HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eganist

5 karma · joined June 18, 2024

I'll largely use this account for talking about advice subreddits and forums specifically.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/bryant; my proof: https://keybase.io/bryant/sigs/-R8Ky9MLcrIhyNpFXZWTI6B6qQdfdG5dt89OuG-Jxv4 ]

submissionscomments
eganist··on Johnson and Johnson to pay $6.5B to resolve talc ovarian cancer lawsuits in U.S.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3230399/

Have you seen anything newer that resoundingly disputes this and the studies cited herein?

More recent, and accounting for more recent studies: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S209379112...

eganist··on I've forked neofetch to keep it alive
> That’s seems fine to me if they’re all reasonable. You’re using a very sinister tone.

What aspect of their reply "Not even, this person is complaining about the color scheme options in multiple threads" registered as "very sinister" to you?

eganist··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
Others are calling this out but they're not able to state why:

They're listed as adversaries and not enemies because aiding an enemy country suddenly unlocks a litany of other crimes.

Enemy is very specifically defined: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/2204

Adversary is very specifically defined: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-15/subtitle-A/part-7/subp...

eganist··on Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act
Lots of discussion around this today - figured I'd post the raw text of the bill that was actually signed into law, H.R.815 - "Making emergency supplemental appropriations for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2024, and for other purposes."

The bill itself does single out ByteDance presumably to ensure that they have no way of skirting around the whole Foreign Adversary Controlled thing, but separately from that, the bill is pretty specific around how it's determining whether an app is owned or beneficially controlled by a country that's an adversary of the United States.

Specifically:

> (4) FOREIGN ADVERSARY COUNTRY.—The term “foreign adversary country” means a country specified in section 4872(d)(2) of title 10, United States Code.

The related section: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/4872

eganist··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
The raw text of the bill: https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/815/...
eganist··on Biden signs TikTok bill into law, starting clock for ByteDance to divest
> By the looks of it, it seems like you want the US to be more like the CCP than the other way around. Imitating authoritarian governments harms America's global reputation for "freedom and democracy", if that reputation even still exists.

There's a wild difference between unfettered access to a company's assets, systems, networks, data, etc. vs policywork to simply require that companies be owned at the very least by a country that isn't either Russia, China, North Korea, or Iran.

Yes, I did read the bill. They did specifically single out ByteDance presumably to make sure there wasn't a way ByteDance could claim they weren't under Chinese influence. But they made a point of calling out Foreign Adversary Countries and pointed to https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/4872 in doing so.

Bill raw text: https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/815/...

eganist··on Wikipedia Has Cancer (2017)
> Nobody would donate to Wikipedia if they knew it could survive on a few million dollars each year and it had hundreds of millions of dollars handy, and no new work was being done to add services and improve existing services.

I mean, I would. I'd rather they fulfill their core mission on ROI alone than waste it on stuff that evidently adds no value.

I'd donate for that. I won't donate to see it wasted.

eganist··on Wikipedia Has Cancer (2017)
This is an interesting comment that seems to miss the point.

> If fundraising dips in the future, so what? They cut back? It's sad to see folks get laid off, but that's essentially what the author is arguing for, so it's kind of moot.

The point author is making is that there's no track record to suggest that cost cutting is on the cards, or more broadly, that the organization has any concept of how to manage organizational risk. Author cites a lack of other best practices across the organization + a continued ramp-up in spend not commensurate with what wikipedia needs as a defense of this argument. The best practices and need for fiscal prudence cited by the author exist in essence to mitigate the risk of waste and insolvency against the fulfillment of the mission.

> Incidentally, we did go through a global recession. COVID caused Wikipedia to see almost double it's normal increase in funding while the organization decreased expenses. And the following year, fundraising brought in less cash, but income still far outstripped expenses, and income basically returned to it's trend before the recession.

I'm not sure what this is intending to suggest, but all I can come up with is "because Wikipedia thrived during the biggest imminent risk to humanity in decades, there's not much to worry about." So did Zoom and Pfizer, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't have a good handle of enterprise risk.

