HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7

398 karma · joined October 16, 2019

submissionscomments
eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
> It has the highest dapp compatibility

Mmh thanks, well security is more relevant to me, but I nevertheless went to their website.

Apparently it's a browser plugin. That's a big security no-no from my side, too much attack surface - sorry.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
> It’s odd to accuse the Ethereum Foundation of not delivering and it would be hard to back that claim.

It's actually quite easy: I opened the websites of all the 24 wallets they list and checked the imprint of each. None says it was developed by the foundation.

> Developing yet another Ethereum wallet when there are so many on the market would be a waste.

> It’s better for the foundation to provide a list of high quality wallets that already exist.

What would you think of me if I raised $18M to build a non-profit children's hospital and then used it to instead build a website which lists children's hospitals which were built by other people, most of which being for-profit companies, some even proclaiming themselves as registered in shady tax-haven countries, and most not even clearly showing where their company is registered?

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
Ethereum has 11 000 nodes currently: https://www.ethernodes.org/

There are probably many botnets of IoT devices with 10x that many nodes, aren't there?

So a single botnet could probably ensure that a target victim has the majority of peer connections to the attacker.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
Thanks, what distinguishes it from the other 23?
eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
> I feel it makes little sense for the Ethereum Foundation to pour their own (human) resources into this.

Well, they received $ 18.3 million in crowdfunding [1], so I would dare to say it's not only "their" resources but also the resources of the community which they're spending, isn't it?

Given that the central thing a user needs to use a cryptocurrency is the wallet it would seem a bit weird to collect $ 18M from their users to develop a cryptocurrency and then not develop the software which the users need to use the currency?

I mean they're a non-profit organization, if they don't hand anything out for the $ 18.3 M then they have profited quite a bit by taking in money but not delivering effectively usable goods from it?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-funded_crowdfu...

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
Hey, I tried figuring out what the most recent official Ethereum wallet is, but the wallets which the website lists all seem like third-party ones.

The previous official wallet's repository says "Mist and Ethereum Wallet have been deprecated.".

Is it true that the Ethereum foundation isn't providing a wallet software anymore?

Why is that?

I would consider it as quite unsolvable as a user to determine which of the 24 third-party wallets is the most trustworthy, hence I'd prefer to just use one developed by the same people as Ethereum.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
Google "nothing at stake problem".
eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
> Security deposits of attackers in ethereum are slashed, up to 100%, in case of an attack.

What defends against the attacker configuring his nodes to just not relay the blocks which slash his deposits, by having a majority in the network connectivity, and thereby convincing victim nodes that he in fact is the victim of false slashing because the victims will only discover the slash-claims much after the attackers "valid" blocks?

Or in other words:

Isn't the slashing mechanism also reliant upon mere hope that the network topology randomly happens to be in favor of non-malicious peers?

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
> PoS offers much, much stronger security than PoW

Uh, why do you say that?

The security of PoS in fact ought to be much LOWER than the security of PoW:

The goal of requiring proof of work is that you cannot just send multiple versions of the same transaction into different areas of the network to double-spend your money - because you need to commit work for producing a block, and due to consuming energy you can't fake that.

Well, you can compute two (or more) blocks in parallel, but then you'll spend half of your available CPU (or ASIC nowadays) cycles on each block, thus cutting your speed in half. So the non-malicious competitors on the network will produce more blocks meanwhile because they're not splitting their computation power, and thus your fake blocks will get invalidated because they're on the shorter chain.

With PoS on the other hand you can create as many fake blocks as you want and spam them to the network. The only security is the hope that the random network topology arbitrarily results in the double-spending blocks arriving at the targets under attack after the other blocks arrive.

But if you run thousands of nodes on the cloud and thus have better network connectivity than the victims you can make your double-spend blocks arrive first at the victims.

So:

- PoW: Relies on physical limits, you need to have physical hardware and physical energy to conduct an attack.

- PoS: Relies on the network connectivity of the attacker being hopefully worse than the connectivity of the non-malicious network. Who can guarantee that? Nobody.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ethereum 2.0 launches
> Eventually Proof of Work WILL kill Bitcoin [..]

> Right now, most of the mining is financed via inflation. But as this comes to an end, eventually, the cost of mining will be borne by anyone making transactions on the network through tx fees.

> Somebody has to pay the electricity bill on all these ASICs.

This is just wrong.

If the award available to miners decreases due to lack of inflation they will use less power-consuming hardware.

If that still results in loss due to electricity cost then miners will leave the market until the amount of miners in the market is equal to the amount of tx-fees available.

In other words: This is a market with supply and demand. If one decreases the other also goes down until they're balanced. It won't just make the market disappear!

So even if almost nobody was willing to pay any tx-fees and there was no inflation then Bitcoin would still be running. It may just move back to running in the background on consumer hardware which was bought for other purposes instead of having giant mining data centers.

This also means that mining isn't going to infinitely waste energy:

The demand for energy cannot go higher than the offer of tx fees / block reward.

So there is a finite upper boundary to Bitcoin's power consumption. I think a finite upper boundary is enough to justify its existence, the precise value of such a constant is arbitrary so you might as well not waste your time in arguing if it is too high or too low and instead be happy that there IS a boundary :)

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Libgen Storage Decentralization on IPFS
There is a Freenet "KeepAlive" plugin which can be used to selectively pin files which you want to preserve, even if they are completely unpopular.
eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Libgen Storage Decentralization on IPFS
> I've not tried Freenet for a few years, but every time I did it was very slow

It has become a lot faster recently, try again :) When I look at its statistics during active usage it can easily show 1 MiB/s traffic.

You still can't expect HTML to load in sub-second delays, for large multi-MiB sites it may take a low single-digit amount of seconds, but there is an inherent cost to anonymity which probably induces a boundary on how fast things can be:

To achieve anonymity, data needs to be redirected across multiple people so the sender and recipient can't determine who each other of them is.

Redirecting stuff across a longer path than necessary slows things down.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'national unity'
> There's this thing called "cash". There are (and have been for at least a century) ways to transfer it from place to place, even electronically, in a mostly anonymous way - as mobile minutes, through western union, etc. The farther it has to go, the easier it is to track, but locally, it takes non-trivial effort to track transfer to the point that governments mostly do it when they actually have a reason rather than "just because".

You are right that this COULD be designed in an anonymous way, e.g. with cryptocurrencies, sure :)

It is however naive to believe that governments will actually do that if citizens allow them to require payment for social media access.

It will very certainly wind up being trackable.

> Well then, you're doing it wrong. You are violating FB's "real name" terms of service. And also, rest assured that almost everyone of the people you've talked to on Facebook has de-anonymized you, by having your real name in their address book somewhere which they uploaded to FB/WhatsApp/Instagram knowingly or unknowingly.

That only applies if I tell my real name to any of those people, which I don't.

> If you care about your privacy, get off facebook.

It is impossible to get off of FB without being denied access to things which are a central part of social life, e.g. events.

> > To not become a fascist country, you cannot regulate social media access. > To not become a fascist country, you have to regulate social media.

I'm sorry, my wording was imprecise!

Let me correct it please: To not become a fascist country, you have to regulate social media, but you MUST NOT deny access to it.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'national unity'
> 1) why are you defending Facebook?

Because once such laws are enacted they surely will NOT only apply to FB but to all other social networks as well.

Classic "pandora's box".

> 2) Facebook demands and aggressively enforces that your profile represents you and has your real name and other credentials associated with your identity. If your pseudonym gets reported it will definitely get banned.

How does FB doing a bad thing currently justify demanding the government to even one-up them and make it legally mandatory to do that bad thing?

- I was aware of them doing this, and if that were the subject of the discussion I would have in fact demanded that they're legally forced to stop doing it.

> Yes that's true for literally every transaction on the internet when done with a credit card. Not sure why that's a problem.

Did you have to use your credit card to write this post?

To post on any other forum for the past few decades?

Would you be happy to give me your credit card data in real life before I start listening to anything you say there?

> Facebook is a company selling a product. You do not and definitely should not have any "rights" on their private platform. Just like you do not and should not have the right to force a local business to trade with you if they do not want to.

FB has taken possession of a now essentially public space of which the participation therein is a central component of having a social life. Try finding a party or any other kind of event to attend without FB access.

If you take possession of a part of the commons along with that possession comes the duty to provide proper access to the citizens which are reliant upon it.

E.g. if you own a piece of land below which there is an aquifer, the government will force you to provide access to the water so the public can drink.

There is no reason why this should be any different in cyberspace.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Solomon Islands set to ban Facebook in the name of 'national unity'
> Outright bans are clumsy, but imposing a cost or bar to entry, like most societies do with alcohol and drugs, might be constructive.

With requiring payment comes the ability to trace where the money came from.

So you're essentially demanding:

- that every social media account is easily connectable to the real citizen ID behind it.

- that governments should assist social networks in their already rampant tracking of users by even enforcing it through legislature.

- by that also that governments build infrastructure which can be used to track the political opinion of every citizen, because that's what they can do if every user account is linked to a real person.

I can understand that the goals behind what you say are noble, but please take notice of this:

When I use FB or whatever, I want to be completely anonymous.

