HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ealexhudson

2,978 karma · joined August 11, 2011

London-based hacker of PHP, C, C#, Vala, Javascript and Perl, amongst other languages. Linux-based and proud.
submissionscomments
ealexhudson··on Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO
Actually, you're rephrasing the question - it was specifically about "control", not "alignment".

Even if we substitute "alignment" the problem is that the suggestion is still that Sam would have been "better protected" in some way. A 501(c)3 is just not supposed to function like that, and good corporate governance absolutely demands that the board be independent of the CEO and be aligned to the company goals not the CEO's goals.

ealexhudson··on Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO
No board is ever controlled by a CEO by virtue of the title/office. Boards are controlled by directors, who are typically nominated by shareholders. They may control the CEO, although again, in many startups the founder becomes the CEO and retains some significant stake (possibly controlling) in the overall shareholding.

The top org was a 501(c)3 and the directors were all effectively independent. The CEO of such an organisation would never have any control over the board, by design.

We've gotten very used to founders having controlling shareholdings and company boards basically being advisory rather than having a genuine fiduciary responsibility. Companies even go public with Potempkin boards. But this was never "normal" and does not represent good governance. Boards should represent the shareholders, who should be a broader group (especially post-IPO) than the founders.

ealexhudson··on A Timeline of the OpenAI Board
I think there are a bunch of problems in the timeline, not least the ongoing mismatch between statements and filings, and the lack of anything in 2022.

It does look like governance very much played second fiddle, and the unsurprising outcome of that was that governance hasn't worked very well. I don't know who can rightfully take the blame for that, though, other than the Chair and maybe CEO. If the board wasn't fit, it was their job to fix it.

ealexhudson··on Python 3.12.0 from a supply chain security perspective
I have to say it makes sense to me that the binaries would be built from the source tarballs rather than git, seems a bit odd that you'd have separate pipelines and binaries that are produced from a (slightly) different source.
ealexhudson··on What if OpenDocument used SQLite? (2014)
I think if you have a set that you want the latest value from, in all engines you can do something explicit like:

> SELECT manifest, versionId, checkinTime FROM version ORDER BY checkinTime DESC LIMIT 1

The problem with putting aggregation functions in the select output is that you're being unclear about what is aggregating; that pattern begins to break down once you have e.g. multiple documents in the same schema. Or if versionId somehow wasn't linear (e.g. branches of changes).

ealexhudson··on What if OpenDocument used SQLite? (2014)
ODT was designed to be standardised: while the predecessor format was very similar too, it relies very heavily on XHTML, SVG, and CSS, to name but three (there's a lot more).

Without being able to call out to existing standards, the ODT spec itself would suddenly become massive. The effort to update the standards appears to be significant and hasn't progressed much in recent years already :/

I think realistically, an Sqlite format could be offered as an option, but the office doc ship has really sailed.

Good argument to formalise the spec of Sqlite as a standard though...

ealexhudson··on Non-human“ alien corpses displayed at Mexico's Congress, believed to be 1k year
Or DNA, for that matter, why would they come close to having DNA let alone sharing any %age with terrestrial species?
ealexhudson··on Painting wind turbine blades black help birds avoid deadly collisions (2020)
Persistence of vision. But I don't think these turbines go anywhere near close enough for that to be in danger of happening ;)
ealexhudson··on When did Alan Partridge first appear on television?
BBC probably wouldn't broadcast Blue Jam today, but only because it would get such limited audience. It's niche and of its time.

Similar shows today would include the Skewer, and to be honest I would rank that as more legally dangerous to run, it skirts libel laws much more closely.

ealexhudson··on Deepmind Alphadev: Faster sorting algorithms discovered using deep RL
That sounds obviously transformative and on any non-trivial scale I can't see why copyright would be avoided.
ealexhudson··on The Wembley Point Mystery
The jewelry looked hand-made to me; it's chunky for what it is and quite rustic. Suggests the person is in/around some kind of craft art scene in general, but not necessarily an artist or professionally involved.

Vaguely amazing to me that in 2004 it would be possible to have a building that tall with windows that open fully in a public area that someone could jump out of. That strikes me as unusual, it's amazing they weren't able to figure out her connection to the building back then.

ealexhudson··on Ask HN: What is the license of GitHub's blog and The README project?
Legal advice is an exception. In many jurisdictions, it's a regulated field (like health) and providing legal advice without holding the requisite license is illegal.

Offering your own opinion on the law is fine, but IMHO answering someone else's question with opinion on the law is probably the wrong side of the line.

Disclaimers don't help, either, the regulation exists whether you acknowledge being outwith the licensing or not.

ealexhudson··on Google “We have no moat, and neither does OpenAI”
Well, except that there's no evidence that OpenAI are using the name in a trademark sense, let alone registered it?

Can't really genericise that which was never made specific...

ealexhudson··on Google “We have no moat, and neither does OpenAI”
Consumers recognizing ChatGPT might just end up like vacuum cleaners; at least in the UK, people will often just call it a "hoover" but the likelihood of it being a Hoover is low.

