HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

e63f67dd-065b

1,891 karma · joined September 14, 2019

submissionscomments
e63f67dd-065b··on FICO and the Credit Bureau Cartel
The article mentions that one in ten pulls actually convert into a mortgage, so actually each borrower is paying $1500.
e63f67dd-065b··on LockBit claims to exfiltrate 33TB of data from US Federal Reserve
SARs are reported to FinCEN, which is part of the Treasury, not Fed.
e63f67dd-065b··on Wireless power transfer system achieves 270-kilowatt charge
Claims of electromagnetic sensitivity have been debunked. They show symptoms to fake EM devices, and don’t show symptoms to real but hidden EM devices, so it’s all in their head. It’s the nocebo effect.
e63f67dd-065b··on Swift Static Linux SDK
I'm primarily a C++ developer these days, and if the C++ interop is actually good then I'm very excited for the future. For app-dev type stuff it really does seem like it's better than Rust, and I can definitely see a world where we start migrating some code into Swift.

Edit: back from watching the video, and a few observations:

- Swift does not suffer from Rust's refusal to add things into the standard library. gasp regex support in stdlib? Async/await runtimes?

- Default testing framework is a godsend, especially when integrated into the build system

- Rust but better for everything that's not low-level systems development is the impression I get

e63f67dd-065b··on Swift Static Linux SDK
Yeah, I'm really glad for the trend of statically linked binaries that came with Rust/Go. No more version incompatibilities, fights with downstream packagers, weird build configs, etc, just distribute the binary and that's it.
e63f67dd-065b··on Swift Static Linux SDK
The main reason is that Apple has effectively deprecated Objective-C for ios/macos development going forward. It's not going away for probably another decade+, but all documentation is now in Swift, new APIs are written with Swift in mind, etc.

Think of it this way: in 5-10 years, ObjC will be the python2 of Apple development.

e63f67dd-065b··on Swift Static Linux SDK
It's just classic dependency issues. I'm not familiar with swift specifics, but probably a combination of ABI instability and just plain version incompatibility from one distro to the next with your target program.

My opinion is the opposite: I think the old paradigm of distros managing a giant set of system libraries is a bad one, and is how we ended up in the land of docker. Go and Rust made the right decisions here: vendor all the dependencies, and distros can't mess with them. Makes it easier for upstream and the distro.

Modern languages are not like C/C++: a single non-trivial rust program can easily depend on 100+ crates, and re-creating crates.io in your package manager is just a bad idea, even putting aside that there's probably major version incompatibilities the moment you go beyond a handful of programs. Look at the disaster that's python package management, that's not where you want to end up.

e63f67dd-065b··on When Companies Ask for Your Social Security Number, Try Saying No
Biometrics don't have to be secret to be useful -- my home country has national ID cards with embedded fingerprint data, and certain transactions are required by law to have you physically present yourself and verify your identity with a fingerprint reader that checks it against your card's info.
e63f67dd-065b··on When Companies Ask for Your Social Security Number, Try Saying No
The problem is that SSNs weren't designed as a unique identifier for US identity, with no consideration given for protection, authentication, etc. The earliest SS cards came with 'NOT FOR IDENTIFICATION' on the front, was used for nothing except SS, and was in general designed as nothing more than a record-keeping number.

Then people figured out that since the government went through the trouble of assigning every* [1] american* [2] a unique* [3] number* [4], they might as well use that as their own ID too for inter-operability between different financial firms, and that's how we ended up in this shitty situation.

Every time somebody proposes 'hey we should come up with a better national ID number' you get people yelling about mumble mumble big government mumble mumble privacy mumble mumble feds tracking you around, and the proposal dies in committee.

[1] originally only issued to those who worked, and was not exempted from the SS system, notably children. Of course these days children have SS numbers because they're a de-facto ID number, and it's required to claim dependents, and with varying degrees of resistance from weird groups like the Amish. Additionally, non-eligible people are issued tax IDs instead, which have the same format as SSNs because it was easier that way

[2] big(?) political fights over who exactly must get numbers, of course, from religious groups, illegal immigrants, and many more

[3] except of course it's not unique, there were errors where people got duplicate numbers, and people can get reassigned numbers, thereby having more than one

[4] did you know they used to assign SSNs sequentially? The guy who was next in line got your number + 1

e63f67dd-065b··on Ask HN: Is Stripe the new PayPal, cancelling user accounts without explanation?
It’s not your bank, it’s payment networks and stripe’s partner banks. Visa and MC are notorious for being the de-facto arbiter of allowed businesses, they have extensive yet vague guidelines on what is allowed due to porn stuff a long time ago and their partners try their best to read the tea leaves to see if what they do is fine.
e63f67dd-065b··on Guys what is wrong with ACATS
I never knew about the 3-day limit before, it makes sense that this is the reason behind unverified ACATS transfers (a problem that I've spent no small amount of time arguing about on various online forums long ago).

Interestingly, Fidelity lets you put your account into "lockdown" mode there they'll reject all ACATS (and ACH too I believe) transfers automatically without your intervention. I've always wondered what kind of legal magic they're pulling to make this compliant with FINRA rules.

What eventually convinced me over that it's not a problem is, as Patrick says, that these institutions will with high likelihood make you whole for fraudulent transfers, the same way they will for fraudulent ACH. The financial system generally works.

e63f67dd-065b··on Scaling Monosemanticity: Extracting Interpretable Features from Claude 3 Sonnet
I find Anthorpic's work on mech interp fascinating in general. Their initial towards monosemanticity paper was highly surprising, and so is this with the ability to scale to a real production-scale LLM.

My observation is, and this may be more philosophical than technical: this process of "decomposing" middle-layer activations with a sparse autoencoder -- is it capturing accurately underlying features in the latent space of the network, or are we drawing order from chaos, imposing monosemanticity where there aren't any? Or to put it another way, were the features always there, learnt by training, or are we doing post-hoc rationalisations -- where the features exist because that's how we defined the autoencoders' dictionaries, and we learn only what we wanted to learn? Are the alien minds of LLMs truly also operating on a similar semantic space as ours, or are we reading tea leaves and seeing what we want to see?

Maybe this distinction doesn't even make sense to begin with; concepts are made by man, if clamping one of these features modifies outputs in a way that is understandable to humans, it doesn't matter if it's capturing some kind of underlying cluster in the latent space of the model. But I do think it's an interesting idea to ponder.

e63f67dd-065b··on LineageOS is the perfect minimal smartphone for non-tech savvy folk
The context is that it's somebody else setting up what's basically a dumb phone for family members. I agree that custom roms are a terrible idea for non-tech savvy folks if they have to set it up themselves, but in this specific narrow case it's a good solution.
e63f67dd-065b··on LineageOS is the perfect minimal smartphone for non-tech savvy folk
I was expecting to trash the idea of custom roms for the laymen, but this is actually a really smart idea. In this case, "minimal" means "as close as possible to a dumb phone", which means uninstalling everything that's not the phone app. I'm not sure how much longer society will tolerate somebody with a phone that can only call, but for those who truly only need to be able to call and text I think it's a brilliant solution.
e63f67dd-065b··on Not an iPad Pro Review: Why iPadOS Still Doesn't Get the Basics Right
Apple is caught between a rock and a hard place here. On one hand, probably the vast majority of ipad users don't know multitasking exists, have never even opened the Files app, don't care about the lack of system utilities, and use the iPad as a simple big phone. On the other hand, they've been trying to sell these "pro" devices with impressive hardware to target a small market of consumers with "professional" workflows, who do care about all of these things.

My view is that, fundamentally, a lot of "professional" workflows is just as much about shuffling data around as it is working on said data. Just as data science taught us that data cleaning is 80% of the job, the same applies to video editing, programming, etc. iPadOS is uniquely bad at moving data around due to its onerous requirements around sandboxing and its poor interfaces around inter-app communication, when these are precisely the things that are most needed.

And then there's the multitasking, which remains terrible to this day. Can they improve it? Definitely, but I wouldn't want to be the guy trying to figure out how to do it without ruining the normal user experience.

e63f67dd-065b··on Not an iPad Pro Review: Why iPadOS Still Doesn't Get the Basics Right
My guess is that in addition to Apple just not caring, they have market research telling them that most users don't want this feature. I imagine that the average HN commenter is probably as far as possible from the average iPad buyer. The main usecase is for families, and it's introducing a lot of complexity for basically no return.
e63f67dd-065b··on I'm tired of makefiles
> I also feel like good makefiles are usually very small and dont need much tweaking once they are in place.

This only works for small projects. Once your project grows beyond a handful of files and dependencies this breaks down real fast.

I've been on this train more than once: most non-trivial projects reach a point where you have to build for multiple targets, support multiple configurations, test in all those weird configurations, manage CI, manage external dependencies, build said dependencies, etc. A makefile that supports all of the above becomes a monstrosity long before you get there and at some point you give up and pull in a real build system to take care of it (they're all bad in their own way, pick your poison really with cmake/meson/bazel/<new shiny thing>, just less bad than make).

Sure you can manage a giant pile of target-specific variables, platform-dependent scripts, and what not in make, but really it's much less painful to just bite the bullet and migrate to a build system that thought of these problems before. Things like "this dependency is mandatory is this configuration, optional in these other configurations, and is liked differently depending on whether we're building static or shared objects and whether we're using the platform library or falling back to a vendored version" is basically impossible in my experience.

Makefiles are great when your project is a dozen `.c` files. The moment you grow beyond that it's time to move on and use something else.

e63f67dd-065b··on Exploring GNU extensions in the Linux kernel
As sibling mentioned, you can build the kernel with clang today. `make CC=clang`, and for whatever reason I've found that it produces code that's significantly more pleasant to step through under a debugger than gcc.

If anybody has an explanation for this I'd love to hear it.

e63f67dd-065b··on GameStop shares soar 110% and are halted as trader 'Roaring Kitty' resurfaces
What did they lie about under oath? From what I recall the whole saga was pretty much reddit gamblers blowing through a bunch of liquidity of the major brokers, and triggering a bunch of big margin calls. There were no naked shorts or whatever other conspiracy theory reddit was spinning up, this is the kind of thing the SEC actually gets very angry about regardless of who's on the other side of the trade.
e63f67dd-065b··on Show HN: A web debugger an ex-Cloudflare team has been working on for 4 years
I would love it if you could bundle this into electron, there’s so many random electron apps for which the bug reporting workflow is still stuck in the 90s as you say.
e63f67dd-065b··on A History of C Compilers – Part 1: Performance, Portability and Freedom
It was written by Tanenbaum, who worked at VU Amsterdam, which translates roughly in english to the Free University of Amsterdam. VU remains to this day a fairly significant institution in the field of CS academia.
e63f67dd-065b··on You can't just assume UTF-8
> China does not use UTF-8 and is not, as far as I know, in the process of switching.

That’s … not true? Most Chinese software and websites are utf8 by default, and it’s been that way for a while. GBK and her sisters might linger around in legacy formats, but UTF-8 has certainly reached the point of mass adoption from what I can tell.

e63f67dd-065b··on I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
I've seen a few variants of this question, but not answered in a helpful way:

What is, in your experience, the minimum that gets you a decent shot at a NIW/O1? You previously mentioned that published papers are helpful but not mandatory, but for PhD students/graduates, if publications are not the determining factor, what is?

Looking through the Dhanasar's three prongs, it does seem like papers are the easiest and most consistent way of fulfilling the second prong (that "The Person is Well Positioned to Advance the Proposed Endeavor").

The third prong is the most mysterious to me (that "On balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the job offer and thus the permanent labor certification requirements"), how do people typically meet the requirements for this prong?

e63f67dd-065b··on New 13- and 15‑inch MacBook Air with M3 chip
Tech is known for being international, and even in the US is staffed with a lot of foreign-born labour. I don't find it surprising that a community with a high amount of non-native speakers sometimes misinterprets metaphors.
e63f67dd-065b··on Financial systems take a holiday
Never thought about the fact that holidays are both when there are surges of consumer spending but also when money doesn't settle.

Also quite funny that black friday was translated as a sale on black things in at least one instance. When I grew up a decades ago in east/SE Asia, black friday was not really a thing, but I guess times change.

e63f67dd-065b··on $5 device tests for breast cancer in under 5 seconds: study
It's been a while since I took statistics, but isn't the whole point of <thing> testing that it needs to have a high Bayes factor, and to be confident that said Bayes factor is high?

In this case, and my lack of understanding in both bio and stats is showing here, we're trying to develop a test for breast cancer. An ideal test will have high sensitivity and specificity, and a tight confidence interval for both of those numbers. This way we can be confident that a positive/negative test actually moves our priors meaningfully in either direction.

I guess my question/comment is more on the fact that I don't see how any of the results shown actually translate, as the headline suggests, into a cancer test of high power. The priors for any kind of cancer is pretty low from what I can find, so we need high power tests in both the positive and negative direction to meaningfully effect health outcomes. I can't find any CI numbers in the paper, which may just be me not reading it closely enough, but it doesn't help my confidence.

e63f67dd-065b··on $5 device tests for breast cancer in under 5 seconds: study
Press release: https://publishing.aip.org/publications/latest-content/would...

Actual publication: https://pubs.aip.org/avs/jvb/article/42/2/023202/3262988/Hig...

Experiment size is literally N=21, with 4 healthy participants, 3 in-situ breast cancers, and 14 invasive breast cancers.

N=21 might as well be useless in my opinion. You can't draw any meaningful conclusions about statistical power of this test; if your priors were 10% for breast cancer, after taking this test, your posterior probably remains unchanged.

e63f67dd-065b··on Developers revolt over Apple's new app store rules
I would agree with you if the app could redirect you to a website to subscribe, but that's explicitly against the rules and not currently possible. This wouldn't be an issue at all if a redirect is allowed, or even a sentence saying "please subscribe on our website". Both are currently banned and this banned is strictly enforced.
e63f67dd-065b··on The Mana World Classic – Open-Source MMORPG
I was gonna ask about hosting costs, then I saw "14 players online". I wonder what's the ratio of developer/contributor:player.
e63f67dd-065b··on SCSI isn't dead yet – new SSD for old or obsolete systems
There's a server room right down the hallway with racks of SCSI and SAS drives, some even running 2007 Opterons. I have no clue who's using them, but there's a ton of spares in the room leading into it, so there's definitely demand for these things.

As with all technologies though, the cost first starts out high as it's introduced, is reduced as it becomes popular, and climbs back up as it's obsoleted and nobody makes them anymore but some people are stuck using them.

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →