HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eighthnate

91 karma · joined August 18, 2017

submissionscomments
eighthnate··on Can Germany Fix Facebook?
Sure it does. Depriving people of speech is diminishing their dignity. Even better, depriving people of reading books they want or even wearing clothing they want is diminishing their dignity.

> Banning them from insulting other people’s dignity

So you support banning anti-nazi speech right? All the speech attacking and insulting nazis should be banned right? Because it's wrong to insult people right?

eighthnate··on Internet Association Endorses Internet Censorship Bill
I agree completely. Not only did they lose the high ground, what did facebook, google, reddit and the rest of social media companies think was going to happen once they agreed to a little bit of censorship? Did they really think these anti-free speech crowd was going to go away? No. Extremists always up the ante and they are going to demand more and more censorship.

I've stopped using reddit because so much of the "community" is so extreme now. They are even demanding that pro-Trump subs be banned from reddit and even calling for twitter to ban Trump's twitter account.

What's going to be interesting is what these people will think when people start demanding atheist, lgbt, leftist, etc content be censored.

eighthnate··on Can Germany Fix Facebook?
> As an American I would trust most countries in the EU with stuff like this over even my own country given the direction of the USA.

As an american you trust europeans with free speech more than the US? Doesn't sound like an american to me considering how heavily europe censors.

> Germany already bans Nazi imagery and wording in many forms except for history purposes and they seem to be fine.

Fine by what standard?

> We already have problems in the USA where now nonviolent political protestors are being prosecuted by the federal government and officials are encouraging people to commit violence against the protestors in spite of the protestors having the First Amendment to back them up - statutory limits or freedoms are not magic that make things right.

Can you cite an example?

eighthnate··on Can Germany Fix Facebook?
The promise of the internet was that it would be free and open to all ideas, thoughts and discussions. The hope was that it would raise the rest of the world to american ideals of liberty, free speech and right to assembly. Instead, we are dropping ourselves to the lowest common denominator. Rather than the outside world bettering themselves with free speech, we are instead lowering ourselves to the anti-free speech levels of germany, china, saudi arabia and russia.

We are to stifle free speech because of "human dignity"? That's what dictators say. That's what extremists say. Theo Van Gogh was stabbed to death over a short film that insulted the "dignity" of muslims. North koreans kidnap or kill people because their "dignity" is insulted. Following that logic, aren't neo-nazis human? Don't they deserve "dignity"?

It isn't facebook that needs fixing. It is germany. What germans, chinese, saudis, russians, the extreme liberals and those who are anti-free speech don't understand that free speech is a necessary component of human dignity. You can't have human dignity without it. It is an essential characteristic of human dignity.

eighthnate··on Tesla's 'Production Hell' Threatens Its Future
> No, I don't remember any such thing.

It was called the 2000s. Did you miss that decade?

> The thing that haters fail to recognize is that people buy Tesla cars for more than the government subsidy and fuel economy.

I'm not a hater. I'm just pointing out economic/business reality.

> Ask any actual owner and they will tell you how incredible the cars are in practice. Disclaimer: owner since 2012.

My god, that's exactly what my uncle said about the prius more than a decade ago. Also, tesla isn't the only incredible car. There are lots of incredible cars out there. That's why most people don't buy teslas.

eighthnate··on Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos sold more than $1B worth of stock this week
Because it was probably traded book to book or via the back-end pools. Most likely bezos' broker called other brokers/hedge funds/etc to gauge interest and one or few of them agreed to take on the position.

This happens all the time when the big boys want to open/close/rebalance large positions within a short time frame.

eighthnate··on Tesla's 'Production Hell' Threatens Its Future
That's not why its future is threatened.

1. It's low oil/gas/energy prices and the fact that it looks like we are in for a low energy price environment for a decade or two.

2. Tesla, just their sister company solar city was built entirely on government subsidies. Those look to be going away.

3. They are hemorrhaging money.

Tesla is this decades Prius on steroids. Except that tesla doesn't have toyota's best selling sedans, tacoma trucks or their luxury lexus buttressing their foray into clean cars.

Remember when everyone thought that prius would take over the world?

eighthnate··on Against an Increasingly User-Hostile Web
The sweetspot was mid 90s to mid 00s. We had the benefit of the web without the all-encompassing corporate control. It was a more open and freer place back then. But as the internet got more popular and with more corporate/government involvement, the standards were lowered to accommodate the lowest common denominator.

Less free speech, more control, less privacy and more ads.

eighthnate··on How Russia Got Americans to Turn Against One Another
That applies to the nytimes too. They are in the business of influence peddling.
eighthnate··on How Russia Got Americans to Turn Against One Another
Firstly, we have always been divided and against each other. Rich vs poor, white vs black, rural vs urban, native vs settlers, native born vs immigrants, states vs federal government, etc. What is the NYTimes going to do next? Blame russia for the civil war?

Secondly, the media, including the NYTimes,

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/25/opinion/sunday/hillary-cl...

did far more to divide the country and turn everyone against each other than russians. The nytimes and their fellow media cohorts incessant agenda-pushing via their socio-political propaganda war has soured the nation.

Thirdly, what disturbs me is the coordinated propaganda campaign waged by almost all the media ( nytimes, wapo, bloomberg, cnbc, etc ) all pushing the same message. It almost seems like they are just different mouthpieces of the same propaganda organ.

Fourthly, it's exhausting and quite frankly ineffective to spam "russia is behind everything" everyday. It just makes the nytimes and the rest of the media look like propagandists rather than actual news organizations.

But that's just me. My faith in news organizations is forever lost anyways. Once you peek behind the veil, there is no going back.

eighthnate··on How Russia Got Americans to Turn Against One Another
The NYTimes is upset their candidate didn't win.

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/25/opinion/sunday/hillary-cl...

They have to blame someone because they themselves can't possibly be responsible.

eighthnate··on Cryptographic filesystem for the cloud
The #1 rule of computer/data security is physical security. If you have data/information you don't know anyone to access, don't put it on the cloud. Store it locally somewhere with no or limited internet connection.
eighthnate··on Breitbart, other conservative outlets escalate anti-SpaceX campaign
> I would say the downvotes are more due to the fact you're commenting on an article that says a certain section of what we are still calling "The Right" has incorrectly demonized Musk in this case and you decided to piggyback on the criticism of him.

Okay. But why is arstechnica even defending musk. Is arstechnica musk's PR firm? Isn't that strange in and of itself? Lots of bad things get said about everyone and yet arstechnica decided to jump in on musk's defense.

That seems pretty odd to me.

> you decided to piggyback on the criticism of him.

I've criticized musk. And I've also praised him too. But the problem is that I get attacked for criticizing musk.

I just find it odd how any criticism of musk gets a swarmed response. That isn't an ad hominem. That's just wondering how strange things are.

I would be interested if arstechnica or their employees have any direct or indirect financial stake in musk's enterprises. I also would be interested if breitbart/et al have any financial stake in having musk's companies fail ( ie short positions or interests in musk's competitors ).

eighthnate··on The U.S. Isn’t Prepared for the Next Recession
> Watch the USD. Once it plunges, it's over.

Historically ( past few decades ), during recessions and international crisis, foreign money would flow into the US, japan, switzerland, etc. But primarily to the US because we are the safe haven for the world and that inflow helped prop up the dollar.

If a major recession or international crisis occurred and foreign money didn't flow into the US, then it would signify a paradigm shift in the international political/economic order.

I don't think ( at least I hope ) we are anywhere near a paradigm shift in the world order given our preeminent military and economic position and our alliances around the world.

But I guess even the brits during reign of the british empire thought that their party would last forever.

eighthnate··on Breitbart, other conservative outlets escalate anti-SpaceX campaign
> In the US are only two political parties.

No. We have more than two political parties. It's just that two are dominant and they both work for the same people.

> Yet North Korea and Russia only have one, so its not that bad.

What? We are comparing ourselves to russia and nk? Is that how low we have sunk as a nation?

> And diversity does exists.

What? 2 isn't diversity. And as I pointed out, it doesn't exist in news media.

eighthnate··on Breitbart, other conservative outlets escalate anti-SpaceX campaign
As much as I despise all "news" organizations, I say good.

Considering that most of the media has been fawning over musk and spacex and everything musk does, perhaps some criticism of musk is required in a free and democratic system.

I just don't like how so much of media are pretty much colluding with each other to spread the same narrative. On almost all topics, it seems like most of the media is pushing a particular narrative.

I wish we had a media environment where about a third is pro-musk, a third is anti-musk and a third is neutral.

The same with trump/obama/clinton, politics, technology, business, globalization, economics, international relations, etc.

All we seem to get is cheerleading by the media for one particular agenda.

I'm a believer in diversity and I think we need diversity in the media.

And I don't believe in saints. Musk has done a lot of good things, but he isn't a saint. He has done plenty of things that can be criticized. How most of his business lives off government subsidies. How much in bed he is with wall street. How he really hasn't invented or created anything new. Most of his proclamations and "inventions" are decades old technologies. None of his grandiose proposals have born fruit yet.

If all the media seems to do is praise or criticize, then I know something is wrong.

Edit: Wow, that was a swift and quick number of downvotes. I know that pay to play is a big thing in news ( both arstechnica and brietbart and everyone else does ). But I wonder if musk has pr firms working the social media scene?

eighthnate··on Google, Facebook, and Amazon have fundamentally transformed the web
Agreed. The most astounding part is how corporate america, government and the media changed the culture of the internet ( not just social media ) within a span of a couple of years.

The rampant censorship is something I could not have envisioned.

5 years ago, if you told me censorship would be the norm on reddit, twitter, facebook, youtube, etc. I would not have believed you. 10 years ago, if you told me anyone would support banning/stealing of domains ( daily stormer, etc ), I would not have believed you.

It is just astounding to witness the censorship powers of corporate + government + media.

The promise of the internet as an open platform for ideas/speech/etc that I grew up with in the 90s/00s has ended.

Perhaps it's the result of the centralization of the internet in the past 10 years. Hopefully the pendulum swings back towards a more decentralized version of the internet.

eighthnate··on China's Silk Road Illusions
> Even most blatant Soviet propaganda put that into 4%.

Does it? 4% is still nothing.

> Marshal Zhukov said that Lend-lease was critical to Soviet victory.

So did stalin. Politicians, generals, etc say a lot of things. Especially about "free" stuff.

> Just a few facts: for USSR lend-lease accounted for 30% of trucks, more than half of aviation fuel and about 93% of railroad equipment.

Facts you just made up?

> So it's definetely not a propaganda.

4% to 93%. Sounds a lot like propaganda.

eighthnate··on Amazon now has a billion-dollar ad business
The most disappointing part for me are the prices on amazon. They used to have the best prices. Now their products are overpriced. I noticed this starting in 2013 and bought a sizable stake in amzn ( the 60 minutes report on the amzn drone also helped ). So the appreciation of the amazon's stock price more than made up for their overpriced goods.
eighthnate··on Journalists decry Facebook experiment's impact on democracy
> Furthermore, it's funny hearing this hypocrisy coming from journalists, since they are the ones who are throwing away their "journalistic integrity" to make money. It's impossible to come across a mainstream publication with unbiased point of view nowadays.

Not only that. These same journalists are the ones demanding censorship of opposing views on FB and the rest of social media.

All these selfish greedy journalists want is their own "fake news" making money on social media and other people's "fake news" banned.

Frankly, I wish google, fb, twtr, etc would all band together and just ban all news from their platform for a week. Maybe that will quiet these useless journalists.

eighthnate··on Journalists decry Facebook experiment's impact on democracy
> If Fb suddenly cuts a major source of revenue for a whole industry without any discussion, if that is Fb's power, then this is really unhealthy for our market economy and our ideas of democracy

But that's what journalists are demanding. The NYTimes, Guardian, WaPo, WSJ and all the established news organizations have been pressuring FB, TWTR and google to censor other viewpoints.

The selfish hypocrisy of the media is what I just can't stand. The biggest proponent of censorship on the internet and social media are these supposing "free speech" loving journalists. They don't care about free speech or democracy. They just want money.

eighthnate··on China’s AI Awakening
They are leading in solar, renewable, nuclear, patents, electric vehicles, high speed rail, hydropower, # of cities, industrialization, # of new universities, etc.

China is leading in pretty much everything right now. They are the top trading partner of pretty much every significant country. And they are planning on building another 100 cities in the next 10 years.

It is ridiculous how much change china is going through right now. Historically, urbanization/cities correlated with economic/military strength. Will that trend hold.

China currently has 100 million man cities...

https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/mar/20/china-100-cit...

They are planning to double that in the next 10 years.

We have 10 cities that are 1 million+ people. Europe ( including turkey and russia ) has 33 million man cities.

Think about that.

eighthnate··on China’s AI Awakening
Excellent point. But you have to factor in american companies international reach. Chinese companies dominate china and that is extremely lucrative, but american tech companies dominate europe and the americas and the rest of the world.

Europe and at americas combined have a larger population than china and a geographical landmass 3X larger than china.

The real question is why europe ( 800 million people ) and latin america ceded their tech industry and data to the US.

If data is the oil of the 21st century, then the US, china and india are going to rule the nest. Europe has no future and neither does south america.

I under why china, russia, etc had protected their own internal industries to compete against FB, GOOGL, TWTR, AMZN, etc. I just don't understand why europe, south america, etc haven't.

All europe/south america have/had to do is invest a few billion to capture a few trillion in wealth. Instead, they've ceded all that wealth to predominately american tech companies. It's very strange when you think about it.

eighthnate··on Tesla's mass firings spread to SolarCity
> It is risky basing too much of a business on tax credits and rebates.

This is/was an open secret not only in the solar industry but the entire renewable/clean energy industry ( wind, geo, etc ). These solar companies existed solely because of government support and everyone knew that once the government support was pulled, these companies would immediately be bankrupt.

The first solar companies to fall were those based in germany/uk/spain when european governments pulled the solar subsidies. Followed by the solar companies in the US. Even the chinese solar companies are struggling now.

But the biggest problem going forward for the solar/wind/etc industry is low oil/gas prices. But even with the most optimistic projections, solar would be a relatively small portion of global energy source even by 2050.

eighthnate··on China's Silk Road Illusions
> the USSR's side was largely propped up by the US lend-lease program

This is an oft repeated lie we tell ourselves. US contribution to USSR's military production was less than 1%. And by the time our "help" reached the soviet union, the soviets had already beaten the germans.

The battle of moscow ended in January 1942. That's when ww2 in europe was over. The rest was brutal clean up duty by the soviets.

> Without such support, the USSR would have faced the same problem that Germany did: a critical inability to properly supply their front-line troops.

Firstly, germany's problem was lack of oil. Not the number of trucks. Secondly, The soviet military industry was the largest in the world until we joined the war and their military production was never affected. And the soviets had tons of oil. Only second to the US.

The lend-lease history saving the soviet union is propaganda. If we had stayed neutral in ww2, the soviets would have beaten the germans. Other than stalin giving up, there was no way for germany to beat the soviet union. Look at the stats.

eighthnate··on China's Silk Road Illusions
> To be a modern country, it is hypothesized that the developing country needs immediately adopt American systems, laws, behavior & structures (the Washington consensus, etc.).

Rather than immediately following american "style", it is conjectured that you need to be given america's blessing and be allowed in our international world order.

> China: China is the egg, because they view modernization more or less independent (i.e., democracy is not a necessary).

Britain, Japan, Germany, France, etc all modernized when they weren't a democracy. If we are talking post ww2, south korea, taiwan, singapore, etc all modernized while they weren't real democracies.

You could be a dictatorship and still be part of the american world order - saudi arabia, kuwait, SK/taiwan for most of their history.

> that means more data points to understand how to modernize other parts of the world.

Modernization doesn't require data points. It's simply a political choice. As long as a major power isn't actively preventing you from modernizing, any country can modernize. It's simply a matter of political stability and investing in education and industry.

What makes china unique is that they are building institutions outside of the US world order ( AIIB, RCEP, BRICS, SCO and of course the belt and road initiative ).

https://www.brookings.edu/research/chinas-emerging-instituti...

But world order doesn't necessarily have anything to do with modernization.

eighthnate··on The Battle That Created Germany
> And we know all this from Caesar himself:

Caesar is known to exaggerate and make things up to make his story interesting. Caesar is one of the world's great self-promoters and self-propagandists. He knew the power of propaganda and historical legacy. So I'd take what he wrote with a grain of salt.

eighthnate··on Many junior scientists need to take a hard look at their job prospects
This is an academic industry wide problem, not just for junior scientists. When tenured professors stay on their job for 40 or 50 years and new universities/positions aren't created each year for newly minded PhDs, it's going to create a pyramid like structure in academia with the comfortable professors at the top and legions of phds on the bottom struggling to get to the top.

Ask philosophy, history and even economics PhDs. The research/academic/etc opportunities simply aren't there because it is structurally impossible. And as time goes on, it's only going to get worse and worse.

eighthnate··on DOJ Subpoenas Twitter About Five Users Over a Smiley Emoji Tweet
Well the last 20 years was ridiculous good to security specialists. If you could spell nmap, you would get a 6 figure job. It's ridiculous. The gravy train has to end sooner or later but who knows when.
eighthnate··on Britain's 'concentration camp' in Russia
> As it turns out, backing the losing side in a civil war does not ingratiate you with the winner.

You could say the same thing with the west's relation with china and vietnam and almost every other non-western nation on earth.

It's difficult to form a deep relationship with china or russia or vietnam or anyone else when you back the losing side.

Is there a bigger thorn in the side of the sino-american relationship than taiwan?

← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →