2,946 karma · joined October 29, 2011
Security researcher residing in New York.
It's tough learning how to code out of school, and we could use more business-oriented people who grok technical stuff.
Thanks for sharing, I had heard stories like this, but never knew it was that bad.
Sure, it's not all rainbows and unicorns. But let's not weaken our arguments with ludicrous hyperbole.
You only disagree with it because it's not well-enforced. Seeing other people get away with it sets a precedent for you to feel like it shouldn't be a rule. And the same would happen to Facebook if they paid him - eventually, the whitehat program's "technicalities" would become as pointless to enforce as a police officer ticketing someone for going "1 mph" over the speed limit. "Oh but it doesn't matter! It's just 1 mph!" If a speed limit designed to make a clear cut line doesn't work for you, how do you define rules? There's no objectivity to it at that point. It becomes a slippery slope.
Many people feel that small "technicalities" don't constitute real, ethical laws. This is wrong and an error in thinking. Every rule and every law is a restriction by technicality. Technically, you can go 65 mph, but not 66 mph. That's the line that delineates legality. It doesn't matter if you agree with it, it doesn't matter if you see other people do it, that's what it is.
But it is a rule, just like Facebook's Whitehat TOS. Agree with it or disagree with it, they don't care. You either follow all the rules, or you don't participate. That's the bottomline. They don't owe anyone money, they offer a bounty if you explicitly follow the rules and have proper discretion. It's really not complicated.
I meant that it's an argument in that an argument can be either true or false. But yes, you're right.
Correlation does not imply causation; 100 hours of work is something parents in their 30s and 40s frequently do. For a 20 year old, this alone would just be tiring. He died from something else.
Flagged for sensationalism and linkbait.
Then you'll know at what point we can call the United States and the United Kingdom fascist and police states.
EDIT: If you must downvote me, go ahead, but I'm not making a statement here. I'm joking. I think HN could use it these days.
Except misogyny is a legitimate criticism of a society, a lack of "traditional values" is not.
A lot of social issues, like legitimate discrimination of minority groups in America, are legitimate. On the other hand, there's a second class of social issues, the subjective ones. For example, the view that America is too "Puritan" in political forums. A theme like that is subjective - that would be a "traditional value."
I think 'rayiner's point can best be summed up as an answer to your last sentence. Yes, America, like India, isn't perfect. Both have unique "social issues" - but America is still, objectively, a better place to live.
Yeah, it can be argued that people in India might not glare at you the same way people in the NYC subway do, and that India has nicer scenery. These are irrelevant to a discussion of which place is actually better to live in.
You should be allowed to negotiate as a savvy prospective employee. With very few exceptions, you don't want to put yourself in an environment where terms are dictated to you rather than opened on a floor with you for your input. Even if you fail miserably at the negotiation, at least you had an opportunity.
Second to this - unless you're literally at-will employee, this is grounds for liability. The author was explicitly told, "You didn't do anything wrong, we're just getting rid of you because you don't fit." IANAL, so I won't harp on this as I don't know the particulars, but I'm fairly sure this is a case most lawyers wouldn't shy away from if everything is to be taken at face-value here (anyone with a law degree can correct me if I'm wrong).
In any case...I'm glad the author received validation of his abilities, even if it was nearly a year later. Maybe his former boss will grow a backbone and rehire him for something awesome. At least he didn't burn a bridge.
2. That said...if you were the security researcher, and you received a "This is not a bug." - you would still be fully wrong in selling the exploit to the highest bidder. It's not ethical to do that just because you failed to get a bounty after reporting it, especially if you only tried once.
I think both sides should have done things differently. Hacker News is skewed towards BigCo hatred as a whole, and I think it's showing a bit. The majority is siding with Khalil despite the fact that there are valid reasons for him to not receive a bug bounty.
There's nothing obfuscated about this. It's very straightforward. Yes, he found a security vulnerability. That doesn't earn you points "just cause." You still need to report it with responsible disclosure and not exploit it for the lulz and attention.
He could have done things differently - especially, he could have asked to talk to a Facebook employee who understands Arabic. Or tried to put more effort into a second security report.
Frankly, posting on Mark Zuckerberg's wall about this is childish and just attention-grabbing. It's not a responsible disclosure.
"Oh, if we don't understand your bug report, just post it on our founder/CEO's Facebook wall and it'll shoot right up to the top on our priority list."
I know everyone hates big companies but come on...the argument for Khalil to not be paid is very reasonable. I respect him for being able to find the bug but it's not a conspiracy. He could have sent back an email trying to be more clear, or ask for an Arabic-speaking employee.
Plus, Facebook is not a stingy company when it comes to paying security researchers. Just look at their Hall of Fame. It includes HN's 'homakov (Egor Homakov), who wrote an excellent blog post about finding a vulnerability in Facebook and his primary language isn't English. But he still found a way to report the vulnerability through responsible disclosure and he is very happy with the bounty he received.
Everyone thinks it's so cool and "sticking it to Facebook" and that Facebook is just some big bad company who doesn't care about the small folk. It's not like that at all, change your perspective.
It's not "disgusting"...you just need to be patient.
There was no bait and switch - it's very explicitly stated that he should not be exploiting the vulnerability, and that it needs to be clearly explained.
I respect that he found a vulnerability, but he still needs to adhere to a website's terms and conditions. If the security team he reports a bug to doesn't "get it" the first time he should try again, not publicize it on Hacker News and attract negative publicity by putting it on Mark Zuckerberg's wall.
I live in New York, and I frequently travel in NYC. I've spoken to a number of homeless people. How do you counter the often heard response that homeless shelters pose a risk to people entering them?
I have heard stories (I don't know if they're true, but I wasn't told on the pretense of giving money) that homeless shelters frequently house other members who will steal from their fellows or abuse them (sometimes sexually).
Like I said, I like your argument. But you worked with several homeless shelters, I want to know your take on this.
If you're travelling to Manhattan, I'd like to echo what another commenter said in that New Jersey is not your only or your best option. You can find affordable real estate (especially with your budget of $2k) within Westchester.
A lot of people travel from New Jersey to Manhattan within a a half hour - this is a pretty good commute. But you can still live within New York if you live in one of the lower towns of Westchester and travel using Metro North. It's a higher end train system than the subway, and it goes to Grand Central station from just about every conceivable town that would be a commutable option for you.
New York and New Jersey are fundamentally different. Yes, both can work for you, but one will fit your personality more than another. The outer boroughs and the lower towns of Westchester have a distinct "NY" feel that is still very urban and metropolitan (despite having a lot of suburbs) because it is so close to the city and within the same state. New Jersey isn't bad because it's not quite like this, but it is different - you should hang out around both if it's realistic for you so you can see for yourself which population suits you more. Coming from Hong Kong, you'll want to be as close to the city as possible, I think.
I highly, highly encourage you to not just limit yourself to New Jersey. Good luck :)