HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

egwor

605 karma · joined March 16, 2011

submissionscomments
egwor··on Products purchased at Apple Store in India cannot be refunded or exchanged
Yeah, we had a sensible discussion about this in the store. I was calm and respectful but firm. I explained that since I had literally walked through some water, and it had never gone remotely deep or been in for a long time (10-15 seconds?) that it seems entirely reasonable that it should have been fine. I explained that this was sold as waterproof and that anyone reasonable would have expected it to be waterproof for two years. They thought that maybe a scratch had damaged the seal, but they couldn’t see any damage. My phone was in good condition.

I think I was definitely lucky yeah!

egwor··on Products purchased at Apple Store in India cannot be refunded or exchanged
I have a totally different experience. I accidentally submerged my iPhone X in the sea as I got off a boat[1]. The phone although supposedly considered waterproof went mental and basically stopped working. I was flying back via Singapore (a week later) and went into the apple store at the airport. They replaced the phone and got me back up and running before my flight back to London. I live and had bought the phone in the UK. They even had special versions of the UK phone for this scenario.

[1] I was in the Philippines and I was getting off a boat in shallow sea water. My phone was in the bottom pocket of my beach shorts, and I walked through the sea water for maybe two to three metres distance up to waist height depth. This should have been ok for the depth I went.

Their suspicion was that the outer seal had failed (even though it had always been in a case).

egwor··on Peloton cuts back on Apple Watch support
Maybe it could sync via your phone? That's how I sync pretty much everything else I use (garmin and polar)
egwor··on A reading list for new engineering managers
Link for others: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Elegant-Puzzle-Systems-Engineering-...
egwor··on Docker as an Integrated Development Environment (2019)
The same concept still works; they could have installed IntelliJ and copied over all of the plugins and settings?
egwor··on 533M Facebook users' phone numbers and personal data have been leaked online
That doesn't seem to be correct, although what does 'phone numbers' mean in this context?

Quote: "WhatsApp, which was acquired by Facebook in 2014, does share some limited data with Facebook, including phone numbers. However, the firm has reassured users that messages will always be protected by end-t0-end encryption, which means neither WhatsApp or Facebook can see these private conversations"

Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/carlypage/2021/01/15/whatsapp-d...

egwor··on UK finds 30 blood clot cases after AstraZeneca jab
If I got the vaccine and a blood clot, I'd want to understand it better. I'd want to understand the numbers at large to see whether it was caused by the vaccine. In the UK, the numbers need to be considered fully:

* 30 million have received the first

* 4 million have received the second

Let's assume that 80% of folk got the AZ vaccine and that there's an equal chance of clot after each vaccine. So we're stating that the chance is 42 / 34 * e6 * 0.8. That means that the chance of it happening (from just those numbers) is 0.000001544117647. Since there are some many zeros, 0.000_001_544_117647. These numbers are tiny.

Now compare that with the chance of death from Covid. For over 50 the chance of death is much higher (calculated by UK population number and deaths in population over over 50 from COVID). When I did the calcs yesterday on the Norwegian (iirc) numbers assuming about 30 per million (higher ratio than the UK numbers), it seemed that for the under 40's the chance of death from vaccine was slightly lower than dying from COVID.

In the UK, COVID deaths might be considered higher than other countries due to differences in the way in which deaths are recorded.

The next question to ask is what the likelihood of a similar blood clot within the general population if they'd not had the vaccine. From what I hear those chances are similarly low. From what I've read from doctors it sounds like the chances are higher than without the vaccine. Some joked that this could therefore be considered an anti-blood clotting medicine.

Next put this into comparison with other medications, such as the contraceptive pill where chance of blots clots is 1:1000.

The numbers at large matter.

egwor··on Deliveroo shares drop 30% on UK IPO listing
The barrier to entry isn't the tech (which is why I don't think that this is really a tech firm). The barrier to entry is the relationships with the restaurants and the riders (and advertising to get people to use it)
egwor··on Let’s fix font size
If I have two monitors with two resolutions and I put the two screens together the text is a different size. When I'm reading the text I want it to be consistent as I move it across screens. With this approach will the text be the same size?