I neither want FB, nor random strangers there, nor the government to track what the real person behind my pseudonym posts on FB.

And that should be the right of everyone. Mundane things such as posting your opinion on the internet should not have huge barriers of entry and possibly individual consequences attached to them.

To not become a fascist country, you cannot regulate social media access.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Ik.me: a free email address for life developed and hosted in Switzerland
> privacy !== anonymity

Why not?

With the same reasoning you could deny selling people food unless they show you their government ID.

Would you consider such an abomination a country where privacy still exists?

If you strip people from basic anonymity for no sane reason they have no privacy.

If all you want is to prevent people from signing up infinite accounts then have them solve a bazillion captchas or pay a token amount of cryptocurrency, but don't ask them to connect their account to completely unrelated private information.

Email operates independently of cell phone numbers, so it shouldn't be required to connect yours to your mail address.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1
No, they do not need ordering of time, they need the precise ordering their developers chose for them to make sense:

Code is a well-chosen piece of logic to make sense as a whole. You can't just arbitrarily take to pieces of code and mash them together just because two random developers on the planet happened to write them one after the other in a sequential fashion of time.

E.g if you ask a classroom "What's 1 + 1 ?" then someone might say "3" right after you asked but before someone else says "2", but that does not make "3" right.

Proper order of commits is established by a MUCH more simple mechanism in fact: A git commit includes the hash of the previous commit in the history.

So the plain aspect of "storing some bytes" is needed, not a blockchain :) As someone else said, Git provides just that.

FWIW, censorship-resistant networks such as the aforementioned Freenet can and are used to publish Git repositories in a robust fashion. But no blockchain magic is required here either :)

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1
> I'm unaware of a foolproof way to share future versions aka future sources that can be programmed into deterministic code.

This is entirely possible :)

You would use an "USK" ("updatable subspace key") address of Freenet to achieve that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freenet

Also see my other comment to the parent for an explanation of why Freenet would be preferable to blockchains here.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on New youtube-dl release: v2020.11.01.1
> or a link thereof, is stored on the blockchain so it can't be deleted.

A blockchain is overkill for this:

Its central goal of providing a clear ordering of events by the time at which they happened (t1 < t2 < t3) is not necessary to distribute software updates.

You merely want to be able to sort things by a number, the version of the software, which their author has provided on their own.

Remember, the blockchain was invented so Bitcoin could prevent double-spending of the same coins. I.e. if someone attempts to send the same money to multiple different addresses and thus fool multiple people into believing they were paid it can use the blockchain to determine which attempt was the first and ignore all others.

Such attacks would happen within milliseconds typically, hence the need for a strong mechanism against them.

This is not needed for merely distributing downloads:

You already trust the author enough that you would run their code, so you can as well trust them that the number which they say is the latest version in fact is the latest one. That's also because they have no incentive to fool you into using an older one, there's no money involved.

What you'd want instead is Freenet, the goal of which is preventing censorship and providing anonymity: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freenet

It's "updatable subspace key" (USK) address type is suitable here.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Everything I Know About SSDs
> The way TRIM works, you don't need to trim blocks right before overwriting them.

In my experience "blkdiscard /dev/DESTINATION_DISK" does improve the speed of dd'ing a disk to another one quite a bit though.

And that does make some sense IMHO: If the SSD's internal datastructure which keeps track of pages which hold user-data is empty then each write will consume less time for looking up if the specific sector is contained in the datastructure.

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on No Maintenance Intended
The code for it is on GitHub, can someone please file an issue there to provide an additional green version? (Or fix it right away?)

https://github.com/potch/unmaintained.tech/issues

Thank you!

eMGm4D0zgUAVXc7··on Open-source apps removed from Google Play Store due to donation links
I have done open source development for well over a decade, thousands of hours, tens of thousands of lines of code, and I can tell you:

Considering the amount of donations I got, it would have been much more profitable to clean toilets, to just go begging in the streets, collect bottles from public trash cans for the deposit, or just sell my body.

In fact let's have a look how much I got during the past 12 months for 250 hours of work:

$0.

Had I been working as someone who climbs onto roofs and cleans the dirt off of them I would have gotten this much for that in this country:

$16500

And then, as a cherry on top, you now demand that a giant monopoly, which is trying very hard to soak up as much of people's data as possible - without paying them for it! - should get a cut from donations for my work which I genereally give away for free.

Now I can understand that you did not know this when you wrote down your opinion!

But given that you do now, do you understand how insulting this feels? :) It actually itched me so much that I created this account solely for the purpose of telling you, and I would be very happy if you could change your mind :)

← PreviousPage 7 of 7