HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

dylangs1030

2,946 karma · joined October 29, 2011

dylan.sacco@yahoo.com

Security researcher residing in New York.

submissionscomments
dylangs1030··on Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
Alternatively, quit your whining that you entered a profession where you're not as marketable, and don't minimize the problems people have even if they appear trivial.

I don't think you know much about how recruiters operate...they're very annoying and antagonize the process for small businesses/boutique firms. There is a reason why hiring managers will say they don't want recruiters.

Often, they obfuscate the process so you can't skip them to contact the representative company directly, and they'll embellish your resume in ways that make it impossible for the company to contact you directly.

I am in the camp that considers them more a nuisance than anything for many purposes, and while I appreciate that it might seem nice to be hounded by them, I share the parent's scorn, as I've never had a positive experience with them. And even if I had, it wouldn't invalidate what I've said.

tl;dr - Peoples' problems are peoples' problems. Other peoples' problems don't make them go away.

dylangs1030··on Keep Your GitHub Email Address Private
This isn't a fair perspective. Recruiters are legitimately annoying. Especially as many recruiters obfuscate the hiring process so you can't just skip them directly to the company they're fielding. There's a long litany of abuses they take part in quite frequently, ranging from knowingly introducing you to companies you're not qualified for just because you're a "programmer" to deliberately making the hiring process for a company difficult without their direct participation.
dylangs1030··on Why I Changed My Mind On Weed
I appreciate that you came back with a legitimate citation, but the rest of your comment is uncalled for. What I googled were the points that defend my position, not the other way around - the burden for that is on the opposing defense, not my own.

What about my comments appears as though I just look for self-validating information and ignore the rest? The parts where I questioned scientific rigor, sampling size, case instances, etc?

dylangs1030··on Kids can't use computers, and why it should worry you
This is one of the most fantastically insightful and legitimately important posts I've seen on Hacker News in a while. It's refreshing.
dylangs1030··on Python for Android
S'alright :)
dylangs1030··on Why I Changed My Mind On Weed
[Citation needed.]

How many instances in a sampling size? How large was the sampling size? How rigorous was the study? Peer reviewed? Publisher?

Offhand, I can immediately tell you the overwhelming evidence is that tobacco (cigarettes) is far more harmful than cannabis. I direct your attention to the myth of cannabis being as harmful as x number of cigarettes[1] and the myth that cannabis harms brain cells[2]. While it does alter the brain, it is up for heavy debate whether it's harmful, especially on long-term use.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_misconceptions_about_il...

[2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_misconceptions_about_il...

dylangs1030··on Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job.
Hundreds of millions is a bit more tolerable than an entire planet. I'd like to also point out I agree with you - none of my statements here should be interpreted as support for the NSA's excesses. Rather, my incentive is to:

1) Prevent people on the forum from using it as a buzzword to make points devoid of strong, reasoned arguments,

2) Prevent people from believing the NSA should be burned to the ground and disbanded entirely, when it does serve a very useful purpose.

Historically, there have been far worse totalitarian measures. To give one that is relevant to privacy and this particular issue: consider that in the KGB, the secret police could raid your home at any time without a warrant, and when you picked up the phone an operator immediately told you what you said would be recorded. Oh, sure you knew about it. That makes it so much better, I suppose, even though it was far more reaching than what the NSA is currently doing.

I want it very well understood that while the excesses of the agency should be corrected, and Americans should be entitled to privacy, we can't allow ourselves to just attack things passionately because the NSA scandal tells us to. That, and we should maintain a historical perspective so we understand how bad things are and we don't freak out as if it's the worst thing ever, when far worse things have happened in previous generations.

A level of outrage is appropriate - losing sensibility in debates is not.

dylangs1030··on Python for Android
Reread my comment...I said I felt safer with Python over C.

