. But let's be honest, it doesn't pay the bills as well as working at, say, Microsoft does. Proprietary software attracts the more highly skilled engineers (usually - obviously some people are possessed of such personal conviction in software freedom that they will give up high salaries for their hacker community, but this is not the norm).

Here's a few examples to illustrate my point:

My mother is barely computer literate. If I presented her with Banshee instead of iTunes, she'd freak out. It would either gray out, become non-responsive, and subsequently close on her while syncing, or she wouldn't have all the features that a coordinated group of engineers in a multinational company built and designed for mass production.

As a programmer, I'm the same way. I want things to just work. Just because I know how to do things most other people don't using a computer doesn't automatically mean I'm invested in the free software movement. I dual-boot linux on my Mac, but I only use it for technical reasons. I don't honestly believe it's applicable or relevant to most people's uses of a computer. It doesn't "just work" a lot of the time - enough for it to be annoying. There's a "feel good" euphoria that occurs in an intellectually superior sort of way when you install linux, but it quickly drops off when it's a hassle just to get YouTube videos to play properly.

Secondly, and just as importantly - design. Do rhythmbox or banshee have as sexy a design as iTunes? Could they, with the resources they have? No, and no. Sure, they have accomplished something impressive, and in some respects, they have higher utility than iTunes. But overall, it's not an attractive interface. As Dave Wiskus would say, it isn't relevant and it doesn't match - a program needs to look like it belongs in the system it's designed under in order for it to be liked by a user many times. This doesn't just mean that software has to look like Windows or Mac, but that it has to understand the user and take out cumbersome decisions while preserving features in a way that is similarly intuitive to the system it resides in - that's very hard. It's also why UI and UX designers are as well paid as programmers.

We see this with apps all the time. When an app doesn't look like it matches the sleekness of iPhone's design i.e. it's clunky or looks "themed" with no custom overhead, it has a verifiable impact on the marketability of the app. The same applies to software. patio11's Bingo Card Creator competes with open source by being better because he has higher motivation. It's easier to obtain proprietary software (read: not cheaper, easier) because there's no hierarchy of betas and alphas and complicated names. There's a simple "download" or "install" button. The design has full teams of people behind it, knowing which hundred things to take out for which one thing to keep. Open source can't afford that.

This is why freedom zero isn't popular. I love free software, and I have a good advantage over "normal" (non-technical) users in utilizing it, but it's just not practical if you desire convenience and utility.

[1]: http://www.kalzumeus.com/2009/03/07/how-to-successfully-comp...

dylangs1030··on Hackers vs. suits: Why nerds become leakers
"A good hacker is wasted in public service."

Absolutely wrong. I take issue with this statement. A few points to the contrary:

1. Is it that you consider any non-profit pursuit beneath a competent hacker? What about open source projects and all the work that has been released under various public licences, literally as a "public service"?

2. Is it that you think for profit organizations are more influential and beneficial than non-profits? Tesla Motors and Nanosolar are still businesses at their heart; their markets happen to be environmental. A non-profit is literally devoted to public service first. As such, they have different priorities.

3. Is it that you think every competent hacker has every skill necessary to start Tesla or Nanosolar? Does every hacker that founds a startup succeed? Or is it still the case that most startups fail miserably? Do you think every hacker has this utopian skillset and can do whatever they want to impact the world?

Some hackers are incredibly efficient and merely competent. Some hackers are not so efficient but are incredibly skilled. Some are both. Not everyone can be Elon Musk, and Elon Musk wouldn't be well suited to working in a non-profit. But it's not fair to say that every hacker is above public service. That's elitist.

dylangs1030··on Instagram Django site admin
"Report a bug that could compromise the integrity of Facebook user data, circumvent the privacy protections of Facebook user data, or enable access to a system within the Facebook infrastructure"

^That's Facebook's. Theoretically, an exposed login page "could...enable access to a system within the Facebook infrastructure", but to be fair, I doubt they had that in mind.

dylangs1030··on Everything I Know about Self-Publishing
Thanks, that was a great answer! I just misunderstood your intent in the OP, good clarification.
dylangs1030··on Everything I Know about Self-Publishing
Can someone explain to me why the author is implying CreateSpace is disreputable?

Apparently ISBN's are not acceptable from there an bookstores will not order through them. Why would this be?

dylangs1030··on We Should All Have Something To Hide
I was under the impression that federal crimes of this sort are only actionable if you are aware of the legality before it comes into your possession.

That would correlate with your statement that it isn't actually illegal, is that why? There are some crimes where it seems as though the public domain has enough knowledge that you should know better without being explicitly told so. But for something like an under-sized lobster, I think you should get a pass on not knowing.

This also presents a problem of enforcibility - will a law be enforced, and under what conditions, if it's a "silly law"? I think this is what really makes it important to have things to hide - you could be tried for what they find if they are pursuing you for other reasons.

In other words, I sure hope Edward Snowden doesn't have an under-sized lobster.

dylangs1030··on iOS 7
This is not a fair response to the industry in my opinion.

iOS 7 is not just "flat" - at the risk of sounding like a fanboy, it's so much more than that. You're judging it based on the most obvious first impression - the icons and such.

Those can be improved, yes (especially Safari's...) but you're not reviewing the actual interface. I'm typing this comment on iOS 7 and I assure you it feels smoother. There are kinks to be worked out but the operating system's interface is more intuitive, which allows for more usable space and memory dedicated to features.

You sound kind of bitter about bloggers being fickle; getting past that, I think the design's interface actually looks very polished. It's "smarter" and only has a very small learning curve. Even apps like news:yc (what I'm using now) feel faster and "lighter" despite not yet being optimized for the iOS yet.

The whole thing feels like a more lightweight, versatile experience. I encourage you to download iOS 7's beta and try it out if you can.

dylangs1030··on iOS 7
I'm glad someone wrote a blog post like this.

It's getting to be somewhat annoying how many people are whining about Windows Phone and Android similarities. Design and engineering decisions are not made in a vacuum. Android copies from iOS and vice versa - they each follow the cultural trends of smart design.

I would much rather see blog posts like this - where the author considers the iOS in its own right instead of insisting on nitpicking what's original. Now I can actually see the innovation that went into designing the iOS 7 interface. And as someone typing this comment on iOS 7 beta, I've come to a deeper appreciation of what's already in my hands.

It's not helpful to accuse large design houses and engineering teams of copying each other. That's like saying supercars aren't original because they universally use sleek, aerodynamic ("sexy") design features. No, that's just what sells and what makes sense. It's a natural maturation and trend towards intelligent design. It's just iteration.

It's true that touch interfaces no longer need to be "taught" really. We intuitively know that gestures will do things in the same way (and more efficiently) than buttons. It's all about reducing cluttered design and adding more functionality without reducing usable space. I'm glad we're moving towards this.

dylangs1030··on The Smears Against Edward Snowden Have Begun
Yes, I know, we've all read Jeff Atwood's article on it.

That's not my point. I get what you're saying, but we have informed opinions. To the public, with no technical background, it is very reasonable to question someone's opinion in a domain they have no certifiable expertise or experience in.

EDIT: I can't reply @sillysaurus, "I'm submitting too fast", so here's my reply in the meantime.

I know...you're missing my point. It doesn't matter if a college degree or a high school degree gives you the experience I need. I can attest that you don't need one to have expertise in your domain.

What I am saying is that the public associates a college degree (and awards, other prestige, etc.) with credibility. To a great extent, this is true in most industries - this is why it's reasonable for non-technical people, people who don't know better, to apply this sort of safeguard to all "experts" they see. It doesn't diminish his actual standing, it's just a cursory glance that tells them if they need to find alternative routes to check his credibility.

I'm sorry if I'm not being clear, I'm not trying to say you're regurgitating anything, I was showing you that I'm well aware many CS grads can't code for shit. That's true. But it's not part of what I'm arguing. I'm talking about credibility and public perception, not actual ability or skillset.

dylangs1030··on The Smears Against Edward Snowden Have Begun
A few points:

1. I don't like that this is being said about Edward Snowden, but Occam's Razor implies it's not necessarily a conspiracy (yet). I'm sure it will be, at some point, but as a software engineer who made it without a college degree, I can personally attest that it's not unnatural for people to bring up and question a lack of education. People love to do this - before I was making any real progress in engineering, and even after I succeeded, people thought it was unusual and strange that I didn't pursue a degree. The only people exempt from this are people like Mark Zuckerberg, Bill Gates, David Karp, et al.

2. On citing use of the "fallacy" ad hominem - just stop. You're not doing it properly. Yes, the literal definition means bringing in personal qualities, but personal qualities and background can be relevant. Just as the appeal to authority is not a fallacy if you cite a legitimate expert with established research, it is OK and legitimate to question a high school dropout's ability to understand what he leaked. This should be self-evident - the person is being questioned because they don't have an obvious legitimatization of their expertise. That said, I don't agree with the fact being explored more than the leaked information itself. I'd also like to note that you don't sound any more convincing to people because you just say "ad hominem" - it makes people defensive, causes an audience to think you're pompous (sometimes) and conditions you to try and rebut an entire argument by citing a fallacy and ignoring the substance - which is a method that tends to fail utterly. For more on this, see [1].

3. Finally, it is sad they're talking about his neighbors and school life so much. They have nothing else to go on and they're grasping at straws. It sounds arrogant to say, but that's what most people do. They react to a big crisis and their fear of the unknown causes them to grasp ar any conversation points they can, legitimate or otherwise.

The community of people who recognize this (i.e. Hacker News for one) would benefit from being in a position to correct this mentality and steer the conversation towards the hard issues - the things that really matter. Dump all that shit about his high school diploma, let's start talking about the NSA.

[1]: http://plover.net/~bonds/bdksucks.html

dylangs1030··on Google Maps and Waze
I'm excited about this. I actually wouldn't mind if Waze was shut down instead of the 3-year period, as long as Google assimilated all of its technology.

It would be fantastic to have Google both data mining traffic data (as it does now) and also combining this with user-volunteered traffic reports. Each technology has something to offer the other, and it will be really cool to bring in the best of both worlds. I'm very confident about this acquisition, it feels like it wasn't just an acqui-hire.

← PreviousPage 14 of 28Next →