It is difficult to see where the moat might exist if it's not data and the majority of the workings are published / discoverable. I don't think the document identifies a readily working strategy to defend against the threats it recognises.

ealexhudson··on Facebook is going after LLaMA repos with DMCA's
You only lose rights with respect to trademarks. Copyrights do not need to be consistently enforced in order to be enforceable (although if you're not consistent you'll likely have a tough time arguing significant damages)
ealexhudson··on The Varieties of Bad Stoicism
This is kind of addressed in the article. The specific difference between using stoic techniques/mindsets to do something, versus actually adhering to stoic philosophy.

I think the "strawman" hits the nail on the head in that regard.

The article discusses the capture/torture/etc in some significant detail. Search for "unjust war".

ealexhudson··on Ask HN: Tech and product co-founder in a dilemma after raising seed round
Never hire externally at seed, you're not a mature enough organisation (unless there is a specific individual you have in mind who would be a natural fit for some other reason).

If you're leading the product development you're going to find it difficult to do a CEO-type role. Usually you need someone in the business building solutions to customer problems - that's you - and someone else going out into the world finding customers and selling the product. You don't mention who your cofounder is, but if they're the going-out-selling person then it's more natural for them to be CEO.

If they're not, and you don't have a going-out-selling person, when you really need to figure out how you're going to connect with customers and everything else should come second.

ealexhudson··on NASA’s Double Asteroid Redirection Test Is a Smashing Success
More like cosmic pool, and we have Dave Cinzano Bianco Lister.
ealexhudson··on ‘That girl is going to get herself killed’ (2022)
I've done the whole "why is my arm vibrating thing" before, except in my case I was trying to get the end of a light fitting off, and both the hot and cold prongs were in my hand. Got a nice couple of blisters where they touched the skin.

My guess would be not enough of the main current was passing across your heart to kill you? I didn't think mains electricity was necessary powerful enough to kill people in most scenarios, just that it is powerful enough to do it in an unlucky few. I'd also imagine the floor wasn't really conducting to earth.

ealexhudson··on Be wary of imitating high-status people who can afford to countersignal
Since the Met Gala is in May, the causality must be the other direction..?
ealexhudson··on Open-source hospital price transparency
The cost of the thing is effectively irrelevant if you both need it and don't get the bills for weeks/months. If patients are expected to self-ration, they need the info up front...
ealexhudson··on There Is No Such Thing as Pre-Tax Income
Pretty sure this is going to be a hugely antithetical / heretical article for some, I think it does kind of match the European view.

That said, there are a variety of things you can buy with your pretax salary and some other things you can do which reduce/change the taxes you pay, so it still does make sense in some instances to talk of gross salary.

ealexhudson··on FTX balance sheet, revealed
I believe it is true, and there was a good thread on twitter about Kelly optimal bets. It seems clear that SBF, and maybe therefore Alameda, didn't really understand the right hand side of the Kelly optimum.
ealexhudson··on FTX balance sheet, revealed
But I thought the whole complaint about SBF was the enormous lengths he was going to in order to increase regulation, and effectively pull up the drawbridge behind him?

I think the whole point about campaign financing is well made, but the idea (implied) that this was some massive Dem ruse feels incredibly far-fetched, given the various investors and others involved. If you scratch at the senior leadership of many companies you're going to find political people of all colours, because lots of people get involved in politics.

ealexhudson··on Aluminum formate Al(HCOO)3: Earth-abundant, scalable, & material for CO2 capture
If the source of the flue gas is ~renewable (e.g. wood) and the energy generated is used usefully, this isn't a bad idea for carbon capture. It's much easier to capture the carbon technologically like this, and rely on broader capture (e.g. trees) to pull it out of the atmosphere. What really counts is what happens to the concentrated carbon being extracted - it needs to not go back into the atmosphere.
ealexhudson··on Ask HN: Comment here about whatever you're passionate about at the moment
Even as a class I device (which an ekg is emphatically never going to be), the ISO audit is three months between the first two stages alone. Under MDD 3 months is a push, but under MDR I think 6 is a much more realistic minimum (if you're starting from literal zero).
ealexhudson··on It looks like I’m moving to Mastodon
If Musk wants twitter to be the town square for the world, that town square needs to be accessible for all.

Even though this might not directly affect Simon, hats off to him for making that decision. If twitter starts becoming as inaccessible as most other systems it will lock out people and remove their voices from twitter. That feels like an incredibly valid reason, and isn't the point of free markets to vote with your feet?

ealexhudson··on Amsterdam looks incredibly realistic in the new Call of Duty
It did an excellent job, and considering the amount that was cut out it was still extremely easy to navigate from the east to west end along entirely recognisable roads.

The pub over the road from Parliament was a bit jarring but understandable.

ealexhudson··on Microsoft Office 365 Message Encryption Insecure Mode of Operation
OME is also accepted/compatible with Gmail, Yahoo!, etc.

Would be interesting to know whether they suffer the same issue, or those implementations chose a proper encryption mode..

ealexhudson··on Microsoft Office 365 Message Encryption Insecure Mode of Operation
You're allowed to assume the phone network is not being eavesdropped, you're not allowed to assume that for Internet transmission. Whether that's true or not, that's the accepted position.

If this encryption genuinely allows structural data retrieval - eg common invoice templates or medical reports - then this is absolutely a HIPAA problem, and once a facility is made aware of it they would need to respond.

FWIW, this message encryption is also accepted by UK NHS, in fact it's virtually the standard.

The mitigating factor is that typically the user is fully authenticated before being allowed to access the encrypted data...

← PreviousPage 2 of 17Next →