I'm well aware that, e.g. a buffer overflow is something you'd want to worry about in writing C code. I guess I worded my comment strangely? I said I would "rather have that" than C, to which I was referring to a high level language like Python.

dylangs1030··on Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job.
Thank you for the citations. I agree with you on all points, my point was simply that Russia is not a superlative example either. Both the U.S. and Russia are locked in a murky political limbo with all sorts of controversies, but neither should be a shining example to the other.

Russia has (as other commenters and myself noted elsewhere) historically been against privacy and press freedom when it's inconvenient for them, and has a host of other human rights violations. But you're right, I'm definitely not attacking Russia from a superior position as an American here :)

dylangs1030··on Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job.
...Really? Please don't yell - it's not conductive to making your point.

I said "ridiculous" because it was a narrow, misinformed comment that failed to properly encapsulate the entire subject at hand. It wasn't representative of what's really going on in the political theater between Russia and the United States right now, e.g. no consideration of Russia's motives, positive impact of the NSA, how Russia would be hypocritical to endorse press freedom and citizen privacy, etc. etc. etc.

In fact, nothing about his comment was obvious - if you continue on through the thread, you can clearly see how my rebuttal dissects the entire view that Russia "gets" anything very sufficiently.

dylangs1030··on Python for Android
Well, I hope it's being done securely. I don't know much about the particulars of Android's iOS, but having a low-level language with access to the whole OS (which is what a real user would want for mobile programming, really) could be dangerous for native security.

On the other hand, if Google or Apple backed a high-level scripting language like Python, that could also lead to security concerns, but I would feel safer with that than something like C on my mobile device.

dylangs1030··on Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job.
Well...I agree personal experience can be a powerful motivator for changing opinions. But what I'm saying is what I have found through researching it.

As to my feelings for whether or not the NSA should be preserved vs. destroyed entirely - yes, I could see how personal experience could skew this. I, thankfully, haven't had such interference in my life.

But I also want to point out I'm not protecting the NSA's PRISM et al. programs. I think they're too strong, and too obscured. But I do believe the NSA can replace them with more functional, transparent tools that will achieve the same goals. I also believe people are being swayed by big headlines and pathos arguments that prevent them from examining the NSA critically instead of passionately - I don't think it's as bad as everyone makes it seem.

dylangs1030··on Python for Android
I don't use Android devices, so I wouldn't know, but is this the first instance of mobile Python on Android OS?

Jailbroken iPhones have had this capability for years...not to say iOS is better, just that I'd expected this would happen...sooner?

That said, the Python distro on iOS is only 2.6-ish, not even 2.7, and there's no 3.x release there. It's not very useful but I guess I did use it a lot for learning back then.

dylangs1030··on Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job.
This is one of the few times I've seen a genuine ad hominem on Hacker News...thank you for attacking my "moral compass" instead of the substance of my argument.

Now, to counter what you said - you're reaching by claiming the NSA "secretly stores and analyzes" the private communications of everyone on the planet. One interpretation of the materials originally leaked purports this, but there is also data contesting this view which is equally valid. Again - the echo chamber and bias allows you to just unilaterally suppose the NSA is capable of retrieving all data everywhere, but you're not examining counter evidence.

X-Keyscore allows email and web content surveillance, yes, but it isn't even practical to mine all data at once - it is much more practical (and probable) that this allows for finding and assembling an entry point to see where you should really begin looking in depth as an NSA analyst[1]. But, no, your traffic is not being viewed universally or entirely without someone at least believing there's a reason.

[1]: http://www.theguardian.com/world/interactive/2013/jul/31/nsa...

dylangs1030··on Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job.
You're ridiculous. This comment is a spectacular example of the faulty politicizing and black and white mentality being tossed about willy-nilly since the NSA scandal.

First of all - this is not indicative of Russia. This is just one Russian national giving him a job, and his stated reasons in the press may not be the real reasons why.

Second, Russia gave him asylum yes, but instead of echo chambering your preconceived beliefs about the NSA, why don't you apply the same critical skepticism to news coming out of Russia? Why don't you examine why Russia might want to grant asylum to an American refugee like Snowden instead of just saying, "Oh, they just get it man. They get it."

Third, there isn't anything concrete to get - the NSA isn't an evil, demonic institution sent here as a harbinger of the apocalypse. It's an institution whose abuses were wildly exaggerated and need to be corrected, not something to be burned to the ground. The country would not be better off without the agency in its entirety.

You're just applying this naive sense of cops and robbers to the entire dilemma and not critically examining all the evidence/stories. Your bias allows you to over-criticize one side and over-praise the other.

dylangs1030··on Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job.
How about instead of stumbling about intellectually like a mob intent on hating the NSA, we set a few things straight:

* This is not indicative of Russia as a collective endorsing or supporting Snowden. One man residing in Russia, a Russian national, offered Snowden a job relevant to his experience. This article says nothing about the public perception of Snowden in Russia. Anything else is supposition. All he has is asylum and a job. Both things can be granted by a huge minority of people in government, of which we do not yet understand their obscured motivations and agendas.

* I don't think we should be praising Russia for this - let's remember Russia is the place where homosexuality is almost scathingly rejected, human rights violations are normal, and freedom of the press is in effect...except when it's not. Yes, they gave Snowden asylum. I wonder what they could gain from that aside from just being a bunch of good guys...come on. This says nothing about the Russian people understanding America's problems, and they are certainly not an ideal to strive towards (nothing against Russians as a people, but a lot of their laws are deplorable by modern standards).

* I wouldn't trust the job, and I wouldn't take it. I wouldn't want any solid association with anyone, high-roller or not, who could be leveraged against me. This is paranoid, but whatever is uncertain about the NSA scandal, it's certain the government (or members thereof) is probably desperate to retrieve Snowden.

* Again, as I have said repeatedly since this all came out - don't let your outrage at the (vastly exaggerated) NSA scandal prevent you from seeing the truth - as a government agency, the NSA is largely beneficial to our country, and we shouldn't seek to disband it. Rather, we should correct its abuses and continue forward. I clearly see the black and white "us and them" mentality being tosses around with the NSA, Russia, Snowden and the U.S. government in the comment threads here and it's misinformed.

dylangs1030··on Show HN: LeapFM - A new way to find music
You're right - dictionary attacks aren't more vulnerable using a password hash. As a rule, a hash will obviously only add complexity. Salting the hash in addition to that will prevent a list of common words, and corresponding hashes ("dictionary attack") from working because of the nonsense salt value.

However, the real value of salting a hashed password is in defeating multiple password cracks. The salt is like a nonce added to a each individual password so that if you crack one, you can't formulaically crack them all. While en masse this is tedious, applied to a single password it's meaningless because the processing time for brute-forcing a salted hash and a non-salted hash will be trivial. It's mainly useful because you can't "recycle" computational power applied to one cracked password for another, assuming you have e.g. a database in front of you.

To give a quick explanation of why a salt won't protect a single password, consider it this way - salting passwords allows each hash to come out differently, such that if you try to crack a list of passwords using a single algorithm it won't work because the salt randomizes each one. Repeating the computational steps for cracking one password will be null and void for finding additional passwords if they're salted - you'll have to start over.

dylangs1030··on Federal judge: Bitcoin, “a currency,” can be regulated under American law
No, you missed the point entirely. It's indicative of the slippery slope you encounter when discussing politics on a tech news forum like this at critical mass.
dylangs1030··on Weilos (YC S13) Wants To Pair You With An Online Weight Loss Coach
So my questions/concerns:

1) (asked elsewhere) Do you guys have particular domain experience in nutrition and weight loss? I know one of you is an MD at Cornell, what about specifics?

2) How will you keep people on the site? Weight loss trends and diets are very fickle investments because people kind of jump from one to another inconsistently. You'll need to constantly get new users.

3) What's the revenue source? How are you monetizing this?

dylangs1030··on Weilos (YC S13) Wants To Pair You With An Online Weight Loss Coach
What's your domain knowledge/experience with nutrition and weight loss? I see you're an MD at Cornell, any specifics?
dylangs1030··on Weilos (YC S13) Wants To Pair You With An Online Weight Loss Coach
Strange, I thought it sounded like Wales...I wonder if they're implying there's a lot of fat people there.
dylangs1030··on OpenMailBox: An alternative to Gmail based on free software
There are several security concerns here.

First of all, I didn't see any mention of encryption. Is data encrypted at all, or are you able to read everything going on in the server? If encrypted, in what way? Why should I trust you with my data if it's not encrypted? How will I hold you accountable if I'm not paying you?

Second, HTTPS is a nice start, but it's just public/private key encrypted connection. It's still susceptible to a MITM using a proxy. Most users will click through a security certificate warning generated by their browsers for the sake of convenience. Bam, there goes the HTTPS protection. Especially since all that's stated is you hold the data in a directory. So, if it's in a directory unencrypted, what's stopping someone from path traversing into that directory and either stealing my data, doing things with my credentials or taking down your entire application by shifting through file directories to root acccess? Are there auth checkpoints so you can't climb up to root privileges?

Third, you state there is "powerful antivirus protection." How powerful? Tailor-made for the application or stock bought/outsourced? Do you have an in-house team experienced in crypto working on the development? Are they carefully writing source code with security in mind or checking for it afterwards?

Attempts like this are somewhat misguided in that they're misinformed by anti-government and anti-BigCo trends. Your data is safer with Google. They pour more resources into security than this project could reasonably hope to bring in revenue in a decade. I'm not saying this because I always believe open source is always, universally less secure than proprietary, but because it's Google's GMail we're talking about. A dedicated security engineering team larger than the entire team building this OSS project.

Security is very much a game of resources. You should assume you will be hacked, at some point, inevitably, and work from there. I trust Google more with my data because I know several facts:

1. Google will only cooperate with law enforcement if there is a reasonable need requested of them - contrary to popular belief, the government has more efficient ways of stealing and doesn't have "direct access" to Google's servers;

2. It encrypts data, which is something I'd hope to see at the very least (and which I didn't see here); and

3. Considering the government can probably catch you with or without Google, I'm more impressed with its engineering team than yours. No offense.

dylangs1030··on Steps To $5,000 In Monthly Recurring Revenue
I'm glad this worked, so congrats on that. However, I don't agree that this is good, actionable advice.

1. Find a problem.

2. Get to hacking.

3. Soft launch.

4. Synthesize feedback, build more.

5. Expand the funnel (user acquisition).

6. Aha/Win/Rich/Yay

...That's the formula for any startup/technology service. It's literally those steps, a little individual secret sauce, and you win or you die (figuratively speaking). I know it worked for you, but things like

>"In our minds, there is no better way to build a product that people want than to be the customer you plan to sell to."

...aren't very helpful. It's a broad characterization of how to put yourself in that mindset.

But in any case, good explanation of what you did for your own project :)

dylangs1030··on Slashdot founder Rob Malda on why there won’t be another Hacker News
You could theoretically use the Streaming API to analyze tweets en masse from different sources/individuals. Coding in a bit of text analysis (length, blacklisting/whitelisting keywords, sentiment, etc.) would discriminate between superfluous tweets and the ones you care about. That'd would be a great way to automate the process of scrolling through crap every morning, but you'd need to build a web app to house the results and scroll through that instead.

Of course, that's how I would do it as a third-party developer. Will Twitter ever support this? Doubt it. I don't think it's relevant to enough users to implement that kind of feature. Most people who use Twitter evidently enjoy reading what Justin Anniston and Jennifer Bieber eat for breakfast.

dylangs1030··on Slashdot founder Rob Malda on why there won’t be another Hacker News
Did you read what Malda said after that? He then explained why that isn't a suitable alternative for the exact reasons you just stated.

He basically explained you have to eat all the insignificant minutia of individual peoples' daily lives, no matter their public stature, if you want their opinions and views on the world at the same time.

dylangs1030··on Slashdot founder Rob Malda on why there won’t be another Hacker News
1. None of the HN knockoffs can really clone Hacker News because, for one thing, it's missing everything in the original HN's code. pg mentions that there's a missing "secret sauce" that ties it all together. That, and you really need to have some sort of heavy involvement in the community before you try to start it, so you'll need someone of pg-level importance to start it. Specializations could be started by very knowledgable HN users in their field but very general implementations would need an all around "ideologue." EDIT: I don't know if you're already aware of this, I'm just explaining because the way you wrote it appears as though you may think the Arc code is packaged with a full implementation of HN.

2. I don't think this would be allowed via the HN Search API...that's a lot of content.

3. This is a cool idea, but how would you get people to participate and add content to what is essentially a ghost, rather than just come back here, where there's news? I also don't think it solves the problem HN is currently facing. It merely puts a bandaid on it until we get back up to 2013 level volume.

dylangs1030··on Slashdot founder Rob Malda on why there won’t be another Hacker News
Slightly misleading, only a paragraph or two were really about Hacker News in particular. More about why there won't be another "x", of which Hacker News is one iteration.

I'm glad Malda spoke to the issue of volume. A lot of users on Hacker News (with varying levels of prominence, seniority and notability) have noted the issues arising with volume.

The NSA scandal was the most recent example of this. Political discourse on Hacker News is almost cancerous it's so bad. there is widespread misinformation and a quick glance at the "New" page shows that the guidelines are frequently not even regarded for submissions.

I think Malda is on point with his view of Hacker News being at critical mass right now.

dylangs1030··on Slashdot founder Rob Malda on why there won’t be another Hacker News
https://lobste.rs is what you're talking about. Invite-only, hardcore relevance in topic submissions.
dylangs1030··on Here's the Most Idiotic and Brilliant App Ever
Sure. Not that it helped any. Interestingly, it's more my "untechnical" friends - exclusively those, actually. The technical ones are somewhat invested in technology news and wouldn't do that because they understand a lot more of the process. On the other hand, those that are dishonest in this way, in my experience, know nothing about the tech of Apple except that it's, well, new and shiny.

As for myself, my iPhone 4 is half-broken and I'm still eeking out whatever life I can get from it before I get the iPhone 6 in the Fall.

dylangs1030··on Keep Your Identity Small (2009)
Counters to your counters:

>1) Does a homosexual couple with no knowledge of US marriage law not have a valid opinion on whether they should be allowed to marry?

No, that couple doesn't have a valid opinion. How could they? They don't understand that marriage is in the United States. That conceptualization of "togetherness" as a couple doesn't exist in their minds. The threshold at which they can form a valid opinion is, therefore, at the entry-level of understanding United States marriage laws.

>2)Did poorly educated blacks or women need training in the subtleties of constitutional law before they could have a valid opinion on universal suffrage?

Depends on what you mean by "training" - they need to understand what suffrage is, so in that sense, yes, they do need training. This is the threshold for having a valid opinion.

Here are concrete counter-examples to your counter-examples:

1) If a gay couple were asked if they wanted the right to be married without first being told the sociological context and culture of marriage in the United States, and without understanding the legal ramifications of being married, their opinion would be null and void - just noise. They don't know what they're agreeing/disagreeing with.

2) If you asked women if they'd like the ability to vote, and they said yes, but couldn't answer you when you asked them what a democratic republic is, or how representation works in the United States, their opinions would be meaningless. It would be equivalent to pathos-driven desire to be able to do something - ultimately, a useless opinion.

Understand - I'm not being pedantic. Your examples may show a somewhat low threshold for meaningful opinions, but the parent is correct in that you need some threshold for every opinion.

← PreviousPage 10 of 28Next →