The main issue I have as I get older is that as the resolution increases the text size seems to get smaller

egwor··on Google’s top security teams unilaterally shut down a counterterrorism operation
I think you made a jump there. This could equally be one of the other in the Five Eyes group e.g. Canada, Uk, Australia, NZ.
egwor··on Gitlab default branch name changes to main
We have auto merges setup vs master within bitbucket. I've asked our support team to raise it with them and get it addressed. Thats the only reason we've not changed it. We don't develop off master anymore anyway, so it is a bit of a moot point from anyone using the repo. The main annoyance is that when you clone a repo it always comes from master so you have to tell people.
egwor··on Gitlab default branch name changes to main
Totally agree with this.

If someone still struggles to get behind it, think of the few chars that will be shorter to type and also think how it is much easier to compare the branch concept a real tree, and talk about the main branch. Maybe they could have gone for trunk? (If you care so much about main vs trunk, then choose whatever makes you happy)

egwor··on On power markets, snow storms, and $16k power bills
To 1.: didn't one provider email their client base to warn them of this?
egwor··on WhatsApp to move ahead with privacy update despite backlash
I'm so disappointed in this. Whatsapp is a functional tool. It was successful since it worked.

Facebook has entirely failed to utilise it - to allow external systems to connect in so that businesses can do business on there. The voice calls are also a disaster.

They've now come along to start messing with the privacy to start selling ads. It is insane that they're able to make such a mess of this. Is there a word for anti-innovation?

Considering that they're linking Facebook ad platform with the chats, and they're forcing this upon everyone, why isn't this covered by the monopoly laws? Most of us paid some money for the app.

egwor··on Why SELECT * is bad for SQL performance (2020)
Most ORM's I've used carefully choose just the columns required. i.e. they don't use 'select *'.
egwor··on Is the Industry Ready for T-0 Settlement? (2018)
In the UK we have instant transfers between bank accounts. For larger quantities there can be a bigger delay.
egwor··on Counterfeiting Stock – Explaining illegal naked shorting and stock manipulation
Agreed. One of the reasons is that the option has a risk and therefore there's a cost associated with managing that risk and taking on the trade.
egwor··on Counterfeiting Stock – Explaining illegal naked shorting and stock manipulation
I agree on the mechanism. If the objection is that someone can influence the price of an instrument without owning it (like in short selling (although in short selling you can borrow the instrument and then short it)), then should the argument be that put options should also not be allowed without ownership of the underlier too?
egwor··on Counterfeiting Stock – Explaining illegal naked shorting and stock manipulation
If I want insurance to protect against the price going down, I'd buy a put option. I know a bit about this but I'm not an expert on this. Naively, those put options are effectively offered by those providing a short (they think the price is going to go down, or have a way to hedge the price decrease). Those don't get represented as shorts either. https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/knowledge/tr...

The other thing to consider here: if some entity needs to provide the put option, how does one hedge (risk manage) a put option ? They need to consider what would happen if the price drops, and as the price drops their hedge needs to increase in price. There's undoubtedly more to this, but that relationship sounds awfully like a short.

Any experts want to wade in here?

egwor··on Analysis: Robinhood protected from lawsuits by user agreement, Congress
Agreed. Probably highly likely that few others using that broker were involved.
egwor··on Statement of SEC Regarding Recent Market Volatility
Replying to myself to avoid edits.

The other reason that listening and not spouting fiction is a good idea is that it is a lot of effort correcting people d that effort could otherwise be spent elsewhere. Folk have good will, but there's a finite amount that shouldn't be wasted! Once that's run out they look to use their time effectively. Correcting you /again/ won't be up high on the list.

egwor··on Statement of SEC Regarding Recent Market Volatility
I think it would be helpful if folk highlighted when they don't know an area and are not experts. I think this is a better way to do it because it is clear that the person is trying to learn rather than spouting nonsense. Also, it takes a lot of effort to correct people, and when emotions are high this is a painful process. The RH post was a great example of this.

I've commented on some of the RH posts and got downvoted because people didn't like the facts (and I think maybe took it personally too). I've worked in Finance long enough professionally to know that I don't understand this fully and few people do. I do know enough to know when the comments are nonsense though.

I think that some of these issues comes down to respect and also arrogance. Imagine going into a new field and after 30 seconds deciding that you know everything (the Dunning–Kruger effect?)! Have a little bit of respect for those in the field and listen. Feel free to comment/ask, but don't spout 'facts' without checking and I think we'd all move forward faster.

egwor··on Statement of SEC Regarding Recent Market Volatility
I think that there's a real problem with people using 'Cunningham's Law' as a way to learn. It might be fine for that person (because they know their limits), but then anyone reading it could incorrectly quote that person as being right (because it wasn't corrected). These ideas are then duplicated and we get into a real mess where we can't differentiate widely held views vs the experts/most agreed upon view by experts.

In general, this can't be a way to move forward as a society if people just make stuff up.

egwor··on Google Deleted over 100k Negative Robinhood Reviews
There's also an article supporting my points that sometimes there are restrictions (fine print) that stop trading.

From: https://www.theverge.com/2021/1/28/22255031/robinhood-gamest...

Quote: As a brokerage firm, we have many financial requirements, including SEC net capital obligations and clearinghouse deposits. Some of these requirements fluctuate based on volatility in the markets and can be substantial in the current environment,” the post argues. “To be clear, this was a risk-management decision, and was not made on the direction of the market makers we route to.”

egwor··on Google Deleted over 100k Negative Robinhood Reviews
The original parent is 'This is worrying indeed because the negative reviews are clearly justified.'. I don't agree with this and the thread explains why.

There are two issues to your comment:

1. Trading (including risk management) is really complicated. It isn't something that you can pick up in 30 seconds after downloading an app. This exact scenario (where broker stops taking orders on a stock likely due to internal risk limits) is a great example of an unusual scenario that has to be risk managed. This isn't some nose-upturned view but a fact.

2. Many of the comments here are made in good faith but it is pure speculation. 500K reviews were apparently posted and automatically removed. In any usual day we'd assume this was the usual spam. Again there's speculation about why there were removed. My point here is that there needs to be time to actually find out what happened.

egwor··on Robinhood, in Need of Cash, Raises $1B from Its Investors
> Robinhood played with people phschology

I disagree. They've offer a way to trade like other platforms. Other platforms did the same thing and blocked trading.

The question you need to be asking is why did they ALL block trading?

They're competitors to each other, so why did they make the same decision? Remember that these firms make money on every trade done. They want to take your trades. BUT they have to manage risk. They lose money if the client can't pay. They're there to facilitate but they are taking risk themselves if they provide leverage. They, like banks providing mortgages have to have limits set. If would be unprofessional and irrational to do otherwise. These firms are there to make money in a highly competitive environment. They are professionally run to ensure that they stay in business.

The comments here are of the theme 'RH has screwed us to make money'. No, what they've most likely done is made a decision to take no more risk to ensure that they remain in business. EVERYONE is speculating though. If that's the case these arguments that the clients are somehow being screwed over is really unfair and shows a lack of understanding. Clients need to understand the risks of what they're doing, and need to understand the risks associated with executing via one broker. It's a professional environment and drive by retail unfortunately are mostly unaware of the true risks.

Examples: 1. Traders have multiple brokers to trade via because there are technical issues

2. If something is too good to be true, it probably is.

3. If you're betting against some professionals, you need to ask what they know that you don't. Why are they comfortable taking on the risk. The professionals will try very hard not to be emotional and have more info that a retail customer will.

4. The retail investor need to understand the business model of the brokers. Why are they in business and what are their limits?

I see the real problem here is that it is easy to put a trade on. It is difficult to know how to risk manage it and understand the risks. This squeeze has identified a limit in the market that wasn't considered.

egwor··on Google Deleted over 100k Negative Robinhood Reviews
I agree with that. I assume that this is an algo at work.
egwor··on Robinhood, in Need of Cash, Raises $1B from Its Investors
Hasn't SI/Float been around there for more than a year? I'm not an expert on this.

Source: https://www.ortex.com/symbol/nyse/gme/short_interest

egwor··on Robinhood, in Need of Cash, Raises $1B from Its Investors
So the market price which is made from all transactions from all brokers will drop because robinhood users could not buy.

That makes no sense to me. If they really wanted to buy they could use another broker? If the market really is dropping then tough luck. You can lose all your money investing in the stock market. If you're leveraged you can lose even more (which might explain why some accounts were closed).

egwor··on Google Deleted over 100k Negative Robinhood Reviews
Can I propose changing the description slightly to frame how big of an issue it is:

I downloaded the app to buy shares. It is the weekend. The markets are closed, so I can't buy shares. Delete app, 1* rating, false advertising.

There is always fine print. The challenge is that the fine print here is really complicated. In extreme situations there are rules to consider.

← PreviousPage 3 of 9Next →