> The argument "it's not their place to spend the money they raise" seems, at this point, like such a ridiculous argument

It's probably the most grounded argument I've read about WMF's incapability to handle risk as it relates to its mission.

WMF is non-profit. They serve a mission foremost. It's on their board to ensure that the mission is served effectively today and can continue to be served effectively for as long as is relevant, or in the case of Wikipedia, as long as possible.

Not contributing is an option, but in the absence of alternatives, it's the option that most greatly jeopardizes the mission in the eyes of donors. This is why people may choose to use their voices rather than their dollars.

eganist··on Asus refunds Zenfone buyer for failing to provide bootloader unlock tools
> SMS is magnitudes less secure than the Secure Enclave in my phone.

The secure enclave on a rooted phone that no longer has execution integrity?

eganist··on Asus refunds Zenfone buyer for failing to provide bootloader unlock tools
Curious, can you name this institution that only allows the app to be used as the second factor without fallbacks?
eganist··on Asus refunds Zenfone buyer for failing to provide bootloader unlock tools
How would that stick? You can just sign into the bank via your web browser in the case of a nonfunctional app. The apps just give you added security assurances beyond using the web.

"The app can't function in a low security environment, but complainant is free to use the web client in such event." case dismissed

(obviously an oversimplification, but the point stands)

eganist··on HIV in cell culture can be completely eliminated using CRISPR-Cas gene editing [pdf]
Way out of my depth here, but I'm guessing the main hurdles to turning this into a drug are encapsulation in a way that survives injection (or better yet, ingestion) as well as either targeting of infected cells or at least ensuring that even if it touches every cell, it only affects HIV DNA?

Basically, what's needed to commercialize this?

eganist··on Show HN: Not sure you're talking to a human? Create a human check
When bots invariably redirect captcha chat messages to a call center in (x) country to solve for 1̶0̶ ̶c̶e̶n̶t̶s̶ (thanks flotzam) 0.2 cents, what's the next step in this cat and mouse game?
eganist··on Mozilla will be retiring the Mozilla Location Service
You're entirely right. I was mostly just picking nits at op saying the funding wasn't direct. But it's functionally both direct and exclusive in that if Google pulls out, even if e.g Bing comes in with a bid it'll likely be drastically less, and Mozilla would be stuck restructuring pretty substantially in order to survive.
eganist··on Mozilla will be retiring the Mozilla Location Service
> Is Walmart now beholden to me?

They owe you a box of crackers. Once you've departed with it, they're no longer beholden to you.

eganist··on Mozilla will be retiring the Mozilla Location Service
> But not the only, nor a direct funding.

Being paid directly for a service by a company (Google paying for the privilege of being the default) is to be directly funded by that company. You're right that it's not the only source of revenue, but it's absolutely a direct source of funding.

eganist··on Ask HN: If you could spend $100k to get healthy and fit, how would you do it?
Did keto 10.5 months of last year, lost 51lbs. Stopped, regained 20lbs and stabilized.

I still want to lose more though as I'm not where I should be for my height, so I'm going the medicated route.

If you're going to spend the money, do it on a trainer and do it often. You're talking a hollywood film prep training budget, that's probably how you should approach it to get to your target and then wean it back.

I talk about both of these because you can achieve the weight loss without spending the money, you just need to power through the first two weeks with strictly less than 20g carbs. At that point, you're probably golden (much like cutting nicotine or caffeine).

But if your goal is a transformation, your budget buys you accountability.

eganist··on What it's like to staff the home of a billionaire
I think you're assuming more about my policy preferences than I've let on. This conversation isn't likely to be productive as a result.
eganist··on What it's like to staff the home of a billionaire
> That you are in some real or perceived negative situation does not mean I should be obligated to help you. Whether I help you or not is my own decision.

Since it's a core belief of yours, you should keep voting that way, whereas I'll keep voting to make sure the social safety nets exist since fairness and successful bootstrapping are never guaranteed.

eganist··on Ex-Google engineer charged with stealing trade secrets
> You expect Google to scan the database of companies in every country continuously to see if employees are executives of them? How would this handle different people who have the same name?

> Disclosure: I work at Google.

It's Google. Not a mom and pop shop, not a startup, not even a large bank. It's a massive conglomerate who's entire business model revolves around data.

So yes. And same-name conflicts can be handled case by case.

eganist··on U.S. students will take the SAT online
> eventually want to build out a tool to accurately monitor a student's performance over time.

How does AutoMark account for disparities in quality of education?

eganist··on Adaptive immune responses larger and functionally preserved in a hypervaccinated
The tldr is basically:

* Guy vaccinated himself very, very often for reasons unknown.

* We observed interesting things [implied: that we probably would never have observed otherwise because nobody would ever set up a study for this specifically] like mildly elevated levels of spike-specific B cells

* It doesn't look like it made him any more or less protected.

* The guy never caught covid as best as anyone can tell, but other factors (was he a recluse?) can't be ruled out.

* We're not endorsing this as a strategy, we're just writing up interesting stuff since the opportunity arose.

The news media is also widely reporting this. https://www.google.com/search?q=217&tbm=nws

eganist··on [dead]
I *really* don't want to see us encourage gamifying HN submissions. Something can be highly ranked for a myriad of reasons, including for technically controversial ones (e.g different philosophies in solving specific technical challenges).

A discussion here is a discussion, not a selling point. Makes me less willing to contribute to conversation about a product if the parent company promotes in this manner, though I might be in the minority there.

eganist··on What it's like to staff the home of a billionaire
Nowhere in my comment did I imply that everyone thinks this way, or that op specifically thinks this way.
eganist··on What it's like to staff the home of a billionaire
> Your needs and wants are not a claim on my life. My life is my own. If you want to feed your money into whatever you define good as, go ahead. Dont expect anyone to cater to your whims with the fruits of their labors though.

This quote is interesting, as it supposes that you'll ever be in this position (and you may be. It's HN and I haven't opened your bio). Many people think the same way, which leads into my point:

A lot of policy failures arise from voters being wooed away from the certainty of a social safety net by the idea of obscene wealth. And therefore we end up overborrowing for infrastructure when we should be taxing based on how someone benefits from it.

> Everyone thinks they have a claim to goods and services they did not earn and hate people that earned them

Not everyone, only the people who recognize that the infrastructure that enabled someone's success still needs to be paid for, and that many of those who thrive on such underlying infrastructure refuse to pay for it.

eganist··on Avoiding fusion plasma tearing instability with deep reinforcement learning
The concept of "cognitive confinement" (your term I presume. It's neat, I hope it sticks) was explored in Spiderman 2.

I'm being entirely serious. Even though the visualization of the reactor was wildly off the mark, this specific concept fits what the writers had in mind with the AI mechanical limbs.

eganist··on Satoshi – Sirius emails 2009-2011
With the US at least, it can probably be loosely tested by comparing declassified records (50 years on) with program size at the time.
eganist··on Astronomers observe the Radcliffe Wave oscillating
If you're wondering what the Radcliffe Wave is like I was, from the article:

> A few years ago, astronomers uncovered one of the Milky Way's greatest secrets: An enormous, wave-shaped chain of gaseous clouds in our sun's backyard, giving birth to clusters of stars along the spiral arm of the galaxy we call home.

Tldr: the clouds both look like a wave and move like waves too (analogized to wave-like motions in stadiums). Which is pretty neat. They speculate it's because of gravitational interactions.

More: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07127-3

eganist··on Tesla worker killed in fiery crash may be first 'Full Self-Driving' fatality
So there's an interesting legal question here.

If someone's drunk (i.e diminished reasoning) and steps into the car expecting that a feature named "full self driving" will safely drive them home, how is responsibility divided between the person who got drunk and the entity who created and named the "full self driving" feature?

I don't think even a reasonable person could consistently conclude that "full self driving" isn't actually full self driving.

eganist··on Violent crime is dropping fast in the U.S. – even if Americans don't believe it
The stats here on carjacking are so bad that I just avoid taking my car places that show nasty trends on https://crimecards.dc.gov

Example: https://crimecards.dc.gov/stolen%20autos:property%20crimes/a...

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →